stevyy Posted July 14 Posted July 14 3 minutes ago, Charmed Life said: I doubt that very much. Isn't it evident that Madonna influenced performers and Mariah influenced singers? I would never discredit anyone of them. Both are influental. (and the new gen has nothing on them....) Beyoncé is a great performer and good singer... she may be their daughter. Taylor cannot sing nor dance and her success goes over my head tbh. (she's a good songwriter, is what people are saying - allegedly). Gaga is a great performer and a good singer... she may be their daughter. (However, her venture into film is more like Streisand or Whitney). Adele is a good singer, but cannot dance at all. (but her personality is so amazing, i love her). Alicia = good singer, doesn't dance. Kelly C = good singer, doesn't dance. Dua Lipa = mediocre singer, cannot dance, but tries. Rihanna = mediocre singer, OK-ish dancer I guess. Madonna comes from dancing, Mariah came from the the recording booth... Céline and Whitney - also masterfully influental legends, didn't write their music.... but also influenced everyone under the sun. 2 1 3
HardBambi Posted July 15 Author Posted July 15 (edited) Just to clarify, I was right, Madonna is outstreaming Mariah Madonna's top 5 latest update: 01 (=): Popular - 851,734,449 (+1,198,379) 02 (=): La Isla Bonita² - 405,252,297 (+409,402) 03 (=): Material Girl³ - 515,303,472 (+322,738) 04 (=): Like a Prayer³ - 467,319,027 (+314,352) 05 (=): Hung Up² - 472,560,454 (+291,543) Mariah's top 5 latest update: 01 - 406,494,882 - +359,520 - 2009 - Obsessed 02 - 623,353,021 - +314,568 - 2005 - We Belong Together 03 - 413,872,378 - +272,594 - 1995 - Fantasy 04 - 379,081,758 - +213,064 - 2003 - I Know what you Want 05 - 392,054,641 - +192,115 - 1996 - Always be my Baby Edited July 15 by HardBambi 1
John Slayne Posted July 15 Posted July 15 On 7/14/2024 at 12:07 AM, suburbannature said: Ok, so then we won't be removing AIWFCIY anymore looking at yearly totals. not really interested in this stale beef about Madonna/Mariah streams but literally when have lambs ever removed AIWFCIY stats from any discussion? 1
Lover Posted July 16 Posted July 16 16 hours ago, HardBambi said: Just to clarify, I was right, Madonna is outstreaming Mariah Madonna's top 5 latest update: 01 (=): Popular - 851,734,449 (+1,198,379) 02 (=): La Isla Bonita² - 405,252,297 (+409,402) 03 (=): Material Girl³ - 515,303,472 (+322,738) 04 (=): Like a Prayer³ - 467,319,027 (+314,352) 05 (=): Hung Up² - 472,560,454 (+291,543) Mariah's top 5 latest update: 01 - 406,494,882 - +359,520 - 2009 - Obsessed 02 - 623,353,021 - +314,568 - 2005 - We Belong Together 03 - 413,872,378 - +272,594 - 1995 - Fantasy 04 - 379,081,758 - +213,064 - 2003 - I Know what you Want 05 - 392,054,641 - +192,115 - 1996 - Always be my Baby
stevyy Posted July 16 Posted July 16 14 hours ago, John Slayne said: not really interested in this stale beef about Madonna/Mariah streams but literally when have lambs ever removed AIWFCIY stats from any discussion? u must be forgetful. every single time. Also: I'm just glad that Madonna finally has her biggest song doing big numbers. Who would have thought that Popular would eclipse her 80s, 90s and 00s like that. 1
stevyy Posted July 16 Posted July 16 July 14th: songs above 1 million daily: 1 - Madonna 0 - Mariah songs above 300k daily: 2 - Madonna 1 - Mariah songs above 200k daily: 5 - Madonna 3 - Mariah songs above 100k daily: 8 - Madonna 6 - Mariah songs above 90k daily: 8 - Mariah 8 - Madonna songs above 80k daily: 9 - Mariah 8 - Madonna songs above 70k daily: 11 - Mariah 9 - Madonna songs above 60k daily: 13 - Madonna 12 - Mariah songs above 50k daily: 14 - Mariah 13 - Madonna songs above 40k daily 17 - Mariah 14 - Madonna song above 30k daily 20 - Mariah 18 - Madonna **July 14th was a Sunday. 1 1
HardBambi Posted July 16 Author Posted July 16 2 hours ago, stevyy said: July 14th: songs above 1 million daily: 1 - Madonna 0 - Mariah songs above 300k daily: 2 - Madonna 1 - Mariah songs above 200k daily: 5 - Madonna 3 - Mariah songs above 100k daily: 8 - Madonna 6 - Mariah songs above 90k daily: 8 - Mariah 8 - Madonna songs above 80k daily: 9 - Mariah 8 - Madonna songs above 70k daily: 11 - Mariah 9 - Madonna songs above 60k daily: 13 - Madonna 12 - Mariah songs above 50k daily: 14 - Mariah 13 - Madonna songs above 40k daily 17 - Mariah 14 - Madonna song above 30k daily 20 - Mariah 18 - Madonna **July 14th was a Sunday. Loving the stats Statsvvy What a cruel Sunday for both though 😅
stevyy Posted July 16 Posted July 16 2 hours ago, Alongoria13 said: Wasn't the thread from 2023 enough This is round #3. 1 3
Chris Posted July 17 Posted July 17 On 7/15/2024 at 3:29 PM, HardBambi said: Just to clarify, I was right, Madonna is outstreaming Mariah Queen Madonna. I guess she is more relevant to the younger generation than Marissa Cary after all. 1
stevyy Posted July 17 Posted July 17 7 hours ago, Chris said: Popular may be on the verge one day to out-stream AIWFCIY. U think so? Last year it did 350 million streams. Maybe 400 million this season? I assume, it will reach 2,2 billion by January. But Popular has all the chances of outstreaming it. 1
Poncho Barlliams Posted July 18 Posted July 18 On 7/13/2024 at 8:37 PM, Popboi. said: Madonna is getting 4,751,535 daily streams, 3,358,083 as lead artist (no Popular). Mariah is getting 3,328,320, 2,894,576 as lead artist. So Popular is not the only reason (asking to remove 1 song is kinda ironic here considering this topic is threaded all the time in vice versa nearing xmas - also for 1 song). Madonna has almost 200 more songs than Mariah on Spotify generating a flow of streams that is the reason
Popboi. Posted July 18 Posted July 18 1 hour ago, Poncho Barlliams said: Madonna has almost 200 more songs than Mariah on Spotify generating a flow of streams that is the reason Yes, I'm sure Crazy - Live at the Coliseu dos Recreios, Lisbon, Portugal, 1/12-23/2020 is making a big difference 5
Prodigal Self Posted July 18 Posted July 18 On 7/17/2024 at 4:39 AM, Chris said: Popular may be on the verge one day to out-stream AIWFCIY. Good for the Weeknd. 1
QuanticXplosion Posted July 19 Posted July 19 Do Mariah stans seriously compare her to Madonna with a straight face? Like, Madonna could be getting 500l daily streams in total but she will still be bigger than Mariah because she is Madonna... Michael Jackson's only peer. 4 1
Chris Posted July 19 Posted July 19 11 minutes ago, QuanticXplosion said: Madonna... Michael Jackson's only peer. Who is Mariah's peer? JLO? 2
QuanticXplosion Posted July 19 Posted July 19 32 minutes ago, Chris said: Who is Mariah's peer? JLO? Probably Celine and that's me being nice because even Celine yanks her wig and she never touched Whitney.
stevyy Posted July 19 Posted July 19 3 hours ago, QuanticXplosion said: Probably Celine and that's me being nice because even Celine yanks her wig and she never touched Whitney. Céline debuted in 1981... even ahead of Madonna. Mariah is peerless... bc those from the 90s... (Shania, MJB) are ... way below her in terms of sales. Mariah has sold over 100 million more albums than MJB... over 120 million more than J.LO. J.LO who - btw - debuted in 1999... debuted 9 years after Mariah... that's an even longer gap than between Mariah and Madonna or Mariah and Whitney. Peerless queen Mariah. Furthermore... these super harsh words from some people who denounce her as an artist so completely like you and other people in this thread... is not very smart. 1
Gladiator Posted July 19 Posted July 19 (edited) 4 hours ago, Chris said: Who is Mariah's peer? JLO? Trans Siberian Orchestra. Edited July 19 by Gladiator 1
Mandalay Posted July 19 Posted July 19 7 hours ago, QuanticXplosion said: Do Mariah stans seriously compare her to Madonna with a straight face? Like, Madonna could be getting 500l daily streams in total but she will still be bigger than Mariah because she is Madonna... Michael Jackson's only peer. With a straight face, yes. 1
Recommended Posts