Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 I may have to adjust my score for Florida after hearing it just now
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 1 minute ago, Klein said: I leave for a couple hours and I come back to people trashing the Red and Speak Now vault, and being Fearless vault apologists? Just go ahead and delete your ballots for this rate, for god's sake, we can't trust anyone. Literally the best vaults 2
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 2 hours ago, PoisonedIvy said: Did anyone else give "That's When" a 0? It is literally one of the worst songs in her catalogue to me It's nice having a definitive ranking/scoresheet of her songs & albums (even though it would literally change next month if I were to re-do this) Absolutely not. The only Fearless vault that deserves a score that low is We Were Floppy 2
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 Ballots Received (103): Spoiler 1. terrorblade 2. tb6591 3. SlyMacPer 4. PaloSanto 5. greento 6. NordicGuy 7. Forever Winter 8. The Music Industry 9. Solaria 10. pinkbowvintage 11. 1989 12. Peroxide 13. DevilsRollTheDice 14. NEX 15. Live To Tell 16. Teen Spirit 17. sanzo 18. MidnightsAtPeace 19. Avrileon 20. CamiloPg_ 21. 4Real 22. KillingYourCareer 23. a_d_22 24. Namigo 25. llikeh 26. 305 27. Arrows 28. skizzo 29. Soobin 30. Tusk 31. Riverbank 32. theluckyone 33. LastKiss 34. itsjem 35. Hurem 36. Life Savers 37. folkloreking 38. gagacasanova 39. Vespertine 40. freakum. 41. chosensparkles 42. reputation1989 43. D-@-N 44. badidearight 45. Velvet Night 46. Enrique523 47. Mr. Duff 48. AshleyLovescats887 49. ChapelHooker 50. Gorjesspazze9 51. halcyonday 52. iamanearthling 53. AbeHicks 54. Axolotl 55. jacobhalkohit 56. PerfectSacrifice 57. Frankvert 58. Venice B 59. vinicius 60. Fitzswiftie 61. Yog 62. Ampersand13 63. Feanor 64. wastedpotential 65. Prismee 66. idkwiam 67. Schami66 68. Støned 69. G.U.Y_Del_Rey 70. djcalpal 71. Great Username 72. Tedwards 73. tjspy 74. Mezik 75. LVP 76. Miles. 77. NextBish90 78. liam13 79. SLUTTVFTV 80. Sad Beautiful Tragic 81. Losing my ground 82. GuyNextDoor 83. ?????? 84. burninredhot 85. americanlife 86. Supernatural 87. Terylee 88. Mocha 89. Modern thing 90. TaylenaStan 91. Nein 92. Ger.vaz 93. fridayteenage 94. ONOPKA 95. makeawish 96. Holy Ground 97. LovaticSwiftie 98. RihannaLoverrr 99. Dear Reader 100. roso 101. Catch22 102. holyground13 103. creativity.
PoisonedIvy Posted August 27 Posted August 27 1 minute ago, Forever Winter said: Ballots Received (101): Reveal hidden contents 1. terrorblade 2. tb6591 3. SlyMacPer 4. PaloSanto 5. greento 6. NordicGuy 7. Forever Winter 8. The Music Industry 9. Solaria 10. pinkbowvintage 11. 1989 12. Peroxide 13. DevilsRollTheDice 14. NEX 15. Live To Tell 16. Teen Spirit 17. sanzo 18. MidnightsAtPeace 19. Avrileon 20. CamiloPg_ 21. 4Real 22. KillingYourCareer 23. a_d_22 24. Namigo 25. llikeh 26. 305 27. Arrows 28. skizzo 29. Soobin 30. Tusk 31. Riverbank 32. theluckyone 33. LastKiss 34. itsjem 35. Hurem 36. Life Savers 37. folkloreking 38. gagacasanova 39. Vespertine 40. freakum. 41. chosensparkles 42. reputation1989 43. D-@-N 44. badidearight 45. Velvet Night 46. Enrique523 47. Mr. Duff 48. AshleyLovescats887 49. ChapelHooker 50. Gorjesspazze9 51. halcyonday 52. iamanearthling 53. AbeHicks 54. Axolotl 55. jacobhalkohit 56. PerfectSacrifice 57. Frankvert 58. Venice B 59. vinicius 60. Fitzswiftie 61. Yog 62. Ampersand13 63. Feanor 64. wastedpotential 65. Prismee 66. idkwiam 67. Schami66 68. Støned 69. G.U.Y_Del_Rey 70. djcalpal 71. Great Username 72. Tedwards 73. tjspy 74. Mezik 75. LVP 76. Miles. 77. NextBish90 78. liam13 79. SLUTTVFTV 80. Sad Beautiful Tragic 81. Losing my ground 82. GuyNextDoor 83. ?????? 84. burninredhot 85. americanlife 86. Supernatural 87. Terylee 88. Mocha 89. Modern thing 90. TaylenaStan 91. Nein 92. Ger.vaz 93. fridayteenage 94. ONOPKA 95. makeawish 96. Holy Ground 97. LovaticSwiftie 98. RihannaLoverrr 99. Dear Reader 100. roso 101. Catch22 I need 11 more people to submit so I can submit as ballot #113, the most important of all 4
Klein Posted August 27 Posted August 27 1 minute ago, PoisonedIvy said: I need 11 more people to submit so I can submit as ballot #113, the most important of all I want to be #143 for the lore 5
PoisonedIvy Posted August 27 Posted August 27 4 minutes ago, Klein said: I want to be #143 for the lore I have a feeling you'd be waiting lifetimes 3
TaylenaStan Posted August 27 Posted August 27 This underrated Red Vault classic Oh sacRED melodies will always be famous 3
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 6 minutes ago, Klein said: I want to be #143 for the lore 2 minutes ago, PoisonedIvy said: I have a feeling you'd be waiting lifetimes Is this foreshadowing a future Katy rate hosted by one of you two?
TaylenaStan Posted August 27 Posted August 27 (edited) One of her MOST underrated tracks EVER i feel like i never see anyone talking about it and i fear it will end up at #130 or whatever Spoiler hopefully this promo can help it move up a spot or two Edited August 27 by TaylenaStan 1 1
PoisonedIvy Posted August 27 Posted August 27 12 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Is this foreshadowing a future Katy rate hosted by one of you two? You couldn't pay me to do this
PoisonedIvy Posted August 27 Posted August 27 19 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Not you being ended @PoisonedIvy They persecuted Jesus too 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 Updated averages (without 11s or 0s): Taylor Swift - 7.242 Fearless (OG) - 8.607 Fearless (TV) - 7.764 Speak Now - 8.470 Speak Now (TV) - 8.408 Red (OG) - 7.562 Red (TV) - 7.535 1989 (OG) - 8.531 1989 (TV) - 7.895 reputation - 6.633 Lover - 5.668 folklore - 9.158 evermore - 9.056 Midnights - 6.790 THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT - 6.796
PoisonedIvy Posted August 27 Posted August 27 4 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Updated averages (without 11s or 0s): Taylor Swift - 7.242 Fearless (OG) - 8.607 Fearless (TV) - 7.764 Speak Now - 8.470 Speak Now (TV) - 8.408 Red (OG) - 7.562 Red (TV) - 7.535 1989 (OG) - 8.531 1989 (TV) - 7.895 reputation - 6.633 Lover - 5.668 folklore - 9.158 evermore - 9.056 Midnights - 6.790 THE TORTURED POETS DEPARTMENT - 6.796 Lover you will ALWAYS be Taylor's worst album! 1
PoisonedIvy Posted August 27 Posted August 27 Let me tank folklore a bit so evermore can rightfully take its place at the pinnacle of her catalogue 2
Miles. Posted August 27 Posted August 27 8 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Updated averages (without 11s or 0s): Fearless (OG) - 8.607 Fearless (TV) - 7.764 1989 (OG) - 8.531 1989 (TV) - 7.895 Lover - 5.668 The way those vault flops DRAGGED the TVs down Oh We Were Flopping, Bore Bore Baby, You (Came) All Over Me and Sloot, don't make that face! Kept Loser's score in too just for extra lols 1 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 @holyground13 Received your ballot. Thanks Spoiler Ik we DM'd but I'm documenting it here too
Miles. Posted August 27 Posted August 27 Anyway, the OBJECTIVE Vault ranking is: Red = Speak Now >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 19Antonoff9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Fear(This Vault) Funny how Red's Vault contains a career highlight magnum opus (Forever Winter), proof that she could go back and dominate country music if she wanted (Babe, Better Man, IBYTAM), and two pop SMASHES that fit better on an AOTY than anything from the actual 1989 Vault (MIAB, TVFN). If only she'd deleted Run (Far Away From This Song). Meanwhile Speak Now's Vault is just perfection all the way through. Six iconic masterpieces 1
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 7 minutes ago, Miles. said: The way those vault flops DRAGGED the TVs down Oh We Were Flopping, Bore Bore Baby, You (Came) All Over Me and Sloot, don't make that face! Kept Loser's score in too just for extra lols Red's vaults are so good but it has some duds. Message in a Butthole really f*cks brings the average down. And I don't know what she was thinking with these Fearless vaults cause chile
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 1 minute ago, Miles. said: Anyway, the OBJECTIVE Vault ranking is: Red = Speak Now >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 19Antonoff9 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Fear(This Vault) Funny how Red's Vault contains a career highlight magnum opus (Forever Winter), proof that she could go back and dominate country music if she wanted (Babe, Better Man, IBYTAM), and two pop SMASHES that fit better on an AOTY than anything from the actual 1989 Vault (MIAB, TVFN). If only she'd deleted Run (Far Away From This Song). Meanwhile Speak Now's Vault is just perfection all the way through. Six iconic masterpieces Oh I spoke too soon. Not you stanning the butthole song
Miles. Posted August 27 Posted August 27 2 minutes ago, Forever Winter said: Oh I spoke too soon. Not you stanning the butthole song Pop Vault Songs: I Can See God = Message From Heaven = The Very First Hymn >>>> Say Don't Go > Is It Over Now >>>>>>>>> zzzburban Legends >>>>>>>> Now That Me & Jack Don't Write Hits Anymore >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Sl0t 2
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 1 minute ago, Miles. said: Pop Vault Songs: I Can See God = Message From Heaven = The Very First Hymn >>>> Say Don't Go > Is It Over Now >>>>>>>>> zzzburban Legends >>>>>>>> Now That Me & Jack Don't Write Hits Anymore >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Sl0t Not the Slvt! hate. Jail
Brooklyn Baby Posted August 27 Author Posted August 27 1 minute ago, creativity. said: submitted @Forever Winter TTPD got 4 of my zeroes Received! Omg I CACKLED at your 0s screaming
Recommended Posts