Redporus Posted July 18 Posted July 18 24 minutes ago, Chris said: Okay if I am being objective I will remove RIVERDANCE but everything else stands when it comes to musical quality!!! 2 2
Redporus Posted July 18 Posted July 18 (edited) 28 minutes ago, Chris said: Ok but RedAnus is asking about vocal arrangements, musical arrangements, lyrics, and artistical input. Not if it gets your hole wet or getting you on your feet. There are a couple of Renaissance tracks above it. I hate you so much but Thique and AHAP(which is an excellent song) is NOT above ITG Edited July 18 by Redporus 1 1
Redporus Posted July 18 Posted July 18 27 minutes ago, Chris said: Clearly not because it's levels above. Durgh. Jealous is a cute Alt-Rnb song if we are being musically objective.
Chris Posted July 18 Posted July 18 (edited) 5 minutes ago, Redporus said: I hate you so much but Thique and AHAP(which is an excellent song) is above ITG Oh don't get me wrong, I love love love love ITG. But when it comes to vocal arrangements, musical arrangements, lyrical arrangements, artistical output I would even put Alien Superstar and even Summer Renaissance (yes I know some of you are going to groan about this) over it. Just my opinion. And maybe Church Girl too but that's when the bias for it personally kicks in dhjsbhd Edited July 18 by Chris 1
Redporus Posted July 18 Posted July 18 Just now, Chris said: Oh don't get me wrong, I love love love love ITG. But when it comes to vocal arrangements, musical arrangements, lyrical arrangements, artistical output I would even put Alien Superstar and even Summer Renaissance (yes I know some of you are going to groan about this) over it. Just my opinion. And maybe Church Girl too but that's the bias for it personally from me kicks in dhjsbhd Hmmm Summer Renaissance - Great Vocals, nice/okay arrangement or interpolation of the Donna Summer sample but it isnt on the level of others. Alien Superstar is def above or on par with ITG Soooo we agree on something. Church Girl actually has some great musical elements Vocals are excellent, arrangement of harmonies are great, the sampling is uniquely done, lyrics are good it just gets repetitive at the "drop it like a thotty" parts which reduces points on overall quality. 1
Chris Posted July 18 Posted July 18 4 minutes ago, Redporus said: Hmmm Summer Renaissance 4 minutes ago, Redporus said: Alien Superstar is def above or on par with ITG I am very intrigued by how this song changes towards the end and the outro. If that's your man then why he over heeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeere? 6 minutes ago, Redporus said: Church Girl actually has some great musical elements To be honest, I primarily listen to the RWT version of it though. 1
Chris Posted July 18 Posted July 18 23 minutes ago, Redporus said: but Thique and AHAP(which is an excellent song) is NOT above ITG You had it right the first time. 1
Redporus Posted July 18 Posted July 18 1 minute ago, Chris said: You had it right the first time. You noticed! 1
Chris Posted July 18 Posted July 18 Also @RedporusI forgot to say 2 Hand(jobs) 2 Heaven is objectively one of the top when it comes to your "criteria". Hands down. How did I forget?
Redporus Posted July 18 Posted July 18 Just now, Chris said: Also @RedporusI forgot to say 2 Hand(jobs) 2 Heaven is objectively one of the top when it comes to your "criteria". Hands down. How did I forget? It's objectively great and a career highlight tbh but the lyrics are wonky at parts otherwise its def one of her best. 1
Chris Posted July 18 Posted July 18 1 minute ago, Redporus said: It's objectively great and a career highlight tbh but the lyrics are wonky at parts otherwise its def one of her best. You are ridiculous. As if American Requiiem doesn't have wonky lyrics. Oop. 1
Redporus Posted July 18 Posted July 18 (edited) 11 minutes ago, Chris said: You are ridiculous. As if American Requiiem doesn't have wonky lyrics. Oop. True tea but we all know AR is a career highlight that mops 2H2H Edited July 18 by Redporus 1 1
Redporus Posted July 18 Posted July 18 Objectively which song is the best written on Cowboy Carter? For me it's DAUGHTER and there is no competition. @Chris and other Base members feel free to join in this lovely commentary. 1
Chris Posted July 18 Posted July 18 Hmm maybe: Looka-looka, looka there, looka there Looka-looka, looka there, looka there Looka-looka, looka there, looka there (oh, yeah) Looka-looka, looka there, looka there Can you stand me? (Can you stand me? Can you stand me? Can you stand me?) Ooh-ah Can we stand? (Can you stand me? Can you stand me? Can you stand me?) Can you stand with me? (Can you stand me? Can you stand by me?) Looka there, looka there Looka, look Looka-looka-looka-looka-looka-looka Looka there, looka there L-l-l-l-l-l-l-l-l-l-l-l-looka there Oh, looka there, looka there Looka there, looka there (Can you stand me? Can you stand me?) La-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la-la (Can you stand me? Can you stand me? Can you stand by me?) 2
family.guy123 Posted July 18 Posted July 18 I ain't in no gang but I got shooters and I bang-bang At the snap of my fingers, I'm THA-nose gets my vote. Beautiful couplet 1
QueenB Posted July 18 Posted July 18 Daughter is the best written, especially considering the Jolene cover.. there's layers to it 3
Negiiiii Posted July 18 Posted July 18 4 hours ago, Redporus said: Musically , what are the 2 Best Songs on each album since 4? Criteria: Vocal arrangement, musical arrangement, lyrics and overall artistic/musical output. 4- I Care, Love On Top ST- Haunted, Blow LEM- Daddy Lessons, Love Drought REN- Virgo's Groove, Alien Superstar CC- American Requiem, Daughter Honourable Mentions: Party, Cuff It, I'm That Girl, America Has a Problem, Ya Ya, Riverdance Try to be objective! Imma try this. Not my faves but the best musically speaking and trying to be objective : 4 - Dance For You and I care/End of time ST - No Angel and Ghost-Haunted LEM - Love Drought and Sorry (Original Demo) REN - Virgos Groove and Alien 100% CC - Daughter and American Requiem 1
Redporus Posted July 18 Posted July 18 21 minutes ago, Negiiiii said: Imma try this. Not my faves but the best musically speaking and trying to be objective : 4 - Dance For You and I care/End of time ST - No Angel and Ghost-Haunted LEM - Love Drought and Sorry (Original Demo) REN - Virgos Groove and Alien 100% CC - Daughter and American Requiem Great Choices! Sorry tho
Negiiiii Posted July 18 Posted July 18 12 minutes ago, Redporus said: Great Choices! Sorry tho I actually chose the Demo Version on purpose. Not a fav of mine but it's VERY unique musically and very well mastered idk how to explain it (and y'all know damn well I struggled to choose from Lemonade lmao) 1
QueenB Posted July 18 Posted July 18 dance for you is truly one of beyoncé's best songs of all time, how she thought initially to make it a Target bonus track is CRIMINAL 1
Negiiiii Posted July 18 Posted July 18 12 minutes ago, QueenB said: dance for you is truly one of beyoncé's best songs of all time, how she thought initially to make it a Target bonus track is CRIMINAL The ultimate truth sis… like this song is EVERYTHING
Pepo Posted July 18 Posted July 18 2H2H was on repeat today. I think I listened to it ten times in a row It's her best song since Love On Top I fear. 2
Pepo Posted July 18 Posted July 18 (edited) 6 hours ago, Redporus said: Musically , what are the 2 Best Songs on each album since 4? Criteria: Vocal arrangement, musical arrangement, lyrics and overall artistic/musical output. 4- I Care, Love On Top ST- Haunted, Blow LEM- Daddy Lessons, Love Drought REN- Virgo's Groove, Alien Superstar CC- American Requiem, Daughter Honourable Mentions: Party, Cuff It, I'm That Girl, America Has a Problem, Ya Ya, Riverdance Try to be objective! Love On Top, Party Superpower, No Angel Don't Hurt Yourself, Daddy Lessons Virgo's Groove, POTS 2H2H, American Requiem Edited July 18 by Pepo 3
cloudbusting Posted July 18 Posted July 18 actual discussion in here??? what's next, Cécred shutting down tomorrow? 3
Recommended Posts