Saddy Posted December 3 Author Posted December 3 1 hour ago, Album Leak said: Whitney's album has such a spectacularly strong start but then the album kind of falls of. But then Higher Love? So ******* good. Ngl the album deserves three 11s, even if the rest of the songs are whatever. I only have Celine left, let's see what she has to offer! Oh you're so quick
Album Leak Posted December 3 Posted December 3 4 minutes ago, Saddy said: Oh you're so quick I started the minute I got the notification Also, Celine was mid. But like, in a Mariah/Whitney/Celine-mid way where the songs are always going to be decent enough because they are phenomenal vocalists, even if I don't particularly like the song. Had a few bops though! 1
Saddy Posted December 3 Author Posted December 3 I wonder how many people will participate this time. The first rate had 22 participants and the second one had 17 participants If u know someone from here who's into our 6 divas' music, let them know about this rate
GreatestLoveofAll Posted December 3 Posted December 3 Sent mine in! The averages, and they are much higher than the last one so we love improvement for our ladies! Janet got the second highest average this time while Kylie's album was a bit of a drag and unlike Celine or Mariahs's which had great vocals to fall back on, my good sis dont got nun. Control- 8.9 True Blue- 8.6 Im Your Baby Tonight- 9.3 Rhythm of Love- 6.4 Music Box- 7.9 The Colour of My Love- 8.3 1
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted December 3 ATRL Moderator Posted December 3 On 12/2/2024 at 3:19 PM, Album Leak said: You all lied several times about Control. It's only marginally better than the first two, completely carried by Nasty. But Janet is getting her first 10 so good job Janet. Still not liking your music overall. Babe, Control is the best album here by a longshot. The only classic. True Blue is a great pop album (and a much better disc than the Madonna fans here would have you believe.) Rhythm of Love - my heart! The parts of I'm Your Baby Tonight that work REALLY work. The less said about Music to Die To the better. 1
Album Leak Posted December 3 Posted December 3 4 minutes ago, Ace Reject said: Babe, Control is the best album here by a longshot. The only classic. True Blue is a great pop album (and a much better disc than the Madonna fans here would have you believe.) Rhythm of Love - my heart! The parts of I'm Your Baby Tonight that work REALLY work. The less said about Music to Die To the better. I just don't see it. But I mean... I don't see it for ANY of these albums. I've never been an album person. If we make it to the 4th album, Rhythm Nation 1814 will be getting good scores though. 1
Mariya Takeuchi Posted December 4 Posted December 4 #JusticeForJanet at laaaast I'll get my votes in over the weekend 1
sparrowblue Posted December 4 Posted December 4 im in on this one too. really glad you included Do You Think Of Me. it might be mariahs best(90s) song 1
Saddy Posted December 5 Author Posted December 5 Listened to Kylie's album and.... it was okay?! I don't hate it and don't like it
Curaga Posted December 5 Posted December 5 3 minutes ago, Saddy said: Listened to Kylie's album and.... it was okay?! I don't hate it and don't like it I wanna say I'm but I'm in the same boat nnn. I like Shocked and Things Can Only Get Better the most. 1
Saddy Posted December 5 Author Posted December 5 7 minutes ago, Curaga said: I wanna say I'm but I'm in the same boat nnn. I like Shocked and Things Can Only Get Better the most. Yeah, I also liked Shocked. One Boy Girl wasn't bad either in my opinion 1
Saddy Posted December 7 Author Posted December 7 I think today I'm gonna rate Janet and Celine tomorrow
ATRL Moderator madonnas Posted December 7 ATRL Moderator Posted December 7 I'm going to do this but it's tough, I'm going to look like a hater to Whitney/Celine/Mariah - decent albums, but TB/Control/ROL are all among my top 25 of all time. 1
ATRL Moderator madonnas Posted December 7 ATRL Moderator Posted December 7 On 12/3/2024 at 12:23 PM, Ace Reject said: Babe, Control is the best album here by a longshot. The only classic. True Blue is a great pop album (and a much better disc than the Madonna fans here would have you believe.) Rhythm of Love - my heart! The parts of I'm Your Baby Tonight that work REALLY work. The less said about Music to Die To the better. ROL is a classic too imo, its basically the strongest SAW-produced album front-to-back. I love them, but there's not much competition since they're so singles focused but it *is* better than youthquake and another place and time which are great albums. 1
blown away Posted December 7 Posted December 7 Now that Janet's 2 mixtapes have passed, I'd love to join. There are some gems among each of these albums. 1
Saddy Posted December 7 Author Posted December 7 18 minutes ago, madonnas said: I'm going to do this but it's tough, I'm going to look like a hater to Whitney/Celine/Mariah - decent albums, but TB/Control/ROL are all among my top 25 of all time. It's fine honey. We listen and we don't judge 3 minutes ago, blown away said: Now that Janet's 2 mixtapes have passed, I'd love to join. There are some gems among each of these albums. Not u skipping the first two rates on purpose (or maybe not)
ATRL Moderator madonnas Posted December 7 ATRL Moderator Posted December 7 Just now, Saddy said: It's fine honey. We listen and we don't judge Not u skipping the first two rates on purpose (or maybe not) I'm not a hater btw! but Control is IMO the best album of all time, rhythm of love is perfection , true blue is sooooo overhated by M fans... so when I have to put Music Box next to them SORRY Mimi, but Ive Been Thinking About You can get an 11 and so can Susan. 1
blown away Posted December 7 Posted December 7 4 minutes ago, Saddy said: Not u skipping the first two rates on purpose (or maybe not) I actually saw the first one and wanted to participate, but I forgot to submit in time and I completely missed the thread for the second rate. 1
Saddy Posted December 8 Author Posted December 8 Listened to Janet's Control and it was kinda good. Definitely better than her 2 previous ones
Saddy Posted December 9 Author Posted December 9 Just a quick reminder before ATRL goes offline again (or maybe not lol) Don't forget about this rate cuties. If you don't want me to continue to tag you, please let me know (or if you want me to add you to the tag list) @Mariya Takeuchi @KillingYourCareer @jacklovesyou1 @ChooseyLover @Curaga @Soda Pop Queen @GraceRandolph @SoldierofLove @allforyou @Ewan Chaos @sparrowblue @Nightingale @Quicksand @poki @creativity. @Ace Reject @pinkbowvintage @Suilen @Achilles. @supaspaz @madonnas @blown away 3 1
confide in me Posted December 9 Posted December 9 I think i'm gonna join this series with this rate! I've heard all of them but Whitney and Celine 1
Saddy Posted December 9 Author Posted December 9 4 minutes ago, confide in me said: I think i'm gonna join this series with this rate! I've heard all of them but Whitney and Celine Take your time with Whitney and Celine
Recommended Posts