poki Posted November 15, 2023 Posted November 15, 2023 On 11/13/2023 at 12:55 PM, Ace Reject said: Rating their albums or singles? I have these artists in mind: Sarah McLachlan Kelly Clarkson P!nk Avril Lavigne Michelle Branch Natalie Imbruglia From my experience there is a lot of overlap between fans of these artists. I think their 10 most successful hits may be good? I remember there was a rate with such a format for individual Spice Girl careers.
poki Posted November 15, 2023 Posted November 15, 2023 10 hours ago, Hurem said: Does anyone have the results of Her Madgesty: The Madonna Discography Rate? I missed that one and would love to see how it all went down Can't access it but I remember someone said Sky Fits Heaven won (it also won in the oldATRL rate as well apparently)
Graves Posted November 15, 2023 Posted November 15, 2023 I want to do a Utada rate or something fun like that - where the j-pop girlies at?
poki Posted November 15, 2023 Posted November 15, 2023 19 minutes ago, Subomie said: I want to do a Utada rate or something fun like that - where the j-pop girlies at? I'll definitely participate!
naval23 Posted November 15, 2023 Posted November 15, 2023 15 hours ago, Hey Dude said: I have these artists in mind: Sarah McLachlan Kelly Clarkson P!nk Avril Lavigne Michelle Branch Natalie Imbruglia From my experience there is a lot of overlap between fans of these artists. I think their 10 most successful hits may be good? I remember there was a rate with such a format for individual Spice Girl careers. This would be such an iconic rate I'm here for it! Maybe a misc category for some classics like Ashlee Simpson and other pop rock icons 1
poki Posted November 15, 2023 Posted November 15, 2023 7 minutes ago, naval23 said: This would be such an iconic rate I'm here for it! Maybe a misc category for some classics like Ashlee Simpson and other pop rock icons Yeah I think these would be fun to add too Meredith Brooks - ***** Joan Osborne - One of Us Lisa Loeb - Stay (I Missed You) / I Do Billie Myers - Kiss the Rain I would even like a few male artists as well cause these tracks in particular would really fit the vibe: John Rzeznik - I'm Still Here Nick Carter - Help Me BBMAK - Back Here / Always Know Where You Are The Calling - Wherever You Will Go I think I'll make a list of about 100 tracks cause there's a specific vibe of alt rock I'm trying to aim for.
naval23 Posted November 16, 2023 Posted November 16, 2023 44 minutes ago, Hey Dude said: Yeah I think these would be fun to add too Meredith Brooks - ***** Joan Osborne - One of Us Lisa Loeb - Stay (I Missed You) / I Do Billie Myers - Kiss the Rain I would even like a few male artists as well cause these tracks in particular would really fit the vibe: John Rzeznik - I'm Still Here Nick Carter - Help Me BBMAK - Back Here / Always Know Where You Are The Calling - Wherever You Will Go I think I'll make a list of about 100 tracks cause there's a specific vibe of alt rock I'm trying to aim for. Love it! I'd definitely help make the list if you need some extra suggestions
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted November 16, 2023 Author ATRL Moderator Posted November 16, 2023 On 11/15/2023 at 3:15 AM, Hey Dude said: I have these artists in mind: Sarah McLachlan Kelly Clarkson P!nk Avril Lavigne Michelle Branch Natalie Imbruglia From my experience there is a lot of overlap between fans of these artists. I think their 10 most successful hits may be good? I remember there was a rate with such a format for individual Spice Girl careers. Hmm.... you'd be missing a lot of the original Lilith Fair girls? Might rethink the lineup!
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted November 16, 2023 Author ATRL Moderator Posted November 16, 2023 15 hours ago, Subomie said: I want to do a Utada rate or something fun like that - where the j-pop girlies at? Let's!
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted November 16, 2023 Author ATRL Moderator Posted November 16, 2023 On 11/15/2023 at 3:15 AM, Hey Dude said: I have these artists in mind: Sarah McLachlan Kelly Clarkson P!nk Avril Lavigne Michelle Branch Natalie Imbruglia From my experience there is a lot of overlap between fans of these artists. I think their 10 most successful hits may be good? I remember there was a rate with such a format for individual Spice Girl careers. 14 hours ago, naval23 said: This would be such an iconic rate I'm here for it! Maybe a misc category for some classics like Ashlee Simpson and other pop rock icons 14 hours ago, Hey Dude said: Yeah I think these would be fun to add too Meredith Brooks - ***** Joan Osborne - One of Us Lisa Loeb - Stay (I Missed You) / I Do Billie Myers - Kiss the Rain I would even like a few male artists as well cause these tracks in particular would really fit the vibe: John Rzeznik - I'm Still Here Nick Carter - Help Me BBMAK - Back Here / Always Know Where You Are The Calling - Wherever You Will Go I think I'll make a list of about 100 tracks cause there's a specific vibe of alt rock I'm trying to aim for. So, ixnay on the men - and on the artists who were never a part of it (sorry Ashlee!) The main stage performers from 97-99 (ignoring the 2010 lineup): Main stage artists Fiona Apple Tracy Bonham Meredith Brooks The Cardigans Mary Chapin Carpenter Tracy Chapman Paula Cole Shawn Colvin Sheryl Crow Indigo Girls Emmylou Harris Jewel Lisa Loeb Sarah McLachlan Joan Osborne Suzanne Vega Main stage artists Sarah McLachlan Bonnie Raitt Chantal Kreviazuk Cowboy Junkies Des'ree Diana Krall Emmylou Harris Erykah Badu Indigo Girls Joan Osborne Lisa Loeb Liz Phair Luscious Jackson Mary Chapin Carpenter Meredith Brooks Meshell Ndegeocello Missy Elliott Natalie Merchant Paula Cole Queen Latifah Shawn Colvin Sheryl Crow Sinéad O'Connor Suzanne Vega Tracy Bonham Main stage artists Sandra Bernhard Shawn Colvin Deborah Cox Sheryl Crow Dixie Chicks Indigo Girls Queen Latifah Lisa Loeb Luscious Jackson Martina McBride Sarah McLachlan Monica Mýa Meshell Ndegeocello Liz Phair The Pretenders Joanelle Romero Disappear Fear Suzanne Vega Obviously some of these names can be excised (what the hell is Disappear Fear?) and others don't fit the time period (The Pretenders - GOAT. But not exactly relevant in 97-99!) Let's do 3-5 singles from the MAJOR women of the time, and 2-3 from the 'minor' ones. What do you think?
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted November 16, 2023 ATRL Moderator Posted November 16, 2023 Yeah, someone needs to finaly do the Lilith Fair rate we've always talked about.
Graves Posted November 16, 2023 Posted November 16, 2023 (edited) Hehehe, the Hikki discography rate will begin preparations then Edited November 16, 2023 by Subomie
naval23 Posted November 16, 2023 Posted November 16, 2023 3 hours ago, Ace Reject said: So, ixnay on the men - and on the artists who were never a part of it (sorry Ashlee!) The main stage performers from 97-99 (ignoring the 2010 lineup): Main stage artists Fiona Apple Tracy Bonham Meredith Brooks The Cardigans Mary Chapin Carpenter Tracy Chapman Paula Cole Shawn Colvin Sheryl Crow Indigo Girls Emmylou Harris Jewel Lisa Loeb Sarah McLachlan Joan Osborne Suzanne Vega Main stage artists Sarah McLachlan Bonnie Raitt Chantal Kreviazuk Cowboy Junkies Des'ree Diana Krall Emmylou Harris Erykah Badu Indigo Girls Joan Osborne Lisa Loeb Liz Phair Luscious Jackson Mary Chapin Carpenter Meredith Brooks Meshell Ndegeocello Missy Elliott Natalie Merchant Paula Cole Queen Latifah Shawn Colvin Sheryl Crow Sinéad O'Connor Suzanne Vega Tracy Bonham Main stage artists Sandra Bernhard Shawn Colvin Deborah Cox Sheryl Crow Dixie Chicks Indigo Girls Queen Latifah Lisa Loeb Luscious Jackson Martina McBride Sarah McLachlan Monica Mýa Meshell Ndegeocello Liz Phair The Pretenders Joanelle Romero Disappear Fear Suzanne Vega Obviously some of these names can be excised (what the hell is Disappear Fear?) and others don't fit the time period (The Pretenders - GOAT. But not exactly relevant in 97-99!) Let's do 3-5 singles from the MAJOR women of the time, and 2-3 from the 'minor' ones. What do you think? This seems like a totally different rate than the one Hey Dude proposed - I prefer their idea but that's just me
Graves Posted November 18, 2023 Posted November 18, 2023 @Ace Reject I can put up a thread for Utada's rate whenever - just gimme the go ahead, king
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted November 19, 2023 Author ATRL Moderator Posted November 19, 2023 You got it! 1
ATRL Moderator Legend E Posted November 19, 2023 ATRL Moderator Posted November 19, 2023 @Hey Dude PLEASE do that Lilith Fair rate but choose one or a few more singles per artist. I'd love if we'd include the 2010 lineup too tho
poki Posted November 19, 2023 Posted November 19, 2023 3 hours ago, Legend E said: @Hey Dude PLEASE do that Lilith Fair rate but choose one or a few more singles per artist. I'd love if we'd include the 2010 lineup too tho Yes I'll make a list based on Ace Reject's concept and share it here soon 1
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted November 20, 2023 Author ATRL Moderator Posted November 20, 2023 18 hours ago, Hey Dude said: Yes I'll make a list based on Ace Reject's concept and share it here soon And I'm always here if you want to debate who's 'minor' and who's 'major!' Also, be careful to not include women who anti-Lilith Fair at the time - Alanis and Tori went on tour together in 1998 TO NOT BE included in it! So they can sit this one out!
touya kinomoto Posted December 10, 2023 Posted December 10, 2023 @Ace Reject rate suggestion: Ultimate Other Girls 2010s version! 1
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted December 11, 2023 Author ATRL Moderator Posted December 11, 2023 On 12/9/2023 at 7:26 PM, touya kinomoto said: @Ace Reject rate suggestion: Ultimate Other Girls 2010s version! Next year - have playlists all worked out! 1
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted December 11, 2023 Author ATRL Moderator Posted December 11, 2023 On 11/13/2023 at 11:47 PM, Ace Reject said: So, We've had a consensus. Year ends are approaching and we have to sort this out! THIS WAS 2023 will be split into TWO rates. I believe @supaspaz has expressed interest in the first lineup: Boygenius Jessie Ware Victoria Monet Zach Bryan Olivia Rodrigo Which leaves the second edition needing a host! Rating these albums.... Lana Del Rey Kelela Caroline Polachek Mitski Sufjan Stevens And THIS WAS POP 2023 will be split up into two, as well Rate 1 - Icons and Legends Miley Cyrus Pink Kelly Clarkson Kylie Minogue Nicki Minaj (if it actually is released this year) Rate 2 - The New Class Amaarae Madison Beer Troye Sivan Chappell Roan PinkPantheress Who wants in? So... who's going to start one of these? Are we waiting for the SZA to drop?
touya kinomoto Posted December 11, 2023 Posted December 11, 2023 4 hours ago, Ace Reject said: Next year - have playlists all worked out! love it! ready for the mess!
poki Posted December 11, 2023 Posted December 11, 2023 I will get back to the Lilith Fair idea around Christmas A pokemon rate will keep me busy this week.
Graves Posted December 23, 2023 Posted December 23, 2023 Somebody should re-up a Bjork discography rate next year - it's been ten years since it was last done 1 1
Recommended Posts