Chris Posted July 14 Posted July 14 People saying remove "The Weeknd" song. Let's remove AIWFCIY then. 3
naval23 Posted July 14 Posted July 14 Not XMas song getting more daily streams than her magnum opus "Shake It Off" ... that's a crime
Chris Posted July 14 Posted July 14 Why does Popular not count for Madonna but AIWFCIY counts for Mariah?
banterfly Posted July 14 Posted July 14 10 minutes ago, Chris said: Why does Popular not count for Madonna but AIWFCIY counts for Mariah? Maybe ask first the Madonna fans why they keep on not including AIWFCIY for years now every time this kind of thread gets brought up? 2
Chris Posted July 14 Posted July 14 6 minutes ago, banterfly said: Maybe ask first the Madonna fans why they keep on not including AIWFCIY for years now every time this kind of thread gets brought up? Who said that?
fever2288 Posted July 14 Posted July 14 Only someone on ATRL would claim that Mariah is bigger then Madona. 7 1
ChooseyLover Posted July 14 Posted July 14 2 minutes ago, fever2288 said: Only someone on ATRL would claim that Mariah is bigger then Madona. I think it's obvious Mariah's music has resonated better with younger generations. That doesn't mean she's better or bigger but that's what streaming tells us most of the time. 1
GoodGuyGoneGhetto Posted July 14 Posted July 14 Why would we remove "Popular" for Madonna when she has a whole verse on the song + sings on the chorus? Like…
stevyy Posted July 14 Posted July 14 30 minutes ago, fever2288 said: Only someone on ATRL would claim that Mariah is bigger then Madona. Who's Madona? 1
stevyy Posted July 14 Posted July 14 Top albums: (as of July 12th, 2024) 916,130,283 - Like a Virgin --------- 2,608,196,650- Merry Christmas 758,488,395 - True Blue ----------- 1,098,647,089 - Daydream 700,453,830 - COADF -------------- 992,109,122 - TEOM 596,596,021 - Like a Prayer --------- 768,626,255 - Music Box 484,745,776 - Hard Candy ---------- 587,850,694 - Memoirs 357,976,904 - Madonna -------------390,129,329 - E=MC² 316,246,005 - Ray of Light ---------- 366,189,823 - Butterfly 296,100,747 - Rebel Heart -----------342,954,250 - Rainbow 230,078,312 - Madame X ------------190,118,228 - Me. I am Mariah 217,878,387 - Music -----------------161,938,070 - Mariah Carey
Charmed Life Posted July 14 Posted July 14 Streaming numbers don't paint a true picture. Mariah's great and all, but her impact on music and breaking down barriers has never been as big as Madonna's. Her globality isn't as big either. Never was. 3
stevyy Posted July 14 Posted July 14 Mariah Carey's career streaming distribution: 5,6 billion - 1990s material (7 studio albums) 2,8 billion - 2000s material (5 studio albums) 665 million - 2010s material (3 studio albums) 400 million - 2020s material (0 studio albums) = 9,4 billion 1
Mandalay Posted July 14 Posted July 14 39 minutes ago, Charmed Life said: Streaming numbers don't paint a true picture. Mariah's great and all, but her impact on music and breaking down barriers has never been as big as Madonna's. Her globality isn't as big either. Never was. Mariah has more influence on the 'music' people make than Madonna. 2
HardBambi Posted July 14 Author Posted July 14 9 hours ago, Breathe On Moi said: one world crisis at a time please True, I opened this thread right after the Trump one got posted
NoAngelus Posted July 14 Posted July 14 madonna's daily streams this year are her lowest in 5 years, without popular her daily streams are lower than 3m on average day, last time they were below 3m on daily basis was in 2019. 1 1
Homebrand Posted July 14 Posted July 14 7 hours ago, Chris said: People saying remove "The Weeknd" song. Let's remove AIWFCIY then. Why would we remove a song that she has 100% of the credits on? 1 1
stevyy Posted July 14 Posted July 14 38 minutes ago, Charmed Life said: Streaming numbers don't paint a true picture. Mariah's great and all, but her impact on music and breaking down barriers has never been as big as Madonna's. Her globality isn't as big either. Never was. Globality clashed: (chartsmasters) 80,1m - NA - Madonna -------- 78,0m - NA - Mariah 79,3m - EU - Madonna --------31,5m - EU - Mariah 20,2m - AS - Madonna --------33,7m - AS - Mariah 12,1m - SA - Madonna ---------3,8m - SA - Mariah 5,0m - OC - Madonna ---------3,9m - OC - Mariah I'd always say that Mariah was global. 2
stevyy Posted July 14 Posted July 14 6 minutes ago, NoAngelus said: madonna's daily streams this year are her lowest in 5 years, without popular her daily streams are lower than 3m on average day, last time they were below 3m on daily basis was in 2019. Same for Mariah btw. (not the below 3m part, but the part that her current activity is way below of what she was doing at the same point last year). 1
Charmed Life Posted July 14 Posted July 14 18 minutes ago, Mandalay said: Mariah has more influence on the 'music' people make than Madonna. I doubt that very much. 1
stevyy Posted July 14 Posted July 14 3 minutes ago, Homebrand said: Why would we remove a song that she has 100% of the credits on? Furthermore... even without Xmas... it is Mariah's 11th strongest song and in comparison to Madonna's catalogue, would be in Madonna's top 10 as well... without any single Xmas stream. It's a song that is in demand all year long... it only happens to explode in the 4th quarter. (btw, Mariah already has 5 XMAS songs in her daily top 80). #11 - 74k daily - AIWFCIY #57 - 6k daily - Christmas (Baby Please Come Home) #70 - 3,9k daily - O Holy Night #74 - 3,5k daily - Oh Santa Remix #76 - 3,1k daily - AIWFCIY (Super Festive Version) = 91k of Xmas streams from those songs in JULY! By this point next month, all of them will double in daily streaming. 1
Recommended Posts