Saddy Posted Saturday at 02:29 PM Posted Saturday at 02:29 PM (edited) 9 hours ago, Ace Reject said: 1) Whitney presents a dilemma - if you include soundtracks, would you then have to include Christmas releases? Live albums? Remix albums? I was planning to skip Mariah's 4th album in case if the diva's rates would continue (meaning not include Mariah at all, so it would be only 5 girls instead of 6). It would be Whitney's The Bodyguard, Like a Prayer, Janet Jackson's Rhythm Nation 1814, Falling into You and Let's Get to It. For the Christmas release, it think it would be better to do a Christmas rate, but I don't think ppl will participate in this one And I never planned to include remixes or live albums. 9 hours ago, Ace Reject said: 2) It is ... unfair to put two of the best pop albums of all time (LAP and JJRN1814, of course) up against...Let's Get To It. And I love LGTI! More than most. But, come on? It's unfair but it's fun, that's what these rates are about in my opinion. The suspense is here and you don't know what song is gonna be out next. And who knows maybe 2 songs gonna end up having the same score so they will have the same spot But still, you're the one who approves it, I just listen to people's wishes. Many of them want 3rd, 4th and even 5th rate to happen, cuz there are good albums and the real fun will start with them Then I'll leave Britney rate for later and continue with the Divas. I'll open the thread in December, maybe on the Xmas week (or a week earlier) cuz we are having so many rates rn and i don't want to add a new one Edited Saturday at 02:31 PM by Saddy
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted Sunday at 09:28 PM Author ATRL Moderator Posted Sunday at 09:28 PM And a new rate idea, from the always great @Patrick: "Life Alert: Help! MY Career's Fallen and It Can't Get Up!" 143 v. 7 v. Bouquet v. This is Me... Now Who wants to host? @touya kinomoto? 3
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted 17 hours ago ATRL Moderator Posted 17 hours ago I was just reminiscing on Jewel's 0304 with @Reverie and we need to get this masterpiece into a rate somehow. What other sellout albums we could throw in together? Maybe Liz Phair? 1
Suilen Posted 16 hours ago Posted 16 hours ago 1 hour ago, supaspaz said: I was just reminiscing on Jewel's 0304 with @Reverie and we need to get this masterpiece into a rate somehow. What other sellout albums we could throw in together? Maybe Liz Phair? Courtney Love's America's Sweetheart? Not exactly a sellout record, but fits the 'downfall' theme.
SupremeGoddess Posted 6 hours ago Posted 6 hours ago 11 hours ago, supaspaz said: I was just reminiscing on Jewel's 0304 with @Reverie and we need to get this masterpiece into a rate somehow. What other sellout albums we could throw in together? Maybe Liz Phair? Her best album ahh the way 0304 would just dominate the entire top 10. Id be here for a underappreciated supposed sell out pop girls. Jewel, Liz Phair's self titled, maybe Courtney Love's In Conversation, Tori's To Venus and Back? @Ace Rejecti want to host canadian portuguese legend nelly furtado discography rate
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted 5 hours ago Author ATRL Moderator Posted 5 hours ago 11 hours ago, supaspaz said: I was just reminiscing on Jewel's 0304 with @Reverie and we need to get this masterpiece into a rate somehow. What other sellout albums we could throw in together? Maybe Liz Phair? Maybe Bittersweet World? But Ashlee never had any credibility, so... C'mon C'mon! Still remember the criticism Sheryl got for posing for either FHM or Maxim. And if you're opening up to all of the early/mid-aughts, Faith's Cry! She had to come back with her own version of "Jenny From The Block" to combat the criticism she got for making that record.
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted 11 minutes ago ATRL Moderator Posted 11 minutes ago 5 hours ago, Ace Reject said: C'mon C'mon! Still remember the criticism Sheryl got for posing for either FHM or Maxim. Now you're talking! The Lilith Fair sellouts.
Recommended Posts