rl231 Posted November 12, 2023 Author Posted November 12, 2023 Spoiler @Alldeezy @Armani? @Aurora @blackoutbaby @EnterTheAttic @fiercE @gardendreams @Golden Hour @HungryByTheBuffet @Kyuti @Lemon @Devon Robot @MusicLoverDude @Seffers @Titsanny @ZORBIT Welcome castaways to your 6th results show! The judges have scored all of your entries out of 10, and I will now reveal their comments and scores. After I reveal the scores, I will post the final results which will include how you ranked against all castaways, and finally the overall rankings after this round. With that said, here it is…
rl231 Posted November 12, 2023 Author Posted November 12, 2023 (edited) Houdini Contestants Song Object Armani Barenaked Ladies - Alcohol Alcohol Lemon B.B. King - Lucille Guitar EnterTheAttic Harry Nilsson - My Old Desk Desk Alldeezy Queen - I'm In Love With My Car Car fiercE Neil Patrick Harris - Nothin' Suits Like Me a Suit Clothes Kyuti Ghostface Killah - The Sun Sun Aurora Diana Ross - My Old Piano Piano Devon Robot Rick James - Mary Jane Marijuana Harry Nilsson - Good Old Desk Auburn - 8 - This fits perfectly in every way besides the lack of him recognizing that it’s a weird/unhealthy obsession. He really finds comfort with this desk and stability it provides. Boys - 8.5 - I liked the unique tone this song had. It’s been so different from everything else we’ve had. Good job. Staryu - 8 - I liked the lyrics, it fit the theme well it was just missing the unhealthy part. Wish - 8 - Stanning a desk? Anyway this is pretty good, it's just missing the tidbit about his desk obsession being "unhealthy" B.B. King - Lucille Auburn - 8.5 - I can see how there’s a teeny tiny hint of him acknowledging that this obsession is sorta weird, but he doesn’t seem to think it’s an issue. Other than that, this hits the theme bang on. Boys - 9 - Lucille the original Harriet Tubman Staryu - 8.5 - Another good fit just missing a little unhealthy mention. Wish - 9 - "Maybe I'm lonely" kinda adds that extra layer of self-awareness I'm looking for, but I wish there was a BIT more. This is still a good entry overall! Queen - I'm In Love With My Car Auburn - 8 - Oh, he’s weird weird. Again this one fits great aside from the acknowledgment. I have a feeling this is going to become a theme across most entries. Boys - 8 - Fits part of what we asked for sure, nothing spectacular but it works. Staryu - 8 - Weirdo behaviour, men and their cars. This works for the theme, just missing a bit of something unhealthy mention whatever. Wish - 8 - Yeah, this matches the theme nicely but it's just missing that recognition of his unhealthy relationship with his car. Ghostface Killah - The Sun Auburn - 7 - This is decent. I feel like the fact that the sun is not a tangible object for humans to interact with weakened this entry a bit. Boys - 7- Interesting choice let’s just say that. Staryu - 7.5 - IDK this was a weird one, the lyrics mostly fit but still no real unhealthy acknowledgement. Wish - 8 - There's a lot of obsessive lyrics here but I don't see anything here that mentions an unhealthy relationship. Neil Patrick Harris - Nothin' Suits Like Me a Suit Auburn - 8 - This nails the obsession part, but it becomes a bit repetitive and he doesn’t address that it’s weird. Boys - 8 - Neil Patrick Harris is very unfunny. Staryu - 8 - Missing unhealthy but fits the theme otherwise. Wish - 8 - OKAAYYY almost none of you fully followed the instructions so far Once again this fits the theme but still missing that unhealthy detail Barenaked Ladies - Alcohol Auburn - 9 - I think this song shows good hints of recognition that it’s not healthy for him, but sometimes I can’t tell if he’s acknowledging that or asking forgiveness from the alcohol itself lol Boys - 10 - Finally a song that hits the unhealthy portion I felt when he said. “Oh alcohol, would you please forgive me? While I cannot love myself” I get an acknowledgement from him that he knows this is unhealthy but he needs it to comfort himself. Staryu - 10 - Giving this a 10 because it finally mentioned some unhealthy parts of their obsession, good job. Wish - 10 - This hits all of the marks for me, the narrator definitely seems self-aware of his harmful addiction, but still obsesses over drinking anyway. Diana Ross - My Old Piano Auburn - 7 - The theme is there but it’s not strong to me, it doesn’t feel like an unhealthy obsession. She just really likes her piano. Boys - 6.5 - She definitely wouldn’t shut up about the piano but it didn’t serve like show up on an episode of Maury talking about how you’re obsessed with it levels of crazy we needed. Staryu - 7 - She needed to be a bit more obsessed for my taste. Wish - 7.5 - This is cute but a bit less "obsessive" than some of the others. Rick James - Mary Jane Auburn - 5 - The fact that I need to assume and infer that he’s talking about weed rather than a living woman very much hinders this one. It should be spelled out clearly. Boys - 5.5 - I’m fighting with this entry because I myself clearly know he’s talking about weed but of course the song itself is leading you to believe it could be about a woman. I also don’t get obsessed with this as much as others. Staryu - 5 - The double entendre doesn’t work too well here compared to most of the other songs this round, sorry sis. Wish - 4 - Ugh the double entendre really messes you up here, bc there isn't anything explicitly telling me that he's talking about an inanimate object. This is why I've been advising y'all to send SPECIFIC lyrics! Tamariz is next... Edited November 12, 2023 by rl231
rl231 Posted November 12, 2023 Author Posted November 12, 2023 Tamariz Contestants Song Object MusicLoverDude Miranda Cosgrove - Headphones On Headphones Titsanny 6arelyhuman - Luv my drugz (feat. Omu) Pills gardendreams Elsa Vendella - Phone Addiction Phone Golden Hour Poppy - Computer Boy Computer blackoutbaby Efe Oraka - Comfort Food Food Seffers Danii Minogue - Vibe On Dildo/Vibrator ZORBIT Melanie Martinez - Teddy Bear Teddy Bear Melanie Martinez - Teddy Bear Auburn - 5 - She threw it out so I don’t think she’s got an unhealthy obsession here… she’s very scared of her murderous teddy bear because she got rid of him so this is kinda off-base for me. Boys - 1 - Staryu - 2 - It’s a chop. Wish - 3 - There's no obsession or devoted relationship here, in fact she's terrified of the teddy bear. Efe Oraka - Comfort Food Auburn - 9 - This is pretty good theme-wise! +1 because she recognizes it’s not healthy but -1 because the obsession seems to be actually with her ex-lover and not the object. Boys - 8 - Needed this song to not mention the lover at all and you’d have a 10 from me. Staryu - 8 - I think this was pretty good but I agree she was a little too focused on the lover for a lot of the song. Wish - 7 - Hmm, she’s using comfort food as an unhealthy coping mechanism, but she’s actually pining for another person. I'm not convinced that she would choose this food over the ex-boyfriend she's missing. So it's missing the mark a bit for me Poppy - Computer Boy Auburn - 8 - Good for theme, no recognition of it being unhealthy. Boys - 10 - I actually disagree with the judges. I feel as though when she says she’s trying not to get attached to you it's because she’s aware it’s not healthy but that computer is the only thing that gets her so she can’t help it. Could it be more detailed? Sure but I feel like it works for me. Staryu - 9 - I feel like her acknowledging that she’s trying not to get attached, it kinda gives an unhealthy angle to the lyrics, maybe not a full 10 but a good 9. Wish - 8 - Good but lacking that unhealthy detail Elsa Vendella - Phone Addiction Auburn - 9.5 - This is quite good for the theme, but sometimes it feels like she’s critiquing society and everyone else rather than herself. Boys - 9 - Definitely obsessive. Staryu - 9 - Another close but not quite perfect entry, good choice overall though. Wish - 9 - Obsessive for sure, I'm not totally convinced by the vague "are we just robots" lyric but it’s good Miranda Cosgrove - Headphones On Auburn - 10 - Leave it to Miranda to have a perfect song for the theme. Queen, she can truly do no wrong. Boys - 10 - Another 10 for Michael Jackson. Staryu - 10 - She gave us everything we asked for. Wish - 10 - Period, who doesn't wanna put on their headphones and escape the world sometimes? She recognizes that she's running late, wasting time, and procrastinating due to her unhealthy obsession. This was actually a great entry! 6arelyhuman - Luv my drugz (feat. Omu) Auburn - 9 - Needed more elaboration in my opinion but tackles the theme very well. Boys - 10 - Whether he loved or hated the drugs he was still popping them like candy even after acknowledging in the beginning that it's so unhealthy it's killing him. Good entry. Staryu - 10 - Yas emo king luvs his drugz and knows they’re killing him but likes that anyway, period. Wish - 9 - Good entry, this hits the marks but it's missing some detail that would make me give this a perfect score. Dannii Minogue - Vibe On Auburn - 8 - sadjfklsdlk I- Boys - 7 - I needed more from an obsessive stand point with this song. I get the feeling that she loves her good vibrations clearly but I need to know that she’d rather shove an extra large alien vibrating dildo up her cooch than go to work and pay her rent. Staryu - 8 - One horny ***** but no unhealthy mention. Wish - 7.5 - Oh- oh wow! Kinda obsessed with the term "vibraholic" djfkfd... this is good but lacking the recognition that her habit is unhealthy in any way. It’s also a bit less obsessive than I’d like. Final results up next!
rl231 Posted November 12, 2023 Author Posted November 12, 2023 Now that you've all seen how you've done independently, let's see how you rank among your tribe, among all players, and finally the overall tribe averages. HOUDINI 1. Armani - 9.75 - IMMUNE 2. Lemon - 8.75 3. EnterTheAttic - 8.13 4. Alldeezy - 8.00 4. fiercE - 8.00 6. Kyuti - 7.38 7. Aurora - 7.00 8. Devon Robot - 4.88 TAMARIZ 1. MusicLoverDude - 10.00 - IMMUNE 2. Titsanny - 9.50 3. gardendreams - 9.13 4. Golden Hour - 8.75 5. blackoutbaby - 8.00 6. Seffers - 7.63 7. ZORBIT - 2.75 OVERALL RANK: 1. MusicLoverDude - 10 (+9) 2. Armani - 9.75 (+9) 3. Titsanny - 9.5 (+12) 4. gardendreams - 9.13 (+5) 5. Golden Hour - 8.75 (-1) 5. Lemon - 8.75 (=) 7. EnterTheAttic - 8.14 (-6) 8. Alldeezy - 8 (-2) 8. blackoutbaby - 8 (-5) 8. fiercE - 8 (=) 11. Seffers - 7.63 (+5) 12. Kyuti - 7.38 (-6) 13. Aurora - 7 (-1) 14. Devon Robot - 4.88 (-1) 15. ZORBIT - 2.75 (-13) CUMULATIVE RANK: 1. Golden Hour - 8.90 2. MusicLoverDude - 8.73 2. Galaxy - 8.73 4. fiercE - 8.60 5. blackoutbaby - 7.73 6. Kyuti - 7.54 7. Armani - 7.29 8. Alldeezy - 7.22 9. Seffers - 7.04 10. gardendreams - 7.02 11. EnterTheAttic - 6.94 12. Aurora - 6.92 13. Lemon - 6.83 14. Titsanny - 6.50 15. HungryByTheBuffet - 6.28 16. stupidjock - 5.81 17. Dr. Alexander - 5.77 18. ZORBIT - 5.40 19. Hey Dude - 5.21 20. Devon Robot - 5.08 21. rickycabello123 - 3.46 22. Kayseri Mantisi - 3.13 23. Queen - 1.38 24. Big Bad Wolf - 1.00 Who wins? Click the spoiler below. Spoiler The winner is... ...with an average of 7.96... ...and separated by a mere 0.23... TAMARIZ!!!! Congratulations, you all are safe! Houdini, for the first time, I can't say the same for you. It's time for you to go to Tribal Council. When you're ready, please send your vote, along with your parchment (in #rules-and-reminders) AND an updated bootlist, to the same DM on Discord you submit your songs in. Votes are due on Monday, November 13th at 12:00 PM EDT, and you may not vote for Armani. Good luck!
gardendreams Posted November 13, 2023 Posted November 13, 2023 (edited) Welcome to Round 4s - The Judges' Reviews Recap Where your favorite girl in STEM will be taking a deeper look into how the judges reviews compare to each other! Are there any significant differences in data? You'll find out here. Round 4 we had @Auburn @boys @Staryu @wish Who was the most generous judge? @Auburn with a 7.93 average score in round 4! Who was the most critical judge? @wish with a 7.73 average score in Round 4. Congrats for your third time being the most critical. Third place was Staryu with a 7.86 Second place was Boys with a 7.83 Which song had the judges most divided? @ZORBIT you had most polarizing songs this week with a 4 point difference. Zorbit has had three songs here, making his entries the most polarizing. Data can be fun, here's some fun facts! Houdini needed 8 points to beat Tamariz this round. Just like last week! Fun fact, Round 5 the judges did not agree unanimously on a score. This the judges gave 3 songs the same score! Judges Cumulative Ranking (more points = more critical) 1. Luckystrike - 1 2. Staryu - 2 2. Supaspa - 2 2. Auburn - 2 5. Boys - 5 6. Rotunda - 6 8. Wish –9 8. Gateau - 9 and cheers to @Seffers for helping last week xoxo. Edited November 13, 2023 by gardendreams
MusicLoverDude Posted November 13, 2023 Posted November 13, 2023 So happy to see Miranda slayed. I thought of that song almost instantly when the round came up.
rl231 Posted November 13, 2023 Author Posted November 13, 2023 Spoiler @Alldeezy @Armani? @Aurora @Devon Robot @EnterTheAttic @fiercE @Kyuti @Lemon Welcome Houdini to Tribal Council! One of you will become the tenth person to get voted out. If any of you have an item to play, now would be the time to do so... Spoiler Aurora stands. I would like to use the power of Hypnosis on Devon Robot. Devon's vote will now be controlled by Aurora. I'll read the votes...
rl231 Posted November 13, 2023 Author Posted November 13, 2023 Spoiler @Alldeezy @Armani? @Aurora @Devon Robot @EnterTheAttic @fiercE @Kyuti @Lemon First vote... 1 vote Devon. Second vote... 2 votes Devon. Third vote... 3 votes Devon. Fourth vote... 3 votes Devon, 1 vote Lemon. Fifth vote... 3 votes Devon, 2 votes Lemon. Sixth vote... 3 votes Devon, 3 votes Lemon. Seventh vote... 4 votes Lemon, 3 votes Devon. Eighth vote... Spoiler And the tenth person voted out of ATRL Survivor 14... Lemon, the tribe has spoken. Thanks for playing!
Lemon Posted November 13, 2023 Posted November 13, 2023 Thanks for having me, hosts. It was fun. The amount of work invested into gameplay is fantastic. However, maybe Piper doesn’t like lemonade, but Ghostface sure does love making people sour. I will be waiting some of you at the other side of the island soon enough. Make no mistake, sweeties. 6 1
fiercE Posted November 13, 2023 Posted November 13, 2023 Hoests asked 9 minutes ago and was ignored. We're so rude.
gardendreams Posted November 13, 2023 Posted November 13, 2023 Just now, fiercE said: Hoests asked 9 minutes ago and was ignored. We're so rude. honestly we are
Seffers Posted November 13, 2023 Posted November 13, 2023 Just now, fiercE said: Hoests asked 9 minutes ago and was ignored. We're so rude. our reputation era
fiercE Posted November 13, 2023 Posted November 13, 2023 Imagine thinking it was the hosts who were slow, but it was really us who are the problem.
MusicLoverDude Posted November 13, 2023 Posted November 13, 2023 Just now, fiercE said: Imagine thinking it was the hosts who were slow, but it was really us who are the problem. We're the anti-heros
.thumb.gif.813ce109798ef00c6ec6d9e88cf1c923.gif)
Recommended Posts