The Taylor Swift Discography Rate || Winner Revealed!

[Navy4Life]

3 hours ago, 1989 said:

 

 

38. Death By A Thousand Cuts - 8.221
 

Lovers(10): The Argonaut, Peroxide, inshadesofcool, michael196, sanzo, Ethereal Cat, Ken Lee, Pink Whitney, The Music Industry, Hunter_13, Wolf Alice, Mr. Duff, Prison, pinkbowvintage, 

Haters(1): By The Water

Haters(0): Taylor fanboy 

Comments:

wastedpotential: Who knew in August 2019 that this would be half of the sonic direction of the next two Taylor albums.

eli’s_rhythm: A beautifully written song marred by questionable production choices

 

 

This should’ve been put 4 rates ago

 

 

3 hours ago, 1989 said:

 

 

34. My Tears Ricochet - 8.276
 

Stans(11): Wolf Alice, fama,

Lovers(10): Bindi, MardinBeksloy, The Argonaut, Peroxide, Miles., a_d_22, feelslikeadream, JoanneActII, michael196, wastedpotential, Ethereal Cat, Navy4life, Taeyong, The Music Industry, Isaiah, Brando, Holy Ground, NordicGuy, Prison, 1989, KillingYourCareer, SleepingTigers, Byzantium, 

Haters(1): sparrowblue, Allday, Taylor fanboy, TMRA

Hatera(0): Ken Lee 

Comments:

wastedpotential: Hauntingly sad and perfect. The Long Pond version is superior.

 

 

I’m officially an ex-Swiftie! Y’all are so trash for this. 
 

Anti-Hero still in?  Over MTR, coney island, illicit affairs, OOTW, evermore etc. 

[Prismee]

2 hours ago, 1989 said:

 

31. Cruel Summer - 8.331
 

Stans(11): Shendelzare, =NEX=, Quicksand

Lovers(10): 4real, RihannaLoverrr, creativity., Tusk, pinkbowvintage, NordicGuy, Prison, Holy Ground, MardinBeksloy, The Argonaut, Peroxide, Miles., a_d_22, feelslikeadream, PopA911, JoanneActII, Kyungsooswift, eli’s_rhythm, sanzo, jacklovesyou1, Ken Lee, sparrowblue, Taeyong, Pink Whitney, The Music Industry, Hunter_13, Wolf Alice, Supernatural, TaylenaStan, Fifteen, Brando, fama, 

Haters(1): luckythisway, Mr. Duff, KillingYourCareer 

Haters(0): Taylor fanboy, By The Water

Comments:

wastedpotential: A very serviceable pop song, would have been a hit if it was a single, but y’all give it too much credit.

I gave this trash a 1, I hope you counted my score correctly @1989

[Dear Reader]

I’m glad I couldn’t be here last night cause the folklore purge was NOT cute 

 

I’m still excited that all my 11s made it to top 30 though  thank you for all your effort @1989

[wastedpotential]

I cannot believe that I slept through this entire round, and woke up to find this 

 

I hate YouTube for age-restricting this but it's worth a watch nnnn

 

 

[wastedpotential]

 

I'll be seeing y'all in hell

[State of Grace.]

47. Don’t Blame Me - 8.117

45. Out Of The Woods - 8.140

44. Illicit Affairs - 8.142

43. Seven - 8.163

42. The 1 - 8.182

41. Evermore (feat. Bon Iver) - 8.183

36. Mirrorball - 8.260

34. My Tears Ricochet - 8.276

33. Dear John - 8.281

32. ‘Tis The Damn Season - 8.317

 

I expected the worst, but this is even worse than I expected. You b*tches are ******* TASTELESS.  

 

Corny Street, Corona Summer and Death By A Thousand Snoozes outlasting all those folkmore masterpieces is yet another reason why swifties only deserve MID albums forever.

 

Dear John missing Top 30. Under WCS too. 

 

ANTI-HIT STILL IN!!!!

 

Edited February 27, 2023 by State of Grace.

[wastedpotential]

1 minute ago, State of Grace. said:

I expected the worst, but this is even worse than I expected. You b*tches are ******* TASTELESS.  

 

Corny Street, Corona Summer and Death By A Thousand snoozes outlasting all those folkmore masterpieces is yet another reason why swifties only deserve MID albums forever.

 

Dear John missing Top 30. Under WCS too. 

 

ANTI-HIT STILL IN!!!!

 

ALLL OF THIS 

 

[Velvet Night]

I’m honestly happy I was asleep during this round because I wouldn’t have been able to sleep after seeing folklore getting slaughtered. Also Safe & Sound out and Anti-Hero and CIWYW still in 

[RihannaLoverrr]

6 hours ago, 1989 said:

 

 

43. Seven - 8.163
 

Stans(11): Rev8, eli’s_rhythm, TMRA,

Lovers(10): Bindi, The Argonaut, chaeyonce, a_d_22, JoanneActII, State Of Grace., Ethereal Cat, sparrowblue, Taeyong, Hunter_13, Wolf Alice, Sanguine, Brando, roso, By The Water, Byzantium, pinkbowvintage, RihannaLoverrr, Tusk, 

Haters(1): Quicksand, Taylor fanboy,

Haters(0): SleepingTigers

Comments:

wastedpotential:  I know everyone will give it a 7, and I don’t think it deserves that fate.

Rev8: underrated, just because it's next to august

TMRA: this song makes me cry

 

 

 

5 hours ago, 1989 said:

 

 

37. Haunted - 8.240
 

Stans(11): Bussea, Prison, RihannaLoverrr,

Lovers(10): The Argonaut, Miles., chaeyonce, JoanneActII, Kyungsooswift, State Of Grace., eli’s_rhythm, Ethereal Cat, sparrowblue, Taeyong, Hunter_13, jacobhalkohit, Mr. Duff, TMRA, Sanguine, Brando, Holy Ground, NordicGuy, KillingYourCareer, creativity., SleepingTigers, AbeHicks, 

Haters(1): Taylor fanboy,

Comments:

Rev8: I been hearing hints of Evanescence till now, but this just proves she been listening it at the time 

Bussea: deserves all the acclaim that Enchanted gets x

wastedpotential: The bells from the Speak Now tour are one of the best live elements a song of hers has ever had, and the build throughout the bridge is immaculate.

eli’s_rhythm: Queen of rock

 

 

 

4 hours ago, 1989 said:

 

 

34. My Tears Ricochet - 8.276
 

Stans(11): Wolf Alice, fama,

Lovers(10): Bindi, MardinBeksloy, The Argonaut, Peroxide, Miles., a_d_22, feelslikeadream, JoanneActII, michael196, wastedpotential, Ethereal Cat, Navy4life, Taeyong, The Music Industry, Isaiah, Brando, Holy Ground, NordicGuy, Prison, 1989, KillingYourCareer, SleepingTigers, Byzantium, 

Haters(1): sparrowblue, Allday, Taylor fanboy, TMRA

Hatera(0): Ken Lee 

Comments:

wastedpotential: Hauntingly sad and perfect. The Long Pond version is superior.

 

 

 

4 hours ago, 1989 said:

 

 

33. Dear John - 8.281
 

Stans(11): 1989, feelslikeadream, freakum.,

Lovers(10): a_d_22, Shendelzare, The Argonaut, JoanneActII, State Of Grace., wastedpotential, Holy Ground, Ethereal Cat, jacklovesyou1, Ken Lee, Quicksand, Ayanaa, Pink Whitney, Hunter_13, Wolf Alice, Supernatural, Fifteen, Mr. Duff, fama, NordicGuy, greento, Byzantium, pinkbowvintage, TMRA, 4real, Prison,

Haters(1): Allday, Taylor fanboy, 

Comments:

TMRA: I took your matches before fire could catch me -WHEW a lyric!

Fifteen: drag him

wastedpotential: People were slandering it in the Midnights thread a while ago and I had a coronary. This is one of her best songs ever and it deserves all the respect and accolades itgets.

 

 

 

4 hours ago, 1989 said:

 

31. Cruel Summer - 8.331
 

Stans(11): Shendelzare, =NEX=, Quicksand

Lovers(10): 4real, RihannaLoverrr, creativity., Tusk, pinkbowvintage, NordicGuy, Holy Ground, MardinBeksloy, The Argonaut, Peroxide, Miles., a_d_22, feelslikeadream, PopA911, JoanneActII, Kyungsooswift, eli’s_rhythm, sanzo, jacklovesyou1, Ken Lee, sparrowblue, Taeyong, Pink Whitney, The Music Industry, Hunter_13, Wolf Alice, Supernatural, TaylenaStan, Fifteen, Brando, fama, 

Haters(1): luckythisway, Mr. Duff, KillingYourCareer, Prison,

Haters(0): Taylor fanboy, By The Water

Comments:

wastedpotential: A very serviceable pop song, would have been a hit if it was a single, but y’all give it too much credit.

These all deserved to be a bit higher imo. Especially Haunted, it must be my most played Taylor song - a literal masterpiece. Deserved top 10 at least. My second 11 gone. 

 

[Alldeezy]

Wait when did bad blood and bad blood Remix leave 

 

Okay I only have 2 songs I love left then

[Peroxide]

31 minutes ago, Allday said:

Wait when did bad blood and bad blood Remix leave 

 

Okay I only have 2 songs I love left then

Sis they left AGES ago.

 

This ain’t a bad top 30. I’m not mad… the only song I’m not overly fussed on is Treacherous (and I always found Wildest Dreams overrated but I get why it’s here)

 

SHOCKED about Cruel Summer leaving

[byzantium]

5 hours ago, 1989 said:

Your Top 30!
 

Fearless:

Love Story

 

Speak Now:

Sparks Fly 

Back To December 

Enchanted

 

Red:

State Of Grace

Red

Treacherous 

All Too Well 

Holy Ground

Begin Again 

All Too Well (10 Min Version) 

 

1989:

Blank Space

Style

Wildest Dreams 

Clean 

 

Reputation:

Delicate

Getaway Car 

Call It What You Want 

 

Lover:

Cornelia Street 

 

Folklore:

Cardigan

Exile

August

This Is Me Trying 

 

Evermore:

Ivy

Cowboy Like Me 

Right Where You Left Me 

 

Midnights:

Maroon 

Anti-Hero 

You’re On Your Own, Kid 

Would’ve, Could’ve, Should’ve

Is there any question that RED is her best album? 

[TMRA]

Im happy seven made it that far

And Dear John deserves to be top 15 at least. Im really surprised at This Is Me Trying I hope it makes top 10!!

[Cleanromantic]

Exile does not deserve to be above Illicit Affairs or in the top 100. It sounds like that sleep inertia feeling you get after a nap. 

The last time and Everything has changed >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Exit 

[Navy4Life]

5 minutes ago, Cleanromantic said:

Exile does not deserve to be above Illicit Affairs or in the top 100. It sounds like that sleep inertia feeling you get after a nap. 

The last time and Everything has changed >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Exit 

Now sis there is no need to lash out like this just because you’re hurt 

[Cleanromantic]

4 minutes ago, Navy4Life said:

Now sis there is no need to lash out like this just because you’re hurt 

I did what I did, I said what I said, end of story .

[ithinkheknowsoutsold]

Based on the songs left thus far, I think it is safe to say this is what the fan ranking of Taylor's albums (at least on ATRL) looks like:

 

1. Red

2. Folklore

3. Speak Now

4. Evermore/1989

5. Reputation

6. Midnights

7. Fearless

8. Lover

9. Debut

[Shendelzare]

Stale and Maroon needs to go I-

[Peroxide]

Oh I see Cowboy Like Me is still here. Can this go next plz 

[Icarus]

4 minutes ago, Shendelzare said:

Stale and Maroon needs to go I-

I can maybe understand why people like the Teenage Dream/Dangerous Woman reject so much, especially ATRLers who love very generic pop. Stale is as generic pop as it gets.

 

But the Maroon love is so puzzling to me. The worst song of 2022 and her worst song ever in my opinion. The instrumental is nightmare inducing

[Dear Reader]

the last three takes in here  

[TaylenaStan]

2 hours ago, State of Grace. said:

47. Don’t Blame Me - 8.117

45. Out Of The Woods - 8.140

44. Illicit Affairs - 8.142

43. Seven - 8.163

42. The 1 - 8.182

41. Evermore (feat. Bon Iver) - 8.183

36. Mirrorball - 8.260

34. My Tears Ricochet - 8.276

33. Dear John - 8.281

32. ‘Tis The Damn Season - 8.317

 

I expected the worst, but this is even worse than I expected. You b*tches are ******* TASTELESS.  

 

Corny Street, Corona Summer and Death By A Thousand Snoozes outlasting all those folkmore masterpieces is yet another reason why swifties only deserve MID albums forever.

 

Dear John missing Top 30. Under WCS too. 

 

ANTI-HIT STILL IN!!!!

 

Edited February 27, 2023 by TaylenaStan

[Rev8]

Too many Red songs left in

 

wonder which one will be on top

august? wildest dreams? state of grace?

 

do yall even like that 10 minute song? should've left ages ago

[TaylenaStan]

Oh WOW all 3 of my 0s still being in and 2 11s aswell

The 10 songs that need to leave before top 20 (the bolded ones especially HAVE to surely leave..)
Corny Street
Moron
Anti-Hit
Yoko Ono
Overrated, Overrated, Overrated
ATWTMVFTV
Call It What You Want
Clean
Back To December
Treacherous

Edited February 27, 2023 by TaylenaStan

[Klein]

1 hour ago, ithinkheknowsoutsold said:

Based on the songs left thus far, I think it is safe to say this is what the fan ranking of Taylor's albums (at least on ATRL) looks like:

 

1. Red

2. Folklore

3. Speak Now

4. Evermore/1989

5. Reputation

6. Midnights

7. Fearless

8. Lover

9. Debut

Tbh that seems like an accurate ranking of her albums taking into account the opinion of all the fans I've read on this forum over the years. 

 

I wonder what the average for each album will look like though. I imagine Red's will be relatively bad considering the amount of songs on the TV. 

Edited February 27, 2023 by Klein