Ewan Chaos Posted September 24, 2024 Posted September 24, 2024 Oh wow 2023 actually looks good. It's tough because I initially felt like it was unfair to her competitors to have Miley in a rate with Jessie/Kylie/Troye since I feel like she has HUGE stans on her (if you look at the ATRL Grammys at least), but idk I think that lineup works. If we're doing 4 artists for most of these rates let's make like Year-End lists and ignore Terfy I like that you keep trying to make that specific alt 2023 lineup work sjdshhdisohdiso I mean it's surprising to me as well that everyone you've pitched it to keeps saying "I normally would because I stan Lana but I loathe Sufjan" or replace x artist with y artist. Chappell being launched into 2024 makes way too much sense too, so I like that decision. Add Sia, Meghan, or (if you want male edginess) Justin to the flop line and you're probably set. Feels weird not including one of the highest-scoring albums ever in TW2024 (Charli) but Sabrina-Chappell-her-Tinashe were the undeniable breakouts of this year so it's hard to separate any of them. Normally it'd be fun to offer to host a rate but I'm way too busy in the final stretches of wedding planning I'm a naur until 2025! Will participate in any tho
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted September 24, 2024 Author ATRL Moderator Posted September 24, 2024 9 minutes ago, Ewan Chaos said: Oh wow 2023 actually looks good. It's tough because I initially felt like it was unfair to her competitors to have Miley in a rate with Jessie/Kylie/Troye since I feel like she has HUGE stans on her (if you look at the ATRL Grammys at least), but idk I think that lineup works. If we're doing 4 artists for most of these rates let's make like Year-End lists and ignore Terfy I like that you keep trying to make that specific alt 2023 lineup work sjdshhdisohdiso I mean it's surprising to me as well that everyone you've pitched it to keeps saying "I normally would because I stan Lana but I loathe Sufjan" or replace x artist with y artist. Chappell being launched into 2024 makes way too much sense too, so I like that decision. Add Sia, Meghan, or (if you want male edginess) Justin to the flop line and you're probably set. Feels weird not including one of the highest-scoring albums ever in TW2024 (Charli) but Sabrina-Chappell-her-Tinashe were the undeniable breakouts of this year so it's hard to separate any of them. Normally it'd be fun to offer to host a rate but I'm way too busy in the final stretches of wedding planning I'm a naur until 2025! Will participate in any tho Yeah, I think the traditional TW2024 will have to be converted into an alt lineup of, like, St. Vincent, VW, and maybe Magdalena Bay/MJ Lenderman/Clairo? Jamie xx? TWA23 is causing so many unexpected problems! Like, Kelela and Caroline are a perfect pair because of their history. But, who else... if you don't want Sufjan, you're not going to want Wednesday or ANOHNI! You know what I mean? I think JT and not Meghan or Sia (because did anyone expect anything more) would be the perfect album to round out At Least You Tried - but, ATRL and men... WAIT - it will be Shawn whenever that album drops and flops. Duh!
Graves Posted September 24, 2024 Posted September 24, 2024 Camilla, Normani, Katy and Shawn??? Oh my god, that rate will be deliciously diabolical. The drama, mama... As for the alt situation... if Sufjan is holding things up then maybe dropping it down to a trio? A small rate, but if that's the only way to get it a host then it might have to be so. It's kind of poetic. Question for the Culture vs Cancelled by Kelela vs PS5s for sale.
greento Posted September 24, 2024 Posted September 24, 2024 Charli/Chappell/Sabrina as just a three album rate for like Summer 2024 albums would be perfect. You could throw Billie in but it doesn't fit the exact same vibe that those three albums encompass. They're all their respective "breakthrough" albums, kinda, and each have multiple hits smashing at the same time. it just seems too perfect to separate these albums and put them with flops.
PokiTails Posted September 24, 2024 Posted September 24, 2024 It is finally here. My first draft for the Lilith Fair Rate. ~40 tracks so far but 80% of these I assume the average ATRL member will be able to instantly recognize. - Sarah McLachlan was the head of Lilith Fair so gave her the honor of 2 tracks for each year she hosted. - Don't know what are the odds we'll ever be able to host Sheryl / Jewel rates so this is a good chance to let their top hits get attention. - Apparently Nelly Furtado and Christina Aguilera did a show or two in 1999? Would that really qualify them to join? Spoiler Main focus is acts who played Main Stage / Secondary. Artists' top hits at the time get priority. Sarah McLachlan - Building a Mystery Sarah McLachlan - Possession Sarah McLachlan - Adia Sarah McLachlan - Angel Sarah McLachlan - When She Loved Me Sarah McLachlan - Sweet Surrender Sheryl Crow - Strong Enough Sheryl Crow - All I Wanna Do Sheryl Crow - My Favorite Mistake Sheryl Crow - If It Makes You Happy Jewel - You Were Meant for Me Jewel - Foolish Games Jewel - Hands Suzanne Vega - Luka Suzanne Vega - Tom's Diner (DNA Remix) Lisa Loeb - Stay (I Missed You) Lisa Loeb - I Do Fiona Apple - Criminal Tracy Chapman - Fast Car Meredith Brooks - ***** Joan Osborne - One of Us Shawn Colvin - Sunny Came Home Pat Benatar - Hit Me With Your Best Shot Sinead O'Connor - Nothing Compares 2 U Des'ree - You Gotta Be Missy Elliott - Sock It 2 Me Billie Myers - Kiss the Rain Martina McBride - A Broken Wing Sixpence None the Richer - Kiss Me The Chicks - Cowboy Take Me Away The Pretenders - I'll Stand By You Monica - Angel of Mine Mya - It's All About Me Deborah Cox - Nobody's Supposed To Be Here Dido - Here with Me 2010 Cancelled Revival, do we want to include this? If so: Kelly Clarkson - My Life Would Suck Without You Norah Jones - Don't Know Why Colbie Caillat - Bubbly Heart - Alone Mary J. Blige - Family Affair Miranda Lambert - The House That Built Me Sarah Bareilles - Love Song
greento Posted September 24, 2024 Posted September 24, 2024 2 minutes ago, greento said: Charli/Chappell/Sabrina as just a three album rate for like Summer 2024 albums would be perfect. You could throw Billie in but it doesn't fit the exact same vibe that those three albums encompass. They're all their respective "breakthrough" albums, kinda, and each have multiple hits smashing at the same time. it just seems too perfect to separate these albums and put them with flops. Also I would be happy to host this if it were to be picked
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted September 25, 2024 Author ATRL Moderator Posted September 25, 2024 1 hour ago, greento said: Charli/Chappell/Sabrina as just a three album rate for like Summer 2024 albums would be perfect. You could throw Billie in but it doesn't fit the exact same vibe that those three albums encompass. They're all their respective "breakthrough" albums, kinda, and each have multiple hits smashing at the same time. it just seems too perfect to separate these albums and put them with flops. Adding Superstar T ( @supaspaz would kill me/you/us if I didn't!) and we have it. Honestly, it's so far the 2024 rate I'm most excited about! 1
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted September 25, 2024 Author ATRL Moderator Posted September 25, 2024 3 hours ago, Graves said: Camilla, Normani, Katy and Shawn??? Oh my god, that rate will be deliciously diabolical. The drama, mama... As for the alt situation... if Sufjan is holding things up then maybe dropping it down to a trio? A small rate, but if that's the only way to get it a host then it might have to be so. It's kind of poetic. Question for the Culture vs Cancelled by Kelela vs PS5s for sale. Let's switch Sufjan out for the Z100 playlisted Mitski. Man, men can't catch a break here! Lana/Caroline/Kelela/Mitski - SOMEONE snatch this one up! Hot out the oven!
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted September 25, 2024 ATRL Moderator Posted September 25, 2024 8 hours ago, Ace Reject said: As for 2024? @supaspaz would you be doing both TTPD and that anthology or whatever? 31 tracks plus all of Cowboy Carter... that's an ask in today's world! This is what I don’t know! I’ve been struggling over what to do, which is why I haven’t launched this rate that I promised to host months ago.
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted September 25, 2024 Author ATRL Moderator Posted September 25, 2024 Just now, supaspaz said: This is what I don’t know! I’ve been struggling over what to do, which is why I haven’t launched this rate that I promised to host months ago. I mean, having two very short albums with two long albums makes sense in a way! So, yes. "TOO BIG TO FAIL - SPRING BEHEMOTHS" will be your rate. Beyoncé, Taylor, Billie, and Wicked star Ariana Grande. @greento - Summer Breakthroughs and Comebacks (Chappell, Charli, Sabrina, and... yes, Tinashe) is all yours to start! Looking for a host for SOFT LANDINGS of '23/'24 (Doja, Kacey, Dua, Megan) next! We'll save the flops for when Shawn drops. Also, maybe a SOFT LAUNCHINGS rate as well? Tyla, Benson Boone, RAYE, Renee Rapp?
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted September 25, 2024 ATRL Moderator Posted September 25, 2024 2 minutes ago, Ace Reject said: We'll save the flops for when Shawn drops. I cackled
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted September 25, 2024 Author ATRL Moderator Posted September 25, 2024 4 hours ago, Ewan Chaos said: Oh wow 2023 actually looks good. It's tough because I initially felt like it was unfair to her competitors to have Miley in a rate with Jessie/Kylie/Troye since I feel like she has HUGE stans on her (if you look at the ATRL Grammys at least), but idk I think that lineup works. If we're doing 4 artists for most of these rates let's make like Year-End lists and ignore Terfy I like that you keep trying to make that specific alt 2023 lineup work sjdshhdisohdiso I mean it's surprising to me as well that everyone you've pitched it to keeps saying "I normally would because I stan Lana but I loathe Sufjan" or replace x artist with y artist. Chappell being launched into 2024 makes way too much sense too, so I like that decision. Add Sia, Meghan, or (if you want male edginess) Justin to the flop line and you're probably set. Feels weird not including one of the highest-scoring albums ever in TW2024 (Charli) but Sabrina-Chappell-her-Tinashe were the undeniable breakouts of this year so it's hard to separate any of them. Normally it'd be fun to offer to host a rate but I'm way too busy in the final stretches of wedding planning I'm a naur until 2025! Will participate in any tho BTW, CONGRATS!!! 1
Saddy Posted September 25, 2024 Posted September 25, 2024 33 minutes ago, Ace Reject said: Looking for a host for SOFT LANDINGS of '23/'24 (Doja, Kacey, Dua, Megan) next! I'd love to host it, but idk if I can host 2 rates at the same time tbh
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted September 25, 2024 Author ATRL Moderator Posted September 25, 2024 36 minutes ago, Saddy said: I'd love to host it, but idk if I can host 2 rates at the same time tbh One at a time! 1
touya kinomoto Posted September 25, 2024 Posted September 25, 2024 17 hours ago, Ace Reject said: Part 4: Camila/Normani/Katy/add one or two other flops (Well, At Least You Tried) [ @touya kinomoto, it's your time to shine!] i would love to but i don't think i have the bandwidth to host a rate right now... plus Camila 17 hours ago, Ace Reject said: 2023 THIS WAS POP 1: Kylie/Jessie/Miley/Pink (and maybe TERF) THIS WAS POP 2: Troye/Tate/PinkPantheress/Newjeans VODKA SODA GIRLS: Ava/Kim/Bebe/Madison THIS WAS ALT POP: Lana/Kelela/Caroline/Sufjan no Carly tho? we need a rate for Psychedelic Switch to win 1
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted September 25, 2024 Author ATRL Moderator Posted September 25, 2024 3 hours ago, touya kinomoto said: i would love to but i don't think i have the bandwidth to host a rate right now... plus Camila no Carly tho? we need a rate for Psychedelic Switch to win Do you know what? Let's replace Pink with Carly!
touya kinomoto Posted September 25, 2024 Posted September 25, 2024 i would love to see katy on a rate with her contemporaries AND get obliterated. i am not a katycat for this album so she deserves to bomb any rate 143 is in. 1
greento Posted September 26, 2024 Posted September 26, 2024 On 9/25/2024 at 2:23 AM, Ace Reject said: @greento - Summer Breakthroughs and Comebacks (Chappell, Charli, Sabrina, and... yes, Tinashe) is all yours to start! If someone else wants to host this, that's fine. I only really wanted to do it if it was Charli/Chappell/Sabrina only.
prézli Posted September 29, 2024 Posted September 29, 2024 Tomorrow is the last day to participate in the Ashlee Simpson Discography Rate! After that, it will be a bittersweet world.
creativity. Posted October 8, 2024 Posted October 8, 2024 I want to host a discog rate pls. Which do you think would get the most participants? - Joanna Newsom - Nelly Furtado - Róisín Murphy (solo, not incl Moloko) - Robyn
Saddy Posted October 8, 2024 Posted October 8, 2024 26 minutes ago, creativity. said: I want to host a discog rate pls. Which do you think would get the most participants? - Joanna Newsom - Nelly Furtado - Róisín Murphy (solo, not incl Moloko) - Robyn From this list I know only Nelly & Robyn, but I think Nelly will get more participants
greento Posted October 8, 2024 Posted October 8, 2024 3 hours ago, creativity. said: I want to host a discog rate pls. Which do you think would get the most participants? - Joanna Newsom - Nelly Furtado - Róisín Murphy (solo, not incl Moloko) - Robyn Robyn for sure
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted October 9, 2024 Author ATRL Moderator Posted October 9, 2024 18 hours ago, creativity. said: I want to host a discog rate pls. Which do you think would get the most participants? - Joanna Newsom - Nelly Furtado - Róisín Murphy (solo, not incl Moloko) - Robyn Oh, the Swedish Queen!
prézli Posted October 10, 2024 Posted October 10, 2024 Boyfriend is the winner of Little Miss Obsessive: The Ashlee Simpson Discography Rate. @Ace Reject
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted October 18, 2024 Author ATRL Moderator Posted October 18, 2024 On 9/25/2024 at 9:56 AM, touya kinomoto said: i would love to but i don't think i have the bandwidth to host a rate right now... plus Camila no Carly tho? we need a rate for Psychedelic Switch to win And another idea: Odds and Ends. TTPD: The Anthology, brat (remix), Tension II, Jaguar II Deluxe. Who wants it?
Recommended Posts