Inspired from Brandy v Alicia stans on Twitter

Which song is better, bigger, and more remembered?

 

No One and Girl On Fire are 2 of the most annoying songs I’ve ever heard. Boy Is Mine is a classique. 

The Boy Is Mine to No One

 

I didn’t even know who you were talking about with “No One” from the title. 
 

Boy is mine.

The Boy Is Mine and it’s not even close 

I dont even know what The Boy Is Mine is until i joined this site 

 

The GLOBAL Song aka NO ONE 

The Boy is Mine popped up randomly today and it's still a bop. The back and forth, Monica's and Brandy's vocals, the instrumentation are all fire.

 

Alicia's songs have grown out of favor with me since her vocals have been pretty messy and her hooks/melodic choices don't really leave a lasting impression. I mean, Diary and Like You'll Never See Again are my jams but gawd, my ears hurt whenever I hear New York, No One, Girl On Fire, etc etc. There's more grating than good, imo. 

 

Easy choice. 

15 minutes ago, Cryptique said:

I dont even know what The Boy Is Mine is until i joined this site 

 

The GLOBAL Song aka NO ONE 

 

OT: TBIM is an R&B classic, No One is a cute hit.

i love the boy is mine but no one was huge. i dont get the alicia disrespect, give the credits where is due

46 minutes ago, Karla Cabello said:

i love the boy is mine but no one was huge. i dont get the alicia disrespect, give the credits where is due

right...

the comparison is actually fair because both are R&B classic, idk why some people are pissed about No One and mistaking their favorite song to the bigger one 

The Boy Is Mine

No One is a clasic where I'm from. Boy is Mine was never huge in Asia to begin with. 

Objectively I think The Boy is Mine is bigger/more acclaimed/more remembered but I still prefer No One

the boy is mine feels more like an event