Auburn Posted August 3 Author Posted August 3 @wish Upon a Star What to do: 1. Listen to all the entries in your group and write your critiques 2. Post your critiques for each song in your group in this thread (including your own) 3. Rank ALL of the entries in your group from most favorite to least favorite [excluding your own] 4. DM me your rankings on Discord (preferably) or ATRL PM (please do not unless you absolutely have to) IMPORTANT: DO NOT make it obvious or outright reveal what your entry is until after results have been posted. Thank you! GROUP A Spoiler Alena brycehooha CBC Crashed electrahard Element Julia Fox Kyuti luckystrike MusicLoverDude Noah nostalgic Odd Post Malone Prismee skinnyspice Tom Vercetti Touch It Spoiler PinkPantheress - The Aisle Beyoncé - Ya Ya Perfume Genius - On the Floor Ava Max - Choose Your Fighter Troye Sivan - Can't Go Back, Baby Cocteau Twins - Pitch the Baby PinkPantheress - Ophelia Tove Lo - I Like U Beabadoobee - Ever Seen Taylor Swift - I Wish You Would (Taylor's Version) Kaiyko - End Now I See You Janelle Monáe - 57821 Tinashe - Treason Azealia Banks - Liquorice Avril Lavigne - Avalanche Kelela - All the Way Down Ethel Cain - Sun Bleached Flies Mandy Moore - Only Hope SPOTIFY GROUP B Spoiler boggington Devin DevonRoars Galah ho Kayseri Mantisi Kelp Kinich Luckitty Not Like The Movies Overprotected richelle Rotunda Seffers Staryu Taeyeon thecptz wehavetostan Spoiler Rachel Chinouriri - If Only Tinashe - Gravity Mitski - Working for the Knife Mutya Buena - Real Girl JPEGMAFIA - Either On or Off the Drugs Alessia Cara - October Remi Wolf - Soup Kehlani - Wish I Never Artful Dodger - Twentyfourseven Dua Lipa - Happy for You Cecile Believe - ***** Bites Dog Fiona Apple - Paper Bag Raveena - Pluto Hatchie - Sunday Song Madonna - The Power of Good-Bye Toni Braxton - Spanish Guitar Ariana Grande - Don't Wanna Break Up Again Lil' Kim - Crush on You SPOTIFY DEADLINE: MONDAY, AUGUST 5 @ 12:00 PM EDT Spoiler @thecptz @Crashed @Overprotected @Noah @Staryu @Element @smholiv @Touch It @Kinich @Kelp @Alena @Julia Fox @nostalgic @wehavetostan @Seffers @Not Like The Movies @brycehooha @Rotunda @MusicLoverDude @Post Malone @Kayseri Mantisi @CBC @DevonRoars @Kyuti @Tom Vercetti @Prismee @Odd @Devin @luckystrike @Galah @Luckitty @Taeyeon @skinnyspice @richelle @boggington @electrahard
Auburn Posted August 3 Author Posted August 3 Spoiler @thecptz @Crashed @Overprotected @Noah @Staryu @Element @smholiv @Touch It @Kinich @Kelp @Alena @Julia Fox @nostalgic @wehavetostan @Seffers @Not Like The Movies @brycehooha @Rotunda @MusicLoverDude @Post Malone @Kayseri Mantisi @CBC @DevonRoars @Kyuti @Tom Vercetti @Prismee @Odd @Devin @luckystrike @Galah @Luckitty @Taeyeon @skinnyspice @richelle @boggington @electrahard Please note if you are in Group A that one of the songs has been swapped for the correct entry, apologies to the player I almost screwed over
Auburn Posted August 3 Author Posted August 3 Just now, Devin said: mess. 3/3 rounds of host screwing up. and? you're free to QUIT if the hosting is not up to your standards 1 1
Rotunda Posted August 3 Posted August 3 If Only - Not my favorite Rachel song but I found it quite pleasant
Rotunda Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Gravity - A pleasant lil background song. Feel like this could be on the soundtrack for like a snowboarding/skateboarding video game.
Rotunda Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Working for the Knife - A song I know and like. This album is overhated tbh.
Rotunda Posted August 3 Posted August 3 (edited) Real Girl - Do you ever listen to a song and just know she'd struggle through it live? That's how this sounds to me. With that said, it is a Rotunda favorite and we love the Lenny Kravitz sample. Edited August 3 by Rotunda
Rotunda Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Either on or off the drugs - This kinda feels like something one of my old high school classmates would release and you kinda have to pretend like you like it when he sends it to you. Instrumental was alright.
Touch It Posted August 3 Posted August 3 can't go back baby: better than I expected I didn't care for the singles for this album so I never listened to the album. this is more my vibe I like it but not LOVE
MusicLoverDude Posted August 3 Posted August 3 The Aisle - @Tom Vercettiintroduced me to this in ASC when he sent this last season. I still enjoy it
MusicLoverDude Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Ya Ya - pretty easily the best song from Cowboy Carter so great job
MusicLoverDude Posted August 3 Posted August 3 On the Floor - I actually discovered this song during the pandemic. Great surprising pick.
MusicLoverDude Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Choose Your Fighter - @Psycho sent this in during the 2023 season of ASC. It's a fun song, light enough to fit in with the Barbie movie. Not sure where it will land in my rankings though since I haven't really sought the song out outside of the movie since it was sent in last year. 1
MusicLoverDude Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Can't Go Back, Baby - a bit mid tbh. The sample doesn't sound good with the minimal production. Might be middle of my rankings but given how stacked this list will be it isn't looking good.
MusicLoverDude Posted August 3 Posted August 3 Pitch the Baby - this was definitely a choice to send this outside of a 20th century round given that both Cocteau twins songs had gotten mid reviews on ASC, this one included. The production is fine but I still can't get behind the drowned out vocals.
Recommended Posts