rate The Taylor Swift Discography Rate 2024 | WINNER REVEALED! | Results on First Page

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

 

64. marjorie

7.920

 

Saviours (11s): Avrileon, PerfectSacrifice, modern thing, Lazuli

Stans (10s): Achilles., PaloSanto, NordicGuy, pinkbowvintage, 1989, Peroxide, MidnightsAtPeace, 305, Arrows, Tusk, folkloreking, reputation1989, AbeHicks, jacobhalkohit, Fitzswiftie, Feanor, wastedpotential, Prismee, Mezik, GuyNextDoor, Supernatural, RihannaLover, holyground13, Strawberry Bubble, Hooker Barbie, Heldenzeit, Where are you now, greeneyedsoul, Taylor fanboy, K$Ellie, SoSickOfThatSOL, Bosque, StonedSoulPicnic, heckinglovato

Admirers (9s): Soobin, Forever Winter, Lorenzo22, idkwiam, Ger.vaz, Top Dash, LastKiss, TheArgonaut, Michael196, roso, Cruel Summer, Live To Tell, skizzo, Life Savers, chosensparkles, Enrique523, AshleyLovescats887, Uncatena, iamanearthling, Axolotl, vinicius, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, tjspy, Sad Beautiful Tragic, burninredhot, Holy Ground, paulyyyozd, FolkLover1989, Diarrhoea, Bartender, Blood Magic

Haters (1s): KillingYourCareer, Terylee, LovaticSwiftie, Sanguine

Saboteurs (0s): None

 

Comments

Achilles.

10 - "People whose lives were not destroyed by their grief for losing a grandparent will never understand."

1989

10 - "Seeing this live was an experience. I love that this song is getting so much love now."

reputation1989

10 - "I'm so so glad this made the eras tour setlist."

RihannaLoverrr

10 - "Hits very different now I lost my nana. Was not able to listen to it for a long time."

Where are you now?

10 - "Grand, regal, chilling, incredibly touching. I don't think I've ever skipped this song. Top 10 bridge in her discography? Her grandmother's vocals weaved in was such a beautiful touch."

Forever Winter

9.5 - "Can't not think of my grandmother who passed in 2017 when I hear this. A tearjerker."

wastedpotential

10 - "This song really makes me miss my grandmothers. I'm so glad Lord performs this at every Eras show because I love hearing it every time I watch a livestream. If you can, hug your grandmother for me."

gagacasanova

8 - "As a person with dead grandmother syndrome, this hits hard."

SLUTTVFTV

8 - "Almost didn't rate this, but the bridge is very nice, can't wait to see it on tour."

Edge of Glory

7 - "My grandma died last year and this has grown on me since."

LoveInStereo

7 - "'Never be so kind you forget to be clever, never be so clever you forget to be kind' is 1 of the many amazing lyrics on here, the music mostly bores me, though. Aaron's overrated. There are exceptions but in general, her Jack stuff is better)."

blown away

4.7 - "The song feels a bit lifeless to be honest. It sounds like Taylor on autopilot."

 

 Reveal, Part 5 Results (So Far)

Spoiler

90. Dress - 7.588

89. I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) - 7.595

88. Afterglow - 7.603

87. This Love - 7.623

86. Teardrops on My Guitar - 7.624

85. I Can See You - 7.632

84. False God - 7.640

83. invisible string - 7.666

82. Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) - 7.673

81. So High School - 7.691

80. But Daddy I Love Him - 7.722

79. The Black Dog - 7.753

78. Forever Winter - 7.790

77. Forever & Always - 7.798

76. Look What You Made Me Do - 7.801

75. Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince - 7.8021

74. loml - 7.8025

73. I Knew You Were Trouble - 7.803

72. the lakes - 7.804

71. All You Had to Do Was Stay - 7.809

70. Lavender Haze - 7.846

69. The Great War - 7.853

68. Hits Different - 7.854

67. Better Than Revenge - 7.883

66. Lover - 7.898

65. The Prophecy - 7.906

64. marjorie - 7.920

 

[Klein]

4 minutes ago, By the Water said:

The Prophecy and The Great War below all of the OOTW sisters... This is the price to pay for Lord's 2024 popularity

 

Yeah let's just collectively agree that the next discography rate cannot happen before she's not the #1 artist in the world by a large margin anymore because between the locals, the success stans and the haters, this rate just makes no sense. 

Edited September 6 by Klein

[1989]

Marjorie 

[wastedpotential]

1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

I fear only a small percentage of the participants were non-Swifties. Most of us are Swifties but a huge chunk don't like TTPD.

 

I'm sorry we should expel Swifties who don't at least PRETEND to like TTPD 

 

 

Y'all are NOT welcome, and I will make that clear again and again going forward!

 

Lessons learned!

 

[Peroxide]

Right girls. We need to make a pack - the next rate, we need to give all our 11's to GAS and have it WIN-THE-RATE.

 

We will not forget this massacre…

 

 

[Taylor fanboy]

66. Lover

7.898

 

Saviours (11s): Rev8
 

OH @Rev8 you

 

 

 

[Bussea]

21 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

 

 

66. Lover

7.898

 

Saviours (11s): Edge of Glory, Rev8, Bussea, 305, DevilsRollTheDice

Stans (10s): Avrileon, Hurem, gagacasanova, freakum., reputation1989, halcyonday, Namigo, iamanearthling, AbeHicks, vinicius, Støned, NextBish90, GuyNextDoor, Nein, fridayteenage, ONOPKA, Holy Ground, Catch22, BOAZ, FolkLover1989, Hooker Barbie, Quicksand, fab, Kyle-x, jacklovesyou1, Where are you now?, greeneyedsoul, blown away, Bartender, SoSickOfThatSOL, By the Water, LoveInStereo, heckinglovato

Admirers (9s): wehavetostan, Lorenzo22, wastedpotential, Michael196, Bindi, PaloSanto, Theluckyone, G.U.Y_Del_Rey, SLUTTVFTV, djcalpal, TheArgonaut, Ms. Togekiss, MidnightsAtPeace, PoisonedIvy, tb6591, greento, NEX, Live To Tell, sanzo, CamiloPg_, itsjem, Enrique523, Uncatena, PerfectSacrifice, Venice B, Feanor, Mezik, burninredhot, Supernatural, modern thing, Kyungsoowift, yourfaveisaflop, chiliam, Blood Magic, TMRA

Haters (1s): 1989, Prismee

Saboteurs (0s): Tusk, Cruel Summer

Comments

Bussea

11 - "And Shawn's version isn't bad either??? It's a 8 with him but this is probably my fav Taylor song I wanna get married to it. 😭"

Edge of Glory

11 - "I need to walk down the aisle to this...i also need a man. :sadchick:"

reputation1989

10 - "Thanks for the horrible reminder that titanic version exists, the original remains a classic though."

By the Water

10 - "I knew from the moment I first heard this song that it would be a classic. Talent always wins!"

AbeHicks

10 - "Using a fake ID in 2019 to see a DJ set centered around LOVER is still the best decision I've ever made. LOVER is forever!"

Where are you now?

10 - "I shouldn't have just read the words Shawn Mendes. And there's a dazzling haze, a mysterious way about you dear. Other pop girls WISH they knew how to write."

blown away

10 - "The lyrics are beautiful."

Lorenzo22

9.9 - "Kinda a 10 but i was not bumping loser's overall score."

wastedpotential

9.6 - "To start off, Titanic does not exist. Moving on, I love the way this is produced, it really is quite timeless, and I love the verses (even the January lyric that gets her flack) and the bridge. However. I HATE elements of the chorus here. "Can I go where you go"... yada yada is pleasant enough stock-standard guitar love ballad but that "you're my-my-my-my Lover" is absolutely nails on a chalkboard for me. It's the way that this would've been a stone cold smash hit with a changed later chorus lol. I mean, it's enduringly popular on Spotify, and definitely challenges 22 for "single with the lowest peak and weakest initial reception to have the strongest legacy", so clearly I'm in the minority re that hook, but it shouldn't be a surprise to anyone that this failed on the radio."

SLUTTVFTV

9.5 - "The Shawn Mendes version does not exist, I am in denial of that."

kyungsoowift

9 - "For the love of god please count this as solo, the remix is atrocious I'm sorry."

Starchild

8 - "This is a very confusing score combination as Shawn adds negative 5 points to a 8/10 song so I will ignore Shawn in this score."

Klein

8 - "Lovely song. The Titanic remix however. Whew. Could make me become an OTH."

Miles.

8 - "I'd go down with the Titanic, it's true, for youuu."

holyground13

6.9 - "It was really pretty on the Eras Tour and seemed God sent at the time since it was a vast improvement on Me! and You Need To Calm Down. Overall I find it to be too wedding-adjacent for me to enjoy it all the time."

Achilles.

6 - "It was hilarious how desperately she pushed this in a transparent bid to finally win Song of the Year, made all the funnier by the fact that it wasn't ranked amongst her top 75 back then and isn't top 100 now."

NewStanner

5 - "Overrated."

1989

1 - "That remix with Shawn had us in the trenches. The song isn't good on its own either, sorry."

 

Reveal, Part 5 Results (So Far)

  Reveal hidden contents

90. Dress - 7.588

89. I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) - 7.595

88. Afterglow - 7.603

87. This Love - 7.623

86. Teardrops on My Guitar - 7.624

85. I Can See You - 7.632

84. False God - 7.640

83. invisible string - 7.666

82. Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) - 7.673

81. So High School - 7.691

80. But Daddy I Love Him - 7.722

79. The Black Dog - 7.753

78. Forever Winter - 7.790

77. Forever & Always - 7.798

76. Look What You Made Me Do - 7.801

75. Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince - 7.8021

74. loml - 7.8025

73. I Knew You Were Trouble - 7.803

72. the lakes - 7.804

71. All You Had to Do Was Stay - 7.809

70. Lavender Haze - 7.846

69. The Great War - 7.853

68. Hits Different - 7.854

67. Better Than Revenge - 7.883

66. Lover - 7.898

 

GIRL GET THE **** ON THIS WAS MY ******* 11 I HATE YOU ******* ARE YOU DUCKING KIDDING MY ******* GOD @1989 YOU SWEATY GREASY PIT STAINED UNIFORM HAVING LITTLE GAY BOY WHEN I CATCH YOU AT YOUR MF JOB IM ASKING FOR EXTRA FRESH FRIES SO THEYRE PIPING HOT WHEN I GET THEM AND THROWING IT IN YOUR MF FACE ALONG WITH THE BIG MAC

 

FAT @1989 I HATE YOU FAT 1989. I HATE YOU B*TCH!

[AdrianNicki]

I wanted Evermore to take a hit for a long time but Marjorie is actually one of the few songs I like from that album. What is wrong with you?

Edited September 6 by AdrianNicki

[RihannaLoverrr]

Marjorie now too?

[By the Water]

Forget puta stans. TTPD haters are my new enemy. I hope TS12 is a synth-pop Hack album so maybe we'll get rid of them for good 

[1989]

The Prophecy and Marjorie back to back HURT 

 

[Catch22]

marjorie is top 3 on evermore, it doesn't deserve to be below tis the damn season/ivy/cowboy like me/evermore

 

[Bussea]

@wastedpotential @Forever Winter????? MODS???? SOMEONE ******* DO SOMETHING 

[Where are you now?]

1 song left from TTPD...swear to god you all are so fake with your TTPD hate. 

[Brooklyn Baby]

I'm checking scores right now for TTPD and a lot of the mid to low scores after coming from Swifties themselves.

 

Even OTH Solaria gave higher scores than a lot of y'all 

[4Real]

i'm actually happy TTPD is getting the fate it deserves. The people spoke!

[Bussea]

YALL BETTER BE ******* GLAD THIS SERVER IS SLOWER THAN SOME OF YOUR TASTES BC I WAS ABOUT TO BLOW THIS SERVER TFFF UP IM LAUNCHING A CITIZENS ARRESTS THIS RATE WILL NOT CONTINUE ANNOUNCE ANOTHER SONG AND YOU WILL BE IN JAIL ***** YOURE GOING TO JAIL PERIODDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

[Taylor fanboy]

Just now, Forever Winter said:

I'm checking scores right now for TTPD and a lot of the mid to low scores after coming from Swifties themselves.

 

Even OTH Solaria gave higher scores than a lot of y'all 

[wastedpotential]

1 minute ago, Forever Winter said:

I'm checking scores right now for TTPD and a lot of the mid to low scores after coming from Swifties themselves.

 

Even OTH Solaria gave higher scores than a lot of y'all 

Dear God 

 

I'm too busy mourning The Prophecy to even ponder Marjorie but this is the WORST timeline

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

But we're nearing the 8 averages, and The Prophecy is still pretty high 7.906, even though it should be a 10.

 

 

I guess a lot of Swifties just like the other albums more

 

[Edge Of Glory]

the sheer amount of divas that have been sacrificed simply so random folkmore khias can make top 50…no shade but yall kinda need to die

 

[Brooklyn Baby]

 

63. Last Kiss

7.930

 

Saviours (11s): greento, LastKiss, 4Real, Nein, LovaticSwiftie, Safe&Sound, sparrowblue

Stans (10s): chosensparkles, The Music Industry, Forever Winter, pinkbowvintage, NEX, DevilsRollTheDice, PaloSanto, 1989, Arrows, sanzo, Theluckyone, itsjem, folkloreking, freakum., reputation1989, D-@-N, AshleyLovescats887, halcyonday, iamanearthling, Ampersand13, wastedpotential, Prismee, Great Username, GuyNextDoor, fridayteenage, Holy Ground, Dear Reader, roso, Strawberry Bubble, ellis-bell, Klein, Clauss, Quicksand, Kyle-x, PoisonedIvy, enchanted0, chiliam, greeneyedsoul, Lazuli, Taylor fanboy, Bartender, Don, K$Ellie, TMRA, Cruel Summer, StonedSoulPicnic, Achilles., wehavetostan

Admirers (9s): byzantium, twoheadlightshine, My Tears Ricochet, SleepingTigers, LoveInStereo, americanlife, burninredhot, Losing my ground, liam13, Feanor, Enrique523, Feanor, Vespertine, Live To Tell, Lorenzo22, FolkLover1989, Peroxide, Diarrhoea, Tedwards, idkwiam, MidnightsAtPeace

Haters (1s): KillingYourCareer, SoSickOfThatSOL

Saboteurs (0s): AdrianNicki

 

Comments

Nein

11 - "Oh the bridge will forever haunt me even when I'm dead."

greento

11 - "I always say this is my favourite song by her, but it changes between this and Treacherous all the time. The bridge is immaculate and heart wrenching. I also love the subtle production changes made with the TV."

sparrowblue

11 - "But wow what a moment. Superior to ALL of the Track 5s."

The Music Industry

10 - "Almost gave this one of my 11s. This is Taylor's saddest pre-folklore song, and you can't convince me otherwise. While the TV is great, nothing beats the original version. It's such a gem, so raw and emotional. It's one of those songs that stays with you, especially when you've gone through something similar. To this day, "All that I know is I don't know how to be something you miss" is still one of my favorite lyrics from Taylor. :heart:"

Ampersand13

10 - "I wish I could have given this an 11 because I genuinely think it's one of Taylor's best songs and a defining example of her distinct artistic sensibilities. I recoginize on its face, this song is deceptively easy to write off as just another breakup song, but to me it's so much more than that. Taylor is in no rush to get through the story allowing the instrumentation the perfect amount of time to let her breathe and engross the audience further into her vulnerability. Sometime I feel as though it's difficult to justify longer songs because they inherently beg the question "do these feelings necessitate so much exploration and time?" Last Kiss effortlessly answers such inquiries with "They absolutely do.""

wehavetostan

10 - "A slow burner, such a masterpiece."

Forever Winter

10 - "Contender for one of her saddest songs ever."

pinkbowvintage

10 - "Truly one of the saddest songs I've ever heard."

1989

10 - "One of THE best ballads of her career, which is saying something."

Achilles.

10 - "In my heart Taylor Swift will always be the girl in the ponytail and purple dress singing the greatest song of all time while strumming a koi fish guitar underneath a lit up tree. This song IS Taylor Swift."

wastedpotential

10 - "Okay, FINE Lord, you can make me sympathize for Joe Jonas, just a little bit. I think where this song succeeds the most is in spelling out the smallest and most mundane lyrical details "the look on your face/1:58/The smell of the rain/July 9th/etc", and that really humanizes him in a way that nothing has ever done. I've had more than my fair share of drunken candle-lit bath-tub breakdowns post-breakup to this song, because even in its intricacies and specificities, it's quite easy to apply to your own life and memories. I have a few people in mind every time I listen to this song, and this song maybe more than any other from this time period evokes the strongest emotions in me. I've been trying to train myself out of it, because whew I do not need to be thinking about my... 2017 who're era philanderizations. Those men are happy and healthy and so am I and I no longer have to associate them with this song <3. Please everyone, at least pretend to buy into my delulu here, I'm hoping to finally move on. The breathy vocals and the sad and strummy guitar chords are lab-designed to yank at the heartstrings like I want to yank on Bob Lefsetz's few remaining strands of natural hair. Even without the sigh, "you can plan for a change in weather or time, but I never planned on you changing your mind" *sad chord* *little base descending thing* is still just so sad to me. Joe Jonas will rot in hell and I will no longer think about anyone when I hear this song, right?"

AshleyLovescats887

10 - "one of Taylor's best songs"

Where are you now?

6.1 - "Admire the somber mood & the skillful songwriting, but the sleepy melodies don't do it for me! Really picks up on the bridge though."

kyungsoowift

6 - "Idk if I sound weird, but on YouTube I listen to this on 1.25x and makes my life more compact, maybe it's a sign of ADHD idk."

Bussea

6 - "It's cute but goes nowhere. Sounds like a bunch of words after a while."

blown away

6 - "It's good. Nothing more, nothing less."

Rev8

4 - "Giving this song a bit of a lower number..but it really makes me glad that Taylor grew melodically since her songs really hit hard with lyrics like these. Kind of wish she remade some songs. New melodies, same lyrics."

 

Reveal, Part 5 Results (So Far)

Spoiler

90. Dress - 7.588

89. I Bet You Think About Me (feat. Chris Stapleton) - 7.595

88. Afterglow - 7.603

87. This Love - 7.623

86. Teardrops on My Guitar - 7.624

85. I Can See You - 7.632

84. False God - 7.640

83. invisible string - 7.666

82. Nothing New (feat. Phoebe Bridgers) - 7.673

81. So High School - 7.691

80. But Daddy I Love Him - 7.722

79. The Black Dog - 7.753

78. Forever Winter - 7.790

77. Forever & Always - 7.798

76. Look What You Made Me Do - 7.801

75. Miss Americana & The Heartbreak Prince - 7.8021

74. loml - 7.8025

73. I Knew You Were Trouble - 7.803

72. the lakes - 7.804

71. All You Had to Do Was Stay - 7.809

70. Lavender Haze - 7.846

69. The Great War - 7.853

68. Hits Different - 7.854

67. Better Than Revenge - 7.883

66. Lover - 7.898

65. The Prophecy - 7.906

64. marjorie - 7.920

63. Last Kiss - 7.930

 

[TaylenaStan]

4 minutes ago, Forever Winter said:

I'm checking scores right now for TTPD and a lot of the mid to low scores after coming from Swifties themselves.

 

Even OTH Solaria gave higher scores than a lot of y'all 

Like she has 11 studio albums, TTPD is like 8th or 9th best for ME!. how is that so hard to comprehend that not everyone thinks every new Taylor album is instantly the best 
And im not even one of those pop stans, folkmore are both in my top 5

Edited September 6 by TaylenaStan

[Don]

8 minutes ago, AdrianNicki said:

I wanted Evermore to take a hit for a long time but Marjorie is actually one of the few songs I like from that album. What is wrong with you?

What's wrong with YOU!!

[wastedpotential]

1 minute ago, Bussea said:

YALL BETTER BE ******* GLAD THIS SERVER IS SLOWER THAN SOME OF YOUR TASTES BC I WAS ABOUT TO BLOW THIS SERVER TFFF UP IM LAUNCHING A CITIZENS ARRESTS THIS RATE WILL NOT CONTINUE ANNOUNCE ANOTHER SONG AND YOU WILL BE IN JAIL ***** YOURE GOING TO JAIL PERIODDDDDDDDDDDDDDD

I've got extra weapons if you want to perform some extrajudicial... terminations of tasteless losers with me 

 

Spoiler

The way I've been jumping between homicidal and suicidal thoughts all day should be studied in a Psychology journal