GreasyBruce

It used to be MUCH worse In the 90s Mariah used to have these huge stands next to cash registers selling her singles for 49 cents a pop. No shade but that's how she got some of her #1s!

"River" might be a hit and could save the album in terms of SPS but yeah, his days as a huge force are over.

It's almost impossible for it to go #1, airplay and sales aren't nearly high enough. Still insanely impressive and in the long run it might become the biggest song of all time.

All I Want For Christmas Is Red Bottoms

Despite a so-so performance on pop radio, "Too Good at Goodbyes" has held on rather well on the Hot 100. A real hit with longevity. I think "Palace" could be another hit from the album. The melody is really beautiful.

Didn't she outsell Starboy? This era ended up proving that she has a huge and very loyal fanbase unlikely to go away anytime soon. Good for her.

What did I tell y'all? Dissing Trump isn't cool to the kids. https://atrl.net/forums/topic/120-stand-your-ground/?page=23451# https://atrl.net/forums/topic/120-stand-your-ground/?page=23448# https://atrl.net/forums/topic/99280-is-eminem-trying-too-hard/#

Random but there are many more classics than that lol. Channel Orange is definitely a modern classic, as is To Pimp a Butterfly. Random Access Memories is one too. As is 1989. And EMOTION is a modern pop classic among its niche audience. Racine Carrere is a classic in France. There are other examples too. OT: Shook at Halsey getting her first Top 10.

"Never Be the Same" is doing really well with iTunes buyers. This could help her expand her fanbase to an older audience.

Hi. I've never done this before so here it goes. I'll be counting down my Top 20 for Singles, Albums, and giving out Special Awards, including some slightly shady ones hihi. I shall start after I'm done listening to this new Eminem album

Slay, Michelle!

What kind of mess is this post M!ssundaztood era was huge in America and basically started the pop rock girl trend of the mid 00s. Im Not Dead and Funhouse were also successful with multiple big hits

"Revenge" is coming

White women aged 25-35, the demographic that spends the most + advertisers want the most P!nk won

P!nk's label gets nothing from her tour.