rate Mariah Carey's Discography Rate | Top 246-1 Revealed

[James_Dean]

8 minutes ago, suburbannature said:

I am STILL pissed this couldn't be on Emancipation. One of my favorite Mariah deep cuts

When she includes it in The Rarities II

[Devin]

Finally got time to attend.

 

Spoiler

and a bit tipsy 

 

[naval23]

When Ypu Believe outlasting Through the Rain 

[Quiqui4eva]

Disgusting that The Wind was knocked out already  I should’ve voted 

[suburbannature]

15 minutes ago, naval23 said:

When Ypu Believe outlasting Through the Rain 

 

[Ken Lee]

On 12/21/2022 at 2:46 PM, Saddy said:

191. Heat
Score: 6.183

High score: 10 (Saddy, JoAddams, Pecinta Mariah, Quicksand, curiosity)
Low score: 0 (Limitless)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "they said I couldn’t come no harder wanna sleep on this heat don’t bother"

Y'all hate fun

 

On 12/21/2022 at 3:16 PM, Saddy said:

181. Camouflage
Score: 6.419

High score: 11 (killer_rose, Melancholy)
Low score: 0 (rocket)

 

Noooooo literally one of her best and most devastating ballads

 

On 12/21/2022 at 3:21 PM, Saddy said:

179. I Wish You Well
Score: 6.442

High score: 11 (suburbannature)
Low score: 0 (jacklovesyou1)

 

Among her best closers 

 

On 12/21/2022 at 3:24 PM, Saddy said:

178. Bye Bye
Score: 6.467

High score: 11 (Ken Lee)
Low score: 0 (Sjane, suburbannature)

 

Opinions:
james_dean: "Appreciate the message, but no."
pickachoo: "a great song that is hated because people say it was 'mariahs downfall'"

This hymn may have ended her career but boy was it worth it 

 

On 12/23/2022 at 9:39 AM, Saddy said:

160. You're So Cold
Score: 6.636

 

High score: 11 (jacklovesyou1)
Low score: 0 (xfreshkidxx)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "my jaw dropped the first time I heard this. the sharpest, cleanest, most powerful whistle of all time."

Y'all hate fun

 

On 12/23/2022 at 9:54 AM, Saddy said:

155. Cool On You
Score: 6.659

 

High score: 11 (Ken Lee)
Low score: 1 (Onopka, xfreshkidxx, Bacardo Royale)

 

Y'ALL HATE FUN

 

2 hours ago, Saddy said:

150. Jesus Oh What A Wonderful Child
Score: 6.728

High score: 11 (Zaynsus, Ken Lee)
Low score: 0 (jacklovesyou1)

 

 

This hymn... I can hear god

 

2 hours ago, Saddy said:

148. Cry.
Score: 6.733

 

High score: 10 (JoAddams, killer_rose, Ken Lee, Limitless, Reverie, Melancholy, Bacardo Royale, curiosity)
Low score: 1 (DemDam92, xfreshkidxx)

 

Opinions:
pop culture: "I wish I could rate it higher, but the badly melodyned vocals are laughable"
james_dean: "Most boring opener. I can’t recall the last time I listened to it in full."

MIAMTEC Moo was in her bag with these ballads... my god

 

1 hour ago, Saddy said:

129. The Art Of Letting Go
Score: 6.978

 

High score: 11 (Saddy, Zaynsus, Ken Lee, James_Dean)
Low score: 1 (Devin, sparrowblue)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "oh it’s just exceedingly hurtful."
james_dean: "Should have been on the standard. The best song on the album idc."

That’s my mama and y’all can tweet you can do whateva you can tweet till you get blue in the face I don’t care she can have whatever she want cause that’s my mama

[naval23]

17 minutes ago, Ken Lee said:

That’s my mama and y’all can tweet you can do whateva you can tweet till you get blue in the face I don’t care she can have whatever she want cause that’s my mama

😭😭😭

 

[Melancholy]

2 hours ago, Saddy said:

james_dean: "******* hate this song."

******* hate you

[JoAddams]

Lambs really hates TEOM & Charmbracelet 

 

3 hours ago, Saddy said:

139. Meteorite
Score: 6.859

 

High score: 11 (Kiss It Better)
Low score: 1 (That Bad Eartha, Onopka, xfreshkidxx, rocket)

 

Opinions
Keter: "it’s giving dancefloor chanteuse"

 

3 hours ago, Saddy said:

140. Sweetheart
Score: 6.858

 

High score: 11 (jacklovesyou1, Quicksand)
Low score: 0 (Keter)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "get the **** outta here"

bops deserve better 

Edited December 24, 2022 by JoAddams

[°ColdFire°]

Thirsty and O.O.C. out?

 

Cancel Christmas, please!

Bring 503's back!

[Guest]

3 hours ago, Saddy said:

131. O.O.C.
Score: 6.956

High score: 11 (Zaynsus, Limitless)
Low score: 0 (Bacardo Royale)

 

THIS DESERVES BETTER! F*CKIN F*GUETTES!

3 hours ago, suburbannature said:

Trash, I fear

watch your mouth! 

3 hours ago, Saddy said:

No 

I CHIRPED, a bit!

3 hours ago, Saddy said:

128. To Be Around You
Score: 7.000

 

High score: 11 (That Bad Eartha, Limitless, Reverie, Melancholy, Bacardo Royale)
Low score: 1 (xfreshkidxx)

 

Opinions:
Limitless: "no, you don’t understand, I am OBSESSED!"
Keter: "i'm in heaven babe!"

TBAU, sweetie, I am SO sorry!

2 hours ago, Devin said:

Finally got time to attend.

 

  Hide contents

and a bit tipsy 

 

So glad you could join us, BRO!

3 minutes ago, °ColdFire° said:

Thirsty and O.O.C. out?

 

Cancel Christmas, please!

Bring 503's back!

 

[Pecinta Mariah]

6 hours ago, Saddy said:

129. The Art Of Letting Go
Score: 6.978

 

High score: 11 (Saddy, Zaynsus, Ken Lee, James_Dean)
Low score: 1 (Devin, sparrowblue)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "oh it’s just exceedingly hurtful."
james_dean: "Should have been on the standard. The best song on the album idc."

This such a grower, deserved better placement

[Kool_Aid_King]

This rate is so damn random LMFAO. The fact that Irresistible and The Wind made it that far  

[Quicksand]

On 12/23/2022 at 7:11 AM, Saddy said:

168. Mesmerized
Score: 6.569

 

High score: 11 (Melancholy, Quicksand)
Low score: 0 (xfreshkidxx)

 

A CRIME

[Quicksand]

On 12/23/2022 at 7:51 AM, Saddy said:

156. My All (Morales "My" Club Mix)
Score: 6.658

High score: 10 (BenAmuro, SinnerCity, Zaynsus, killer_rose, Keter, Ken Lee, curiosity)
Low score: 1 (Miss Show Business, xfreshkidxx, Bacardo Royale)

 

This not making top 50 

[Quicksand]

11 hours ago, Saddy said:

142. Your Girl
Score: 6.817

 

High score: 11 (Melancholy, Quicksand)
Low score: 0 (Pecinta Mariah)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "another deviation from the norm for her. This surprised me too."

WHAT 

[Quicksand]

11 hours ago, Saddy said:

140. Sweetheart
Score: 6.858

 

High score: 11 (jacklovesyou1, Quicksand)
Low score: 0 (Keter)

 

Opinions:
Keter: "get the **** outta here"

The Lambs underrate this so much

[Saddy]

25 minutes ago, ONOPKA said:

my only zero  bye to trash

[Saddy]

I'm gonna post 40 songs today, starting in 5 minutes 

@JoAddams @BenAmuro @Miss Show Business @Nightingale @Kiss It Better @Devin @SinnerCity @DemDam92 @GraceRandolph @Zaynsus @killer_rose @Ken Lee @Pecinta Mariah @That Bad Eartha @Keter @ONOPKA @Limitless @Pop culture @Reverie @sparrowblue @jacklovesyou1 @°ColdFire° @Quicksand @suburbannature @xfreshkidxx @SJane @James_Dean @Ivory. @Pikachoo @Bacardo Royale @Melancholy @xrosup @Curiosity @Rocket @Kool_Aid_King

[suburbannature]

 

its 8am in Murrica but I’m here for it 

[xrosup]

It's too early  

[Saddy]

120. When I saw you
Score: 7.097

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, Onopka, °ColdFire°)
Low score: 1 (Sjane)

 

[SinnerCity]

2 minutes ago, suburbannature said:

 

its 8am in Murrica but I’m here for it 

It's 1pm in the UK, so let me spend my lunch break questioning y'all taste 

 

[Saddy]

119. You Got Me
Score: 7.100

 

High score: 11 (Reverie, Bacardo Royale)
Low score: 2 (Quicksand)

 

[suburbannature]

2 minutes ago, Saddy said:

120. When I saw you
Score: 7.097

 

High score: 11 (JoAddams, Onopka, °ColdFire°)
Low score: 1 (Sjane)

 

Everyone was really soft on this song this time around. I guess it grew on us.