Jump to content

This Was Pop 2022 | Part 1 | Charli, Rina, Tove & Carly (Winner Revealed!)


Recommended Posts

Posted

Ooohhhh, love all four albums, I'll definitely join! :hippo:

  • Replies 775
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • greento

    148

  • madonnas

    70

  • halcyonday

    58

  • CBC

    56

Posted
2 hours ago, supaspaz said:

Hold the Girl needs to get massacred. Can’t compare to the other three.

As long as Holy gets the 10s she deserves!

 

Spoiler

And This Hell gets the 0s she deserves!

 

Posted
3 hours ago, supaspaz said:

Hold the Girl needs to get massacred. Can’t compare to the other three.

It’s best songs are top 10 worthy actually :michael:

Posted

Oh lemme do this, I've actually heard all of these!

Posted

I will do this :cupid:

Posted

 

Posted

perched :heart:

Posted

Ooh I might actually do this one :duca: I've listened to them all except Carly's but I'd love to revisit the other 3 and curious to finally check out a Carly album

Posted

doing this for sure. praying taste succeeds and carly wins.

Posted

Sent! 

 

Carly's is still one of my faves from last year, I like pretty much everything although the title track and bonuses are kinda overrated. Rina's is great outside of two awful songs and Tove's grew on me a lot but doesn't have any 10/10 bangers on it tbh. Then Crash... half excellent half some of the worst songs of 2022, easily her weakest album

Posted

i wanna be included

Posted

we're at 4 lists already, including my own. the results are pretty interesting so far. every album is represented in the top 5 at the moment, we'll see how much that will change as more lists come in :coffee:

  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

I haven't done a rate in a while, might do it just to tank Rina's awful effort here 

Posted

OK I will play.

 

Sorry If I Hurt You NEEDS to be #1.

Posted
5 minutes ago, SLIME said:

OK I will play.

 

Sorry If I Hurt You NEEDS to be #1.

TASTE :jonny: top 3 Charli songs of all time 

Posted

I'm in :D

Posted

finally one with 4 albums I like! i'll def be doing it

Posted

The way I saw rina on the HTG tour and will be seeing tove in less than a month but will still vote charli >>> everybody & everything

 

tbh carly's voice kind of grates for me so I've never kept up w her but I'll give her another chance for this :gaycat4:

Posted (edited)

can't believe Carly's is the album most people are yet to hear out of these :deadbanana2: thought she was the favourite of the four on this site

Edited by greento
  • ATRL Moderator
Posted
1 hour ago, greento said:

can't believe Carly's is the album most people are yet to hear out of these :deadbanana2: thought she was the favourite of the four on this site

These new gays don’t know their pop history!

Posted

Wait. I might do this since I'm seeing Tove Lo in July!

 

spacer.png

Posted
On 6/25/2023 at 4:50 PM, greento said:

can't believe Carly's is the album most people are yet to hear out of these :deadbanana2: thought she was the favourite of the four on this site

ATRL opened their eyes and saw what overrated means I fear

Posted
On 6/19/2023 at 6:31 PM, madonnas said:

No 11s?

 

 

crash is easily the best album here tbh, but I’m hoping no thinking over the weekend makes the top 10 

We love taste 

Posted

Just sent my scores for these amazing albums. And while I was wrapping up my scores yesterday I realized I've seen all 4 of these ladies for the tours of these albums nn so let me rank them here just for fun.

  1. Carly. It's kinda funny that she usually just shuts up and plays as many songs as possible but she did. AND The Loneliest Time came out the same day as the concert, so it was a special moment (even though she should have scrapped most of those Dedidated Side B songs for some actual TLT songs). Made some new friends too!
  2. Charli. Okay to be honest. This may have been above Carly if I wasn't so ******* drunk LMFAO but that also added to the experience! It was opening night which made it even more exciting. The dancers totally elevated this experience from when she performed the Charli album.
  3. Rina. HTG is my least favorite of these albums, and I knew she barely did any Sawayama/RINA songs so I went in with more mild expectations and wound up really pleasantly surprised! She can SING and PERFORM. And I saw the friends I made from Carly here!
  4. Tove. I mean this one was great too, but I think it just wasn't quite as lively as her Sunshine Kitty tour (ironically, since on that tour it was the last day she was in her cast) and not quite as new and exciting as her first album's tour. Still a great time though!
  • Like 2
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.