Saddy Posted October 22 Posted October 22 (edited) Welcome to the 2nd rate of pre-2000s divas (Janet, Madonna, Whitney, Kylie, Mariah and Celine). Last time we were rating their debut albums (you can check the results here if you didn't participate and/or missed the reveal) and now it's time to rate their 2nd album a.k.a sophomore albums. You can also invite your friends to participate Rules: Rate each song from 1 to 10. Decimals are allowed but only to 1 decimal place (7.8 is fine, but 7.82 is not). Now you can give each album 11 but only ONCE (example, if u gave 'Can't Let Go' from 'Emotions' 11, u can't give other song from this album another 11), but only ONE 0 (example, if u gave 'Can't Let Go' from 'Emotions' 0, u can't give any other song from 'Emotions' or other album 0). Rate only songs that are on the list. Comments are optional. Send your ballot to me via DM (pls copy and paste the list below). Deadline: November 21st Song List Spoiler Dream Street (1984) Don't Stand Another Chance Two to the Power of Love Pretty Boy Dream Street Communication Fast Girls Hold Back the Tears All My Love to You If It Takes All Night Like a Virgin (1984) Material Girl Angel Like a Virgin Over and Over Love Don't Live Here Anymore Dress You Up Shoo-Bee-Doo Pretender Stay Whitney (1987) I Wanna Dance with Somebody (Who Loves Me) Just the Lonely Talking Again Love Will Save the Day Didn't We Almost Have It All So Emotional Where You Are Love Is a Contact Sport You're Still My Man For the Love of You Where Do Broken Hearts Go I Know Him So Well Enjoy Yourself (1989) Hand on Your Heart Wouldn't Change a Thing Never Too Late Nothing to Lose Tell Tale Signs My Secret Heart I'm Over Dreaming (Over You) Tears on My Pillow Heaven and Earth Enjoy Yourself Emotions (1991) Emotions And You Don't Remember Can't Let Go Make It Happen If It's Over You're So Cold So Blessed To Be Around You Till the End of Time The Wind Celine Dion (1992) Love Can Move Mountains Show Some Emotion If You Asked Me To If You Could See Me Now Halfway to Heaven Did You Give Enough Love If I Were You Beauty and the Beast I Love You, Goodbye Little Bit of Love Water from the Moon With This Tear Nothing Broken but My Heart Edited November 25 by Saddy 1 2
Saddy Posted October 22 Author Posted October 22 (edited) Participants Spoiler 1. @Saddy 2. @Mariya Takeuchi 3. @Album Leak 4. @GreatestLoveofAll 5. @KillingYourCareer 6. @jacklovesyou1 7. @ChooseyLover 8. @Curaga 9. @Soda Pop Queen 10. @GraceRandolph 11. @SoldierofLove 12. @allforyou 13. @Ewan Chaos 14. @sparrowblue 15. @Nightingale 16. @Quicksand 17. @poki Results Spoiler #62 Fast Girls by Janet | Score: 3.76 #61 Communication by Janet | Score: 3.90 #60 Two to the Power of Love by Janet | Score: 4.31 #59 All My Love to You by Janet | Score: 4.57 #58 Heaven and Earth by Kylie | Score: 4.59 #57 My Secret Heart by Kylie | Score: 4.65 #56 Pretty Boy by Janet | Score: 4.67 #55 Dream Street by Janet | Score: 4.78 #54 Don't Stand Another Chance by Janet | Score: 5.08 #53 Shoo-Bee-Doo by Madonna | Score: 5.24 #52 Hold Back the Tears by Janet | Score: 5.25 #51 For the Love of You by Whitney | Score: 5.36 #50 Where You Are by Whitney | Score: 5.39 #49 Pretender by Madonna | Score: 5.41 #48 Little Bit of Love by Celine | Score: 5.46 #47 I Know Him So Well by Whitney | Score: 5.54 #46 Love Will Save the Day by Whitney | Score: 5.56 #45 You're Still My Man by Whitney | Score: 5.65 #44 Tell Tale Signs by Kylie | Score: 5.67 #43 Love Don't Live Here Anymore by Madonna | Score: 5.76 #42 Over and Over by Madonna | Score: 5.78 #41 Love Is a Contact Sport by Whitney | Score: 5.82 #40 If I Were You by Celine | Score: 5.96 #39 I Love You, Goodbye by Celine | Score: 6.01 #38 If You Could See Me Now by Celine | Score: 6.03 #37 Show Some Emotion by Celine | Score: 6.08 #36 If It Takes All Night by Janet | Score: 6.09 #35 Stay by Madonna | Score: 6.11 #34 With This Tear by Celine | Score: 6.16 #33 Halfway to Heaven by Celine | Score: 6.19 #32 Till the End of Time by Mariah | Score: 6.21 #31 Water from the Moon by Celine | Score: 6.28 #30 To Be Around You by Mariah | Score: 6.30 #29 Enjoy Yourself by Kylie | Score: 6.32 #28 Tears on My Pillow by Kylie | Score: 6.36 #27 Just the Lonely Talking Again by Whitney | Score: 6.38 #26 Nothing Broken but My Heart by Celine | Score: 6.48 #25 Love Can Move Mountains by Celine | Score: 6.62 #24 I'm Over Dreaming (Over You) by Kylie | Score: 6.66 #23 So Blessed by Mariah | Score: 6.67 #22 Wouldn't Change a Thing by Kylie | Score: 6.69 #21 If It's Over by Mariah | Score: 6.76 #20 Nothing to Lose by Kylie | Score: 6.79 #19 Did You Give Enough Love by Celine | Score: 6.84 #18 Angel by Madonna | Score: 6.94 #17 And You Don't Remember by Mariah | Score: 7.00 #16 Hand on Your Heart by Kylie | Score: 7.08 #15 The Wind by Mariah | Score: 7.09 #14 You're So Cold by Mariah | Score: 7.11 #13 Where Do Broken Hearts Go by Whitney | Score: 7.23 #12 Beauty and the Beast by Celine | Score: 7.26 #11 If You Asked Me To by Celine | Score: 7.30 #10 Didn't We Almost Have It All by Whitney | Score: 7.31 #9 Never Too Late by Kylie | Score: 7.97 #8 Make It Happen by Mariah | Score: 8.01 #7 Dress You Up by Madonna | Score: 8.08 #6 Can't Let Go by Mariah | Score: 8.16 #5 I Wanna Dance with Somebody (Who Loves Me) by Whitney | Score: 8.58 #4 So Emotional by Whitney | Score: 8.74 #3 Like a Virgin by Madonna | Score: 8.82 #2 Material Girl by Madonna | Score: 9.06 #1 Emotions by Mariah | Score: 9.32 Edited November 26 by Saddy
Saddy Posted October 22 Author Posted October 22 @GraceRandolph@Album Leak@GreatestLoveofAll@Soda Pop Queen@KillingYourCareer@ChooseyLoverMariya Takeuchi@Curaga@creativity.@Ace Reject@pinkbowvintage@sparrowblue@Nightingale@SoldierofLove@Suilen@Ewan Chaos@Achilles.@jacklovesyou1@supaspaz@poki Since y'all participated in the first rate I decided to tag y'all 1 4
Album Leak Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Oh heck yeah, this'll be fun! And here I was thinking I'll go to sleep early. I'll be sending my scores in 24 hours 2
Saddy Posted October 22 Author Posted October 22 (edited) 2 minutes ago, Album Leak said: Oh heck yeah, this'll be fun! And here I was thinking I'll go to sleep early. I'll be sending my scores in 24 hours Omg I guess rip Janet Edit: remember that now u can give each album one 11 Edited October 22 by Saddy
Album Leak Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Just now, Saddy said: Omg I guess rip Janet Well, I'm pretty confident she'll be getting a 4 in one song. Highest score I gave in the debut album was 3. She is improving, me thinks! 1
Saddy Posted October 22 Author Posted October 22 I hope this rate is gonna be pinned too, we need more ppl to join this messy rate
suburbannature Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Emotions soul classic that it is better eat this 1
Saddy Posted October 22 Author Posted October 22 2 minutes ago, suburbannature said: Emotions soul classic that it is better eat this U better participate then
Curaga Posted October 22 Posted October 22 omg the sophomore albums so soon! You were behind the scenes WORKING! Janet's, Mariah's, and Céline's albums will all be new to me, so I probably won't submit till close to the deadline I'm hoping I can find some of the Janet songs enjoyable like I did with her debut, but it seems like people hate Dream Street even worse based on the comments I've seen so far ddd 1
Saddy Posted October 22 Author Posted October 22 2 minutes ago, Curaga said: omg the sophomore albums so soon! You were behind the scenes WORKING! Didn't want to wait too long, cuz some ppl were asking to start the 2nd rate asap 3 minutes ago, Curaga said: I'm hoping I can find some of the Janet songs enjoyable like I did with her debut, but it seems like people hate Dream Street even worse based on the comments I've seen so far ddd This will be my 4th time listening to it and honestly it's not that bad. Definitely not perfect like her next albums but definitely not the worst. So you might actually like this album like I did when I first heard it 1
ChooseyLover Posted October 22 Posted October 22 (edited) We'll exit these rates having turned into diva connoisseurs I'm only familiar with Mariah, Kylie and Madonna's albums (I was too turned off by Janet's to listen more than once) so this should be fun. Edited October 22 by ChooseyLover 3
Album Leak Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Is Dream Street better than her debut? Well after listening to it.. sorta kinda...
SoldierofLove Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Looking forward to this! Thanks for organizing again @Saddy! Nude swaps now open to coordinate rating our faves. Preview: Spoiler Yes, that's me. More available for 11s! 1
Saddy Posted October 22 Author Posted October 22 Just now, Album Leak said: Is Dream Street better than her debut? Well after listening to it.. sorta kinda... See? I told y'all
Album Leak Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Just now, Saddy said: See? I told y'all The last three songs kinda saved it tbh. 1
KillingYourCareer Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Poor Janet, she surely won't stand another chance here! 2
Album Leak Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Kylie's album was surprisingly weak, though I wouldn't say her debut was all that either. But her debut had I Should Be So Lucky and Loco-Motion which really improved it's score. I am debating whether I want to give a 11 to Whitney's IWDWS or not, because it's going to be super predictable and I think another song I love could benefit from it more, even if I wouldn't say I like it more than IWDWS. BUT, do I want Material Girl, Like a Virgin or Emotions winning over IWDWS? Still have to listen to Mariah's and Celine's albums, I'm hoping Celine will surprise me. Celine's album will have Beauty and the Beast, wonder how that's going to place in the rate. The Disney nostalgia could help it a lot, or maybe people are tired of Disney and have little nostalgia for it, idk. And none for Janet Jackson, BYE. 1
Saddy Posted October 22 Author Posted October 22 Received the 1st ballot (2nd if counting myself) I'm kinda wondering if sophomore rate is gonna be way better (in the number of participants) than the debut rate
Ewan Chaos Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Poor Janet getting a back-to-back lashing, just wait until album 3 though This Kylie album is way worse than her debut so I don't think I'll be giving her graces just for being one of my faves... but there will be a few high scores sprinkled in. LAV is for sure my least favorite 80s Madonna album, which is a shame cuz if they'd cut a song or two and added in Into the Groove then it'd leap up to being her 2nd best 80s album. BUT. It will be getting some high scores and my favorite Madonna song is on here. So I can't wait for it to undeniably flop with my luck! And then Celine, Mariah (sans singles) & Whitney (besides Dance) will be new for me. 1
Recommended Posts