As we slowly shift to Midnight era, it means we should say goodbye to the folk-ish, forest-y themed era, the sisters, folklore and evermore

It's been around 2 years since both album existed

 

 

To settle this down, when you rank the entire tracks from both albums, what will your Top 5 be?

Which album has more spots in it? folklore or evermore?

Exile

Tolerate it

August

Betty

Happiness 

 

 

this is me trying

the lakes

my tears ricochet

tolerate it

ivy

cardigan

mirrorball

seven

august 

peace

 

gold rush

tolerate it

ivy

cowboy like me

right where you left me

 

Picking my favorite 5 from this group is really hard, but I think I’d say: 

 

cowboy like me

ivy

august

seven

peace

In no order:

 

August

Champagne Problems

Exile

Cardigan

Cowboy Like ME!

 

Folklore

 

 

cowboy like me
august

willow

cardigan

champagne problems

 

folklore is the better overall album and evermore has more highs between individual tracks. wbk

 

(Also not me claiming the singles + august + cp like a LOCAL  I used to stan so many of the less popular tracks like mad woman and illicit affairs but lately the fan faves have been HITTING)

august 

right where you left me

this is me trying

cowboy like me

the lakes

1) Right Where You Left Me

2) ‘Tis the Damn Season

3) Illicit Affairs

4) Mirrorball

5) Ivy

 

Evermore, the superior sister, wins!  Two flawless albums though. 

august

mirrorball

this is me trying

the lakes

ivy / closure

 

folklore wins by a mile. that's what happens when you compare it to the B sides + throwaways mixtape.

in no order bc it changes all the time

 

cardigan

champagne problems

august

the lakes

exile

 

Its so hard to pick though, I would say folklore is overall better but I've grown to like evermore a lot more than I did when it first came out. Both are great though

 

exile

evermore

tolerate it

august

illicit affairs

 

honorable mention: the 1, cardigan, right where you left me

 

cardigan

august

mirrorball

this is me trying

coney island

1. cardigan
2. champagne problems
3. tolerate It
4. ’tis the damn season
5. it’s time to go
6. evermore (honourable mention(

i def prefer evermore overall 

right where you left me

cardigan

seven

gold rush

tolerate it

 

the superior sister wins 

champagne problems

’tis the damn season

cardigan

tolerate it

willow

 

Honorable mentions: august and the 1

overall:

 

cardigan

exile

seven

this is me trying

willow

 

HM: cowboy like me and mirrorball

illicit affairs 

tolerate it

exile

right where you left me

seven

My Tears Ricochet - Seven - This Is Me Trying - Exile - Mirrorball 

 

Most of the tracks are great although there are some I have still to get into. Same goes for Evermore, it hasn't clicked yet for me.

Yes, I am loving the This Is Me Trying love.

 

Continue people.

Folklore: there is NOT one track i can listen to in full 

Evermore: No Body, No Crime is only song I use

 

Evermore was slightly bearable. 

epiphany

cardigan

exile

cowboy like me

evermore

 

 

the last great american dynasty

willow

ivy

tolerate it

coney island

 

Honorable mention: this is me trying, exile

 

evermore is my favorite album of the two (folklore is still flawless). These 5 songs are absolute masterclasses of songwriting. Really wish she can match those with Midnights.

this is me trying

 

 

well, that was easy

36 minutes ago, Allday said:

Folklore: there is NOT one track i can listen to in full 

Evermore: No Body, No Crime is only song I use

 

Evermore was slightly bearable. 

the most tasteless person ????

My top 5 : tolerate it , my tears ricochet, champagne problems, seven, right where you left me

2 minutes ago, pccp said:

the most tasteless person ????

My top 5 : tolerate it , my tears ricochet, champagne problems, seven, right where you left me

I don't like folk/ballads that all sound the same