Jump to content

Vanishing Letters 9 | WINNER REVEALED (p.187)| #WinterComing


Recommended Posts

Posted
2 minutes ago, clue said:

More information on the comeback/elimination:

 

1. The comeback kid whose song is ranked in 1st place by the current cast is automatically entered back into the competition

 

2. The current contestant whose song is ranked in 1st place by the comeback kids will select the second comeback kid from that group's top 3

 

3. The two comeback kids who are entered back into the competition will then choose two current contestants from that group's bottom 4 to eliminate

 

 

Not a Bottom 4 :chick3:

  • Replies 4.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • ughgabriel

    409

  • Kavish

    322

  • Dessy

    288

  • Overprotected

    269

Posted
1 minute ago, Rotunda said:

Not a Bottom 4 :chick3:

Love you for the double bump to the next page

Posted

Finally a round I am euthastic for. I enjoyed every song to varying degrees. I wish the comeback girls luck :wanda:

C5jum45.gif

 

 

Aaliyah - If Your Girl Only Knew
This is kinda the perfect vibe for Aaliyah in general. Not really one of her best imo but it’s really good for its time and you can’t just help to sing along. 

 

Fantasia - When I See U
This was cute at the time but now it’s just okay. I don’t hate it though it just isn't top material for me. Fantasia herself was solid as always though. 

 

Lizzo - Truth Hurts
Took a DNA test turns out I’m 100% loving this. I’m still not over part of the song sounding a bit like Rude Boy by Rihanna. But the lyrics >>>> Lizzo's lyricism in general I just really enjoy. 

 

Missy Elliot - Hot Boyz (Remix)
This is a risk. And it was one worth taking IMO. Nas and Eve :jonny:  I’m not sure if it’ll stack up against some of these other songs but I love the effort. 

 

Usher - Climax
Abel WHO? This is the real R&B king of vocals. The high notes. The sadness. The excellence. IT just all came together so perfectly. I’d sing this in my car everytime!

 

Santana - Maria Maria
This is cute actually. I wish it was a BIT shorter but I’m not holding it against it here. Solid choice. 

 

Sean Paul - Get Busy
Classic Sean Paul is always a good vibe. I think this song will be underappreciated by the cast but we will see. For me it’s probably in the upper middle out of what I heard so far.

 

Kelly Rowland - Motivation
WINNER. 
jJbBll9.gif
You won. Of this I am certain. If I'm wrong I'm sending you nudes.

 

Drake - One Dance
I’m here to warn this sender that this ABSOLUTE CLASSIC is about to get panned. Easily top 3 for me. 

 

Earth, Wind & Fire - Let's Groove
Wow you dug deep. It’s fun and made me move which is what you’d expect from the title. Good choice

 

Miguel - Sure Thing
Omg I haven’t heard this song in years. I completely forgot this existed. But I can kinda see why; it’s just a decent song for me now. Nothing to really write home about. However, I do enjoy the lyrics so that's what helping it out for me.
XvkVYwm.gif

 


En Vogue - Don't Let Go (Love)
En Vogue??? I need to hook up with this sender cause whew. The opening alone is :chefskiss:
Actually the entire song, they. Did. Not. Let. Up. And I love that for them. Top 5 for me. 
 

Posted
25 minutes ago, clue said:

More information on the comeback/elimination:

 

1. The comeback kid whose song is ranked in 1st place by the current cast is automatically entered back into the competition

 

2. The current contestant whose song is ranked in 1st place by the comeback kids will select the second comeback kid from that group's top 3

 

3. The two comeback kids who are entered back into the competition will then choose two current contestants from that group's bottom 4 to eliminate

 

 

oh wow!

Posted

oh oops I didn't see it was already bumped ljskfjs

Posted
4 minutes ago, minho said:

the speedy

I only never heard one song before so :wanda:

Posted
4 minutes ago, minho said:

oh wow!

:kii6: ty

Posted (edited)

DEATH ROW GIRLS 

 

IF YOUR GIRL ONLY KNEW: I guess it doesn’t matter what I think about this song, since you sent a banned letter. :rip:
 

WHEN I SEE YOU: :falcon:. Yes bitch rise from the dead! 
 

TRUTH HURTS: A bop, maybe you deserve to be reincarnated. 

HOT BOYZ: This is nice, I’ll give it some thought before making a judgement. 

 

CLIMAX: Ah I remember this. Idk if this is good enough to save you from eternal damnation but I like it. 
 

MARIA MARIA: Wild Thoughts is kinda the new and improved version for me, but it’s not a bad choice. Sadly I don’t think you’ll be pardoned. 
 

GET BUSY: Hell is hot but this song is hotter :flame:

 

MOTIVATION: I should bury you under the jail for stealing this choice from me, but I can’t be mad at you for snagging a smart choice. 
 

ONE DANCE: Happy Kamala Harris GIF by Joe Biden (idk if you’re getting off death row but this is a bop and has grown on me)

 

LET’S GROOVE:  A (very long) classic  Judge Judy GIF by Lifetime Telly

 

SURE THING: Angelic :angelo:


DONT LET GO (LOVE): This isn’t bad but it’s kinda not holding up hereJudge Judy Do Not Want GIF

 

 

Edited by Rotunda
Posted
4 minutes ago, Rotunda said:

DEATH ROW GIRLS 

 

IF YOUR GIRL ONLY KNEW: I guess it doesn’t matter what I think about this song, since you sent a banned letter. :rip:
 

WHEN I SEE YOU: :falcon:. Yes bitch rise from the dead! 
 

TRUTH HURTS: A bop, maybe you deserve to be reincarnated. 

HOT BOYZ: This is nice, I’ll give it some thought before making a judgement. 

 

CLIMAX: Ah I remember this. Idk if this is good enough to save you from eternal damnation but I like it. 
 

MARIA MARIA: Wild Thoughts is kinda the new and improved version for me, but it’s not a bad choice. Sadly I don’t think you’ll be pardoned. 
 

GET BUSY: Hell is hot but this song is hotter :flame:

 

MOTIVATION: I should bury you under the jail for stealing this choice from me, but I can’t be mad at you for snagging a smart choice. 
 

ONE DANCE: Happy Kamala Harris GIF by Joe Biden (idk if you’re getting off death row but this is a bop and has grown on me)

 

LET’S GROOVE:  A (very long) classic  Judge Judy GIF by Lifetime Telly

 

SURE THING: Angelic :angelo:


DONT LET GO (LOVE): This isn’t bad but it’s kinda not holding up hereJudge Judy Do Not Want GIF

 

 

Us being firsts as we should be :wanda:

Posted

2AopB7c.png

 

Aaliyah - If Your Girl Only Knew - R.I.P. 

 

Fantasia - When I See U - A nice throwback. 

 

Lizzo - Truth Hurts - Don't like it really. Sorry. 

 

Missy Elliot - Hot Boyz (Remix) - Hmm it's okay. It doesn't really compare to the highs here however. 

 

Usher - Climax - A return to form after all the dance-pop he was serving before. Very solid entry. 

 

Santana - Maria Maria - A culture classic that I don't spin often anymore. 

 

Sean Paul - Get Busy - Bingo! One of my favorite songs. The Diwali Riddim production remains iconic. 

 

Kelly Rowland - Motivation - Love this song and the night club vibe it accomplishes *chef's kiss* 

 

Drake - One Dance - In 2016 I overplayed this song so now it's just whatever to me. Would've appreciated his earlier hits more. 

 

Earth, Wind & Fire - Let's Groove - My favorite EWF song. Nothing but respect for this choice. 

 

Miguel - Sure Thing - Enjoyable. I missed when he was delivering quality content. 

 

En Vogue - Don't Let Go (Love) - It's alright. It doesn't give me much of anything. 

Posted

Aaliyah - If Your Girl Only Knew - f**k clue’s banned letters, right?

 

Fantasia - When I See U - it’s alright

 

Lizzo - Truth Hurts - a f*cking CLASSICCCCC :WAP:

 

Missy Elliot - Hot Boyz (Remix) - a chill bop :jamming:

 

Usher - Climax - it’s a cute sing

 

Santana - Maria Maria - a big bop that was the blueprint for an even bigger bop :katie2:

 

Sean Paul - Get Busy - hmmm I don’t think

 

Kelly Rowland - Motivation - cute bop :jamming: love ms juicy’s version

 

Drake - One Dance - a cute radio classic :katie2: makes me nostalgic to summer 2016

 

Earth, Wind & Fire - Let's Groove - a classic bop

 

Miguel - Sure Thing - ughh such a good song :jonny2: this is really hitting right now

 

En Vogue - Don't Let Go (Love) - sexy sensual bop :gaynetcat4:

Posted

h7utISH.png

 

CURRENT CONTESTANTS

 

Spoiler

MARVIN GAYE - SEXUAL HEALING

This is one of my favorite songs of all time. It's so sexy and sultry without having an ounce of cringe. Totally a staple in music period.

 

WHITNEY HOUSTON - ALL THE MAN THAT I NEED

It's alright. The chorus is nice, but this song is really a product of its time, it doesn't have that timeless feel that some of her other songs have.

 

THE WEEKND - BLINDING LIGHTS

Pretty much a perfect song. I couldn't ask for anything more from it. Production is great and punchy, the melodies are great, lyrics work well with the production. Zero complaints. It's a classic for a reason. Yeah, it's not R&B or Hip-Hop, but blame Billboard.

 

NE-YO - MISS INDEPENDENT

I've never liked this. Really corny. I always RUN to change the radio when this comes on.

 

MIGUEL - ADORN

Should've won Song of the Year the year it was nominated. A timeless piece of art. The production is pure decadence.

 

Eu2WmPK.gif

 

MEGAN THEE STALLION - SAVAGE REMIX

The only version of this song I ever wanna hear. Should've won Record of the Year this year. It's just a really fun song and it manages to bring these two extremely successful women in the industry together in the most perfect way. Beyoncé's adlibs add TEXTURE. She really just... did that.

 

MARY J. BLIGE - REAL LOVE

Omg this ~sitting on the stoop drinking a quarter-water on a hot summer day~ classic.

 

JENNIFER HUDSON - SPOTLIGHT

This song choice is a scream. And I also don't remember radio supporting this THAT much, but go off Oscar Winner Jennifer Hudson. Umm time definitely hasn't been kind to this song. It's a cute little bop, but it sounds very dated to me.

 

TWEET - OOPS (OH MY)

A classic. The production is some of the best of its decade.

 

JAZMINE SULLIVAN - NEED U BACK

Thank you for this. This takes me back to my childhood every time I hear it. The SOURING chorus. So great.

 

JAY-Z & KANYE WEST - *****S IN PARIS

Beyondddddd a classic. No complaints.

 

AMERIE - 1 THING

I've always haaaaaaaaaaated this song. Loud and irritating. The chorus deadass makes my ears bleed.

 

JAY-Z - EMPIRE STATE OF MIND

This would've been on my decade WORST list a few years ago. Ummm, it grew on me a little bit recently, but it's still an annoying ass song. Like that chorus is GRATINGGG.

 

NELLY - DILEMMA

Have always hated this. The rapping isn't good, the chorus is irritating. Nope. Cheesy and corny.

 

LIZZO - RUMORS

Really fun. I want this to smash harder. Verses are great, chorus is great. Those horns >>>. Also love how confronting the song is + confident they both are on it. It's just a cool ass song.

 

JENNIFER HOLLIDAY - AND I AM TELLING YOU I'M NOT GOING

Shoutout to Chi Chi Devayne. This song is beyond iconic. The drama of it all is just incredible. I definitely prefer Jennifer Hudson's ridiculous shouty version, but I'll take this.

 

GENUWINE - PONY

Corny as ****, but that's its charm. A mega classic, the production + that chorus is literally so iconic.

 

AALIYAH - I MISS YOU

A cute moment for Aaliyah.

COMEBACK KIDS
 

Spoiler

AALIYAH - IF YOUR GIRL ONLY KNEW

One of her best songs. The production is so slick and I love the lyrics.

 

FANTASIA - WHEN I SEE U

This hood classic. The chorus is like engrained in my soul.

 

LIZZO - TRUTH HURTS

Still a dreadful song. Just absolutely annoying.

 

USHER - CLIMAX

One day I will see the hype with this song. Ariel did his thing with the production, I guess. But I really just don't care for the song, I've always found it to be boring.

 

SANTANA - MARIA MARIA

A classic, but I don't like it. Really corny for me.

 

SEAN PAUL - GET BUSY

A fun classic. I'm annoyed that Temperature never reached #1.

 

KELLY ROWLAND - MOTIVATION

I've always liked this, but something happened to me and this song this year. It like became one of my favorite songs ever. The production is DELICIOUS, the lyrics are great and she's so confident on it. Wayne's verse is also good. Zero complaints.

 

DRAKE - ONE DANCE

A classic. It's kinda background music for me, but cute enough background music.

 

EARTH, WIND & FIRE - LET'S GROOVE

TikTok classic. The vocal effects are soooooooo iconic. The chorus is pretty much engrained in the soul of Black America.

 

MIGUEL - SURE THING

I'm shakingggggggg. This takes me back to like middle school. I'm legit emotional rn.... Oh wow... anyway.. a classic. Production is A1.

 

EN VOGUE - DON'T LET GO (LOVE)

A classic. It's never been a favorite of mine, but it's a cute song.

 

MISSY ELLIOTT - HOT BOYZ (REMIX)

This is cute. I like the chorus. Not a super duper interesting song as a whole, though.

 

 

Posted

Mixed reviews so far. The people with TASTE please submit your reviews ASAP :heart:

XvkVYwm.gif

Posted (edited)

Aaliyah - If Your Girl Only Knew: TWO banned letters... :toofunny3: bon voyage

 

Fantasia - When I See U: lovely, super chill vibe and her I've always loved her tone 

 

Lizzo - Truth Hurts: I cannot put into words how much I HATEEEEEEE this goddamn song, I hope you get eliminated again.

 

Usher - Climax: sure!! I do not support men but I cannot deny this is a nice little song I guess

 

Santana - Maria Maria: Wild Thoughts actually outsold, do not hate it though!

 

Sean Paul - Get Busy: I am gonna very respectfully pass love x

 

Kelly Rowland - Motivation: pretty sure anyone with a brain tried to send this, immaculate piece, congratulations on coming back to the game!

 

Drake - One Dance: see Truth Hurts critique above. 

 

Earth, Wind & Fire - Let's Groove: cute fun lil listen, so funny how this is kind of viral all over TikTok right now, cute choice

 

Miguel - Sure Thing: a man that I can support I guess, this is fine and all that

 

En Vogue - Don't Let Go (Love): was never crazy over this, vocals are lovely though

 

Missy Elliott - Hot Boyz: not really feeling it, didn't grab my attention at all 

Edited by luckystrike
Posted

Waiting for a comeback girl review

  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

Aaliyah - If Your Girl Only Knew

RIP to u

 

Fantasia - When I See U

I liked the melody to this, but her vocals were a bit tough to absorb at times

 

Lizzo - Truth Hurts

I was soooo into this song in 2019. It's still fun, but I won't lie I can see how ppl thought it was grating

 

Missy Elliot - Hot Boyz (Remix)

this was fine... didn't really vibe w me like a lot of other missy songs do

 

Usher - Climax

lovely song by a man yup; those falsetto notes whew

 

Santana - Maria Maria

i feel like it was fun at the time but it's just ok now

 

Sean Paul - Get Busy

perhaps this still bops a bit

 

Kelly Rowland - Motivation

really great!!! tried to send this tbh

 

Drake - One Dance

yup loved this in 2016 and it still holds up very very well here

 

Earth, Wind & Fire - Let's Groove

aw this is a very cute and fun throwback! love it.

 

Miguel - Sure Thing

this was nice

 

En Vogue - Don't Let Go (Love)

i debated about sending this but it ultimately felt a bit like it would get lost in the pack

Posted

qGQDsYX.jpg

 

Kavish ⛧ Kritiques 

~

 

Aaliyah - If Your Girl Only Knew

The thumping beat is engaging and the song is chill overall.

 

Fantasia - When I See U

Cute voice and sweet flutter-of-wings-when-I-see-my-crush theme.

 

Lizzo - Truth Hurts

Reminiscent of OutKast's "Hey Ya", Rae Sremmurd's "Black Beatles", and Khalid's "Young Dumb & Broke" at parts, but it's still a fun and catchy song.

 

Missy Elliot - Hot Boyz (Remix)

Pleasant melody, and the featured artists complement Missy's parts perfectly, as if the song wasn't even a remix.

 

Usher – Climax

The constant build-ups and mini-explosions feels like edging and reaching a satisfying release.

 

Santana - Maria Maria

A classic with an infectious instrumental. The Spanish parts elevates it.

 

Sean Paul - Get Busy

An absolute banger.

 

Kelly Rowland – Motivation

Kelly is sensual and sultry, and Lil Wayne's questionable and funny lines work just fine here.

 

Drake - One Dance

Danceable indeed, with a delightful and lowkey experimental production towards the end.

 

Earth, Wind & Fire - Let's Groove

Happy and cheerful ambiance with a groovy rhythm and the voices are inviting.

 

Miguel - Sure Thing

A neat blend of tempo and breezy vocals with ad-libs that add a delightful layer.

 

En Vogue - Don't Let Go (Love)

Lovely showcase of vocals and the song is charming overall.

 

~

 

a50cdf30e3d3c6b1ddeca063e0013c2a.gif

Posted

Marvin Gaye - Sexual Healing / https://voca.ro/19Q5n4vJ72Sj

 

Whitney Houston - All the Man That I Need / https://voca.ro/17yn14KwlWpN

 

The Weeknd - Blinding Lights / https://voca.ro/19XAC9ifebPg

 

Ne-Yo - Miss Independent / https://voca.ro/16Nnyv9Eh55j

 

Miguel - Adorn / https://voca.ro/19J8EyOYQ4tl

 

Meghan Thee Stallion - Savage Remix / https://voca.ro/1fQ2TmvMnBmk

 

Mary J Blige - Real Love / https://voca.ro/1dtFyeCJl4kS

 

Jennifer Hudson - Spotlight / https://voca.ro/16pHoCJjcJg7

 

Tweet - Oops Oh My / https://voca.ro/17icCW5gM7n6

 

Jazmine Sullivan - Need U Bad / https://voca.ro/1jMSvuFeYUIa

 

Jay-Z - Blank In Paris / https://voca.ro/1a5ycdg8cQbl

 

Amerie - 1 Thing / https://voca.ro/1fkFvFR6qSNg

 

Jay-Z - Empire State of Mind / https://voca.ro/1fJWGkyB0DJU

 

Nelly - Dilemma / https://voca.ro/15X3rl03umGp

 

Lizzo - Rumors / https://voca.ro/1he6Rg5utfbx

 

Jennifer Holiday - And I Am Telling You... / https://voca.ro/1dCbAxZc6Mpc

 

Aaliyah - Miss You Stream on YThttps://voca.ro/18OV9AkdlScI

 

Ginuwine - Pony / https://voca.ro/16KJVSsAtbYR

 

Posted

i'll be doing black magic on some of you :rip:

Posted

lh6WQVX.png


????

Spoiler

Marvin Gaye - Sexual Healing

ooooooh i havent heard this for so long that i forgot how groovy it is :jamming: and it is also so sexy as well omy!

such a great choice honestly and its a good song to start the group with. nice pick hehe

 

Whitney Houston - All the Man That I Need

this is a good song.. i def prefer it to the previous whitney picks but still i don't know how it's gonna do in my rankings

like its good yea but will it be enough for me to rank it high? :katie: have to think about that, yea.. but such a good song

 

The Weeknd - Blinding Lights

a future classic methinks. i remember it being sent in bagels season once.. so not surprised to see it here tbh

i enjoyed it yea even though its kinda more poppy than r&b/hip-hop but it fits the brief so hehe. also might get tired of this song.

 

Ne-Yo - Miss Independent

yea this is a bit corny i think. i don't really enjoy it that much compared to the previous 3 songs

i feel that its a bit dragged on for too long, so i'm sorry boo :emofish:

 

Miguel - Adorn

oooh this one is cool. miguel is kinda a hit or miss for me but this one is absolutely a hit

its such a vibe and his voice is so smooth and together with the production, it makes the song better, yep

 

Megan Thee Stallion - Savage Remix

yup. period. exactly. ate.

 

Mary J Blige - Real Love

mhmm this is very cute submission. i enjoyed it a lot like its fun and its happy and its so cute?

its just a carefree bop and we love to see it. maybe others hit harder but this still hits!

 

Jennifer Hudson - Spotlight

AHHHHHHHH i randomly rediscovered this sometime between 2019 i think and i've been in love since then

an excellent song and she really did that with this. its a vibe, its a mood, its perfect.

 

Tweet - Oops Oh My

personally, i think this is okay? missy really makes this song more interesting for me

but apart from that, its very okay-ish and it serving very there which might not be good :emofish:

 

Jazmine Sullivan - Need U Bad

this is absolutely getting better as the song goes on. like i was having some negative thoughts about it at the beginning

but then the switch up in the chorus did that and im now enjoying the whole song a lot. a cute bop with an amazing chorus <3

 

Jay-Z - Blank In Paris

i have no thoughts about this one.

 

Amerie - 1 Thing

ooooh this song is interesting :jamming: her voice is so high-pitched? that i can see it irritates a lot of people :weeps:

but for me, i think its cute and its very fun! even though its kinda grating towards the end oopsie.. hehe

 

Jay-Z - Empire State of Mind

whewwwww what a classic :weeps: alicia's verse will always live rent free on my mind. its that good, yup.

tbh both of them did an amazing job in order to create this classic and i love it.

 

Nelly - Dilemma

kelly's chorus is amazing and a classic but idk about nelly verses tbh..

so yea, this is a mixed bag but its not the worst but apart from the chorus, its just an okay song

 

Lizzo - Rumors

a future classic tbh and this song has grown on me a lot since the release :eek: i once thought it was just okay

but now im digging it and its so addictive AHHHHHH.. both lizzo and cardi did that :clap3:

 

Jennifer Holiday - And I Am Telling You...

ahhhhhHHHH omg such a BIGGGGG classic and i love this song so much like literally its so powerful

amazing ballad and both jennifer holiday and jhuds versions are amazing.. WHEW tears :cries:

 

Aaliyah - Miss You

its very cute and very smooth. i don't have much to say but this is fine.

 

Ginuwine - Pony

i know lots of people like this but it's not for me, i'm sorry! :)

 

bimlegend.thumb.gif.a2fb5af2334c464104bc

 

?????????

Spoiler

Aaliyah - If Your Girl Only Knew

oh welp i feel for you. thank you for sending in tho :hug: i hope this season has been fun even though u already got eliminated

please participate in season 10!!! :heart2: maybe it will be better.

 

Fantasia - When I See U

wow this is really great like theres something about this song that reels me in and grabs my attention

her voice is def a highlight and its a great submission, yea!

 

Lizzo - Truth Hurts

period. she did that in this song and even though i prefer good as hell, this is still a great pick

its gonna be very polarizing as hell tho so i wish you luck just because i love this song :heart2:

 

Missy Elliot - Hot Boyz (Remix)

eve's verse is really the star of the song cause apart from that, its okay. eve rlly carried this whew.

overall, the whole song is middle of the road for me.. wish u luck tho

 

Usher - Climax

eh this is pretty okay-ish.. like i expected it to be a lil better but its just mediocre hmm!

its not the worst song tho but i don't have much to say about it either

 

Santana - Maria Maria

not really feeling it tbh :emofish: its a little boring for me. the part where wild thoughts sampled this is cute tho.

but thats it, i don't feel anything.

 

Sean Paul - Get Busy

its fun but i don't get the hype for it at all.. hmm at least its fun tho and we'll see how it does

maybe its a hit for others but i dont think i care much about it

 

Kelly Rowland - Motivation

oh yep so much better than lots of songs so im glad that i finally got to this song.

its a nice switch-up from all the pretty mediocre-meh songs above.. a good song!

 

Drake - One Dance

this is such an enjoyable song tbh. its so groovy and its a big vibe :jamming: i can see why this is a smash

and its probably one of his good songs yea yea.

 

Earth, Wind & Fire - Let's Groove

oh wow this tiktok smash :eek: listening to it in full for a first time and i have to say that it doesnt disappoint

its fun and its a groove indeed, wowwww.. the production is so addictive and its such a jam

 

Miguel - Sure Thing

yas omg this classic :jamming: i love this song so much.. i haven't heard it for so long but its such a great song wow

probably another great pick here and im happy that there are some songs in this eliminees group that i enjoy a lot!!!

 

En Vogue - Don't Let Go (Love)

please this is so dramatic at the beginning and it sets the mood for the whole song so well, i'm impressed.

very cute and yea its a great closer for this group :lakitu:

 

bimlegend.thumb.gif.a2fb5af2334c464104bc

 

let me just say that the current top 18 absolutely ate this theme and the eliminees :heart2:

good luck everyone!

 

Posted

 

 

Spoiler

Sexual Healing - Marvin Gaye

Kate Bush could never! Well it's good that we're starting with a real classic!

 

All The Man That I Need - Whitney Houston

Oh I was considering this as my choice, love love love this song!

 

Blinding Lights - The Weeknd

Yes this is too poppy for this rnb/hiphop round but I won't be dragging you for that. I'm just way beyond tired of this song, EVERGLOW did it better anyways!

 

Miss Independent - Ne-Yo

Cute for a throwback I guess, kinda weak though compared to the other songs here x

 

Adorn - Miguel

Very nice, one of my fave songs by him. He was really sangggging here!

 

Savage Remix (feat. Beyonce) - Megan Thee Stallion

I don't really listen to it much now but it's fine, I still vibe with it x

 

Real Love - Mary J. Blige

It's nice, you can really hear and feel the 90s rnb goodness.

 

Spotlight - Jennifer Hudson

Yep, this one knocks and very underrated too x

 

Oops (Oh My) (feat. Missy Elliott) - Tweet

It's good, not really feeling Missy's parts even though they were like 5 seconds or so but I liked the song overall x

 

Need U Bad - Jazmine Sullivan

I really liked the chorus of the song, the verses not so much x

 

Blank in Paris - JAY-Z, Kanye West

That **** cray, that **** cray! I hate to admit it but this is very good x

 

1 Thing - Amerie

Oh here's the classic, I don't really find it annoying.

 

Empire State OF Mind - JAY-Z, Alicia Keys

A lil bit overrated but I'd be lying if I say that I didn't enjoy this back then x

 

Dilemma - Nelly, Kelly Rowland

Well Miss Kelendria did what she had to do here!

 

Rumors (feat. Cardi B) - Lizzo

I know everyone has switched on this song now but I'm still not feeling it sorry x

 

And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going - Jennifer Holiday

Well everyone and their moms know this song and we love it! 

 

Miss You - Aaliyah

This song gives me such nostalgia and good memories, I really enjoyed this one!

 

Pony - Ginuwine

I didn't hate or dislike it and it's not the worst song on this list so there's that!
 

Posted

Marvin Gaye - Sexual Healing

i need some

 

Whitney Houston - All the Man That I Need

slayyyyy. HE FEELS ME UP, HE GIVES ME LOVE!

 

The Weeknd - Blinding Lights

I was the biggest fan of this song when it came out but over the past two years... yeah it got annoying. still gonna rank it high tho i think

 

Ne-Yo - Miss Independent

chill bop

 

Miguel - Adorn

not for me I'm sorry :smiley:

 

Meghan Thee Stallion - Savage Remix

my first choice x

 

Mary J Blige - Real Love

not a big fan of this production yeah

 

Jennifer Hudson - Spotlight

love this

 

Tweet - Oops Oh My

not for me

 

Jazmine Sullivan - Need U Bad

I love the chorus!

 

Jay-Z - Blank In Paris

not me looking for a song 'blank in paris' :rip: i think i like this one more than some other entries here, a brave choice too

 

Amerie - 1 Thing

I have to say no I think but this is definitely not the worst one, you should be safe!

 

Jay-Z - Empire State of Mind

my second choice x

 

Nelly - Dilemma

yep yep yep :heart2:

 

Lizzo - Rumors

I don't really feel it. the chorus slays but other parts aren't it for me. probably ranking it high still tho :deadbanana4:

 

Jennifer Holliday - And I Am Telling You...

absolutely yes

 

Aaliyah - Miss You

not so sure about this one, cute but nothing more than that

 

Ginuwine - Pony

... thinking many thoughts

Posted

:gaygacat3:

 

 

Marvin Gaye - Sexual Healing

 

Love the voice and overall vibe but I got bored

 

Whitney Houston - All the Man That I Need

 

Very nice, love the saxophone part. Good pick!!

 

The Weeknd - Blinding Lights

 

I really like this song but not for this round

valentina.gif

 

 

Ne-Yo - Miss Independent

 

The instrumental is :jamming: but not a fan of Ne-Yo's voice but it totally fits the song:)

 

Miguel - Adorn

 

This made me sleepy:zzz: Not a fan

 

Meghan Thee Stallion - Savage Remix

 

RawPlaintiveBergerpicard-max-1mb.gif

 

Mary J Blige - Real Love

 

Love MJB but not this song. I liked the final few seconds

 

Jennifer Hudson - Spotlight

 

Didn't like this but it's a good song for sure:smile:

 

Tweet - Oops Oh My

 

Oh My this is interesting, I really really like the instrumental. Her voice is:spin:, Missy's feature was too short. Still a very nice choice and something I've never heard before. 

 

Jazmine Sullivan - Need U Bad

 

This was very good

 

stoned-im.gif

 

Jay-Z - Blank In Paris

 

2:57- 3:39 just hits different :jonny6: Excellent song. 

 

Amerie - 1 Thing

 

AHHH my top 2 GTA song, the amount of people that got ran over by me while blasting this on the Non Stop Pop FM radio station....:clownny: 

 

run-over-road-kill.gif

:1stplace:

 

Jay-Z - Empire State of Mind

 

A classic. I used to love this a lot more but still a good pick

 

Nelly - Dilemma

 

:zzz: So chill, I really like this

 

Lizzo - Rumors

 

HATE Lizzo, but this is an excellent song. :clap3:

 

robxrtprint-azealia-banks.gif

 

Jennifer Holiday - And I Am Telling You...

 

Amazing song, the emotion:jonny6:  

 

One of the best lipsyncs in DR history

f75ff3d5e2cbcf6542cc632139240c42.gif

 

Aaliyah - Miss You Stream on YT 

 

I WANTED THIS  :thing:

 

rpdr-alyssa.gif

 

Great pick, great song, I hope you place high! 

 

Ginuwine - Pony

 

OBSESSED:falcon:

 

:2ndplace:

 

 

:gaygacat3:

Posted

GwGkVeR.png?width=360&height=450

CAST

Spoiler

SEXUAL HEALING - Massive classic. I agree that it does sexy and sultry really well without overdoing it or being too cringy. Very smooth

 

ALL THE MAN THAT I NEED - A perfectly fine 7/10. There's not anything crazy here but it's pretty and does its job. 

 

BLINDING LIGHTS - We, or the media, should really have a convo on how this was considered r&b not just on the charts, but also at awards shows. Either way because of that it fits the theme and yeah it's a massive classic. He tried to imitate himself with TMB but it's clearly difficult to recreate perfection.

 

MISS INDEPENDENT - yes it's corny, yes ne-yo is one of the worst people alive, but it's nostalgia is making it somewhat enjoyable to me idk

 

ADORN - yeah this is great. Just super smooth. It's not my fav Miguel song by any means, but it's still nice. Modern R&B just perfectly executed

 

SAVAGE REMIX - Either this or DSN was totally robbed for ROTY. This is just a lot of fun and Bey def elevates to this a new level. 

 

REAL LOVE - cute, not incredibly interesting thoug

 

SPOTLIGHT - Corny and dated

 

OOPS (OH MY) - Actually really cool. The production is one of the most interesting of this round, and it has held up pretty well imo. It may be a bit clunky at moments but overall pretty pleased with this one, esp because it's much more interesting than most songs

 

NEED U BAD - she's cute, not as obsessed as the other judges tho.

 

PARIS - totally obliterates every song in this round and it's already a cute round. Massive classic

 

1 THING - words can't describe how much I HATE this. So annoying :rip:  The only good thing about this is the backstory of her just releasing this instead of JLo stealing another song and then barely singing  in it n

 

EMPIRE STATE OF MIND - classic idc. Jay-Z used to be on a ROLL during this time

 

DILEMMA - kelly ate idc. The rest of the song very bad tho.. so oh well

 

RUMORS - Cardi devoured. The rest of the song was underwhelming but it has some nice one-liners here and there. 

 

AND I AM TELLING YOU I AM NOT GOING - idk if I would've loved this much had this not been an amazing drag race lip sync, but I do now so. The drama is everywhere. Not a dull moment

 

PONY - classic. Can't make it not bop

 

I MISS YOU - it's okay. Cute lil moment

 

COMEBACK

Spoiler

IF YOUR GIRL ONLY KNEW - how do you use BOTH of the banned letters for the songtitle sjsjsj GIRL. 

 

WHEN I SEE U - I'm not gagging. I don't see it sorree

 

HOT BOYZ - not interesting enough to go to youtube for!

 

TRUTH HURTS - JUICE SHOULD'VE BEEN TO BLOW UP!!! FUMING!!

Anyways, it's fun but one of my least fav songs by her tbh

 

CLIMAX - production actually great on this, it's usher who really underwhelms on this. Just screeching like a castrated cat on this

 

MARIA MARIA - I will be saying it, Wild Thoughts is the version I prefer by far. Just a lot more fun. The lyrics on this are super corny but that instrumental is one of the best all time

 

GET BUSY - just a lot of fun. I'm not complaining

 

MOTIVATION - poor almost every other eliminee. Easily one of the best songs here. Just perfectly executed

 

ONE DANCE - This both solidified himself as a hitmaker, and also caused his massive decline in quality. It's kinda background music and became the foundation for every **** song that came afterwards. I at least don't hate this one I guess

 

LET'S GROOVE - the tiktoks to this are so good idc. Anyways massive classic, and super interesting actually. The fact that it could still go viral this year, says a lot about the quality of the song imo. Both nostalgic and timeless

 

SURE THING - very nice. Just really smooth and chill. Can't go really wrong with Miguel

 

DON'T LET GO (LOVE) - oh wow the second half of the comeback kids is really strong huh. This is really nice as well. Lovely pick

 

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.