vale9001 Posted April 22 Posted April 22 (edited) There are threads on threads trying to push a narrative TPPD is a panned album, a mixed reviewed album or whatever. The album sits right now with a more than great 7.6/10 on Anydecent music (an aggregator doesn't count only mainstream magazines but every magazine) and it's true they didn't add a 6.5/10 from Pitchfork (still not a negative review if math is a thing ) but they also didn't still add a 10/10 from artdesk, a 10/10 from American Songwriter, a 9/10 from sputink music (they panned evermore and midnights with a 5/10) and a 9/10 from Q magazine. So probably it's gonna end with something like a 7.8-7.9/10 it's basically more than the 70% of most pop star careers. If you don't like the album it's your opinion but why you are going to such a territory of falsehood it's basically giving post truth and psychosis?. The consesus about this album is: a not so mush sonically innovative album but another solid and very well esecuted pop album from one of the pop most prolific best names. I mean it's just not that deep, move on! .... tryng to push post truth won't change facts. i'm gonna show what is a panned album cause some of you need help at this point Edited April 22 by vale9001 5 9 2 5
.Odyssey. Posted April 22 Posted April 22 Because some of us gO OuTSiDe and our friends and family think the album is absolutely mid. Get away from the critics and go talk to PEOPLE. People do not like this album. 7 2 17
Popular Post Illuminati Posted April 22 Popular Post Posted April 22 Taylor doesn't have a flop era so they have to imagine one 2 7 14 1
Popular Post jonapova Posted April 22 Popular Post Posted April 22 Ok, Taylor. Let's get you to bed. 25
Popular Post SweetOreosOfHeaven Posted April 22 Popular Post Posted April 22 We don't need reviewers to tell us it sucks, we can just hear it. The fact that jokes like RS are giving it 100/100 is not reliable at all. 5 20 10
Popular Post Virgos Groove Posted April 22 Popular Post Posted April 22 Being more acclaimed than Sasha Fierce and Britney Jean is the bar now? 31 1
ATRL Administrator Ryan Posted April 22 ATRL Administrator Posted April 22 Who cares if “People” don’t like the album, it only matters what your personal taste is. Yikes. 9 4 1
SweetOreosOfHeaven Posted April 22 Posted April 22 1 minute ago, .Odyssey. said: Because some of us gO OuTSiDe and our friends and family think the album is absolutely mid. Get away from the critics and go talk to PEOPLE. People do not like this album. Exactly. The lyrics have been the butt of every joke for a few days now... yet swifties still claim people just ~don't get it~. 5 2
St. Charles Posted April 22 Posted April 22 I'm going to be honest. I haven't even listened to this album. But the meltdowns all around have been so entertaining. 5
getBusy Posted April 22 Posted April 22 I still don't understand why the fanbase of the most successful artist in recent times feels so threatened by the opinion of others. You're winning, enjoy that. 4
duybeeGAshantiGA Posted April 22 Posted April 22 (edited) The fact that some publications can give this a 100 is telling you sth. It's just not a 100/100 album by any means. Somewhere from 6 to 7.5 MAX should be the score of this album. I mean this album is receiving better scores than Ocean Blvd ??? Like forreal? Edited April 22 by duybeeGAshantiGA 3
.Odyssey. Posted April 22 Posted April 22 Just now, St. Charles said: I'm going to be honest. I haven't even listened to this album. But the meltdowns all around have been so entertaining. Give it a listen as part of your evening routine tonight. It'll put you right to sleep! 1 1
Tudors Posted April 22 Posted April 22 Have you tried forming your own opinion baby? Who are these strangers who's opinion you are posting. Are they your freinds or something? 1
Nico Robin Posted April 22 Posted April 22 The album is super acclaimed. Two mixed/bad reviews wont change that lol 1 2
JC. Posted April 22 Posted April 22 For all the defending you stans do for this rich and successful woman, I hope she gives you a discount on her next overpriced tour tickets or merch. 3
.Odyssey. Posted April 22 Posted April 22 Just now, JC. said: For all the defending you stans do for this rich and successful woman, I hope she gives you a discount on her next overpriced tour tickets or merch. She'll release a few new variant$ to say thank you!!
ATRL Moderator Bloo Posted April 22 ATRL Moderator Posted April 22 13 minutes ago, .Odyssey. said: Because some of us gO OuTSiDe and our friends and family think the album is absolutely mid. Get away from the critics and go talk to PEOPLE. People do not like this album. Most people I know don’t follow pop music enough to have opinions of the albums we talk about on this forum. That includes TTPD. The “people” care less about pop music than most of y’all pretend they do. 3
.Odyssey. Posted April 22 Posted April 22 Just now, Bloo said: Most people I know don't follow pop music enough to have opinions of the albums we talk about on this forum. That includes TTPD. The "people" care less about music than most of y'all pretend they do. Well most people I know do, so
ATRL Moderator Tsareena Posted April 22 ATRL Moderator Posted April 22 we hype up "panned" reviews. you're not new here. also reviews are generally much nicer nowadays. most of the albums you posted are from before 2015 when pop music reviews were a lot harsher 1
K$Ellie Posted April 22 Posted April 22 not to make it all about numbers but if "people" HATED the album I don't think it would be breaking all these streaming records 5
Achilles. Posted April 22 Posted April 22 I mean, 3-4 songs from Taylor's album were enough to outdo any of their faves' latest debuts, of course they're going to take absolutely any chance to drag her. Even if they have to lie to themselves and others about the album's generally positive critical reception. 4 2
Recommended Posts