Jump to content

Can black artist get away with less than mediocre vocals like Taylor?


Recommended Posts

Posted
2 hours ago, Not Like The Movies said:

yall bringing up Rih, Normani and Janet, yet all 3 can sing circles around TS. 

 

 

Normani can not sing circles around ANYBODY let’s stop :rip:

  • Replies 382
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • lonnie

    18

  • Sex with Rih

    13

  • Josh

    9

  • ImsoLOUD

    9

Posted

Ta

29 minutes ago, ImsoLOUD said:

Taylor’s songwriting is arguably mediocre and childish in itself (hence Kids Bop esque songs like “Me!”). Which is why you constantly attempting to use songwriting as her one trick that keeps her afloat never holds any weight. If Rihanna sucks, so does she. 
 

With a half Rihanna username :rip: I would certainly imagine that you have seen enough Rihanna performances to acknowledge that at the very least she does posses vocal talent. Even if she is inconsistent. 

 

She is a great songwriter, that's obvious, you just can't admit it because you don't like her. Which is fine but

Taylor connects with people because of dat and she's a great melody maker because she can play alot of instruments, her voice is pleasant to people, that's it. She isn't a vocalist but people love her tone. If they didn't, she wouldn't be so consumed.

 

Idg why her success upset you so much? Is it really that serious? Y'all stan people like ava Kim Petra's and Katy etc but Taylor is the only white girl that gets crap for nothing?

 

If I wanted to see a dope dance choreo show or a power vocalist then I obviously ain't going to Taylor but she fits a different slot for a nice day chillin. As a black woman, I don't see who this girl is hurting? She's harmless af and has never said crap about the community like other we seem to stan on here

Posted

 

47 minutes ago, ImsoLOUD said:

Taylor’s songwriting is arguably mediocre and childish in itself (hence Kids Bop esque songs like “Me!”). Which is why you constantly attempting to use songwriting as her one trick that keeps her afloat never holds any weight. If Rihanna sucks, so does she. 
 

With a half Rihanna username :rip: I would certainly imagine that you have seen enough Rihanna performances to acknowledge that at the very least she does posses vocal talent. Even if she is inconsistent. 

 

If Taylor's songwriting is arguably mediocre then Rihanna certainly has zero talent related to music

Posted
6 minutes ago, Andre2000 said:

Ta

She is a great songwriter, that's obvious, you just can't admit it because you don't like her. Which is fine but

Taylor connects with people because of dat and she's a great melody maker because she can play alot of instruments, her voice is pleasant to people, that's it. She isn't a vocalist but people love her tone. If they didn't, she wouldn't be so consumed.

 

Idg why her success upset you so much? Is it really that serious? Y'all stan people like ava Kim Petra's and Katy etc but Taylor is the only white girl that gets crap for nothing?

 

If I wanted to see a dope dance choreo show or a power vocalist then I obviously ain't going to Taylor but she fits a different slot for a nice day chillin. As a black woman, I don't see who this girl is hurting? She's harmless af and has never said crap about the community like other we seem to stan on here

 

 

 

Posted
7 minutes ago, GoatGly said:

Normani can not sing circles around ANYBODY let’s stop :rip:

That's a bold lie. 

She has a stronger voice than a lot of those white pop girls yall stan 

She could also do whistle note.  

 

 

Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, Monster Queen said:

 

If Taylor's songwriting is arguably mediocre then Rihanna certainly has zero talent related to music

I already said that Monster Queen. I’m glad that we can agree.

Edited by ImsoLOUD
Posted
1 minute ago, ImsoLOUD said:

I already said that Monster Queen. I’m glad that we can agree.

So Taylor is still more talented than Rihanna.  I’m glad that we can agree.

Posted (edited)

Rihanna literally exists who is the 2nd biggest female artist of this century

 

You all try too much sometimes 

Edited by FolkLover1989
Posted
Just now, Monster Queen said:

So Taylor is still more talented than Rihanna.  I’m glad that we can agree.

spacer.png

 

Posted
5 hours ago, Big Bad Wolf said:

No. Just look at Rihanna and how people bash her for being “talentless”, but others have literally PRAISED someone like Selena Gomez for having a “good career despite no talent” or whatever + they eat up her whisper vocals like no tomorrow too. But Rihanna gets dragged for everything under the sun even though her discography is full of literal classics. 

That's true. Rihanna is a good singer. She is no Whitney but it's okay. Not everyone has to be a vocalist.

MadonnasBoyfriend
Posted

Janet Jackson

Posted

Can a Black artist get away with mediocre vocals and be successful and well-liked? Yes. 

 

Will they be as successful as Taylor Swift? No. 

Posted (edited)
8 hours ago, Holiest Dreams said:

None of you that are claiming this actually believe it :toofunny3:

Taylor’s voice is extremely bland and mediocre and she can’t sing AT ALL which is why 99% of her current tour is lip-synced and she hasn’t delivered a highly praised vocal performance in a century (since she debuted). This is just facts and i am in no way being biased. She has absolutely nothing going for her voice. She excels in the songwriting department though so there’s that!

 

Going to a Taylor concert is like listening to Spotify loudly because the playback encapsulates her horrendous “vocals”.

 

Swifties under this thread lack self awareness. Your fave is a terrible singer with ZERO vocal talent. She’s the bottom of the barrel in that department. Rihanna on the other hand, has more hits than misses. 

 

9F9C84F1-878C-4137-80AD-45A55FE38185.jpe

Edited by airplane
Posted

You can stay pressed because nobody Stan’s Taylor as a vocalist, people stan her as a lyrical and melodic mastermind, this is like someone asking Can a x artist get away with less than mediocre lyrics like Beyoncé just because she sings “That's that thick, that's that real **** that's that jelly, baby, champagne and cherry, baby that's that thick” in her last album.

Posted

The fact that every single black woman that was named in this thread is much better at singing that Taylor Swift. :rip:

 

Posted

Jhene Aiko doesn’t have a show-stopping voice but that’s not what people go to her for. I don’t get this thread. Irrespective of race, lots of well-written contemporary music is sung by people who are technically meh singers with a likeable & distinct persona & vocal tone. The era of virtuosic powerhouse vocals is gone

Posted
8 hours ago, MadonnasBoyfriend said:

Janet Jackson

is a much better singer than TS.

Posted

All the black female artists named here sing way better than Taylor so y'all aren't helping anyone.

Posted

I don't know why swifties are bringing up writing as if the OP didn't say ' Vocals'- which Taylor lacks.

Posted

well y'all praise normani and girl can't hold a note

Posted
20 minutes ago, Stankonia said:

The fact that every single black woman that was named in this thread is much better at singing that Taylor Swift. :rip:

 

 

6 minutes ago, Sex with Rih said:

All the black female artists named here sing way better than Taylor so y'all aren't helping anyone.

 

5 minutes ago, Sex with Rih said:

I don't know why swifties are bringing up writing as if the OP didn't say ' Vocals'- which Taylor lacks.

So Taylor can write much better than them

 

Maybe that's the reason of her success 

Posted

Bringing up Rihanna & Normani are all much more capable vocalist than Taylor, so it doesn’t make sense to bring them up. 

Posted
12 hours ago, Helios said:

Yes Janet Jackson did. :michael:

i challenge you to find me a single video of Janet singing out of tune live. I’ll find you 100 videos of Taylor.
 

Janet has a soft voice naturally which does not mean she’s vocally unskilled. Anyone that has actual vocal knowledge would tell you she’s 100x the vocalist Taylor is let’s not :dies:

Posted
14 hours ago, TheArgonaut said:

Rihanna is not a better vocalist than Taylor.

I refuse to believe Taylor’s label isn’t paying you for this.

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.