poll Is Gaga the most talented pop star of all time?

[OCBoy212]

No.  She’s talented no doubt but i wouldn’t cite her as such.

[Dula Peep]

On 6/4/2023 at 8:22 AM, GraceRandolph said:

Funny how Gaga’s talent is measured by 19192919 different metrics when Taylor fans only measure her talent by songwriting ability. If Taylor had to withstand the scrutiny of being compared to the best vocalists, best dancers, best actresses, best fashion icons, and best songwriters simultaneously she would be a laughing stock, but somehow the rules are different for her. 

this. 

 

Also, Gaga is a better pop songwriter 

[toxicgenie]

She's very creative, especially during the Fame - BTW eras. 

[Erreur2 La Nature]

...no ? I assume this thread was made to get her dragged ?

 

Lady Gaga is very talented but she has many issues:

• Her music is largely regarded as weak by those who don't stan her.
• She might have the worst single choices out of any popgirls.
• Her music videos stopped being good after The Fame Monster.
• She tries too hard to be cool and can be really cringe.
• Her voice can be really irritating sometimes.

I genuinely think this woman could have been "the next Madonna" with the right choices but her career feels like a huge mess.

[GraceRandolph]

On 6/8/2023 at 5:20 PM, Erreur2 La Nature said:

...no ? I assume this thread was made to get her dragged ?

 

Lady Gaga is very talented but she has many issues:

• Her music is largely regarded as weak by those who don't stan her.
• She might have the worst single choices out of any popgirls.
• Her music videos stopped being good after The Fame Monster.
• She tries too hard to be cool and can be really cringe.
• Her voice can be really irritating sometimes.

I genuinely think this woman could have been "the next Madonna" with the right choices but her career feels like a huge mess.

Half of these “issues” have nothing to do with talent. Poor single choices could be a result of Interscope, Jimmy Iovine has picked some singles that Gaga wouldn’t have for instance, and Gaga actually has a ton of respect from people outside the pop music world due to her SOM tribute performance and rock inspirations.