Jump to content

Vanishing Letters 9 | WINNER REVEALED (p.187)| #WinterComing


Recommended Posts

Posted

:gaygacat4:

  • Replies 4.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • ughgabriel

    409

  • Kavish

    322

  • Dessy

    288

  • Overprotected

    269

Posted

oh wow

Posted

:celestial5:

Posted

ROUND 9: FANTASY

 

Rank the entries and send them to me through ATRL or Discord preferably

 

 

Excluding your entry, rank from 1-15:

 

1. ex: Overprotected [BEST SONG]

2. ex: I'm a Slave 4 U [2ND BEST SONG]

15. ex: When I Found You [WORST SONG]

 

Judges will be ranking and critiquing too

 

Spoiler

Bastille - Icarus

Kylie Minogue - Supernova

Celine Dion - Beauty and The Beast

Kylie Minogue - Aphrodite

Chairlift - Planet Health

Ellie Goulding - Ritual

Bridgit Mendler - Atlantis

Lana Del Rey - Season of the Witch

Aespa - Next Level

Kesha - Supernatural

Fleetwood Mac - Seven Wonders

Coldplay - Princess of China

Prince - When Doves Cry

Janelle Monae - Wondaland

Azealia Banks - Ice Princess

Grimes - Be A Body

Spotify Playlist

 

Send on time or request an extension beforehand

DEADLINE: MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 20TH 9PM EST

 

Posted
21 minutes ago, Overprotected said:

ROUND 9: FANTASY

 

Rank the entries and send them to me through ATRL or Discord preferably

 

 

Excluding your entry, rank from 1-15:

 

1. ex: Overprotected [BEST SONG]

2. ex: I'm a Slave 4 U [2ND BEST SONG]

15. ex: When I Found You [WORST SONG]

 

Judges will be ranking and critiquing too

 

  Hide contents

Bastille - Icarus

Kylie Minogue - Supernova

Celine Dion - Beauty and The Beast

Kylie Minogue - Aphrodite

Chairlift - Planet Health

Ellie Goulding - Ritual

Bridgit Mendler - Atlantis

Lana Del Rey - Season of the Witch

Aespa - Next Level

Kesha - Supernatural

Fleetwood Mac - Seven Wonders

Coldplay - Princess of China

Prince - When Doves Cry

Janelle Monae - Wondaland

Azealia Banks - Ice Princess

Grimes - Be A Body

Spotify Playlist

 

Send on time or request an extension beforehand

DEADLINE: MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 20TH 9PM EST

 

Not my comeback announced

Posted

Bastille - Icarus: It's alright but there plenty songs I like more here

 

Kylie Minogue - Supernova: She washed Dua Lipa. Why?

 

Celine Dion - Beauty and The Beast: Dated :heart2:

 

Kylie Minogue - Aphrodite: Banger, sounds fresh after 11 years

 

Chairlift - Planet Health: It's quite nice :jamming:

 

Ellie Goulding - Ritual: Really nice and unique sounding

 

Bridgit Mendler - Atlantis: 2016 classic :praisepoor:

 

Lana Del Rey - Season of the Witch: Nice cover but kinda boring

 

Aespa - Next Level: This SOTY.

 

Kesha - Supernatural: A banger from her best album :clap3:

 

Fleetwood Mac - Seven Wonders: One of their many classics :heart2:

 

Coldplay - Princess of China: Lovely song and video idec

 

Prince - When Doves Cry: Absolute classic

 

Janelle Monae - Wondaland: It's nice, kinda reminds me of Vows Kimbra, but her voice is kinda annoying here

 

Azealia Banks - Ice Princess: Mother****ing queen of rap

 

Grimes - Be A Body: it's whatever

Posted

my thoughts, round 9

c63c78c671da9fe4feef7fdf178e4d313251eb52.jpg

 

Bastille - Icarus - absolutely not... this feels like a VERY weird choice.

Kylie Minogue - Supernova - i listened to this album once and wasn't the biggest fan of this but i'm actually quite liking this song! a nice bop.

Celine Dion - Beauty and The Beast - she sounds beautiful but this just isn't exactly my kind of music fff, sorry peppa <3 i appreciate your nerve though xoxo

Kylie Minogue - Aphrodite - this used to be my favorite album when it came out! <3 this doesn't hit as hard as it used to but it's still very good <3

Chairlift - Planet Health - it's alright. doesn't really excite me in any way but it was fine.

Ellie Goulding - Ritual - not on spotify here :c but it's a nice song! not exactly my favorite of the great album though (can tell its a bonus track)

Bridgit Mendler - Atlantis - i hadn't heard this before and it's actually really chill and cool! even the feature was great.

Lana Del Rey - Season of the Witch - pretty sure Lana would've had better choices for this theme but i do kinda enjoy it.

Aespa - Next Level - iconic. it's funny cause on first listen i wasn't exactly a fan of it but after a couple more listens i fell in love with it. such an anthem.

Kesha - Supernatural - so good! such a bop. the song also stays v. interesting the complete duration with how the feel of the song changes during it (atleast to me fff)

Fleetwood Mac - Seven Wonders - i do like parts of it but it's not exactly something i'd look for. it's ok.

Coldplay - Princess of China - not really feeling this. it's decent ig.

Prince - When Doves Cry - it's alright. some parts of the song i enjoy a lot uwu. (it's the cute beat thing)

Janelle Monae - Wondaland - sounds like a children's song on crack.

Azealia Banks - Ice Princess - i hate her, no thank you.

Grimes - Be A Body - very cool production! the sound definitely suits the theme of the round very well.

 

Posted

I2T8iZF.jpg

 

Spoiler

BASTILLE - ICARUS

This is giving boring radio fodder. It's not terrible, but nothing I'd ever listen to by choice

 

KYLIE MINOGUE - SUPERNOVA

This PUNCHESSSSSSSSSSSSSS, absolute pop perfection. The way that the verses are able to keep up with the punchy chorus too..... But on to the negative, mixing is really really bad, it's way too loud. But it is from a quarantine album after all so whatever. Really nice choice for the theme

 

CÉLINE DION & PEABO BRYSON - BEAUTY AND THE BEAST

Very boring and trite. Good luck to you

 

KYLIE MINOGUE - APHRODITE

Ummm. It's cute, it's VERY campy in an almost off-putting way for me. Not really one of my favorites on Aphrodite. It sounds cheap.

 

CHAIRLIFT - PLANET HEALTH

This is cute. I don't like the reverb on the vocals, though. It's really off-putting against the production imo. Other than that, it's very cute

 

ELLIE GOULDING - RITUAL

BITCHHHHHHH ITS THE SERVE. The production and the lyrics are like exactly what the round called for in my mind. And that chorus is DELICIOUS

 

BRIDGIT MENDLER - ATLANTIS

It's okay/pleasant enough. Not interesting to me at all, though

 

LANA DEL REY - SEASON OF THE WITCH

A cute little cover. Jack did a nice job adding his touches to the production. Not really something that I return to often, though, I'll admit

 

AESPA - NEXT LEVEL

That heavy synth omg. That was nice. The chorus was a serve too. It was definitely losing my attention until the beat drop, though. And I kinda don't know why the beat drop was there dsjkfd it felt so random when the song went back to normal

 

KESHA - SUPERNATURAL

Cute track on the album. Doesn't really do a WHOLE lot for me, though. Kinda drags at a certain point

 

FLEETWOOD MAC - SEVEN WONDERS

This is a classic, but I've never been a fan of it at all. "Everywhere" and "Little Lies" >>

 

COLDPLAY & RIHANNA - PRINCESS OF CHINA

This cute little classic. One of Coldplay's best hits. The synth solo after the bridge serving ASCENSION

 

PRINCE - WHEN DOVES CRY

This felt like a stretch at first for the theme, but it's not. He's literally asking her to picture a fantasy in the first few lines. A classic, of course. One of my favorite Prince songs.

 

JANELLE MONÁE - WONDALAND

I don't listen to her anymore, but this used to be my favorite Janelle song. Camp deliciousness and that's just the way it is.

 

AZEALIA BANKS - ICE PRINCESS

One of her best songs. Maybe her best song. Who knows… I just know that this is a classic. Her flow is insane here.

 

GRIMES - BE A BODY

Used to be my favorite Grimes song back in the day… oh wow… anyway it has aged very well for me. Definitely one of her best production moments. GarageBand DID that.

 

Posted

Bastille - Icarus: kinda laughable that you sent this when someone bombed with Pompeii earlier on, this one is even worse baby gyal

 

Kylie - Supernova: mhmmmmmmmmmm this smashes hard, my favorite on DISCO perhaps, it's Kylie at her prime and I'm obsessed

 

Céline Dion - Beauty and the Beast: you know you were hella wrong for this... au revoir

 

Kylie - Aphrodite: another absolute banger from her, I think this song is super underrated and her title tracks are always immaculate, although I prefer Supernova a bit more

 

Chairlift - Planet Health: I was so bored. nothing salvageable from this I fear

 

Ellie Goulding - Ritual: a deep album cut smasher mhm, the last chorus especially knocks so hard, lovely choice

 

Bridgit Mendler - Atlantis: years go by and this song remains immaculate, feel like pure shite just want her back

 

Lana Del Rey - Season of the Witch: hard pass

 

aespa - Next Level: nahhhhhhhhh you really snatched this CLASSIC?????????????? I'm kinda mad, but of course this is a winning song and you know it

 

Kesha - Supernatural: no cause this song feels like being at the gay club and getting a rush of poppers (not that I know what that feels like), she came on this bitch mad as hell and we stanned

 

Fleetwood Mac - Seven Wonders: does absolutely nothing for me

 

Coldplay & Rihanna - Princess of Chine: should've asked if this was eligible before sending I fear, this is too good, too bad it will be doubled 

 

Prince - When Doves Cry: lovely, will be a bit middling for me though since competition is though

 

Janelle Monae - Wonderland: probably my least favorite Janelle song I have ever heard, not feeling this entirely, the chorus is cute sometimes

 

Azealia Banks - Ice Princess: awwww hell nah this is actually pretty nice but my morals stop me from giving this a good rank sorry, maybe I won't rank her last for once!

 

Grimes - Be a Body: not sure how I feel about this, okay?

 

 

Posted
2 minutes ago, luckystrike said:

this is actually pretty nice but my morals stop me from giving this a good rank sorry, maybe I won't rank her last for once!

?????

Posted
1 minute ago, Navyofbadgals said:

?????

can I help you. 

Posted
1 minute ago, Navyofbadgals said:

?????

The girls only tank and sabotage when it's a woman! If Dr. Luke was a choice last round, he would've swept without any questions!

Posted
Just now, luckystrike said:

can I help you. 

Don’t think you’re able to do so no

Posted
Just now, Touch It said:

The girls only tank and sabotage when it's a woman! If Dr. Luke was a choice last round, he would've swept without any questions!

Oop :mandown: I fear you spilled

Posted

ICARUS

I feel like this is a song that I would have used in middle or high school. It's a standard Bastille song, so it isn't bad but also isn't as gripping as it could be. 

 

SUPERNOVA

This is a cute lil disco track. I'm grooving a bit. 

 

BEAUTY AND THE BEAST 

This song reminds me of my creepy piano teacher

This is cute

 

APHRODITE 

I find Kylie to usually be kind of...rudimentary...but I like this a lot

 

PLANET HEALTH

Very cool and interesting lyrically 

 

RITUAL 

Oh wow oh wow oh wow 

 

ATLANTIS 

I know I don't have room to talk considering the indie girls I stan but her vocals here are...something. The feature is also kinda useless. Regardless, I still really like the chorus and this won't be at the bottom

 

SEASON OF THE WITCH

I really thought this girl was banned. It's a nice listen vocally, but I wish the song had more umph to it. 

 

NEXT LEVEL 
Nnnn the breakdown was so unexpected. I guess it helps cuz the song was kinda forgettable with out. Not bad tho. 

 

SUPERNATURAL 

The non-LMFAO'd parts of this song are nice

 

SEVEN WONDERS

This is a reach imo but I like the song so I'm going to shut up 

 

PRINCESS OF CHINA 

ngl I've never heard this before but it's good 

 

WHEN DOVES CRY

It is a classic

 

WONDALAND

Probably the best Janelle option available for this round. I like it 

 

ICE PRINCESS

I will be separating the art from the artist for this classic

 

BE A BODY 

I definitely like the production but idk where this will fall

Posted

I see the people with taste showing taste period 

Posted
2 minutes ago, Touch It said:

The girls only tank and sabotage when it's a woman! If Dr. Luke was a choice last round, he would've swept without any questions!

This unironically

Posted

GwGkVeR.png?width=360&height=450

 

ICARUS - I could let Pompeii slide cause there's a lot of nostalgia attached to it. This has none of it, and won't get any cause it's a chaotic noisy mess. 

 

SUPERNOVA - A definite highlight of Disco. Just a whole lot of fun and a very well crafted pop song. 

 

''BEAUTY'' AND THE BEAST I hate old ppl

 

APHRODITE - sadly I don't love this as much as the other Kylie song. It's kinda a mess that lacks any euphoric moment that Supernova does so well. Not a fan

 

PLANET HEALTH - there are some interesting and dazzling moments here and there, but I don't think it ever comes together. Esp towards the ending this starts to drag. Not terrible, but yeah this ain't gonna win

 

RITUAL - once again proof that Halcyon is one of the best and most forward-thinking pop albums of the 10s. Such an excellent pop song. 

 

ATLANTIS - we don't deserve her yeah..  I love when this vocal effect is well utilized in a song and this one does it really well. great pick

 

SEASON OF THE WITCH - excellent song. I love the vibe of it and the more campy parts here and there by the usage of multiple vocal layers. Anyone hating on it is stupid yeah

 

NEXT LEVEL - this feels like 20 songs in one. I like many parts of it but it's a bit too much all over the place for me

 

SUPERNATURAL - time wasn't super kind to this sadly. Most of the song revolves around a drop that just sounds awkward now. 

 

SEVEN WONDERS - It's okay. I kinda can't believe it's less than 4 minutes because it feels like it drags and is like 6+ minutes. Anyways it has its moments and reminds me of Coven so there's that but it's not my fav

 

PRINCESS OF CHINA - yeah they were in their bag. When Coldplay actually used interesting instrumental and it's a huge plus that I don't just have to listen to Chris Martin. Such a dazzling and beautiful adventure

 

WHEN DOVES CRY - Not my favorite Prince song and it's kinda middling here in the midst of the songs I feel more strongly about but it's not bad. 

 

WONDALAND - no cause this is still SO good, I feel like her EL and DC both really miss moments like this that really build the world of the album in a cool and interesting way. Great song

 

ICE PRINCESS - It's kinda funny how the chorus is somewhat underwhelming but the verses go so hard. Anyways this overall is still great, one of my favorite Azealia songs

 

BE A BODY - ABSOLUTELYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

 

 

Posted

Yas bagels exactly 

 

Posted

Wait Princess of China is getting doubled? :rip:

Posted
7 minutes ago, Rotunda said:

Wait Princess of China is getting doubled? :rip:

Yes sir

Posted
6 minutes ago, clue said:

Yes sir


 

 

Posted

hmm

Posted

Qhb3qvm.png

 

 

Bastille - Icarus

This is giving me 2013 filler, it makes me envision str8 college dudes guzzling beer with it dripping down their beards, no ty

 

Kylie Minogue - Supernova

If a MPG released this in 2014-2016, it would have went top 3 on the Hot 100 for sure

 

Celine Dion - Beauty and The Beast

Classic song from a classic film

 

Kylie Minogue - Aphrodite

One of my favorite songs from that album, I love the chorus, it's empowering for us golden girls

 

Chairlift - Planet Health

The title makes me think of a gym. It has some cute moments, drags a bit thru the middle, picks back up at the end

 

Ellie Goulding - Ritual

Fits this round perfectly, from the sound to the lyrics, Ellie did everything right with Halcyon

 

Bridgit Mendler - Atlantis

This is nice :jamming: love an educated indie pop princess

 

Lana Del Rey - Season of the Witch

This is cute, it feels/sounds surprisingly light for a Lana song, especially one called season of the witch. This cover is serviceable but not the best. 

 

Aespa - Next Level

What is this multiple personality bop :jamming: 

 

Kesha - Supernatural

One of Kesha's best songs tbh!! The chorus :winnie: the production a bit dated at times but still good

 

Fleetwood Mac - Seven Wonders

A nice song, chill vibe, Stevie is a witchy queen

 

Coldplay - Princess of China

This song has always felt like a journey to me, on a hot air balloon traveling the world while microdosing lsd or something, love Rih's vocals on it

 

Prince - When Doves Cry

An actual classic, not sure why this site likes to act like Prince isn't a legend, and this is his 2nd best song period

 

Janelle Monae - Wondaland

This is a weird song, it does sound like it could be for a kids show but also like a magic mushroom theme song too, it's kooky

 

Azealia Banks - Ice Princess

Still a big bop, production still sounds fresh, have never cared about AB personally but she has some bops, papi pahsicle 

 

Grimes - Be A Body

Cute vibe, her fairy airy vocals can be annoying at times but I liked it overall

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.