Jump to content

The Taylor Swift Discography Rate || Winner Revealed!


Recommended Posts

Posted
Just now, 4Real said:

Sweet Nothing deserved

:cm:

  • Replies 5.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • wastedpotential

    583

  • 1989

    517

  • Klein

    362

  • By the Water

    232

Posted
1 minute ago, State of Grace. said:

Giving 0s to august, Style, and Out of the Woods is NOT the flex you think it is

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Oh I used my 11s to prevent some of these sabotages :eli:

Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, State of Grace. said:

Giving 0s to august, Style, and Out of the Woods is NOT the flex you think it is

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

As if Out of the Charts would even make top 20. This isn't 2015

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Edited by By the Water
Posted

Dear Reader and Labrynth were right there 

Posted
Just now, Wolf Alice said:

Oh I used my 11s to prevent some of these sabotages :eli:

Hope they work :eli: 

 

Just now, By the Water said:

As is Out of the Charts would even make top 20. This isn't 2015

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

People here are too tasteless to appreciate OOTW's excellence so I don't expect it to be that high yeah

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

  • ATRL Moderator
Posted

Both of Us is great. Y'all just gave it bad scores cause it's a collab :coffee2:

Posted

I love the bad ***** Billie aesthetic she was going for with Vigilante ****, but she really dropped the ball with regards to the actual execution.  The most disappointing song on Midnights.

 

Still should've lasted longer than Karma and Sweet Nodding Off To Sleep.

 

4 minutes ago, 1989 said:

I said just let me know if I’ve missed you sis, pointing out high and low scores is the hardest part of the rate cause there’s no formula for it :gaycat6:

 

:hug: 

 

But I'm watching you bro.  If any L0ser songs squeak into the top 20, we'll know for sure this is rigged :flower:

Posted

Out Of The Woods has her greatest bridge of ALL TIME, and "the monsters turned out to be just trees" is a line so sharp it could cut glass.  It SHOULD be in the top 10, but there are too many tasteless talentphobes here unfortunately.

Posted

kemKXfx.jpg

 

202. Beautiful Eyes - 4.998
 

Lovers: Hunter_13, 

Haters: Klein, 

 

Posted
1 minute ago, Miles. said:

Out Of The Woods has her greatest bridge of ALL TIME, and "the monsters turned out to be just trees" is a line so sharp it could cut glass.  It SHOULD be in the top 10, but there are too many tasteless talentphobes here unfortunately.

It’s in my Top 5.  The emotion she sings with is orgasmic.

 

I gave it a 10. I had to use my 11s to hopefully save some others.

Posted (edited)

Mixtape, 1989, Lover and Midnights all getting punched

 

Fearless, Speak Now, Red, reputation, folklore, evermore untouched

 

It feels right 

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Edited by Icarus
Posted

Not all of this Out of the Charts stanning in 2023 :redface:

 

I even gave it a fair 3

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Posted
3 minutes ago, 1989 said:

 

kemKXfx.jpg

 

202. Beautiful Eyes - 4.998
 

Lovers: Hunter_13, 

Haters: Klein, 

 

 

 

I only listen to this during your rates.

Posted
1 minute ago, Icarus said:

Fearless, Speak Now, Red, reputation, folklore, evermore untouched

 

It feels right 

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

This is why I can't take puta stans seriously. I mean, we all see the huge sneak

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Posted

aIQbfEK.jpg

 

201. Last Christmas - 5.510
 

Lovers (10): a_d_22, creativity., 

Haters (0): feelslikeadream, 

 

Posted
1 minute ago, By the Water said:

This is why I can't take puta stans seriously. I mean, we all see the huge sneak

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Yes we all see Fearless but it has some classics

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Posted
5 minutes ago, By the Water said:

Not all of this Out of the Charts stanning in 2023 :redface:

 

A classic is a classic. Period.

Posted

LWYMMD in the top 200, a WIN!

 

I was worried certain tasteless rats would sabotage it.

Posted
2 minutes ago, State of Grace. said:

Yes we all see Fearless but it has some classics

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Don't you ever compare Diamond certified AOTY winner Fillerless to that

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Posted
2 minutes ago, By the Water said:

Don't you ever compare Diamond certified AOTY winner Fillerless to that

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Not with its 26 songs tracklist

 

dancingwithmyself1.thumb.gif.ec75527e8c4

Posted (edited)
kemKXfx.jpg

 

200. I Heart ? - 5.646
 

Lovers (10): a_d_22, Hunter_13, 

Haters (0): Klein, 

 
Edited by 1989
Posted

That gets us to the Top 200! :gaylorcat2:Should we do a few more or wait until tomorrow? 

Posted
Just now, 1989 said:

That gets us to the Top 200! :gaylorcat2:Should we do a few more or wait until tomorrow? 

i’m hungry for more :redface:

Posted
2 minutes ago, 1989 said:

That gets us to the Top 200! :gaylorcat2:Should we do a few more or wait until tomorrow? 

Stop at 190

Posted

It’s 1:16am here but I can perch for a couple more… :giraffe:

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.