KillingYourCareer Posted October 20 Posted October 20 1 minute ago, supaspaz said: Not even top ten? Flop results! I guess our tea is canceled! 1
prézli Posted October 20 Posted October 20 28 minutes ago, Saddy said: Low score: 4 @KillingYourCareer PFFFFFFFFF!!! Her second best song TO DATE.
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted October 20 ATRL Moderator Posted October 20 19 minutes ago, Saddy said: #3 Someday Score: 8.53 High score: 10 @Album Leak@Soda Pop Queen@KillingYourCareer@Mariya Takeuchi@creativity.@sparrowblue@Nightingale@jacklovesyou1@supaspaz@poki Low score: 4 @SoldierofLove Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "i can see why mariah doesnt care for it but shes her first dance hit so lets give it respect!" Ewan Chaos: "Love her voice on this one" YES THE BEST MARIAH TRACK PREVAILED 2
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted October 20 ATRL Moderator Posted October 20 16 minutes ago, Saddy said: the one true shining moment on the album Wrong! @Ewan Chaos, you’ve been brainwashed by anti-Whitney rhetoric. 2
SoldierofLove Posted October 20 Posted October 20 22 minutes ago, Saddy said: #3 Someday Score: 8.53 High score: 10 @Album Leak@Soda Pop Queen@KillingYourCareer@Mariya Takeuchi@creativity.@sparrowblue@Nightingale@jacklovesyou1@supaspaz@poki Low score: 4 @SoldierofLove Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "i can see why mariah doesnt care for it but shes her first dance hit so lets give it respect!" Ewan Chaos: "Love her voice on this one" 20 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said: Should have joined my @SoldierofLove with a 4 but I gave it a 8 because I'm such a cupcake! Anyways now it's between How Will I Know and Borderline. My vote goes to Borderline The tens are so unserious!!! 1
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted October 20 ATRL Moderator Posted October 20 The top ten is too obvious and extremely underwhelming, but I do love all of the top three songs, so I’ll live. Thank you for hosting, @Saddy! I’m glad we could finally revive this rate. 1
SoldierofLove Posted October 20 Posted October 20 17 minutes ago, Saddy said: That's all. Thanks everyone for participating. Let me know if u want sophomore album rate. I don't think Ace and Supaspaz will mind Thank you for doing this! We appreciate you 1
SoldierofLove Posted October 20 Posted October 20 DM me to exchange nudes and coordinate the sophomore albums rate 1
Saddy Posted October 20 Author Posted October 20 @supaspaz @Ace Reject it's okay if I continue with this pre-2000s divas rate? The next one is gonna be sophomore albums rate
poki Posted October 20 Posted October 20 Thank you for the rate @Saddy If we make it to 3rd albums and onwards, trust I'll have 10s all across the board 1
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted October 20 ATRL Moderator Posted October 20 1 hour ago, KillingYourCareer said: I guess our tea is canceled! I’m going to have to bring you to the red table
sparrowblue Posted October 21 Posted October 21 glad Cèline made it to the top 10. and Someday was CLOSE to getting my 11 which maybe could've pushed it further but at least it beat vision of love. 1
sparrowblue Posted October 21 Posted October 21 thanks @Saddy for another fun rate. the albums only get better from here and I will be there for a sophomore rate if it does happen 1
Curaga Posted October 21 Posted October 21 Not my 11 being #11, oh that's cruel... and not Whitney winning the whole damn thing I should have been more evil lol It was pretty hilarious to see me not listed as the lowest scorer on a bunch of these songs because someone did 3.0 and I did 3.1, someone did 4.0 and I did 4.3, etc. I hope the random decimals helped with tie-breaking. Sorry I couldn't be there for the live results today, but, @Saddy, thank you sooooo much for hosting this + all the time you put into it! 2
Suilen Posted October 21 Posted October 21 How Will I Know is a good winner. I'm surprised Mariah didn't win with Prisoner or Someday considering her domination. Borderline... never got that one personally. 1
Soda Pop Queen Posted October 21 Posted October 21 (edited) lol I forgot all about 'All At Once'. Should've went out in the second wave tbh. It's a snooze. I don't know how I feel about 'How Will I Know' winning. I like the song but I like 'You Give Good Love' and 'Saving All My Love For You' better. I'm surprised Céline even made the top 10 but it her 2 songs that she had left are great, unlike most of the other girls' album tracks. Borderline deserved to be Madonna's highest for sure. Holiday could've traded places with Burning Up 12 inch. I like all the songs Mariah had in the top 20 but some of them are too high. 'Alone In Love' is better than half those songs imo. Thanks for the rate! Edited October 21 by Soda Pop Queen 1
Ewan Chaos Posted October 21 Posted October 21 I'm sorry for missing Saturday & Sunday reveals but whew the chaos fairly fun results though even if the top 3 is predictable, and I would have been happy with any of those 3 songs winning. Thanks for hosting!! 1
naval23 Posted October 22 Posted October 22 Whitney her debut era and 80s eras were truly unmatched 1
GreatestLoveofAll Posted October 26 Posted October 26 I'm so upset I missed this like whattt 😭😭 but Whitney number one iktr and like in the top 20? Oh Legendney 1
jacklovesyou1 Posted October 27 Posted October 27 Actually fine with the results glad it wasn't all one artist being in the top 10 :D @saddy you did a great job and yes i will be doing pt 2 ofc 1
Recommended Posts