Saddy Posted October 18 Author Posted October 18 #49 Have a Heart Score: 5.70 High score: 10 @GreatestLoveofAll@sparrowblue Low score: 2 @GraceRandolph@Album Leak@creativity. Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "The 3rd best song of the rate! if we could have a 11 for each album it would go to this."
SoldierofLove Posted October 18 Posted October 18 14 minutes ago, creativity. said: I didn't expect Janet to get punched this hard is this because of her Kamala comments?? Yes. 2
Curaga Posted October 18 Posted October 18 Just now, ChooseyLover said: I don't know if it's just me but the longer Madonna mixes felt just like the OGs... And if I had to choose I'd stick to the shorter versions. I thought the new Lucky Star mix wasn't very different at all, but the new Burning Up mix was way better than the OG to me! (I still gave both Burning Up mixes 10s ) 1
Album Leak Posted October 18 Posted October 18 Dull ballad to me. To be honest, nothing from Celine's album really left a huge impression, positive or negative
Saddy Posted October 18 Author Posted October 18 #48 I'll Still Be Loving You Score: 5.71 High score: 10 @Mariya Takeuchi@Ace Reject Low score: 1 @Soda Pop Queen@sparrowblue
KillingYourCareer Posted October 18 Posted October 18 Have a Heart so low?! It has such a strong melody, and drama! 3
creativity. Posted October 18 Posted October 18 So Mariah is the only one who hasn't had a song leave yet… interesting 1
Saddy Posted October 18 Author Posted October 18 #47 Unison Score: 5.76 High score: 10 @Curaga@SoldierofLove@poki Low score: 0 @ChooseyLover Comments: Curaga: "Kinda copied Papa Don't Preach a bit, but I'm stanning!" 2
ATRL Moderator Ace Reject Posted October 18 ATRL Moderator Posted October 18 2 minutes ago, Saddy said: #48 I'll Still Be Loving You Score: 5.71 High score: 10 @Mariya Takeuchi@Ace Reject Low score: 1 @Soda Pop Queen@sparrowblue Criminal. @sparrowblue you just didn't get it. 1
Saddy Posted October 18 Author Posted October 18 Just now, creativity. said: So Mariah is the only one who hasn't had a song leave yet… interesting I'm surprised too
Curaga Posted October 18 Posted October 18 (edited) 2 minutes ago, Saddy said: #47 Unison Score: 5.76 High score: 10 @Curaga@SoldierofLove@poki Low score: 0 @ChooseyLover Comments: Curaga: "Kinda copied Papa Don't Preach a bit, but I'm stanning!" @poki, we're besties again edit: WAIT @ChooseyLover MAMA Edited October 18 by Curaga 1
Album Leak Posted October 18 Posted October 18 (edited) This is the first real blunder in this rate. This is one of the best songs of the album! The male parts definitely kill it though. Edited October 18 by Album Leak 3
ChooseyLover Posted October 18 Posted October 18 1 minute ago, KillingYourCareer said: Have a Heart so low?! It has such a strong melody, and drama! I'm so confused because I really liked that one. 5 minutes ago, Curaga said: I thought the new Lucky Star mix wasn't very different at all, but the new Burning Up mix was way better than the OG to me! (I still gave both Burning Up mixes 10s ) I swear I listened to them back to back a few times and I didn't notice anything but I've observed some Madonna stans have strong preferences Makes me feel a bit dumb/deaf/both. 1 1
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted October 18 ATRL Moderator Posted October 18 29 minutes ago, KillingYourCareer said: This was the only song I truly enjoyed from Janet's album Whew, your taste never fails to shock me! 1
Saddy Posted October 18 Author Posted October 18 #46 Thinking About You Score: 5.77 High score: 11 @supaspaz Low score: 1 @KillingYourCareer Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "Another 80s song where production holds it back and worst, where her voice isnt as clear as it should be. not whitney's fault tho." Curaga: "The mixing here is absolutely tragic " Ewan Chaos: "This started off pretty good, but then it was just 5min of a snooze."
ChooseyLover Posted October 18 Posted October 18 2 minutes ago, Curaga said: @poki, we're besties again edit: WAIT @ChooseyLover MAMA I hated it so much. I know Céline loves Michael Jackson but this attempt at doing something similar was so out of place for me. It legit made me so mad for no reason 2
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted October 18 ATRL Moderator Posted October 18 25 minutes ago, Saddy said: #54 I Know It Score: 5.43 High score: 8.6 @Curaga Low score: 1 @poki Comments: Curaga: "Love that harmony in the final chorus!" Ewan Chaos: "Imo this is the "obvious" worst song on the album, but those synthesizer flourishes are so fun I can't give this too bad of a score." Now why on earth is any Madonna song out this early? 1
Saddy Posted October 18 Author Posted October 18 #45 Love by Another Name Score: 5.79 High score: 10 @supaspaz Low score: 1 @KillingYourCareer Comments: KillingYourCareer: "Those vocal effects are beyond ridiculous!" Ewan Chaos: "The Mario underground sample oh period."
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted October 18 ATRL Moderator Posted October 18 12 minutes ago, creativity. said: I thought the Lucky Star new mix was actually a major downgrade from the original. Unlike the Burning Up 12" mix, which is incredible Agree. The extra instrumental on the LS new mix kills the momentum a bit.
ChooseyLover Posted October 18 Posted October 18 Love by Another Name is even more disastrous than most of Janet's debut 1
creativity. Posted October 18 Posted October 18 Love by another name was my second favorite on Celine's album None of this makes sense! 2
Saddy Posted October 18 Author Posted October 18 #44 If We Could Start Over Score: 5.89 High score: 11 @ChooseyLover Low score: 1 @creativity. Comments: Ewan Chaos: "Unfortunately, this is a song that sounds like her future hits but doesn't sound nearly as good."
KillingYourCareer Posted October 18 Posted October 18 I feel like if I listen to Love by Another Name a few other times I'll end up giving it a 10. The vocal effects were truly hysterical! 1
Recommended Posts