Kind of an unnecessary and unprofessional comment... their list isn't even that great and some of the placements are questionable

How broke are they…?

Then why give it such a high score on initial review.

Who gives a F about pitchfork when your album outsells all MPGs combined?

Oh that's some lame ass ****.

But they are talking about it?

Anyway, Showgirl was not good overall. There are 5 good songs on there and the other 7 belong in the bin. She needs to do better.

They got what they wanted which was engagement from the swifties lol

So they won't talk about it... but used it as the opener of their tweet. And they also reviewed it?

Serving OTHs on here who stay posted up in Taylor threads complaining how they're so tired of hearing about her

2 hours ago, Doctor Dick said:

They don't "need" anything from her. Sometimes you Swifties need to take your heads out of your own asses.

2 hours ago, TayDuaStan said:

And the way this is a repost cuz they posted the same thing a couple of hours before without the Taylor mention and barely anyone checked it out…

Notice how Swifties always take the bait

The smerz album IS the best pop album of the year so whatever clickbait caption they use is irrelevant to me!

PANNED.

...Vin

what halsey said

3 hours ago, olivethetree said:

Are they gonna back pedal a few years later like they did with Red?

i doubt it. Red was actually a good album

3 hours ago, KatyPrismSpirit said:

they have never been rage baiting this much... is everything okay over there omg

They tried it with Madame eXcellence and it worked and it's become their model I guess

Ugh Madonna's never ending impacT

Showgirl isn't great but...they did talk about it, and continue to talk about it. Kind of a weird way to getting clicks.

They're talking about it nonstop

20 minutes ago, MissedTheTrain said:

Showgirl isn't great but...they did talk about it, and continue to talk about it. Kind of a weird way to getting clicks.

They need to hire someone from the ATRL mod team ASAP!!

Embarrasing to attack Taylor now that everybody does it and not while she was doing even worse music during TTPD and the eras.

nobody cares for their pretentious list until they put Taylor name in the headline lol.

And are they sure they dont want to mention her Taylor Swift,

Then what is this?? literally obsessed.

this is so embarrassing for them

But then still put her name in the tweet

The best shade would've just been to put their EOY list out without the slightest mention of her or her floppy disk. P4K is always so unserious and it's gotten even worse since they've been under Conde Nast.

That list putting SWAG at #13 above Sabrina, Jade and Gaga, Halsey made some points I fear

Pitchfork reminding everyone of their irrelevancy in 2025 lmao