Harrier Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 The Giselle related meltdowns in here It is obviously true that she is Aespa's Jisoo. But let's not overstate matters. There are countless girl group members who offer literally nothing except for mediocre dancing. No vocals, no stage presence, no it girl factor, no rap. Nothing. And yet y'all don't say a god damn thing. Giselle is bad dancer, especially for 4th gen. But she sings well and her rap is recognisable and cute. She speaks three languages fluently. She isn't offering Aespa nothing. To me it speaks to the overration of dancing in K-pop. You can apparently get away with anything as long as you can dance decently. I disagree. I think the bar should be singing Nothing worse than an idol that delivers mediocre studio vocals without making up for it with exceptional onstage talent. Let's talk about Lesserafim Eunchae. Half of Loona. Multiple NewJennies members (take your pick). G-idle Shuhua. The list could go on and on.
Sugden Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 remember when hybe had that article to say aespa were done aged like milk 2 1 1
Sugden Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 i love giselle serves charisma and ***** people she is useless but she would probably be lead vocalist in most groups out there
Asscatchem Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 2 minutes ago, Harrier said: To me it speaks to the overration of dancing in K-pop. You can apparently get away with anything as long as you can dance decently. I disagree. I think the bar should be singing Nothing worse than an idol that delivers mediocre studio vocals without making up for it with exceptional onstage talent. yall acting like she's mariah carey or nicki minaj the way she makes up for her dancing with her vocals / rapping
Rhythm Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 (edited) 18 minutes ago, Asscatchem said: yall acting like she's mariah carey or nicki minaj the way she makes up for her dancing with her vocals / rapping You’re raising this bar sky-high like any of these other idols are. For certain no member of aespa is a Beyoncé in dance or onstage, or even close, I assure you. Edited May 22, 2023 by Rhythm
ANTIclimatic Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 Ooh the essays in here, let me add another one. I genuinely think y’all hate Giselle because closer to a regular person but was able to fulfill her dream and become an idol. I bet most of y’all wouldn’t have this much energy for her if she was a size zero and as robotic looking as the other members. She was only a trainee for 11 months so SM didn’t have time to do the full renovation like with the others. Who’s spot did she take? As far as I recall SM was still looking for a fourth member until she joined. There was a mass exodus of trainees both male and female because SM was taking too long to debut new groups. Even NN left and went back to China and was called by SM and had to be convinced to come back. Which is funny if you take into account how they treat her now. The group was finally completed when Giselle joined. Giselle is the main rapper, the best female rapper SM has ever had at that. She’s a better rapper than Karina, like be foreal. She specifically auditioned to be a rapper and passed the Saturday exam, only the second female to pass that exam. So who’s the rapper that got her spot taken by her? The position was hers as soon as she joined. Yall talking about dancing when literally all the members are mid. They all got eaten up at their own challenge. Imagine fighting about who’s less stiff. Take Giselle out of the equation and Aespa still wouldn’t be a group of performers. The other member trained for 3+ years and she’s still able to keep up. Clearly dancing was not the priority. Anyways TLDR Giselle earned her spot. She’s still the best SM female rapper, a better vocalist then most 4th gen idols and is only lacking in the investment SM puts in her. Y’all are bitter and will remain so. 3
OrgVisual Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 3 minutes ago, katyberry said: Officially 2 million sellers 2M is the new benchmark for top girlgroup I fear
Asscatchem Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 1 minute ago, ANTIclimatic said: Giselle is the main rapper, the best female rapper SM has ever had at that.
ANTIclimatic Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 (edited) And y’all talking about popularity acting like Karina and NN weren’t known and being showcased way before their debut. Giselle for example was the only member who didn’t already have a China bar predebut. The other members were given opportunities both predebut and after while we’re still waiting for a Giselle solo schedule. Edited May 22, 2023 by ANTIclimatic
ANTIclimatic Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 2 minutes ago, Asscatchem said: If she’s iggy then what does that make everyone else?
Gorjesspazze9 Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 YoonA is the best rapper SM ever had. She came Straight Outta the trenches of Seoul and sold Mixtapes to make it in the Game. Her Opps could never move 185K first week on Hanteo 1 1
ANTIclimatic Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 4 minutes ago, Gorjesspazze9 said: YoonA is the best rapper SM ever had. She came Straight Outta the trenches of Seoul and sold Mixtapes to make it in the Game. Her Opps could never move 185K first week on Hanteo 1
lgaga1fan Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 The random Giselle hate and aespa “bad stage presence” comments… oh they pissed y’all off with that #1 and the 2 million sales didn’t they. 1
Rhythm Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 I’m in love with this already. The girls singing 80% of the song, ahh. Take me back to old K.A.R.D.
BellKat Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 Don't know if you all discussed this but FiftyFifty has broken one of the craziest milestones The best part is that today they gained 500k more listeners. That's half a million people joining the hypetrain daily 1 1
jorjapuss Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 (edited) 3 minutes ago, BellKat said: Don't know if you all discussed this but FiftyFifty has broken one of the craziest milestones The best part is that today they gained 500k more listeners. That's half a million people joining the hypetrain daily insta down, fifty fifty breaking their records. its bad for miss blackpink Edited May 22, 2023 by jorjapuss
ATRL Administrator Ryan Posted May 22, 2023 Author ATRL Administrator Posted May 22, 2023 The obsession. Logging out sometimes is good for you.
Billionaire Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 Higher than Wonyoung oh wow She could be the challenge her for that 4th gen IT Girl title if SM starts playing their cards right
Billionaire Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 Guess we'll be seeing whether or not the hard launch rumors are true
Eternium Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 So close to a RAK, too Remember how people tried to count them out after “Girls” became the best-selling female mini ever? 1
saucy Posted May 22, 2023 Posted May 22, 2023 These random and unnecessary eunchae mentions. She doesn't stick out like a sore thumb. Her only problem is that she should still be in school. Also all those who predicted aespa's demise were premature. Thankfully I was on the right side of herstory for this one. 1
Recommended Posts