Not the backfire what a shaky start.

Well the album wasn't really that acclaimed outside of nostalgia hungry white gay circles.

5 minutes ago, Titanbaddie said:

Well the album wasn't really that acclaimed outside of nostalgia hungry white gay circles.

interesting... is that why it has 6 Grammy noms including one for AOTY?

OGHs just love creating alternate realities to COPE. chi.

The first page of this thread will be the funniest thing to EVER quote after the 2026 GRAMMYs

3 minutes ago, RideOrDie said:

interesting... is that why it has 6 Grammy noms including one for AOTY?

OGHs just love creating alternate realities to COPE. chi.

Celebrating 6 Grammy noms like my fave isn't the most nominated artist EVER. Hopefully she wins a couple of those noms so she can be half way to Beyonce's grammy WIN total.

2 minutes ago, Titanbaddie said:

Celebrating 6 Grammy noms like my fave isn't the most nominated artist EVER. Hopefully she wins a couple of those noms so she can be half way to Beyonce's grammy WIN total.

if only Michael was also bullying and pressuring Scammys publicly to award her every year like someone's hubby

5 minutes ago, RideOrDie said:

if only Michael was also bullying and pressuring Scammys publicly to award her every year like someone's hubby

Well hopefully Gagita can make it down the aisle this time so she actually has a husband to do things for her, we wouldn't want her to have yet another disengagement.

The contradictions in this thread are fascinating.

Who cares about cringey critic lists -> ZOMG LOOK HOW MANY GRAMMYS SHES NOMINATED FOR!! -> The Grammys are a scam and the committee can pressured into giving them!!!

They really are the **** of the Stan world

the title of the thread aged incredibly badly

down to #41

13 hours ago, Yes, AND said:

Well well well what a turnaround. As you were highly involved in threads regarding criticial acclaim or lack there of when it came to Gaga's peers.

Gaga's peers are not Gaga. Some artists need critics approval, not Gaga, hope this helps

Just now, Comedor said:

down to #41

i know gaga haters do not have basic math skills, but 41 < 50

2 hours ago, Titanbaddie said:

Well hopefully Gagita can make it down the aisle this time so she actually has a husband to do things for her, we wouldn't want her to have yet another disengagement.

This is so pathetic

1 hour ago, Weld_E said:

The contradictions in this thread are fascinating.

Who cares about cringey critic lists -> ZOMG LOOK HOW MANY GRAMMYS SHES NOMINATED FOR!! -> The Grammys are a scam and the committee can pressured into giving them!!!

They really are the **** of the Stan world

You stan Britney Spears... the nerve to talk about critics, grammys and acclaim

Edited Thursday at 04:36 PM3 days by Mariano

34 minutes ago, Mariano said:

This is so pathetic

You stan Britney Spears... the nerve to talk about critics, grammys and acclaim

I stan the most talented performer of all time, the Queen B herself, BEYONCÉ, and you can continue to seething about it

19 minutes ago, Weld_E said:

I stan the most talented performer of all time, the Queen B herself, BEYONCÉ, and you can continue to seething about it

Nice try, but you only started cosplaying as a Bey stan after Renaissance era, while you've been on ATRL since forever I remember you stanning Britney very clearly andf making Britney/Xtina topics. So as I said, don't talk about grammys

8 minutes ago, Mariano said:

Nice try, but you only became a Bey stan after Renaissance era, while you've been on ATRL since forever I remember you stanning Britney very clearly andf making Britney/Xtina topics. So as I said, don't talk about grammys

Not me having my own stans who know more about my internet history than I do.

Hopefully you can see the light too one day, but for now, stay seething.

Edited Thursday at 05:54 PM3 days by Weld_E

1 hour ago, Mariano said:

Gaga's peers are not Gaga. Some artists need critics approval, not Gaga, hope this helps

Glad Gaga doesn't need the critics approval actually because from the looks of things, she'll never get it.

3 hours ago, Link16 said:

the same rolling stone that gave Showgurl 5/5?

2 hours ago, Mariano said:

Gaga's peers are not Gaga. Some artists need critics approval, not Gaga, hope this helps

They don't.

9 hours ago, Yanko said:

talking about success, not cringy critics list.

Well the topic is about critics list.

On 12/2/2025 at 8:49 AM, Sannie said:

:ahh: "Gaga misses an arbitrary list" is such a funny attempt at a drag.

Looking at the top ten so far, a pop/dance album isn't exactly going to make the list lol. Let's use our brains, girls. Common sense.

Why are the Beyonce stans so bothered by miss Gaga her album so weird

24 minutes ago, period sis said:

Well the topic is about critics list.

Gaga won. Get over it

On 12/2/2025 at 4:49 PM, Sannie said:

:ahh: "Gaga misses an arbitrary list" is such a unny attempt at a drag.

Looking at the top ten so far, a pop/dance album isn't exactly going to make the list lol. Let's use our brains, girls. Common sense.

#10 FKA twigs - EUSEXUA

#15 Addison Rae - Addison

#18 PinkPantheress - Fancy That

#36 Sudan Archives - The BPM

All of these are dance albums that outranked Mayhem so that's no excuse lol

4 hours ago, Comedor said:

down to #41

#42 (-1)