poll Bigger: Miley or Ariana?

[State of Grace.]

You know it's BAD when they start rambling about Hannah Montana

 

[Freakshowvato]

Ariana is the bigger artist.

 

If Miley did not have Flowers, this would not even be debated.

[flashfox]

hannah montana 

[Freakshowvato]

8 minutes ago, Wildcat said:

Miley Cyrus. Hannah Montana was a cultural phenomenon and she experienced massive success in music, TV and film during her peak. ATRL pretends that Miley's career started with Bangerz but she was already a household name before Ariana came into the picture.

So Miley is bigger because of a Disney channel show

[Strawberry Bubble]

Flowers is the only momentum Miley had to be bigger than Ariana. But Ariana has a whole bigger discography. 

[slobro]

Problem

Break Free

One Last Time

Bang Bang

Side to Side

Love Me Harder

Dangerous Woman

Into You

No Tears Left To Cry

God Is A Woman

Thank U, Next

7 Rings

Break Up With Your Girlfriend

Rain On Me

Stuck With U

Save Your Tears

Die For You

Positions

34+35

Yes, And

 

Vs

 

Flowers

Party In The USA

 

[Blue Monday]

Aren’t both 7 Rings and Thank U, Next eligible for diamond certifications? The fact that she has several other sizable hits has to eviscerate this argument that the size of Ariana’s singles aren’t relevant just because of how massive Flowers was. Clearly the song is more popular than its artist 

Edited March 10 by Blue Monday

[AccioMiley]

Here we go again. Arianators living vicariously through her like her achievements are their own. Bunch of losers

[Raphy23]

Miley. 

[wish]

Another thread 

 

Ariana has enjoyed more album success in the Spotify era, as evidenced by ES numbers. That will never discredit Miley‘s pop culture impact, massive peak, 18 year career longevity, catalog of memorable hits, and immense talent that will continue to carry her for years to come. 

[FailSafe]

Who sold more albums across their entire career?

Who has bigger hits?

Who has more successful movies/tv shows?

Who has more iconic image?

[Wildcat]

32 minutes ago, Freakshowvato said:

So Miley is bigger because of a Disney channel show

Well, that billion-dollar franchise that spawned music albums, concert tours and theatrical films happens to be part of Miley's career. If you want to ignore her early career that's fine, she will still end up having 4 (solo) diamond songs. Not everyone with a Disney Channel show has that!..

 

 

[Miley Cyrus]

Still Miley. No amount of quick lil frontloaded streams that fizzle out after a few weeks and weeknd collabs can change that.

Edited March 10 by Miley Cyrus

[Erreur2 La Nature]

ATRL is the only place where people would claim Ari is bigger than Miley 

While Ariana feels more popular overall, Miley's career is much more impressive.

[Scars]

The Eternal Sunshine Spotify thread is filled with a dozen of Swifties having a circlejerk and trying to paint the genuinely good numbers of ES as an underperformance, but Arianators are still deflecting from that and obsessing over Miley vs. Ariana because of 3-4 trolls. Things have really changed since 2019, I see. 

[Walk_Away21]

1 hour ago, State of Grace. said:

You know it's BAD when they start rambling about Hannah Montana

 

Lmao so Taylor’s accolades don’t include Debut or Fearless because she was young during that time? Hannah Montana is part of her career and was a huge cultural phenomenon that spread across music, tv, and a movie. Sorry Ariana was forgettable on the less popular Victorious? The logic isn’t there.

[unclefloprry]

Ariana and it's not even a debate.

We know things are bad when Miley can't compete with her real peers (Gaga, Taylor, RIhanna, Katy) and needs to be compared to an artist who debuted 10 years later... and still loses ijbol

[State of Grace.]

Just now, Walk_Away21 said:

Lmao so Taylor’s accolades don’t include Debut or Fearless because she was young during that time? Hannah Montana is part of her career and was a huge cultural phenomenon that spread across music, tv, and a movie. Sorry Ariana was forgettable on the less popular Victorious? The logic isn’t there.

[Blue Monday]

17 minutes ago, Scars said:

The Eternal Sunshine Spotify thread is filled with a dozen of Swifties having a circlejerk and trying to paint the genuinely good numbers of ES as an underperformance, but Arianators are still deflecting from that and obsessing over Miley vs. Ariana because of 3-4 trolls. Things have really changed since 2019, I see. 

We’re actually just trying to get y’all to join us on Earth 1 and end this silly debate once and for all, but if you want to keep living in a fantasy world that’s your decision 

[jjmed59]

34 minutes ago, Miley Cyrus said:

Still Miley. No amount of quick lil frontloaded streams that fizzle out after a few weeks and weeknd collabs can change that.

ouuu miley didnt even have frontloaded streams to fizzle out from with ESV  dead from the start

Edited March 10 by jjmed59

[AccioMiley]

29 minutes ago, Blue Monday said:

We’re actually just trying to get y’all to join us on Earth 1 and end this silly debate once and for all, but if you want to keep living in a fantasy world that’s your decision 

Why dont you let us live in this "fantasy world" you speak of and stop being so insecure?? Just a suggestion 

[Marianah Adkins]

Miley has a great career and had her huge moments but careerwise overall its Ariana. 

The fact that Ari’s album is doing well so far despite her homewrecking, the hate train against her, and her lead single tanking faster than the Titanic shows that she has a bigger pull.

Miley literally had one of the biggest hits of all time and it still didnt carry ESV. 

[suburbannature]

Right now or overall?

[Pillz]

Ariana will always generate consistent buzz, but Miley has giant peaks and has proven to be able to re-peak late in her career. So Miley

[rnb]

both