2 minutes ago, Kern said:

Congrats on being #36 in one of the 30 lists of best albums of the year. TLOAS is also in one of them

...you have no idea what the thread is talking about do you?
Are you from USA per chance?

3 minutes ago, Yanko said:

...you have no idea what the thread is talking about do you?
Are you from USA per chance?

I think in this case it's just OGH being unable to read and slow… nothing new for them

Edited Wednesday at 03:01 PM4 days by verthigo

34 minutes ago, Kern said:

Congrats on being #36 in one of the 30 lists of best albums of the year. TLOAS is also in one of them

what?

Taylor isn't in the top 50 yet

2025 Music Year End List Aggregate

7 minutes ago, Green said:

what?

Taylor isn't in the top 50 yet

2025 Music Year End List Aggregate

he thinks were talking about one certain list just loud and wrong and dumb and ugly

Edited Wednesday at 03:27 PM4 days by Yanko

16 minutes ago, Kern said:

Congrats on being #36 in one of the 30 lists of best albums of the year. TLOAS is also in one of them

Don't move the goalpost so quickly now

15 minutes ago, Green said:

The thread was celebrating she isn't in the top 50

i wasn't celebrating that

i just said she isn't magically gonna get tons of high placements after not getting any so far. 1 top 10 placement from RS of all magazines isn't gonna change that

23 hours ago, Sannie said:

:ahh: "Gaga misses an arbitrary list" is such a funny attempt at a drag.

Looking at the top ten so far, a pop/dance album isn't exactly going to make the list lol. Let's use our brains, girls. Common sense.

This excuse.

3 minutes ago, ScorpiosGroove said:

i wasn't celebrating that

i just said she isn't magically gonna get tons of high placements after not getting any so far. 1 top 10 placement from RS of all magazines isn't gonna change that

And she doesn't need to. Do you really think THE Lady Gaga needs critics approval? Those edgy losers who desperately need to feel special? Please.

23 hours ago, Icarus said:

Only Little Monsters will tell you this album is great. It's a Born This Way re-hash attempt sonically, and lyrically it has nothing to say at all.

She's on your mind , like, All the time.

Lack of talent

Just now, Mariano said:

And she doesn't need to. Do you really think THE Lady Gaga needs critics approval? Those edgy losers who desperately need to feel special? Please.

i didn't say any of this

1 minute ago, ScorpiosGroove said:

i didn't say any of this

Period

1 hour ago, Me & My Hits said:

Not surprising. This album is mediocre at best, all of those paid reviews and payola won't change reality.

The nerve to call anything else mediocre while being a Selena "utterly talentless" Gomez stan ffffff

OT: The backfire already. And it took one (1) day.

Let's wait a couple days before a thread title update.

2 hours ago, Kern said:

Congrats on being #36 in one of the 30 lists of best albums of the year. TLOAS is also in one of them

2 hours ago, Green said:

what?

Taylor isn't in the top 50 yet

2025 Music Year End List Aggregate

2 hours ago, Yanko said:

he thinks were talking about one certain list just loud and wrong and dumb and ugly

Y'all this interaction is sending me. Some people really need to use their brain before chatting shite.

On 12/2/2025 at 3:42 PM, ICLDXU4HS said:

She's fully entered Pink territory with that one. Musically and artistically entirely insignificant and inoffensive. Getting so stale was always the last thing I thought would happen to her.

A music writer basically said the same thing back in 2023.

On 12/2/2025 at 4:14 PM, Icarus said:

Only Little Monsters will tell you this album is great. It's a Born This Way re-hash attempt sonically, and lyrically it has nothing to say at all.

And even then, most monsters only like the first five songs and "How Bad…",

9 minutes ago, Fitzswiftie said:

A music writer basically said the same thing back in 2023.

That dude didn't say what you are pretending he said...

10 minutes ago, Fitzswiftie said:

A music writer basically said the same thing back in 2023.

Meanwhile Ed Sheeran's latest two or three albums were cataclismic bombs and Gaga is obliterating him. Maybe that music critic should re-take math class.

And the ToddInTheShadows pushing it like Shallow or Rain On Me were going to be her last hits. Yet she keeps smashing with ballads and non-ballads at that. Feel free to keep doubting her and change goalpoasts because she'll continue to prove naysayers wrong.

Anyway stream Lovedrug and How Bad Do U Want Me for clear skin

This pie in the face of a thread

On 12/2/2025 at 1:14 PM, Icarus said:

Only Little Monsters will tell you this album is great. It's a Born This Way re-hash attempt sonically, and lyrically it has nothing to say at all.

On 12/2/2025 at 1:14 PM, Icarus said:

Only Little Monsters will tell you this album is great. It's a Born This Way re-hash attempt sonically, and lyrically it has nothing to say at all.

1 hour ago, Fitzswiftie said:

And even then, most monsters only like the first five songs and "How Bad…",

^

People who unironically think The Life of a Showgirl is a listenable album lecturing others about what's good, everyone.

ATRL stop ignoring her!

48

THAT'S SHOWBIZ BABY!

JADE

16 Points

On 12/2/2025 at 11:23 AM, Shinning said:

Regardless of little monster propaganda Gaga is not and has never been an acclaimed artist on the level of artistés like Beyoncé, Lorde or Lana. And Mayhem is absolutely mediocre so I'm not surprised critics aren't paying it any mind.

Like why would you listen to Mayhem when you can listen to Addison?

On 12/2/2025 at 11:21 AM, Sabrina Carpenter said:

because she's sh*t

On 12/2/2025 at 11:09 AM, Sasori. said:

contrary to what little monsters will tell you, it's just not an acclaimed album by any stretch of the imagination

On 12/2/2025 at 11:01 AM, LanaDelRey said:

GaGa has never really released any acclaimed albums except maybe TFM. Mayhem was no exception.

ijbol the album has universal acclaim on MetaCritic. That is reality.

It also has a higher score than / is on part with 5/8 Beyoncé albums.

Talking about Lana, Lorde, and Sabrina when the album also has a higher metascore than 7/8 Lana albums, 3/4 Lorde albums, and EVERY Sabrina album.

Edited Wednesday at 08:36 PM4 days by cyberraga

Already top 40