album Maggie Rogers - 'Surrender'

[Argent]

this album is so strong, definitely an AOTY contender for me. shatter especially is one of my fave songs released this year, obsessed with how feral it sounds. overall really impressive! very excited to see her live in november.

Edited August 1, 2022 by Argent

[ryoncé]

BIG BIG BIG BIG step down from her first album 

 

sad

[josesuxx]

GIGANTIC step up from her mediocre first album 

 

[Ice Cream Skies]

Surprised to see this is at 80 on Metacritic

[drip drop]

want want - anywhere with you - shatter - god tier
horses - good tiers
others are meh

[Ice Cream Skies]

This album really falls off at the end. I've Got a Friend is dumb, Honey's kind of annoying, and Different Kind of World is corny.

 

Thank God for Symphony. It's a shame, though, because she has 9 really good songs here. 

[original_lifeline]

36 minutes ago, Ice Cream Skies said:

This album really falls off at the end. I've Got a Friend is dumb, Honey's kind of annoying, and Different Kind of World is corny.

 

Thank God for Symphony. It's a shame, though, because she has 9 really good songs here. 

leave honey alone, she's good

[On The Bound]

the album is amazing, she did that only skip is i've got a friend 

different kind of world deserves more love, hte ha impact 

symphony is also her best song tbh

[likefoxesdo]

The Symphony and Honey stanning 

[Protocol]

It's definitely a lot more straightforward than her debut, but it's still great. She's a fantastic songwriter and singer. 

 

In a way this is like a P!nk album if P!nk had better taste and was more of an artiste.

[Ice Cream Skies]

2 hours ago, original_lifeline said:

leave honey alone, she's good

She's not bad... I think I'm just annoyed by Maggie yelling "I'VE GOT A FRIEND" 100x by the end of the previous song, and her annoying lady friend talking in the last ten seconds... so it sours Honey a bit

[as926]

I’m really digging this. The singles are great, but I’m in love with “Shatter,” “Symphony,” and “Overdrive” too. 

[AM98GJ]

Literally impossible to judge an album based on atrl comments 

 

Bey took my attention this weekend, but excited to give this a go! 

[original_lifeline]

8 hours ago, Ice Cream Skies said:

She's not bad... I think I'm just annoyed by Maggie yelling "I'VE GOT A FRIEND" 100x by the end of the previous song, and her annoying lady friend talking in the last ten seconds... so it sours Honey a bit

don't let this badly recorded poo-poo mess with your impression of the other good songs! just delete Tracks 9 & 12 from your library, hun 

Edited August 2, 2022 by original_lifeline

[HeddaO]

17 hours ago, ryoncé said:

BIG BIG BIG BIG step down from her first album 

 

sad

this, unfortunately 

 

12 hours ago, drip drop said:

want want - anywhere with you - shatter - god tier
horses - good tiers
others are meh

also this 

[Kings.]

On 8/1/2022 at 8:06 AM, SimpleKindofLife said:

This album is really boring compared to her earlier work, even the archived recordings. TWIA is still that song though. Want Want’s chorus lyrics really brings it down a lot.

Same. The first single had me a little hyped, but it was a bit of a snooze. I’ll give it two more listens though to see if my mind changes.

[DancingShoes]

The last 4 songs do absolutely nothing for me but I like-love the rest of them.

[sweetkiss]

im not familiar with her debut so this is my first time listening to her.

 

on honey i realized i dont like her voice too much. i like what seems to be the singles? horses, want want, thats where i am with addition of anywhere with you and symphony.

 

her wiki claims shes singer song writer, im not really impressed with either (her singing nor her song writing)

 

both seems average to me with rare moment when i just thought 'that was nice'. 

 

i think thats where i am is the best because message is so clear and has unique and interesting production.

 

 

[K$Ellie]

is she for real with the vocals on Horses, the belting is unbearable

 

 

this is as hit or miss as her debut but lacks standouts like Alaska, Say It, Fallingwater etc.

[bonkbanisters]

The first half is just amazing, several great songs on the second half as well!! IMO this is a great follow-up to HIIAPL 

[usedtothis]

didn’t chart in the top 10  didn’t really expect it to do all that well but with HIIAPL peaking at #2, 4 months worth of pre orders, and 5 vinyl variants…

[SimpleKindofLife]

I’m pissed that it took her 3 years just to release this she needs to go on another Alaskan hike clearly

[Ichinaru19]

I've Got a Friend being an underrated gem of the album

[On The Bound]

symphony is soooooo good

her best song

this album washes her (extremelyr overrated) debut

[On The Bound]

symphony is soooooo good

her best song

this album washes her (extremely overrated) debut