Space&Time Posted March 12 Posted March 12 (edited) 7 hours ago, Negiiiii said: i think I read/heard somewhere that Bday was not planned / really rushed and that she put the whole concept/recorded the album/did everything within 15 days !? Or am I making that up (very likely lmao). if I’m not tripping, does anyone have the full story/details behind how Bday came to life? I’d love to have details about that. and if that’s true, sis I need a Bday part 2 made within 15 days cuz that album is still the ****. what I love about it ? And about Bey’s songs in general. Do you know what I mean if I say her songs never seem dated ? I swear Bday could have been released this year and it would have been BANGER on BANGER fresh to our ears. I don’t feel any « nostalgic » feeling when I listen to her old music because they still sound so good/fresh. There was some messy tea that I think is plausible regarding Dreamgirls and how Bday was birthed. Beyonce was cast as Deena early on, and considering her star power and although contrary to the essence of the story the producers were going to center Beyoncé as the star. (In the 90’s there were efforts to make a Dream Girls film and Whitney Houston wanted to play Deena cause of the glamour but even she wanted to sing AIATY to have the big moment 😂). Later, they casted Jhud and things changed and it was clear she was going to be the breakout. Beyoncé did Listen in the film to compensate and get her “moment” as promised to her, and she got top Billing as the Lead actress. Any Beyhive who lived through that era had to deal with the annoying comparisons of who did best and who sang best in the film from the general public. When production wrapped and before the film was released Beyoncé proactively wanted to do some control on the narrative that she had a weak voice, and recorded Bday with the most rambunctious vocals possible. Bday being released in the late summer helped mitigate some of the inevitable foolishness when the movie came out at Christmas time. In interviews Beyoncé said being Deena, inspired her to make Bday, and in a very coded way, she didn’t lie. Edited March 12 by Space&Time 5
Machete Posted March 12 Posted March 12 (edited) 8 hours ago, Shelter said: I don’t think this album will have the fan obsession like REN. It will need a bigger push imo. Hope I’m wrong though. This is one of my thoughts too, and one worry I have as a part of #ChartHive for the commercial aspects. Let’s be re, Texas Hold ‘Em is more liked by the GP than it is by the fans, and fans are the ones who are going to tune in without any promo or virality. When the songs were initially released, Hive were hyping up 16C as the “one”. I’ll have faith in her though, cuz she is yet to fail us in quality for a studio album (besides IASF ) Edited March 12 by Machete 2 1
Cbreezy Posted March 12 Posted March 12 Because it feels futile bemoaning the lack of activity at this point, I can only hope the following occur ASAP: The Bare Minimum * Profile picture party trick for album reveal: just like artists wiping their IGs, it's a bit overdone atp, but it does work. Easy, FREE, buzz-building, and signals that it's finally time. * Title, Cover, Preorder Link Icing on the Cake (Not holding my breath for any of this, but...) * Visual Announcement / Trailer: like others have said, even by Bey's standards, the current predicament is so odd that logic leans on there being a something they have up their sleeve. Of course, we could be in unchartered territory with her level of IDGAF, but because I don't believe that to be her sentiment, I'd sooner lean towards there being a "surprise" we're not currently bracing for. * Sphere / Tour / Other Live Thing: much like the visuals, it's something we loosely "know" about or have heard whispers about, but amidst the "where is the album info" frustrations, it's very back of mind for most of us. Her having a whole live "thing" up her sleeve would be amazing.
Arrogant Posted March 12 Posted March 12 The only acceptable use of Jolene is if she's singing from Jolene's perspective, with very much a "I don't want your dusty man, and you're too good for him too" vibe. 2
ThousandMiles Posted March 12 Posted March 12 y’all are so corny with the concept of completely changing the meaning of ‘Jolene’ if Beyoncé does cover it in act ii. The idea is as bad as when straight male artists change the pronouns when covering a song by a woman. She can either sing the original lyrics or keep it. ”Becky you can keep him” BFFR 2 1 2
Draper. Posted March 12 Posted March 12 Why don't you wait to listen what she does with it? She might just use the guitar in the instrumental or the Jolene, Jolene, Joleneee melody with different lyrics. Dolly just said she cleared it. 1
king_queen Posted March 12 Posted March 12 Thankfully I have a busy work load this week and it’s St Patty’s Day weekend so I can be distracted bc I don’t think we’re getting anything until the 22nd
Red Velvet Posted March 12 Posted March 12 3 minutes ago, king_queen said: Thankfully I have a busy work load this week and it’s St Patty’s Day weekend so I can be distracted bc I don’t think we’re getting anything until the 22nd until the 29th* 1
Cbreezy Posted March 12 Posted March 12 15 minutes ago, ThousandMiles said: y’all are so corny with the concept of completely changing the meaning of ‘Jolene’ if Beyoncé does cover it in act ii. The idea is as bad as when straight male artists change the pronouns when covering a song by a woman. She can either sing the original lyrics or keep it. ”Becky you can keep him” BFFR ....or she can just sample part of it. Where is there the rule that she has to take on the whole narrative of the song just because it's a classic? There's no reason it can't just be something similar to what she did with the well-known samples in Summer Renaissance and Alien Superstar. A lil bit of sample flipped into something else. Much as I feel it sometimes restricts her output, Bey's brand is pretty much anchored in "female empowerment"...so I'd actually be surprised if she came through with an outright cover of Jolene as it feels kinda left of what she's about. Yes, we've had the Ring the Alarm's, but they are kind of few and far between in the grand scheme of her catalog and served very specific purposes at the time. I can't see a 2024 Beyonce publicly singing "...I'm begging you please don't take my man" LMAO. At the same time, the idea of her taking a part of the song and doing something unique with it is really exciting. 1
Arrogant Posted March 12 Posted March 12 34 minutes ago, ThousandMiles said: y’all are so corny with the concept of completely changing the meaning of ‘Jolene’ if Beyoncé does cover it in act ii. The idea is as bad as when straight male artists change the pronouns when covering a song by a woman. She can either sing the original lyrics or keep it. ”Becky you can keep him” BFFR Ew. Imagine thinking Beyoncé is ever in her life going to get on a song and beg another woman not to take her faithless man. 1
Lose My Breath Posted March 12 Posted March 12 IDK why y'all were surprised she was going to be doing something with Jolene. Dolly has been talking about it for ages.
Burn Posted March 12 Posted March 12 It’s bigger than just the song. If Bey covers Jolene it will affect her overall brand. Jolene is about an insecure woman who is scared that her man can be easily snatched away. Beyoncé literally says on Renaissance how she’s the baddest ***** and nobody should even try to compete with her. How can she go from that to Jolene? 1
Lose My Breath Posted March 12 Posted March 12 4 minutes ago, Burn said: It’s bigger than just the song. If Bey covers Jolene it will affect her overall brand. Jolene is about an insecure woman who is scared that her man can be easily snatched away. Beyoncé literally says on Renaissance how she’s the baddest ***** and nobody should even try to compete with her. How can she go from that to Jolene? Nah, people aren't going to do all that, it wont be that deep 5
SoundsandSongs Posted March 12 Posted March 12 46 minutes ago, Burn said: It’s bigger than just the song. If Bey covers Jolene it will affect her overall brand. Jolene is about an insecure woman who is scared that her man can be easily snatched away. Beyoncé literally says on Renaissance how she’s the baddest ***** and nobody should even try to compete with her. How can she go from that to Jolene? A cover of Jolene (especially if not a single) would likely be seen by the GP as a homage to Dolly rather than reflect on her brand. Plenty of artists have covered songs different to their brand and the GP sees them as just covers. It would be different if Jolene was on Lemonade. 3
SixWholeYears Posted March 12 Posted March 12 I wish she sampled 9 to 5 instead of Jolene from Dolly. It fits her more, she already mentioned it on Haunted and lowkey BMS is about that (quit my job etc) I'm sure either way whatever song it's sampled in will eat though cause she can do no wrong 1
ShouldersSideways Posted March 12 Posted March 12 1 hour ago, Burn said: It’s bigger than just the song. If Bey covers Jolene it will affect her overall brand. Jolene is about an insecure woman who is scared that her man can be easily snatched away. Beyoncé literally says on Renaissance how she’s the baddest ***** and nobody should even try to compete with her. How can she go from that to Jolene? People already said that about her after she went back to Jay and Lemonade's arc. Who cares 1
Burn Posted March 12 Posted March 12 inb4 she flips the song and calls out the ***** tryna take her man. The song will be called HOELENE
Flanders Posted March 12 Posted March 12 1 hour ago, Burn said: It’s bigger than just the song. If Bey covers Jolene it will affect her overall brand. Jolene is about an insecure woman who is scared that her man can be easily snatched away. Beyoncé literally says on Renaissance how she’s the baddest ***** and nobody should even try to compete with her. How can she go from that to Jolene? She can easily go from that to this, just like she went from ballroom to country. It ain't that deep the only way to stay on top in this business long term is to keep changing and keep surprising people. excited to see what she does with it, personally I doubt it'll be a straight up cover but I could be wrong 1
Jon Snow Posted March 12 Posted March 12 (edited) could she be re-imagining Jolene in a way she did with Vogue? instead of a pretty white woman, she could be singing about a dark-skinned woman like she does with COZY and BROWN SKIN GIRL, in an empowering way. she replaced the names of all the white people from Vogue with African-American female musicians in Queens Remix. she could replace Jolene in a same way, but not make it about a woman that could take her man, but could take any man. that way, she could just change/twist the lyrics, but the song would mostly stay the same Edited March 12 by Jon Snow
satellites.™ Posted March 12 Posted March 12 Lets be honest, sister has some blindspots. - Letting Jay disrespect Tina Turner in Drunk in Love. - collabing with Travis Scott. - not pulling the R. Kelly IWWAB unofficial remix from Youtube. - being near Jason Lee at any time. Anywhoo this is a CLEAR 1
PrettyHurts Posted March 12 Posted March 12 9 minutes ago, Jon Snow said: could she be re-imagining Jolene in a way she did with Vogue? instead of a pretty white woman, she could be singing about a dark-skinned woman like she does with COZY and BLACK SKIN GIRL, in an empowering way. she replaced the names of all the white people from Vogue with African-American female musicians in Queens Remix. she could replace Jolene in a same way, but not make it about a woman that could take her man, but could take any man. that way, she could just change/twist the lyrics, but the song would mostly stay the same
Jon Snow Posted March 12 Posted March 12 (edited) 6 minutes ago, PrettyHurts said: did i just out myself as the BROWN SKIN GIRL hater? Spoiler SPIRIT >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> BROWN SKIN GIRL Edited March 12 by Jon Snow
Nippy'sReceipts Posted March 12 Posted March 12 7 hours ago, Space&Time said: There was some messy tea that I think is plausible regarding Dreamgirls and how Bday was birthed. Beyonce was cast as Deena early on, and considering her star power and although contrary to the essence of the story the producers were going to center Beyoncé as the star. (In the 90’s there were efforts to make a Dream Girls film and Whitney Houston wanted to play Deena cause of the glamour but even she wanted to sing AIATY to have the big moment 😂). Later, they casted Jhud and things changed and it was clear she was going to be the breakout. Beyoncé did Listen in the film to compensate and get her “moment” as promised to her, and she got top Billing as the Lead actress. Any Beyhive who lived through that era had to deal with the annoying comparisons of who did best and who sang best in the film from the general public. When production wrapped and before the film was released Beyoncé proactively wanted to do some control on the narrative that she had a weak voice, and recorded Bday with the most rambunctious vocals possible. Bday being released in the late summer helped mitigate some of the inevitable foolishness when the movie came out at Christmas time. In interviews Beyoncé said being Deena, inspired her to make Bday, and in a very coded way, she didn’t lie. Thanks for this! bday is my fave Beyonce era so I love this insider info. This is so smart. Beyoncé really is in control of her own narrative. I remember people were complaining that she was screaming on Deja Vu and then of course Ring the Alarm and wondering why. She was really SANGING ala 4 on Bday. Bday is like a precursor of 4 vocally, ST visually, Renaissance and Lemonade, and continuation of Destiny Fulfilled written like a musical just like that album. Bday is like The Gift too in that could easily be an inspired by the movie / compilation . it’s the perfect /consummate Beyonce album and era 2 1
Recommended Posts