album Doja Cat - 'Scarlet'

[B-Luke]

2 hours ago, ImpressMeMuch said:

'Fans ain't dumb, but extremists are' is such a mic drop for all the 'kittens' who told on themselves in the month prior to PTTR launching - honestly respect her for taking parasocial **** head on
 

also that pitchfork writer really should have read the room that she isn't in the position to review this - the more I listen the more I cringe

 

I really gotta look up lyrics sometimes, I thought she said "Bandz ain‘t gum but extremely sore" 

Edited September 29, 2023 by B-Luke

[X~MoviePoP]

I thought it was fans aint dumb but extremely sore. (Like fans are reaching) lol

[Mystic Boy]

8 hours ago, ultraviolence.xx said:

with that avi i know youre lovin that song!

The second part of the album is literally a tribute to soft Hip Hop/Neo Soul/ Mid 90s RnB.

It's so well done that it made me return back to that era.

And which masterpiece embodies best that era other than Queen Erykah with "Baduizm" ?

[Flocon]

#05 on Australian Charts for Scarlet.

Planet Her entered at #03, and peaked at #02

[Supervillain]

The fact she has enough songs to give us a sister album, ugh  People are saying this album is too long but I’m craving more  

[Flocon]

They merged the 2 versions on Apple Music charts !

[Kaizen]

Woke up with Agora Hills stuck in my head. 
 

Doja and her hits that stick like grits. 

[Prodigal Self]

2 hours ago, Supervillain said:

The fact she has enough songs to give us a sister album, ugh  People are saying this album is too long but I’m craving more  

It's not even an hour long, I would like a sister album very much

[Alex]

If the project was indeed 2 separate albums, it would be really cool if she did an expanded version and completed each side so it could become a double album. 

[Prodigal Self]

Also how Demons kinda outlasted PTTR

[Kern]

Insane how people are forcing themselves to like this  

[popularmoonlight]

3 hours ago, Supervillain said:

The fact she has enough songs to give us a sister album, ugh  People are saying this album is too long but I’m craving more  

I don't get that. I press play on PTTR and then suddenly Attention is starting. The album flows so well for me, it's a very easy listen so the length never really bothered me

[Flocon]

Another bad news, Scarlet missed the Top 10 in France...

[RihsUmbrella]

Imagine thinking your opinion is so superior that everyone else must be forcing themselves to have a different opinion than you 

[Kaizen]

I can’t wait to get this on vinyl. 

[makeme]

6 hours ago, Flocon said:

#05 on Australian Charts for Scarlet.

Planet Her entered at #03, and peaked at #02

Yeah this is really bad. Oceania usually supports her before other countries. Not a good sign 

[Flocon]

OMG she missed Top 10 in Sweden and Ireland...

[wish]

3 hours ago, Flocon said:

They merged the 2 versions on Apple Music charts !

I'm still seeing 2 versions of Agora Hills (#73 and #78)

[Tangane]

3 hours ago, stupidjock said:

Insane how people are forcing themselves to like this  

And who forced you to enter this thread? Really, some people are just out here on ATRL trying to collect downvotes I swear!

[dabunique]

[Braz]

The chart debuts, oh it's bad for her...

[TiaTamera]

2 hours ago, wish said:

I'm still seeing 2 versions of Agora Hills (#73 and #78)

What’s so bad about there being two versions?

 

for example, if #73 has 1.5 million streams and #78 has 1 million isn’t it still $2.5 million streams regardless of it was combined and at let’s say #65 instead?

[IBeMe]

6 minutes ago, TiaTamera said:

What’s so bad about there being two versions?

 

for example, if #73 has 1.5 million streams and #78 has 1 million isn’t it still $2.5 million streams regardless of it was combined and at let’s say #65 instead?

you're right that the raw streams get combined on the charts but the issue is there are a lot of daily top 50 playlists that a song can only enter if it actually is in the daily top 50 streaming charts so having two versions splits the streams and the song just wont be added on top playlists because of it (at least I think that's one of the issues...not totally sure tbh) 

[wish]

3 minutes ago, TiaTamera said:

What’s so bad about there being two versions?

 

for example, if #73 has 1.5 million streams and #78 has 1 million isn’t it still $2.5 million streams regardless of it was combined and at let’s say #65 instead?

Ultimately the numbers are the same on Billboard combined or not. But if everything had one version on AM, Scarlet would have been #1/#2 on the app and there would have been a dozen of Scarlet tracks rising up the charts, which looks A LOT better and influences the public to stream more bc it looks more successful.

 

When there's 2 versions, nothing is strong enough to chart bc all of the numbers are split. That's why none of the album tracks charted on AM besides Agora Hills 

[TiaTamera]

Just now, IBeMe said:

you're right that the raw streams get combined on the charts but the issue is there are a lot of daily top 50 playlists that a song can only enter if it actually is in the daily top 50 streaming charts so having two versions splits the streams and the song just wont be added on top playlists because of it (at least I think that's one of the issues...not totally sure tbh) 

Okay thank you, so basically it would have more visibility if it was charging higher.