rate Pre-2000s Divas Rate Series - Sophomore Album | Top 62-41 REVEALED

[Saddy]

[Saddy]

		#46 Love Will Save the Day Score: 5.56
		High score: 11 @allforyou Low score: 1 @KillingYourCareer@sparrowblue   Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "Second least fave from the album..." allforyou: "It's easily one of Whitney's greatest dance tracks, it's so energetic and infectious" Ewan Chaos: "I like most versions of this song. Wish it was a bit shorter though." Nightingale: "It's a cute song but I see why it broke her #1 streak"

[ChooseyLover]

1 minute ago, SoldierofLove said:

Janet shouldn't have made it past page 6. I smell rating fraud. 
 

She won't make it to tomorrow that's for sure. How many Janet songs are still there? It Takes All Night only?

[Saddy]

1 minute ago, ChooseyLover said:

She won't make it to tomorrow that's for sure. How many Janet songs are still there? It Takes All Night only?

[ChooseyLover]

1 minute ago, Saddy said:

		#46 Love Will Save the Day Score: 5.56
		High score: 11 @allforyou Low score: 1 @KillingYourCareer@sparrowblue   Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "Second least fave from the album..." allforyou: "It's easily one of Whitney's greatest dance tracks, it's so energetic and infectious" Ewan Chaos: "I like most versions of this song. Wish it was a bit shorter though." Nightingale: "It's a cute song but I see why it broke her #1 streak"

They say sometimes love is not enough.

[Saddy]

		#45 You're Still My Man Score: 5.65
		High score: 10 @KillingYourCareer Low score: 0 @jacklovesyou1   Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "Only getting this score cause ion want the average looking bad but its easily the weak link on the album. she singing heavy tho." Curaga: "Not my fav song, but what an insanely good performance!" allforyou: "In a perfect world this would've been a single"

[ChooseyLover]

Why do I feel the scores will be even lower this time? I already imagine the top 3 being all songs rated an 8.

[Album Leak]

What the hell is going awhn!??! Why are you bullying Whitney like this... and is Mariah going to be overrated yet again this rate 

[Saddy]

2 minutes ago, ChooseyLover said:

Why do I feel the scores will be even lower this time? I already imagine the top 3 being all songs rated an 8.

It's Janet effect 

[Saddy]

Just now, Album Leak said:

What the hell is going awhn!??! Why are you bullying Whitney like this... and is Mariah going to be overrated yet again this rate 

again? what do u mean again? 

[Saddy]

		#44 Tell Tale Signs Score: 5.67 High score: 10 @KillingYourCareer Low score: 1
		@jacklovesyou1   Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "it's cute" Ewan Chaos: "Maybe because this is a change of pace from the bad leftovers from her debut, but I like when the album makes the slower-tempo change with this & the next song." Poki: "She's not famous for her ballads, but the warmth of her voice sure shines on these tracks!"

[ChooseyLover]

That song is underrated af.

[Saddy]

		#43 Love Don't Live Here Anymore Score: 5.76
		High score: 11 @jacklovesyou1 Low score: 1 @poki   Comments: allforyou: "One of her finest vocal moments, it's so raw" Poki: "If you put Crazy For You and Into the Groove instead of this and one other album track, this is a really good 1980s pop album"

[SoldierofLove]

21 minutes ago, Saddy said:

#47
I Know Him So Well

Score: 5.54

High score: 10

@GreatestLoveofAll
Low score: 0

@Mariya Takeuchi

 

Comments:

GreatestLoveofAll: "This is a weird song for a mother and daughter to sing and Cissy's tone is sometimes divisive, but its another fave. They singing this together now once again "
Poki: "Melanie C made a cover of this track. Not sure why."

Poki: "Melanie C made a cover of this track. Not sure why."
 

Sporty Spice:

 

 

[ChooseyLover]

Really agree with Poki. I used to love this song and I don't know why because Madonna's vocal performance is a bit embarrassing.

[Album Leak]

7 minutes ago, Saddy said:

again? what do u mean again? 

It took forever for Mariah to get even one song out the last rate. It seems like we are doing the exact same thing this rate despite Emotions having some dull ass stinkers in there!

 

Unless I missed a Mariah song going out. 

[Quicksand]

8 minutes ago, Saddy said:

		#44 Tell Tale Signs Score: 5.67 High score: 10 @KillingYourCareer Low score: 1
		@jacklovesyou1   Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "it's cute" Ewan Chaos: "Maybe because this is a change of pace from the bad leftovers from her debut, but I like when the album makes the slower-tempo change with this & the next song." Poki: "She's not famous for her ballads, but the warmth of her voice sure shines on these tracks!"

Genuinely shocked this gem made it this far  It's always hated on by Lovers

[ChooseyLover]

1 minute ago, Album Leak said:

It took forever for Mariah to get even one song out the last rate. It seems like we are doing the exact same thing this rate despite Emotions having some dull ass stinkers in there!

 

Unless I missed a Mariah song going out. 

No you didn't sis. But watch your mouth... "dull ass stinkers"?! Omg!

Edited 5 hours ago by ChooseyLover

[Saddy]

Just now, Album Leak said:

It took forever for Mariah to get even one song out the last rate. It seems like we are doing the exact same thing this rate despite Emotions having some dull ass stinkers in there!

 

Unless I missed a Mariah song going out. 

Ppl gave her very decent scores ngl

[Saddy]

		#42 Over and Over Score: 5.78
		High score: 10 @Ewan Chaos Low score: 1 @poki   Comments: Ewan Chaos: "Love this chorus, so fun"

[Album Leak]

1 minute ago, ChooseyLover said:

No you didn't sis. But watch your mouth... "dull ass stinkers"?! Omg!

Are you gagging at Make It Happen because I wasn't! I was so surprised how weak Emotions was overall when I genuinely enjoyed her debut album much more tbh.

[ChooseyLover]

Just now, Album Leak said:

Are you gagging at Make It Happen because I wasn't! I was so surprised how weak Emotions was overall when I genuinely enjoyed her debut album much more tbh.

Ngl initially I wasn't, but it's such an uplifting song and kinda autobiographic considering how bleak Mariah's life was until she became a star. I think most lambs feel that way about Emotions... which I find a bit sad.

[ChooseyLover]

3 minutes ago, Saddy said:

		#42 Over and Over Score: 5.78
		High score: 10 @Ewan Chaos Low score: 1 @poki   Comments: Ewan Chaos: "Love this chorus, so fun"

The chorus is fun indeed. An overall score of 5.78 is CRUEL, I gave it a 8.

[Saddy]

		#41 Love Is a Contact Sport Score: 5.82
		High score: 11 @Mariya Takeuchi Low score: 1 @SoldierofLove@sparrowblue   Comments: GreatestLoveofAll: "A bopppp. the rest of the fandom hates it but I will always defend this smash " allforyou: "It baffles me when people say she has no good album tracks during this period when songs like this one exist" Poki: "Funny title"

[Saddy]

That's all for today. Prob gonna reveal the top 40-21 tomorrow (gonna tag u all before I start)

 

Remaining songs:
Dream Street (1984) 1/9
If It Takes All Night

 

Like a Virgin (1984) 5/9
Material Girl
Angel
Like a Virgin
Dress You Up
Stay

 

Whitney (1987) 5/11
I Wanna Dance with Somebody (Who Loves Me)
Just the Lonely Talking Again
Didn't We Almost Have It All
So Emotional
Where Do Broken Hearts Go

 

Enjoy Yourself (1989) 7/10
Hand on Your Heart
Wouldn't Change a Thing
Never Too Late
Nothing to Lose
I'm Over Dreaming (Over You)
Tears on My Pillow
Enjoy Yourself

 

Emotions (1991) 10/10
Emotions
And You Don't Remember
Can't Let Go
Make It Happen
If It's Over
You're So Cold
So Blessed
To Be Around You
Till the End of Time
The Wind

 

Celine Dion (1992) 12/13
Love Can Move Mountains
Show Some Emotion
If You Asked Me To
If You Could See Me Now
Halfway to Heaven
Did You Give Enough Love
If I Were You
Beauty and the Beast
I Love You, Goodbye
Water from the Moon
With This Tear
Nothing Broken but My Heart