yonsé Posted November 7 Posted November 7 (edited) 21 minutes ago, alien superstore said: Is it only the country voters who can nominate for Country awards? Because if the CMAs are anything to go by we might have a situation where CC has representation in the Big 3 and Pop categories but gets snubbed in the country ones correct. and it will likely be snubbed in those categories. each genre has a "committee" with "experts" in the genre who get to decide the genre categories. daddy lessons was rejected in 2016. it is partially the reason CC exists. https://www.billboard.com/music/awards/beyonce-daddy-lessons-rejected-grammy-country-committee-7604485/ Edited November 7 by yonsé 1
kimberly Posted November 7 Posted November 7 19 minutes ago, alien superstore said: Do we know how genre nominations work in the Grammys? Is it only the country voters who can nominate for Country awards? Because if the CMAs are anything to go by we might have a situation where CC has representation in the Big 3 and Pop categories but gets snubbed in the country ones Grammy's doesn't "enforce" which categories/genres a voter can vote in. They limit the total number of genres one voter can vote in to 3. From the rule book: Quote they may vote in up to ten categories across up to three genre Fields plus the six categories of the General Field 1
yonsé Posted November 7 Posted November 7 1 minute ago, kimberly said: Grammy's doesn't "enforce" which categories/genres a voter can vote in. They limit the total number of genres one voter can vote in to 3. From the rule book: this is for voting for winners i believe. committees decide the nominations.
kimberly Posted November 7 Posted November 7 Just now, yonsé said: correct. and it will likely be snubbed in those categories. each genre has a "committee" with "experts" in the genre who get to decide the genre categories. daddy lessons was rejected in 2016. it is partially the reason CC exists. https://www.billboard.com/music/awards/beyonce-daddy-lessons-rejected-grammy-country-committee-7604485/ Grammys have massively ousted "committees" since the 2018-19 scandals. Bey's music has already been vetted and mainly assigned the categories we know she's submitted them to. This is where her music appeared on the Grammy round 1 ballot: Album of the year — Cowboy Carter Record of the year — "Texas Hold 'Em" Song of the year — "Texas Hold 'Em" Best pop solo performance — "Bodyguard" Best pop duo/group performance — "Levii's Jeans" featuring Post Malone Best R&B song* — "Tyrant" featuring Dolly Parton Best melodic rap performance — "Spaghettii" featuring Linda Martell and Shaboozey Best country solo performance — "16 Carriages" Best country duo/group performance — "II Most Wanted" featuring Miley Cyrus Best country song — "Texas Hold 'Em" Best country album — Cowboy Carter Best Americana performance — "Ya Ya"
yonsé Posted November 7 Posted November 7 Just now, kimberly said: Grammys have massively ousted "committees" since the 2018-19 scandals. Bey's music has already been vetted and mainly assigned the categories we know she's submitted them to. This is where her music appeared on the Grammy round 1 ballot: Album of the year — Cowboy Carter Record of the year — "Texas Hold 'Em" Song of the year — "Texas Hold 'Em" Best pop solo performance — "Bodyguard" Best pop duo/group performance — "Levii's Jeans" featuring Post Malone Best R&B song* — "Tyrant" featuring Dolly Parton Best melodic rap performance — "Spaghettii" featuring Linda Martell and Shaboozey Best country solo performance — "16 Carriages" Best country duo/group performance — "II Most Wanted" featuring Miley Cyrus Best country song — "Texas Hold 'Em" Best country album — Cowboy Carter Best Americana performance — "Ya Ya" committees definitely still exist. from 2023: https://www.billboard.com/lists/grammy-awards-nominations-review-committees-craft-committees/
kimberly Posted November 7 Posted November 7 Just now, yonsé said: this is for voting for winners i believe. committees decide the nominations. nope. Round I voting already happened — open to all voting members of the Recording Academy. Just now, yonsé said: committees definitely still exist. from 2023: https://www.billboard.com/lists/grammy-awards-nominations-review-committees-craft-committees/ yes, there are still committees. they DO NOT decide the nominations, just whether a song/album "fits" the genre category it was sent for and sorts them. 2
Kingdom Posted November 7 Posted November 7 20 minutes ago, yonsé said: correct. and it will likely be snubbed in those categories. each genre has a "committee" with "experts" in the genre who get to decide the genre categories. daddy lessons was rejected in 2016. it is partially the reason CC exists. https://www.billboard.com/music/awards/beyonce-daddy-lessons-rejected-grammy-country-committee-7604485/ She already passed this stage. Daddy Lessons wasn't allowed to be submitted in country. It was outrightly rejected, CC already got in. 3
ScorpiosGroove Posted November 7 Posted November 7 7 hours ago, ShouldersSideways said: 11.29 1+1+2 29=29 2.29 - the length of the bodyguard video tuesday friday tuesday 1
ariesgroove Posted November 8 Posted November 8 2 hours ago, V$. said: I see CIL and BB her influence on the new generation >>> glad to see tyla moving again i know she was going through something! - cowboy carter hitting today given the circumstances we're in 2
Brikenbur Posted November 8 Posted November 8 Just listened to the second half of CC today and by golly she still has it !!! 2
Havoc Posted November 8 Posted November 8 I predict 6 nominations Album of the year COWBOY CARTER Song of the year Texas Hold Em Record of the Year Texas Hold Em Best Pop/Duo Levii Jeans Best R&B Performance Tyrant Best Americana YAYA
kimberly Posted November 8 Posted November 8 (edited) My predictions: Almost 100% getting nominated AOTY - Cowboy Carter ROTY - Texas Hold Em Country Album - Cowboy Carter 90% chance Country Duo/Group - II Most Wanted Best Americana performance - Ya Ya 80% chance SOTY - Texas Hold Em Country Song - Texas Hold Em R&B Song - Tyrant 50% chance Pop Solo - Bodyguard Country Solo - 16 Carriages 30% chance Pop Duo/Group - Levii's Jeans (This is risky because they can't nominate Post Malone twice, both "Fortnight" and "Levi's Jeans," per Grammy rules.) 10% chance - Almost no shot Melodic Rap - Spaghettii Edited November 8 by kimberly 2 1
yonsé Posted November 8 Posted November 8 6 hours ago, kimberly said: nope. Round I voting already happened — open to all voting members of the Recording Academy. yes, there are still committees. they DO NOT decide the nominations, just whether a song/album "fits" the genre category it was sent for and sorts them. I see! My mistake 1
Kristie Kuwa Posted November 8 Posted November 8 8 hours ago, yonsé said: correct. and it will likely be snubbed in those categories. each genre has a "committee" with "experts" in the genre who get to decide the genre categories. daddy lessons was rejected in 2016. it is partially the reason CC exists. https://www.billboard.com/music/awards/beyonce-daddy-lessons-rejected-grammy-country-committee-7604485/ They love to throw her a bone, lure her to attend, only to snub her big time. Just watch
Calypso Posted November 8 Posted November 8 Oh we discussing Grammys. Nothing more depressing for me than such intricate Shammy's talk. Stream CC for clear skin and election cope!
alien superstore Posted November 8 Posted November 8 10 hours ago, kimberly said: Grammys have massively ousted "committees" since the 2018-19 scandals. Bey's music has already been vetted and mainly assigned the categories we know she's submitted them to. This is where her music appeared on the Grammy round 1 ballot: Album of the year — Cowboy Carter Record of the year — "Texas Hold 'Em" Song of the year — "Texas Hold 'Em" Best pop solo performance — "Bodyguard" Best pop duo/group performance — "Levii's Jeans" featuring Post Malone Best R&B song* — "Tyrant" featuring Dolly Parton Best melodic rap performance — "Spaghettii" featuring Linda Martell and Shaboozey Best country solo performance — "16 Carriages" Best country duo/group performance — "II Most Wanted" featuring Miley Cyrus Best country song — "Texas Hold 'Em" Best country album — Cowboy Carter Best Americana performance — "Ya Ya" If Spaghetti wins a Grammy....I'd have to laugh
ReneighIsHere Posted November 8 Posted November 8 (edited) 27 minutes ago, Calypso said: Oh we discussing Grammys. Nothing more depressing for me than such intricate Shammy's talk. Stream CC for clear skin and election cope! It's the only thing i want to listen to at the moment.. the lyrics of American Requiem are so fitting. The first performance of this song is gonna be a moment Edited November 8 by ReneighIsHere 3
Lose My Breath Posted November 8 Posted November 8 I wonder if the GRAMMYs will try to overcorrect Trump's win by pushing more left leaning artists
Draper. Posted November 8 Posted November 8 51 minutes ago, alien superstore said: If Spaghetti wins a Grammy....I'd have to laugh The Grammy Guru (on Twitter) has predicted: AOTY ROTY, SOTY - Texas Hold'Em Melodic Rap - Spaghetti R&B Song - Tyrant They left her out of Pop Solo for Bodyguard and said Pop Duo will come down to wether Levii's Jeans can pull more votes than Fortnight since Post Malone can't be there twice. They didn't do predictions on Country nor Americana.
Bicassie Posted November 8 Posted November 8 9 minutes ago, Draper. said: The Grammy Guru (on Twitter) has predicted: AOTY ROTY, SOTY - Texas Hold'Em Melodic Rap - Spaghetti R&B Song - Tyrant They left her out of Pop Solo for Bodyguard and said Pop Duo will come down to wether Levii's Jeans can pull more votes than Fortnight since Post Malone can't be there twice. They didn't do predictions on Country nor Americana. hmm yeah honestly dont see her snatching a lot of noms… it'll be a handful max
Shelter Posted November 8 Posted November 8 16 minutes ago, Draper. said: The Grammy Guru (on Twitter) has predicted: AOTY ROTY, SOTY - Texas Hold'Em Melodic Rap - Spaghetti R&B Song - Tyrant They left her out of Pop Solo for Bodyguard and said Pop Duo will come down to wether Levii's Jeans can pull more votes than Fortnight since Post Malone can't be there twice. They didn't do predictions on Country nor Americana. Fortnight is a single, course it will be nominated over LJ. Bruno and Gaga are winning that anyway.
alien superstore Posted November 8 Posted November 8 I would be shocked if IIMWwasnt nommed - Miley is a Grammy darling esp after that Flowers perf
ScorpiosGroove Posted November 8 Posted November 8 i told y'all she'll be lucky to get more than 4 noms. her submissions were awful and the competition is just way too tight and all of them are a lot fresher in people's minds than anything off of Forgotten Carter 2
Draper. Posted November 8 Posted November 8 56 minutes ago, ScorpiosGroove said: i told y'all she'll be lucky to get more than 4 noms. her submissions were awful and the competition is just way too tight and all of them are a lot fresher in people's minds than anything off of Forgotten Carter I think she'll get around 8 nominations. I don't see her not being nominated for Country Song and Country Album. Grammys don't get nothing for being controversial in their nominations because, if they don't want to look like some MTV awards, they need Beyoncé in that room.
ScorpiosGroove Posted November 8 Posted November 8 13 minutes ago, Draper. said: I think she'll get around 8 nominations. I don't see her not being nominated for Country Song and Country Album. Grammys don't get nothing for being controversial in their nominations because, if they don't want to look like some MTV awards, they need Beyoncé in that room. but they know throwing her the usual aoty bone is enough to make her ass sit in the first row, why give her anything more ?
Recommended Posts