KatyPrismSpirit Posted October 2 Posted October 2 143 almost outselling double the amount of Harlequin 26k is a collosal bomb 2
eclipsed Posted October 2 Posted October 2 I guess they really were going for arts not the charts with Harlequin. It being sold on her website only was definitely a choice 1
KatyPrismSpirit Posted October 2 Posted October 2 8 hours ago, JO1s said: Looks like she's back on katy's boat Katy actually outsold her last two albums… 5
eclipsed Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, KatyPrismSpirit said: 143 almost outselling double the amount of Harlequin 26k is a collosal bomb and 143 isnt? That had 3 singles, music videos, varients, many performances, collabs, original music like a normal pop roll out. Harlequin is a cover album with no physicals in stores and sold on her website only bffr you are dumb to compare the two.
KatyPrismSpirit Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, eclipsed said: and 143 isnt? That had 3 singles, music videos, varients, many performances, collabs, original music like a normal pop roll out. Harlequin is a cover album with no physicals in stores and sold on her website only bffr you are dumb to compare the two. In the middle of a hate train lmao, and I even admit that Katy bombed. But many little monsters told me Harlequin would sell more than 143 and got brave, just for Harlequin to not even debut top 15. #17 is a chop for a star as big as Gaga. Doesnt matter if its a cover album. Love for Sale was a cover album too and that went top 10? What happened. 2 4
eclipsed Posted October 2 Posted October 2 1 minute ago, KatyPrismSpirit said: Katy actually outsold her last two albums… Both being jazz cover albums and 1 a soundtrack/companion album to a movie.. You are really trying it to make yourself feel better about fave being panned and not doing as well If LG7 does this much then we can talk. Even if LG7 did a quarter of Chromatica it would still be more than Katy so you're really pushing it with a woman who currently has the #1 song in the world.
eclipsed Posted October 2 Posted October 2 (edited) 9 minutes ago, KatyPrismSpirit said: In the middle of a hate train lmao, and I even admit that Katy bombed. But many little monsters told me Harlequin would sell more than 143 and got brave, just for Harlequin to not even debut top 15. #17 is a chop for a star as big as Gaga. Doesnt matter if its a cover album. Love for Sale was a cover album too and that went top 10? What happened. L4S had 4 varients and was sold in stores. Harlequin was not. I'm not acting like these numbers are amazing, but they are to be expected. You shouldn't be comparing a major pop release to this, since when did soundtracks ever do well in this day and age, especially one full of jazz covers and showtunes. ASIB is literally an anomaly and those were all originals. Like I said if LG7 does worse than Katy then the lashings would at least have some merrit but these takes are giving brain dead, which is expected from ATRL but still Oh and also "in the middle of a hate train" then how do you explain Smile Gaga has never had a studio album perform as badly as Smile/143 Edited October 2 by eclipsed
KatyPrismSpirit Posted October 2 Posted October 2 These are the peaks of all of Lady Gaga's albums (including studio albums, collaborative studio albums, soundtrack albums and "companion" albums). (Billboard 200) 2008: The Fame — #2 2009: The Fame Monster — #5 2011: Born This Way — #1 2013: ARTPOP — #1 2014: Cheek To Cheek — #1 2016: Joanne — #1 2018: A Star Is Born — #1 2020: Chromatica — #1 2021: Love For Sale — #8 2024: Harlequin — #17 (HDD early prediction) Note: This list excludes limited edition compilations and remix albums. Hopefully Harlequin gets a bigger boost after the movie comes out so it can go top 10 and the streak will be saved. What do you think? 4 1
Popular Post Klein Posted October 2 Popular Post Posted October 2 The Kats are seeing even the smallest semblance of a win and they're gonna ignore any context and just enjoy every single piece of it to the fullest. Ngl, I would probably do that too if I was in their place. 1 29
Popular Post Infernal Paradise Posted October 2 Popular Post Posted October 2 Probably. But at least she will continue to fill stadiums for the rest of her career as the generational and beloved performer that she is. See what happens when your career depends on your talent and artistry instead of song by song and album by album? 22
Jump Posted October 2 Posted October 2 9 hours ago, Bey_Rihstan said: Hopefully this bombing lets gaga and her team know that absolutely no one wants these jazz albums from her. looks like the monsters are tired of faking the funk regarding these passion projects pop and dance only ***** and stop taking 4+ year breaks between studio albums I think they may have overestimated the jazz demand given that her live jazz shows in Vegas are well received. But yes, I agree she needs to stick to dance pop when it comes to new releases
Jump Posted October 2 Posted October 2 9 hours ago, Bey_Rihstan said: Hopefully this bombing lets gaga and her team know that absolutely no one wants these jazz albums from her. looks like the monsters are tired of faking the funk regarding these passion projects pop and dance only ***** and stop taking 4+ year breaks between studio albums I think they may have overestimated the jazz demand given that her live jazz shows in Vegas are well received. But yes, I agree she needs to stick to dance pop when it comes to new releases
Jump Posted October 2 Posted October 2 9 hours ago, hallucinate said: this was a passion project she released this for HERSELF, not the fans hence the low streams and sales Are you saying it doesn't even qualify as a gift for the fans?
mike_int Posted October 2 Posted October 2 I dont even consider as Gaga album, just like I didnt consider Star Is Born or the Jazz albums. I think mistake they did with Harlequin is to announce it literally days before release with no single before and Die With Smile not being on the album. Die With Smile overlap with Harlequin too much. It is also mostly album of covers and mostly in Jazz style, this is not something regular Gaga listener is interested in. I enjoy Happy Mistake and maybe 1-2 other guitar driven songs on the album but I dont feel like listening Jazz outside of theater or thematic bar I think it is nice companion to the soundtrack and that is it, but I understand some Gaga haters will jerk off their egos that it wont be commercial success, but I dont think it ever was planned to be. 5
simplywohoo Posted October 2 Posted October 2 9 minutes ago, Infernal Paradise said: Probably. But at least she will continue to fill stadiums for the rest of her career as the generational and beloved performer that she is. See what happens when your career depends on your talent and artistry instead of song by song and album by album? Exactly + She will also most definitely go #1 with lg7 and top 10 with her new lead so she's gonna be more than fine 1
Dante Posted October 2 Posted October 2 not bad for a hokey pokey jazz album side project released on a friday of a slow week connected to a flop movie not caused by gaga herself
Junlin Posted October 2 Posted October 2 oh this is bad for ga ga where is Tony save her flop ass king
enchanted0 Posted October 2 Posted October 2 10 minutes ago, mike_int said: I dont even consider as Gaga album, just like I didnt consider Star Is Born or the Jazz albums. I think mistake they did with Harlequin is to announce it literally days before release with no single before and Die With Smile not being on the album. Die With Smile overlap with Harlequin too much. It is also mostly album of covers and mostly in Jazz style, this is not something regular Gaga listener is interested in. I enjoy Happy Mistake and maybe 1-2 other guitar driven songs on the album but I dont feel like listening Jazz outside of theater or thematic bar I think it is nice companion to the soundtrack and that is it, but I understand some Gaga haters will jerk off their egos that it wont be commercial success, but I dont think it ever was planned to be. Very thoughtful consideration but it's indeed Gaga album OT: yes wow so Katy's streak is still intact? @KatyPrismSpirit
KatyPrismSpirit Posted October 2 Posted October 2 Just now, enchanted0 said: Very thoughtful consideration but it's indeed Gaga album OT: yes wow so Katy's streak is still intact? @KatyPrismSpirit It indeed is @enchanted0 thank you for asking! 2008: One Of The Boys — #9 2010: Teenage Dream — #1 2013: PRISM — #1 2017: Witness — #1 2020: Smile — #5 2024: 143 — #6 3 2 5
enchanted0 Posted October 2 Posted October 2 1 minute ago, KatyPrismSpirit said: It indeed is @enchanted0 thank you for asking! 2008: One Of The Boys — #9 2010: Teenage Dream — #1 2013: PRISM — #1 2017: Witness — #1 2020: Smile — #5 2024: 143 — #6 Oh wow 2 2
mike_int Posted October 2 Posted October 2 3 minutes ago, enchanted0 said: Very thoughtful consideration but it's indeed Gaga album OT: yes wow so Katy's streak is still intact? @KatyPrismSpirit I said "I dont consider it" if others does, it is fine, I consider Fame, Fame Monster, ArtPop, Joanne and Chromatica to be Gaga albums Thats all
.thumb.gif.b76ca4d9d1266836992837a38dd37e35.gif)
Recommended Posts