base talk Confessions on a Dance Floor vs Renaissance

[Santhosh]

Madonna sweetie

[UnusualBoy]

Confessions for all.

[byzantium]

Renaissance. 
 

Now let's see how many Madonna fans downvote this.  It's kind of their M.O. 

Edited April 3 by byzantium

[Ewan Chaos]

Renaissance for sure. 

 

I get the love for Confessions because it's kinda lots of people's first Madge album (and stans lauding it for giving Madge an impressive late-career push of commercial success), but like... it's not even in her top 5  Great album regardless of course, but Renaissance is Bey's magnum opus and will probably stay that way even once act iii has come and gone.

[Glamthony]

Madonna.

 

Ren is not that far tho, Beyoncé really made a fantastic album, the best dance record since Confessions on a dancefloor, she really put her heel on every MPG neck. I'm a happier PAP bottom since it came out.

[LikeaRebel]

Confessions for all 

[truthteller]

gays vs f**s

[Oktober Knight]

Confessions 

Confessions 

Renaissance 

[LOTF]

1 hour ago, byzantium said:

Renaissance. 
 

Now let's see how many Madonna fans downvote this.  It's kind of their M.O. 

And swifties don't turn to downvoting? Lmao

[byzantium]

5 minutes ago, LOTF said:

And swifties don't turn to downvoting? Lmao

Now please find anywhere in my post where I said anything to the contrary.  

[John Slayne]

I love Renaissance but Confessions is just better

[Marla Singer]

Album:

 

Singles:

 

Tour:

[Marry The Gods]

COADF for all but Ren is a good album too 

[Chris]

The way the OP exposed his own dupe in his likes.

 

 

@Josh21?

 

At least come up with a different username.

 

[Josh]

3 minutes ago, Chris said:

The way the OP exposed his own dupe in his likes.

 

 

@Josh21?

 

At least come up with a different username.

 

Why would I have a dupe? Why would I need a dupe? 

[GreatestLoveofAll]

confessions had better singles. thats about it.

[nostalgic]

The Confessions Tour is simply unmatched - I'd go as far as saying it's the best concert tour of all time - backed up by one of her best albums which is consistent from beginning to end (yes, even the unfairly panned camp classic I Love New York). 

[Miss Anthropocene]

Confessions is unmatched from start to finish, you really set renaissance up 

[Fleahive]

Can someone post clips of confessions tour im surprised someone said it had better production. I thought Reneigh tour was one of the highest budget tours out there. 

[Cardcaptor Sakura]

8 hours ago, bjorn said:

Hung Up is better than ANYTHING Beyoncé has ever released let's not kid ourselves. 

. 

[Ms. Togekiss]

GODfessions sweetie I am SO sorry

[popmusicisdead]

sorry i love Rene but Confessions is a literal perfect album. the single run was also flawless 

[Eternium]

Renaissance is an abysmal album with terrible singles. The tour was a snooze and I get what she was going for, but it was too long and a slog to sit through. 
 

COADF is far and away the winner.

[Eternium]

8 hours ago, Ewan Chaos said:

Renaissance is Bey's magnum opus

Beyonce, sweetie, I'm so sorry

[tellem]

COADF isn't a great album. look at the tracklist and try to point out the standout tracks