rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[The Music Industry]

My average per album

 

Debut - 7.4

Fearless - 6.8 (the vault tracks dragged this one down)

Speak Now - 8.3

Red - 7.5 (very low lows on this album, otherwise it'd be much higher)

1989 - 8.2 

Reputation - 6.7

Lover - 6.3 

folklore - 9.5 

evermore - 9.2

Midnights - 8

TTPD - 8.1

 

[The Music Industry]

4 hours ago, wastedpotential said:

ddd wait @Forever Winter,  has anyone written things for the Christmas songs? More than like a sentence for each?

I most certainly wrote about how CTF is the greatest (Christmas) song of all time

 

Edited September 1 by The Music Industry

[wastedpotential]

11 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

You and you alone I fear. 

The correct answer is "eyes", which is literally in the title 

[wastedpotential]

5 minutes ago, The Music Industry said:

I most certainly wrote about how CTF is the greatest (Christmas) song of all time

 

I wrote about my agenda to make it the next All I Want For Christmas Is You and also defrauding Amazon Music 

Edited September 1 by wastedpotential

[Brooklyn Baby]

1 hour ago, 305 said:

@Forever Winter can I still submit comments? 

Yes you can. just go to the form, click Edit your responses. Remember to Submit again at the bottom.

[PoisonedIvy]

Perhaps I was generous towards the latter half of her catalogue

 

My averages:

 

Spoiler

• Debut - 7.57

• Fearless - 7.91

• Speak Now - 9.13

• Red - 8.59 (a 9.03 for the standard 16, for what it's worth)

• 1989 - 8.61

• reputation - 8.75

• Lover - 7.54

• folklore - 9.11 ( )

• evermore - 9.24 

• Midnights - 8.89 (8.72 for standard 13, 9.0 for all the extras )

• TTPD - 8.32 (Standard 16 tracks alone are 7.97, Anthology alone is 8.70 though. Look how they carried that)

 

Midnights should not have scored damn near a 9.0 but I had to overcompensate some of my scores because I know it's going to get so much hate. 

 

 

 

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

9 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said:

 

  Hide contents

• reputation - 8.75

 

Spoiler

Why is puta so high

[wastedpotential]

13 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said:

Perhaps I was generous towards the latter half of her catalogue

 

My averages:

 

  Hide contents

• Debut - 7.57

• Fearless - 7.91

• Speak Now - 9.13

• Red - 8.59 (a 9.03 for the standard 16, for what it's worth)

• 1989 - 8.61

• reputation - 8.75

• Lover - 7.54

• folklore - 9.11 ( )

• evermore - 9.24 

• Midnights - 8.89 (8.72 for standard 13, 9.0 for all the extras )

• TTPD - 8.32 (Standard 16 tracks alone are 7.97, Anthology alone is 8.70 though. Look how they carried that)

 

Midnights should not have scored damn near a 9.0 but I had to overcompensate some of my scores because I know it's going to get so much hate. 

 

 

 

 

Spoiler

ddd what I want to know is why Fearless is that close to Lover 

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

Not gonna ping everyone, but if you're reading this, you still have 27ish hours to submit your ballots, so no need to rush if you're re-listening to songs!

[PoisonedIvy]

16 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

  Reveal hidden contents

Why is puta so high

Spoiler

Because I refuse to let you hookers sabotage Ready For It, plus Delicate + Getaway Car + CIWYW + DWOHT + DBM are doing a LOT of heavy lifting. 
 

And because it's her best pop era.

 

[PoisonedIvy]

14 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

  Hide contents

ddd what I want to know is why Fearless is that close to Lover 

 

Spoiler

Fearless was a LOT higher.. until I got to those vault tracks 

 

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

@Where are you now? Received your ballot. Thanks!

 

Btw - you gave 6 11s, please edit to 5 only!  

[Achilles.]

On 8/30/2024 at 1:35 PM, Achilles. said:

  Reveal hidden contents

The way that the rules say we can give decimal scores and that we can give five 11s but they do not prohibit giving 10s decimals. Just wait until our hostess opens my ballot with five 11s and fifteen 10.9s.

@Forever Winter you laughed but you didn't say no…

[Brooklyn Baby]

6 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

@Forever Winter you laughed but you didn't say no…

no 0. or 10. decimals. I'll have to bring those to 1 or 10

 

[wastedpotential]

25 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said:

  Hide contents

Fearless was a LOT higher.. until I got to those vault tracks 

 

 

Spoiler

nnn the way Fearless standard averages over a 9.3 for me, Fearless Platinum averages an 8.9, and then Fearless Plat + Vault is an 8.4

 

Spoiler

The vault average is lower than what I gave the Christmas songs  

 

 

[The Music Industry]

I think we can all collectively agree that Fearless has the weakest vault tracks

 

[Achilles.]

6 minutes ago, The Music Industry said:

I think we can all collectively agree that Fearless has the weakest vault tracks

 

Gonna be super controversial and say that actually Midnights has the worst vault. Even if it is just one song (if you can call it that).
 

[wastedpotential]

10 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

Gonna be super controversial and say that actually Midnights has the worst vault. Even if it is just one song (if you can call it that).
 

Well that's certainly an opinion 

 

I'd say the worst vault is the Lover vault. All Of The Losers You've Paid For is just... musically infuriating, let alone the embarrassment that is Oh, Joe Alwyn, I NEED you! that she thankfully had the tact to not release 

 

Edited September 1 by wastedpotential

[Achilles.]

9 minutes ago, wastedpotential said:

I'd say the worst vault is the Lover vault. All Of The Losers You've Paid For is just... musically infuriating, let alone the embarrassment that is Oh, Joe Alwyn, I NEED you! that she thankfully had the tact to not release 

 

All of The Girls might be top 10 on Loser. I'm not sure. But even if it is, it's not like that's much to write home about. I mean we're talking about a top 10 that includes It's Nice To Have A Friend. Loser top 10 is not a high bar to cross, there's room for everybody (except for Drake and Stella McCartney) let's just say that. 
 

[Brooklyn Baby]

@sparrowblue Received your ballot. Thanks 

[Brooklyn Baby]

2 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

All of The Girls might be top 10 on Loser. I'm not sure. But even if it is, it's not like that's much to write home about. I mean we're talking about a top 10 that includes It's Nice To Have A Friend. Loser top 10 is not a high bar to cross, there's room for everybody (except for Drake and Stella McCartney) let's just say that. 
 

Oh, it is. Better than DBATC, Daylight, The Archer, Lover, and most of the album actually!

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

@enchanted0 Received your ballot. Thank you!

 

Btw - you still have one more 11 to use. You can edit that by going back into the form. Make sure to press Submit again.

[The Music Industry]

7 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Better than DBATC

We need your ballot cancelled 

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

           Ballots Received (137):

Spoiler

1. terrorblade

2. tb6591

3. SlyMacPer

4. PaloSanto

5. greento

6. NordicGuy

7. Forever Winter

8. The Music Industry

9. Solaria

10. pinkbowvintage

11. 1989

12. Peroxide

13. DevilsRollTheDice

14. NEX

15. Live To Tell

16. Teen Spirit

17. sanzo

18. MidnightsAtPeace

19. Avrileon

20. CamiloPg_

21. 4Real

22. KillingYourCareer

23. a_d_22

24. Namigo

25. llikeh

26. 305

27. Arrows

28. skizzo

29. Soobin

30. Tusk

31. Riverbank

32. theluckyone

33. LastKiss

34. itsjem

35. Hurem

36. Life Savers

37. folkloreking

38. gagacasanova

39. Vespertine

40. freakum.

41. chosensparkles

42. reputation1989

43. D-@-N

44. badidearight

45. Velvet Night

46. Enrique523

47. Mr. Duff

48. AshleyLovescats887

49. ChapelHooker

50. Gorjesspazze9

51. halcyonday

52. iamanearthling

53. AbeHicks

54. Axolotl

55. jacobhalkohit

56. PerfectSacrifice

57. Frankvert

58. Venice B

59. vinicius

60. Fitzswiftie

61. Yog

62. Ampersand13

63. Feanor

64. wastedpotential

65. Prismee

66. idkwiam

67. Schami66

68. Støned

69. G.U.Y_Del_Rey

70. djcalpal

71. Great Username

72. Tedwards

73. tjspy

74. Mezik

75. LVP

76. Miles.

77. NextBish90

78. liam13

79. SLUTTVFTV

80. Sad Beautiful Tragic

81. Losing my ground

82. GuyNextDoor

83. ??????

84. burninredhot

85. americanlife

86. Supernatural

87. Terylee

88. Mocha

89. Modern thing

90. TaylenaStan

91. Nein

92. Ger.vaz

93. fridayteenage

94. ONOPKA

95. makeawish

96. Holy Ground

97. LovaticSwiftie

98. RihannaLoverrr

99. Dear Reader

100. roso

101. Catch22

102. holyground13

103. creativity.

104. Strawberry Bubble

105. brokee

106. paulyyozd

107. ellis-bell

108. BOAZ

109. TheArgonaut

110. FolkLover1989

111. Klein

112. MusicLoverDude

113. Clauss

114. Hooker Barbie

115. twoheadlightshine

116. Bussea

117. Quicksand

118. kyungsoowift

119. Flames2Embers

120. Swirl900

121. beagle

122. Flower

123. byzantium

124. fab

125. Hendelzeit

126. Safe&Sound

127. SleepingTigers

128. Diarrhoea

129. My Tears Ricochet

130. Kyle-x

131. jacklovesyou1

132. PoisonedIvy

133. yourfaveisaflop

134. Where are you now?

135. sparrowblue

136. enchanted0

137. greeneyedsoul

[wastedpotential]

11 minutes ago, Achilles. said:

All of The Girls might be top 10 on Loser. I'm not sure. But even if it is, it's not like that's much to write home about. I mean we're talking about a top 10 that includes It's Nice To Have A Friend. Loser top 10 is not a high bar to cross, there's room for everybody (except for Drake and Stella McCartney) let's just say that. 
 

I don't agree with you, but I respect your opinion 

 

8 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

Oh, it is. Better than DBATC, Daylight, The Archer, Lover, and most of the album actually!

 

I do not respect this opinion