Just now, Ace Reject said:

There you have it - that's your rate.

YAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

 

THANK YOU  

I would maybe replace Rachel with 5H but this is a cute list

LEA ALWAYS WIN!

 

 

Not being cocky, Ace. Thanks. I appreciate it

 

 

5H 

Well I'll definitely participate anyway!  

I'll do the formatting tomorrow and open the thread then

Lea is the only one I haven't heard so I'll be doing it too  The Tove rate has 70+ participants and the Fergie/Kehlani threads had lots of posts so this rate could turn out to be a success

Well actually ....

 

Fergie

Fifth Harmony

Nelly

I guess, since you love her, Lea

 

THAT's YOUR RATE.

 

Completely forgot about that true flop album they served!

2 minutes ago, Ace Reject said:

Well actually ....

 

Fergie

Fifth Harmony

Nelly

I guess, since you love her, Lea

 

THAT's YOUR RATE.

 

Completely forgot about that true flop album they served!

Wait what. What.

 

At least let me have Rachel Platten too then   

 

Since her album actually did flop more than Fifth Harmony

Yeah sorry you can't have a rate called "Flops of 2017" on a pop music forum and NOT rate Fifth Harmony. It's not possible!

I just thought of an idea for a rate

 

EP's rate including:

Bebe Rexha - All Your Fault

Julia Michaels - Nervous System

Madison Beer - As She Pleases

Sigrid - Don't Kill My Vibe

Billie Eilish - don't smile at me

Bea Miller - Chapter 1/2/3

Fergie, 5H, Kehlani, Tove, and... Lea would be such a smash rate tbh 

 

 

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

Yeah sorry you can't have a rate called "Flops of 2017" on a pop music forum and NOT rate Fifth Harmony. It's not possible!

Thank you.  (Even if I’m a stan I wanna rate their flop album )

DEFINITELY participating in this

1 minute ago, Ace Reject said:

Yeah sorry you can't have a rate called "Flops of 2017" on a pop music forum and NOT rate Fifth Harmony. It's not possible!

I'll happily include Fifth Harmony. 

But I had five albums and you've replaced one and took away one   

So is it okay if I put Waves back in? Along with Fifth ?

1 minute ago, Loyalty said:

Fergie, 5H, Kehlani, Tove, and... Lea would be such a smash rate tbh 

 

 

FORGET THOSE TWO.

We are actually getting somewhere. STOP  

Sure why not

Just now, Ace Reject said:

Sure why not

okay, thank you very much!

 

--

NO MORE CHANGES.

 

 

2 minutes ago, Lukey said:

FORGET THOSE TWO.

We are actually getting somewhere. STOP  

These two would have made this rate a hit rate but welp

 

 

6 minutes ago, Moonlightbae said:

I just thought of an idea for a rate

 

EP's rate including:

Bebe Rexha - All Your Fault

Julia Michaels - Nervous System

Madison Beer - As She Pleases

Sigrid - Don't Kill My Vibe

Billie Eilish - don't smile at me

Bea Miller - Chapter 1/2/3

@Ace Reject what do you think about that?

I can change the EPs but about the overall idea

 

2 minutes ago, Moonlightbae said:

These two would have made this rate a hit rate but welp

I'm not one that's focused too much on a hit rate or not. 

Omg nooo Blue Lips is flawless and it bombed  and there's lots of Tove fans on ATRL who could have participated

2 minutes ago, Moonlightbae said:

@Ace Reject what do you think about that?

I can change the EPs but about the overall idea

 

Ooh I would participate for AYF and ASP  

Wait wasn’t Blue Lips used in the disco rate? Or does that not count as a use?

1 minute ago, K$Ellie said:

Omg nooo Blue Lips is flawless and it bombed  and there's lots of Tove fans on ATRL who could have participated

OMGG OKAY
 

CAN I REPLACE THE RIDE WITH BLUE LIPS