Jump to content

The Taylor Swift Discography Rate || Winner Revealed!


Recommended Posts

Posted

Alright, our next two should liven things up a bit! One from 1989, one from Rep; what’s leaving? :gaylorcat2:

  • Replies 5.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • wastedpotential

    583

  • 1989

    517

  • Klein

    362

  • By the Water

    232

Posted

End Game and Shake It Off me thinks.

Posted

Another Speak Now track :rip:

 

My money is also on End Game and Turn Shake It Off!

Posted

But don't make her drop you off around the block

Remember that she's getting older too

And don't lose the way that you dance around in your PJs getting ready for school

 

TPdHTpm.gif

Posted

Shake It Off is TOP20 easily it better STAY HERE

 

latoya-right-now.gif

Posted
2 hours ago, 1989 said:

 

h8DktM9.jpg

 

181. Run (feat. Ed Sheeran) - 6.019
 

Lovers (10): a_d_22, Icarus, 

Haters (1): KillingYourCareer, Taylor fanboy, creativity., 4real, =NEX=, Pink Whitney, luckythisway, Allday, Brando, Holy Ground, 

 

Comments:

wastedpotential: Not one of the best Taylor/Ed collabs, but it’s cute. I love that this is the trampoline song we knew about for so long.

Fifteen: superior to that other thing here

 

 

 

Oh come on it’s not that bad. Y’all just hate Ed :rip:

 

1 hour ago, 1989 said:

 

XisQgAm.jpg

 

178. It’s Nice To Have A Friend - 6.116
 

Lovers (10): jacklovesyou1, State Of Grace., AbeHicks, Nordic Guy, Sanguine, Bussea, sparrowblue, a_d_22, 

Haters (1): Taylor fanboy, Holy Ground, Aiya, Allday, Miles., 

Comments:

Holy Ground: “If this was on folklore y'all would love it" noooo, I'd rate it a 1 there too

Fifteen: never got into it

wastedpotential: This song sounds haunted, and not in a good way.  Who knew in August 2019 that this would be the other half of the sonic direction of the next two Taylor albums.

 

 

This garbage stuck around for way too long :deadbanana2:

 

1 hour ago, 1989 said:
KL9yGAM.jpg

 

174. Welcome To New York - 6.145
 

Lovers(10): creativity., Prison, Shendelzare, 

Haters(1): inshadesofcool, KillingYourCareer, Taylor fanboy, Mr. Duff, Icarus, luckythisway, Ken Lee, Kyungsooswift, NMIXX, 

Haters(0): =NEX=, The Argonaut, Miles., 

Comments:

The Argonaut: She deserves a negative number but it's not allowed in this rate, right?

wastedpotential: Filler and repetitive but it sets the tone of the album well.

This garbage stuck around for way too long x2 

Posted

Blissfullnence deserved top 20 if we’re being honest… can’t believe it didnt even make top 170

spacer.png

Posted

Please be King Of My Turds and Shake It Ofbeat :jonnycat:

Posted

I couldn't help but notice that some people gave every song that left today a 1 except for Gorgeous, which got a 10. Surely @1989 wouldn't accept troll ballots, right?

 

latoya-right-now.gif

Posted

Happy to see debut go tho :clap3:I thought the country bumpkins might mess with the rate to keep it around 

Posted
21 minutes ago, 1989 said:

 

BZQYoTy.jpg

 

169. Come In With The Rain - 6.177
 

Lovers(10): Ayanaa, AbeHicks,

Haters(1): KillingYourCareer, Taylor fanboy, 

 

 

 

not this classic out already, deserved top 80. :oxygen2:

Posted (edited)
2 minutes ago, By the Water said:

I couldn't help but notice that some people gave every song that left today a 1 except for Gorgeous, which got a 10. Surely @1989 wouldn't accept troll ballots, right?

 

latoya-right-now.gif

hmmm… now that i think about it, they said Godnocence was underrated and deserved better but still gave it a 1. Suspicious?

 

spacer.png

 

Edited by inshadesofcool
Posted
46 minutes ago, 1989 said:

 

kemKXfx.jpg

 

172. Sweeter Than Fiction - 6.156
 

Lovers(10): AbeHicks, Prison, The Argonaut, Kyungsooswift, State Of Grace., ithinkheknowsoutsold, yeezytaughtme, Quicksand, a_d_22, 

Haters(1): Taylor fanboy, By The Water, Tusk, sanzo, 

 

 

 

My first zero OUT (even though it says I gave it a 10 :gaycat4:)

 

Posted

KL9yGAM.jpg

 

167. How You Get The Girl - 6.195
 

Lovers(10): AbeHicks, feelslikeadream, Quicksand, Sanguine,

Haters(1): Taylor fanboy, By The Water, wastedpotential, 

Comments:

wastedpotential: SKIP! 
eli’s_rhythm: Always sounded like a cheap demo. Mystifying how this made the tracklist over the bonus tracks.

Posted

Thank god it's not shake it off. But HYGTG is also a hymn that deserved better

 

latoya-right-now.gif

Posted
Just now, 1989 said:

 

KL9yGAM.jpg

 

167. How You Get The Girl - 6.195
 

Lovers(10): AbeHicks, feelslikeadream, Quicksand, Sanguine,

Haters(1): Taylor fanboy, By The Water, wastedpotential, 

Comments:

wastedpotential: SKIP! 
eli’s_rhythm: Always sounded like a cheap demo. Mystifying how this made the tracklist over the bonus tracks.

 

 

Shake It Off deserved but I’m not too mad about it 

Posted
3 minutes ago, By the Water said:

I couldn't help but notice that some people gave every song that left today a 1 except for Gorgeous, which got a 10. Surely @1989 wouldn't accept troll ballots, right?

 

latoya-right-now.gif

I said yesterday we had one sabotage ballot :dies: 

Posted

This before Shake It Off? Not sure how I feel about that one.

 

But also that's fine.

Posted
2 minutes ago, 1989 said:

 

KL9yGAM.jpg

 

167. How You Get The Girl - 6.195
 

Lovers(10): AbeHicks, feelslikeadream, Quicksand, Sanguine,

Haters(1): Taylor fanboy, By The Water, wastedpotential, 

Comments:

wastedpotential: SKIP! 
eli’s_rhythm: Always sounded like a cheap demo. Mystifying how this made the tracklist over the bonus tracks.

 

 

these kinda songs are what kept me from taking taylor swift seriously for so long, now as a stan i can appreciate it for what it is but still not that cute

Posted

Yall just hate having fun

 

latoya-right-now.gif

Posted
26 minutes ago, 1989 said:

 

BZQYoTy.jpg

 

169. Come In With The Rain - 6.177
 

Lovers(10): Ayanaa, AbeHicks,

Haters(1): KillingYourCareer, Taylor fanboy, 
 

 

WHAT :biblio: I think this is my first 10 out :jonny2:

Posted
2 hours ago, 1989 said:
z9x6UUz.jpg

 

180. Gorgeous - 6.032

 

Lovers (10): Taylor fanboy, Mr. Duff, 

Haters (1): KillingYourCareer, By The Water, feelslikeadream, Cruel Summer, sparrowblue, Aiya, Brando

Haters (0): 1989, Miles., =NEX=, The Music Industry, luckythisway, 

 

Comments:

wastedpotential: Harmless, and as someone who suffers similarly from crush-anxiety, I can relate to this song.

luckythisway: SKID MARK of a song 

NMIXX: Hated this song at first, but it grew on me :gaycat1:

 

 

I know you said the names are all mixed up but I just hated when I saw my name as part of those who gave this a 10 when I gave this a freaking fat zero. Thank God it’s out but it’s like 30 spots higher than it should have been.

 

1 hour ago, 1989 said:
BZQYoTy.jpg

 

176. We Were Happy - 6.122
 

Lovers (10): creativity., Ethereal Cat, Mr. Duff

Haters (1): greento, Taylor fanboy, 4real, Miles., jacklovesyou1, yeezytaughtme, By The Water,

 

I didn’t give this a 10 although it’s a cute song.

Posted
5 minutes ago, 4Real said:

Yall just hate having fun

 

latoya-right-now.gif

That's what ME! apologists say

 

latoya-right-now.gif

Posted
10 minutes ago, 1989 said:

 

KL9yGAM.jpg

 

167. How You Get The Girl - 6.195
 

Lovers(10): AbeHicks, feelslikeadream, Quicksand, Sanguine,

Haters(1): Taylor fanboy, By The Water, wastedpotential, 

Comments:

wastedpotential: SKIP! 
eli’s_rhythm: Always sounded like a cheap demo. Mystifying how this made the tracklist over the bonus tracks.

 

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Posted
1 minute ago, By the Water said:

That's what ME! apologists say

 

latoya-right-now.gif

I guess they are not wrong. ME! > Lover

 

latoya-right-now.gif

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.