Jump to content

Vanishing Letters 9 | WINNER REVEALED (p.187)| #WinterComing


Overprotected

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 4.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • ughgabriel

    409

  • Kavish

    322

  • Dessy

    288

  • Overprotected

    269

Just now, Psycho said:

Stream Wildest Dreams uwu

I'm good thanks x

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Psycho said:

Stream Wildest Dreams uwu

[2] :cm:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ROUND 8: THE PRODUCERS

 

Rank the entries and send them to me through ATRL or Discord preferably

 

 

Excluding your group's entries, rank from 1-10:

 

1. ex: 8th Grade [BEST SONG]

2. ex: One Mo' Gen [2ND BEST SONG]

10. ex: Portrait [WORST SONG]

 

Judges will be ranking and critiquing too

 

Spoiler

FKA Twigs - Give Up

Lana del Rey - Gods and Monsters

Katy Perry - Roulette

Avril Lavigne - I Love You

Kesha - Blind

Kids See Ghosts - Reborn

CHVRCHES - Forever

Halsey - Devil in Me

Sky Ferreira - Boys

HAIM - You Never Knew

Lorde - Supercut

Lana del Rey - **** It I Love You

Spotify Playlist

 

DEADLINE: SATURDAY, SEPTEMBER 18TH 9PM EST

Send late and you'll be punished :gayrat: 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I’m so I’m so reborn 

I’m moving forward :gaycatina1:

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, mokitsu said:

Yall ****ed up

Y’all ****** up by banning A & H 

Edited by Rotunda
Link to comment
Share on other sites

xgiVequ.png

 

cwOPpau.gif

 

Spoiler

FKA TWIGS - GIVE UP

One of her best songs. Decade highlight for production, etc.

 

LANA DEL REY - GODS & MONSTERS

It used to be one of my favorite Lana songs. It's still cute, actually has aged pretty well

 

KATY PERRY - ROULETTE

A bop. I wanted this to be a single back when I used to pay attention to her

 

AVRIL LAVIGNE - I LOVE YOU

I love her, but no thanks. This is painfully generic. Sounds like something a Five Below would play in their rotation

 

KESHA - BLIND

One of her best songs. Her writing was insane back in the day

 

KIDS SEE GHOSTS - REBORN

This song is incredible. The production is so unique and the lyrics are beautiful

 

CHVRCHES - FOREVER

Not my type of thing. It's just kinda... there. It has no character for me

 

HALSEY - DEVIL IN ME

It's alright. Generic

 

SKY FERREIRA - BOYS

Probably my favorite Sky Ferreira song. The production and her confidence on the verses >>

 

HAIM - YOU NEVER KNEW

A cute lil yacht rock classic. It fits nicely within the album, but it's not a highlight for me. Chorus has a nice melody but that's about it.

 

LORDE - SUPERCUT

Her best song next to Green Light. The melancholic outro is the cherry on top.

 

LANA DEL REY - **** IT I LOVE YOU

Randomly grew on me massively this year. One of her best songs. I love the texture that the synth adds in the second half of the song.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok

 

maria-carey-shade.gif

 

 

FK Twigs - Give Up 
It’s lright for FKs stndrd. Noting to te for me but noting’s wowing me. 

 

Ln del Rey - Gods and Monsters 
Tis is cute ctully. 

 

Kty Perry - Roulette
It’s lright.

 

vril Lavigne - I Love You
I enjoyed tis. Gret job. 

 

Kes - Blind
Kes? bsolutely not.

 

Kids See Gosts - Reborn

Deliciousfinllysomegood****ingfood.png

 

CVRCES - Forever
Tis is ctually good. I vibe. 

 

lsey - Devil in Me
Deliciousfinllysomegood****ingfood.png [2]

 

Sky Ferreir - Boys
Tis is just noise. Like I could replce wite noise wit tis. Sorry.

 

IM - You Never Knew
Idk ow you mnged to find _ song more boring thn Ln but good job tere. 

 

Lorde - Supercut
Okay I’d like to pologize for my downvote. Tis is better tn I remembered fff (upgrded to _ pinc from now on!)

 

Ln del Rey - **** It I Love You
No.
 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

                                          my thoughts, round 8                                       

fcf8d1e3d01df6aeb68cfac8d64d7af0c99a0882.jpg

stream mumumumuch <3

 

FKA Twigs - Give Up - it's pretty cool. not in love with it but i do like it to a point.

Lana del Rey - Gods and Monsters - legendary. i've always loved this song, reminds me of AHS 4 too <3

Katy Perry - Roulette - it's a pretty good song! not exactly a favorite of mine by Katy but it's still a nice bop.

Avril Lavigne - I Love You - i was just listening to this yesterday and it's a very cute song. idk if it's the strongest in this group but it's nice.

Kesha - Blind - i've always loved this song. one of her best album tracks for sure.

Kids See Ghosts - Reborn - it's a no.

CHVRCHES - Forever - her voice is cute and the song is not bad. idk would i go back to it but i did enjoy it somewhat.

Halsey - Devil in Me - yess! i like almost all of her songs so i was excited to see her on this list <3 very good.

Sky Ferreira - Boys - ooh i'm liking this a lot! lately i've been into this kind of sound a lot.

HAIM - You Never Knew - well it's way better than i was expecting... let's keep it at that uwu.

Lorde - Supercut - so sorry but i've turned into an OLH after hearing the WAOTY SP.

Lana del Rey - **** It I Love You - sooo beautiful. a great choice.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

FKA Twigs - Give Up

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

Lana del Rey - Gods and Monsters

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

Katy Perry - Roulette

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

Avril Lavigne - I Love You

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

Kesha - Blind

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

Kids See Ghosts - Reborn

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

CHVRCHES - Forever

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

Halsey - Devil in Me

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

Sky Ferreira - Boys

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

HAIM - You Never Knew

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

Lorde - Supercut

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

Lana del Rey - **** It I Love You

6w6Pcz7.gif

 

 

Spoiler

real critiques later tonight

 

Edited by Rotunda
Link to comment
Share on other sites

j2oaL4R.png

 

My thoughts:

Spoiler

Avril Lavigne - I Love You

Ehhh it’s a bit of a flat song. It doesn’t have enough to make me love it even though I usually like Avril’s stuff from the 2000s.

It’s not bad but will probably be in the middle of the group for me.

 

CHVRCHES - Forever

 

This is pleasant, very typical CHVRCHES.

 

FKA twigs - Give Up

 

This is gorgeoussssss, I love this so much. Atmospheric pop bop.

What I love about this album is everything feels so meticulous, there’s so many fine details that you keep picking up on that add new layers.

But even without all that critical listening, it’s just a bop sljfsj. #1 contender for me

 

HAIM - You Never Knew

 

I almost never listen to this album fff. But I like this, it has cool production and feels like a very chilled vibey song. 

 

Halsey - Devil in Me

 

Hmmm idk not really for me. It doesn't’ really reach anything for me

 

Katy Perry - Roulette

 

Big bop, definitely the best song off Witness along with Tsunami.

Gorgeous production and would’ve been a lovely addition to her big bops singles catalogue… but at least we get to use it here!!

 

Kesha - Blind

 

I like Kesha’s early stuff but this kind of fades into the blur that was 2010-2011 for me. Not bad but not a standout.

 

Kids See Ghosts - Reborn

 

Wait this experimental choice. I’m not a Kid Cudi fan (idk if its just me but he just does the same thing on every song and it’s… tired).

I like Kanye’s parts, one of the better things he’s done lately.

 

Lana Del Rey - **** it I love you

 

A little sleepy and demure for me. I don’t really feel anything either way about this.

There’s a few parts where it gets into a stream of conscious style delivery that I like, but idk I just kind of don’t care.

 

Lana Del Rey - Gods and Monster

 

Absolutely not jlsfjses. This is very reminiscent of a particular period in time, and that’s... whatever, but like lyrically I can’t stand this.

And the weird pause and go delivery I-

 

Lorde - Supercut

 

SOOOO good. I love songs like this. The production is immaculate, could cut glass.

This was a lovely moment from the album and really has that “coming of age” vibe I connect with lyrically. 

 

Sky Ferreira - Boys

 

Also great. VL this season has been great at reminding me how much I enjoyed this album.

This one has this cool balance between the electronic stuff and the noise-rock that I like.

 

 

Players:

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

FKA Twigs - Give Up: I don't like her voice, production is decent

 

Lana del Rey - Gods and Monsters: One of the best from Paradise, Jessica Lange outsang I fear

 

Katy Perry - Roulette: classic banger 

 

Avril Lavigne - I Love You: love Avril but it's painfully generic

 

Kesha - Blind: I love those power pop ballads from that album :jamming:

 

Kids See Ghosts - Reborn: really bad

 

CHVRCHES - Forever: bop from a great album

 

Halsey - Devil in Me: mid tier Halsey for me

 

Sky Ferreira - Boys: rock banger 

 

HAIM - You Never Knew: queens, classic

 

Lorde - Supercut: 2017 classic :chick3:

 

Lana del Rey - **** It I Love You: lovely song

Edited by Psycho
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Vt2dVNT.png

 

Spoiler

FKA Twigs - Give Up

I love the production, just nod your head and get up, good life motto

 

Lana del Rey - Gods and Monsters

It's cute, I identify with the angel looking to get ****ed hard lyrics,

the song kinda drags as it goes on but that's par for the course with Lana

 

Katy Perry - Roulette

One of the most distinct/memorable productions from Witness and one of my faves from the album

 

Avril Lavigne - I Love You

This is a random basic choice, I like Avril but this is forgettable 

 

Kesha - Blind

One of the best Animal songs lyrically :praise: 

 

Kids See Ghosts - Reborn

The production is alright, nice chill vibe, the lyrics are very repetitive, got tired of it

 

CHVRCHES - Forever

Cute production I guess, the song as a whole is kinda forgettable

 

Halsey - Devil in Me

I'm just not feeling this very much :deadbanana2:were there no better Halsey options?

 

Sky Ferreira - Boys

This song has a spark of something that the last 3 I listened to did not, passion? creativity? replay value?

 I like the rough rocky production and vocals too

 

HAIM - You Never Knew

This is giving me 70s Summer evening sun vibes, I'm digging it man, very groovy

 

Lorde - Supercut

Ugh I miss when Lorde was passionate about anything and not opening up a wellness center, this song still hits for me

 

Lana del Rey - **** It I Love You

This is really pretty x

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

panned producers round

 

Pokémon is gamifying the wellness market with new app Pokémon Sleep | Dazed  Beauty

 

FKA Twigs - Give Up: an alright track from LP1, never cared too much for it 

Lana del Rey - Gods and Monsters: this was a classic back in the days but now it's just really meh

Katy Perry - Roulette: deserved to be a single, one of her best songs

Avril Lavigne - I Love You: it's cute but it's just there

Kesha - Blind: I really don't like this at all, the production hurts my ears 

Kids See Ghosts - Reborn: I really don't like this either sorry

CHVRCHES - Forever: this is very cute and dreamy!! good job <3

Halsey - Devil in Me: it's cute, def one of my least favs from the album tho

Sky Ferreira - Boys: NOW THIS IS THE CLASSICCCCCCC.

HAIM - You Never Knew: this is cute, but it's a bottom tier in their discography

Lorde - Supercut: one of my favorite songs of all time, u win.

Lana del Rey - **** It I Love You: EXCELLENCE.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Staryu said:

Halsey - Devil in Me

I'm just not feeling this very much :deadbanana2:were there no better Halsey options?

the halsey options were really bad bc of a being banned

Link to comment
Share on other sites

FKA Twigs - Give Up: this is fine, never got into FKA but this sounds good

 

Lana Del Rey - Gods & Monsters: never liked this song a lot, but it's not bad, it's just there

 

Katy Perry - Roulette: mhmmm this smashes hard, production is delicious and she's still sick in the head for not making it a single

 

Avril Lavigne - I Love You: I love this song sooooo much, it has so much nostalgia value for me so congrats to you on that cause this will probably get shred to pieces by the cast/judges :rip:

 

Kesha - Blind: whewwwwwwww she was SO good back then, this is one of the best songs on Animal without a doubt, still fresh somehow

 

KIDS SEE GHOSTS - Reborn: mama this is garbage 

 

CHVRCHES - Forever: literally all of their music sounds the same :deadbanana2: this is cute, that's it 

 

Halsey - Devil In Me: a HFK filler track, don't care for it a lot

 

Sky Ferreira - Boys: it is a Sky Ferreira song

 

HAIM - You Never Knew:

 

Lorde - Supercut: now I KNOW a classic when I hear one... weddings, graduations, funerals

 

Lana Del Rey - **** it I love You: wayyy better than the other Lana song here, quite stunning 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

160124-sleep-630x421.jpg


FKA Twigs - Give Up
I like her voice. This was okay albeit a little too long for me. 

Lana Del Rey - Gods & Monsters
God her music is such a snooze. 

Katy Perry - Roulette
This was okay but I feel like it needs a little something to make it better.

Avril Lavigne - I Love You
I don’t really have much to say about this… it’s just there.


Kesha - Blind
Not spectacular. The best part is the bridge. But her vocals are nice here at least.

Kids See Ghosts - Reborn
This was pretty harmless but very very meh.

CHVRCHES - Forever
Nice H&M shopping music.


Halsey - Devil In Me
“Gotta wake up” me this entire playlist.

Sky Ferrerorocher - Boys
Nice Tilly’s shopping music.

HAIM - You Never Knew
It’s decent.

Lorde - Supercut
Probably the best entry in this group.

Lana Del Rey - **** it I love you
God her music is such a snooze. [2]

Edited by Guero
Link to comment
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.