ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted October 20 ATRL Moderator Posted October 20 4 hours ago, Saddy said: #29 I Feel Too Much Score: 6.66 High score: 10 @Curaga@creativity.@SoldierofLove Low score: 3 @Album Leak Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "Her closest to the dated sound that makes up a lot of uptempos this era." Not this getting beat out by every Mariah track. Come on now… 2
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted October 20 ATRL Moderator Posted October 20 4 hours ago, Saddy said: #26 Burning Up Score: 6.71 High score: 10 @Soda Pop Queen@Curaga@pinkbowvintage@Ewan Chaos@Achilles. Low score: 1 @Nightingale@poki Comments: Ewan Chaos: "I'm so glad she included this in the Celebration tour. What a fun song and the guitar really makes it punch." Not even top 25?! What are we doing here??? 2
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted October 20 ATRL Moderator Posted October 20 We did not do right by Whitney’s album. Sorry, but some of those cheesy ballads still left are not the true highlights! 1 2
Suilen Posted October 20 Posted October 20 Physical Attraction, The Last to Know, Someone for Me and Turn It Into Love deserved better. 2
sparrowblue Posted October 20 Posted October 20 17 hours ago, Saddy said: #30 The Last to Know Score: 6.62 High score: 10 @Soda Pop Queen@ChooseyLover@Curaga@sparrowblue Low score: 3 @GraceRandolph Comments: Curaga: "Now THAT'S how you do a ballad, mama! Fuckiing stellar instrumental omg" this is top 10 in this rate and would get an 11 if there was more to give 2
sparrowblue Posted October 20 Posted October 20 16 hours ago, Saddy said: #22 Alone in Love Score: 6.82 High score: 11 @Saddy@Soda Pop Queen@sparrowblue Low score: 1 @KillingYourCareer Comments: Curaga: "Her voice is actually flawless in this song " a lot of people don't have ears it seems 1
Soda Pop Queen Posted October 20 Posted October 20 (edited) I knew Janet would be completely out before the top 20. Her debut is the only one without a single hit on it and her album sounds too demo-y even the singles. I mean, she was still just a kid under her father's thumb so it makes sense the album is severely lacking. Some of those Céline songs deserved to be a little higher, especially 'The Last To Know' and 'I'm Loving Every Moment With You.' The former has a great vocal melody and the latter is some nice R&B from the era. Y'all doing Shaylene dirty. Most of Kylie's SAW songs are hilarious. I agree with @Curaga in that she sounds like she's shouting through most of the album. I don't dislike the whole album but I don't think I would've been mad if all her songs were out before the top 20.... except for 'Look My Way'. That's a real cute little funky number. 'Someone For Me' is okay but I think 'Take Good Care of My Heart' is superior, especially with that sax solo, and should've been Whit's highest rated album track. It's clear Clive Davis and Arista spent her album budget on the songs he knew would be singles because everything else is mostly bland and forgettable. Madonna's 'Physical Attraction' is overrated in the base. I would've liked 'Think of Me' to be in it's place. I'd rather even listen to 'Everybody' and I don't even like that one that much. 'Burning Up' should be in the top 20 like what are y'all doing? 'There's Got To Be A Way' should have been out in the first wave and also, 'Alone In Love' should've been top 10. 'Tis all. Edited October 21 by Soda Pop Queen 1
Saddy Posted October 20 Author Posted October 20 @GraceRandolph@Album Leak@GreatestLoveofAll@Soda Pop Queen@KillingYourCareer@ChooseyLoverMariya Takeuchi@Curaga@creativity.@Ace Reject@pinkbowvintage@sparrowblue@Nightingale@SoldierofLove@Suilen@Ewan Chaos@Achilles.@jacklovesyou1@supaspaz@poki Gonna start revealing the top 20 today at 4pm/5pm EST. I'll tag y'all again 30 minutes before I start In the meantime, you can try to guess what the top 20 will look like All at Once All in Your Mind Borderline Burning Up" (12" Version) Greatest Love of All Holiday How Will I Know I Don't Wanna Cry I Should Be So Lucky (If There Was) Any Other Way Je ne sais pas pourquoi Love Takes Time Lucky Star Prisoner Saving All My Love for You Someday Vanishing Vision of Love Where Does My Heart Beat Now You Give Good Love 1 1
Album Leak Posted October 20 Posted October 20 (edited) I know what's not in the top 20 Anyway, ideal top 7! I Should Be So Lucky Someday Vision Of Love How Will I Know Saving All My Love For You Greatest Love Of All Holiday Edited October 20 by Album Leak 1
Saddy Posted October 20 Author Posted October 20 4 minutes ago, Album Leak said: I know what's not in the top 20
Saddy Posted October 20 Author Posted October 20 @GraceRandolph@Album Leak@GreatestLoveofAll@Soda Pop Queen@KillingYourCareer@ChooseyLoverMariya Takeuchi@Curaga@creativity.@Ace Reject@pinkbowvintage@sparrowblue@Nightingale@SoldierofLove@Suilen@Ewan Chaos@Achilles.@jacklovesyou1@supaspaz@poki Starting in 20 minutes 5
creativity. Posted October 20 Posted October 20 I sorta sabotaged I Should Be So Lucky and Greatest Love of All, am wondering if that's gonna affect their results more than I intended
Saddy Posted October 20 Author Posted October 20 1 minute ago, creativity. said: I sorta sabotaged I Should Be So Lucky and Greatest Love of All, am wondering if that's gonna affect their results more than I intended My lips are sealed
Saddy Posted October 20 Author Posted October 20 #20 All at Once Score: 6.90 High score: 11 @KillingYourCareer Low score: 3 @sparrowblue Comments: KillingYourCareer: "I used to think this was a global classic, until I found out it had just been released as a single in Italy and the Netherlands. Radios here still play it regularly. Absolutely one of the most wonderful songs of the old millennium."
Saddy Posted October 20 Author Posted October 20 #19 Je ne sais pas pourquoi Score: 6.91 High score: 10 @KillingYourCareer@Ace Reject Low score: 4 @Album Leak
Saddy Posted October 20 Author Posted October 20 #18 Burning Up (12" Version) Score: 6.95 High score: 10 @Curaga@creativity.@pinkbowvintage@Achilles. Low score: 2 @sparrowblue@Nightingale Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "oooh far superior to the OG." Curaga: "Okayyyyy, what a glow-up! Loved this mix even better than the original." Ewan Chaos: "I mean. It's the same as the original just longer so I'm gonna ding it a little. BOPS though."
ChooseyLover Posted October 20 Posted October 20 (edited) Both songs are supermemorable. I'm expecting an immaculate and packed with timeless songs Top 10 after this. Edit: omg, not Burning Up being out out now Edited October 20 by ChooseyLover 1
Saddy Posted October 20 Author Posted October 20 #17 Vanishing Score: 6.97 High score: 10 @supaspaz Low score: 4.5 @Ewan Chaos Comments: Curaga: "Kinda reminds me of a Carole King tune."
ChooseyLover Posted October 20 Posted October 20 Oh Vanishing... Not surprised tho, only the lambs lambs can appreciate certain songs to the fullest. 1
Recommended Posts