Saddy Posted September 14 Posted September 14 (edited) Yes, you read that correctly - The Holy Sexternity (Mariah, Madonna, Janet, Whitney, Celine and Kylie) debut album rate is here. These albums are different, unique, but what they in common is that they are from incredible singers that we still love, adore and hold a special place in our hearts Rules: Rate each song from 1 to 10. Decimals are allowed but only to 1 decimal place (7.8 is fine, but 7.82 is not). You can give ONE song 11 and 0. Rate only songs that are on the list. Comments are optional. Send your ballot to me via DM (pls copy and paste the list below). DUE DATE: October 14th Song List Spoiler Janet Jackson (1982) Say You Do You'll Never Find (A Love Like Mine) Young Love Love and My Best Friend Don't Mess Up This Good Thing Forever Yours The Magic Is Working Come Give Your Love to Me Madonna (1983) Lucky Star Borderline Burning Up I Know It Holiday Think of Me Physical Attraction Everybody Burning Up" (12" Version) Lucky Star" (New Mix) Whitney Houston (1985) You Give Good Love Thinking About You Someone for Me Saving All My Love for You Nobody Loves Me Like You Do How Will I Know All at Once Take Good Care of My Heart Greatest Love of All Hold Me Kylie (1988) I Should Be So Lucky The Loco-Motion Je ne sais pas pourquoi It's No Secret Got to Be Certain Turn It Into Love I Miss You I'll Still Be Loving You Look My Way Love at First Sight Mariah Carey (1990) Vision of Love There's Got to Be a Way I Don't Wanna Cry Someday Vanishing All in Your Mind Alone in Love You Need Me Sent from Up Above Prisoner Love Takes Time Unison (1990) (If There Was) Any Other Way If Love Is Out of the Question Where Does My Heart Beat Now The Last to Know I'm Loving Every Moment with You Love by Another Name Unison I Feel Too Much If We Could Start Over Have a Heart Edited October 20 by Saddy 7 1
Saddy Posted September 14 Author Posted September 14 (edited) Participants Spoiler 1. @Saddy 2. @GraceRandolph 3. @Album Leak 4. @GreatestLoveofAll 5. @Soda Pop Queen 6. @KillingYourCareer 7. @ChooseyLover 8. @Mariya Takeuchi 9. @Curaga 10. @creativity. 11. @Ace Reject 12. @pinkbowvintage 13. @sparrowblue 14. @Nightingale 15. @SoldierofLove 16. @Suilen 17. @Ewan Chaos 18. @Achilles. 19. @jacklovesyou1 20. @supaspaz 21. @poki Results Spoiler #59 Forever Yours by Janet | Score: 4.14 #58 Nobody Loves Me Like You Do by Whitney | Score: 4.52 #57 Love and My Best Friend by Janet | Score: 4.74 #56 Hold Me by Whitney | Score: 5.00 #55 The Magic Is Working by Janet | Score: 5.06 #54 I Know It by Madonna | Score: 5.43 #53 Take Good Care of My Heart by Whitney | Score: 5.47 #52 Don't Mess Up This Good Thing by Janet | Score: 5.55 #51 Come Give Your Love to Me by Janet | Score: 5.59 #50 Lucky Star (New Mix) by Madonna | Score: 5.68 #49 Have a Heart by Celine | Score: 5.70 #48 I'll Still Be Loving You by Kylie | Score: 5.71 #47 Unison by Celine | Score: 5.76 #46 Thinking About You by Whitney | Score: 5.77 #45 Love by Another Name by Celine | Score: 5.79 #44 If We Could Start Over by Celine | Score: 5.89 #43 Look My Way by Kylie | Score: 5.90 #42 Think of Me by Madonna | Score: 5.92 #41 Love at First Sight by Kylie | Score: 6.01 #40 Someone for Me by Whitney | Score: 6.04 #39 I'm Loving Every Moment with You by Celine | Score: 6.06 #38 I Miss You by Kylie | Score: 6.24 #37 Young Love by Janet | Score: 6.29 #36 If Love Is Out of the Question by Celine | Score: 6.35 #35 It's No Secret by Kylie | Score: 6.41 #34 You'll Never Find (A Love Like Mine) by Janet | Score: 6.42 #33 Got to Be Certain by Kylie | Score: 6.52 #32 Physical Attraction by Madonna | Score: 6.55 #31 Say You Do by Janet | Score: 6.60 #30 The Last to Know by Celine | Score: 6.62 #29 I Feel Too Much by Celine | Score: 6.66 #28 Sent from Up Above by Mariah | Score: 6.68 #27 Everybody by Madonna | Score: 6.70 #26 Burning Up by Madonna | Score: 6.71 #25 You Need Me by Mariah | Score: 6.72 #24 There's Got to Be a Way by Mariah | Score: 6.74 #23 The Loco-Motion by Kylie | Score: 6.80 #22 Alone in Love by Mariah | Score: 6.82 #21 Turn It Into Love by Kylie | Score: 6.88 #20 All at Once by Whitney | Score: 6.90 #19 Je ne sais pas pourquoi by Kylie | Score: 6.91 #18 Burning Up (12" Version) by Madonna | Score: 6.95 #17 Vanishing by Mariah | Score: 6.97 #16 You Give Good Love by Whitney | Score: 6.98 #15 I Don't Wanna Cry by Mariah | Score: 7.01 #14 All in Your Mind by Mariah | Score: 7.07 #13 Lucky Star by Madonna | Score: 7.25 #12 Greatest Love of All by Whitney | Score: 7.36 #11 (If There Was) Any Other Way by Celine | Score: 7.40 #10 I Should Be So Lucky by Kylie | Score: 7.57 #9 Saving All My Love for You by Whitney | Score: 7.71 #8 Love Takes Time by Mariah | Score: 7.82 #7 Where Does My Heart Beat Now by Celine | Score: 8.02 #6 Prisoner by Mariah | Score: 8.04 #5 Holiday by Madonna | Score: 8.20 #4 Vision of Love by Mariah | Score: 8.49 #3 Someday by Mariah | Score: 8.53 #2 Borderline by Madonna | Score: 8.68 #1 How Will I Know by Whitney | Score: 8.89 Edited October 21 by Saddy
KillingYourCareer Posted September 14 Posted September 14 Interesting! I'm worried about Céline's debut ngl, but I'll surely participate. 1
Achilles. Posted September 14 Posted September 14 I feel like using Celine's French album is gonna disadvantage her. Would it be better to sub in her English language debut? Listened to Janet's debut for the first time this year and it was pretty strong. Happy for a reason to revisit it. Borderline + How Will I Know should be top 2. 1
KillingYourCareer Posted September 14 Posted September 14 2 minutes ago, Achilles. said: I feel like using Celine's French album is gonna disadvantage her. Would it be better to sub in her English language debut? I agree, the poor sis is totally getting the boot entirely during the first reveal. Unison would do her better 1
Into The Void Posted September 14 Posted September 14 A French album will be slaughtered ur sabotaging Celine lol 1
Saddy Posted September 14 Author Posted September 14 (edited) 1 hour ago, Achilles. said: I feel like using Celine's French album is gonna disadvantage her. Would it be better to sub in her English language debut? I was thinking about that too, but i was worried that y'all would eat me alive for not using the real debut I'll change it to Unison then Edited September 14 by Saddy
KillingYourCareer Posted September 14 Posted September 14 7 minutes ago, Saddy said: I was thinking about that too, but i was worried that y'all would eat me alive for not using the real debut I'll change it to Unison then Thank heavens for that! 1
Saddy Posted September 14 Author Posted September 14 9 minutes ago, KillingYourCareer said: Thank heavens for that! No prob
holyground13 Posted September 14 Posted September 14 I feel like using Janet's 1982 debut is gonna disadvantage her compared to Control too, but that's just my opinion. Happy to vote either way 3
Saddy Posted September 15 Author Posted September 15 2 hours ago, holyground13 said: I feel like using Janet's 1982 debut is gonna disadvantage her compared to Control too, but that's just my opinion. Happy to vote either way Her debut is good, I really love this album. It's way better than her second one tho
SoldierofLove Posted September 15 Posted September 15 (edited) Sounds fun! Thanks for organizing @Saddy! @ the erasure of Celine's French debut. But it's for the best The campaign starts now! Spoiler Send payola my way to buy my 11s for your fave tracks! Check your DMs for my nudes after sending me proof of your 11 rate for I Feel Too Much Also open to trading nudes Edited September 15 by SoldierofLove 1
Bussea Posted September 15 Posted September 15 oh janet sweetie. i know yall are going to DESTROY her 4
jacklovesyou1 Posted September 15 Posted September 15 Love this idea !! I'm deffo down ... hopefully the rate ends up being a hit so we can slowly go through all their discovery's Part 3 is gonna be messy AF tho lmao 1
ChooseyLover Posted September 15 Posted September 15 I'm a bit worried about Janet's album not being Control too, but since she acknowledged the anniversaries of it in her stories and some of y'all like it I might give it another chance. I lowkey wish Kylie was in the competition too tbh. But by all means count me in! 2
Suilen Posted September 15 Posted September 15 I'll give this a try, I've been meaning to explore Celine's discography and maybe revisit Mariah's, so this is a good opportunity to do that. 1
Saddy Posted September 15 Author Posted September 15 7 hours ago, jacklovesyou1 said: Love this idea !! I'm deffo down ... hopefully the rate ends up being a hit so we can slowly go through all their discovery's Part 3 is gonna be messy AF tho lmao Yes, I'm hoping for this too 1
Saddy Posted September 15 Author Posted September 15 I hope this error thing will be fixed soon, cuz it's gonna be almost imposible to host this rate
Saddy Posted September 16 Author Posted September 16 Just received the first vote. I hope more people will join, so we can move on to the sophomore album rate 1
Ewan Chaos Posted September 16 Posted September 16 I'd love to do this as I know 3 of these & would love to listen to the other two! Keep me on the tag list please. 1
Saddy Posted September 16 Author Posted September 16 4 hours ago, sparrowblue said: glad i found this gonna do this one too Yay 4 hours ago, Ewan Chaos said: I'd love to do this as I know 3 of these & would love to listen to the other two! Keep me on the tag list please. Sure 1 1
Recommended Posts