fan base K-Pop Thread: 2023 Archive

[Witnessed ET]

Not 2001 being the most recent #1  Fifty Fifty could have done it if that mess hadn’t happened 

 

[Mitsuki]

7 minutes ago, Flomik said:

No offence to NMIXX girls I love them but why do they have more entries than... IVE!?

The list is a pretty unfair comparison to IVE.

 

SM, HYBE and JYP distribute well their acts' albums in US and European Markets through Warner and UMG. While IVE only depends of streaming and digital on Europe and on US, when I searched, I'VE IVE was only available with an obscure link on Barnes&Noble. 

 

[Sheep]

5 minutes ago, rzal said:

maybe SM should take some notes 

So aespa has fewer unsold tickets across their entire US tour than BP does at a single date? I finally get why that metlife date is historic.

[Sheep]

3 minutes ago, Mitsuki said:

The list is a pretty unfair comparison to IVE.

 

SM, HYBE and JYP distribute well their acts' albums in US and European Markets through Warner and UMG. While IVE only depends of streaming and digital on Europe and on US, when I searched, I'VE IVE was only available with an obscure link on Barnes&Noble. 

 

I'VE was available at Target.

[Mitsuki]

4 minutes ago, CandyCoatedClouds said:

I would sure hope that they're outcharting considering they released a full length album and not just an EP like TXT darling

Stray Kids is charting on Spotify US since the beginning of the year.... 

 

Their streams on US in 2023 through catalog only: 

 

 

[rzal]

6 minutes ago, Witnessed ET said:

Not 2001 being the most recent #1  Fifty Fifty could have done it if that mess hadn’t happened 

 

they definitely wouldn't 

2 minutes ago, Century said:

So aespa has fewer unsold tickets across their entire US tour than BP does at a single date? I finally get why that metlife date is historic.

no, aespa sold less tickets on their entire US tour than blackpink sold at 2 dates

[Sheep]

9 minutes ago, Witnessed ET said:

Not 2001 being the most recent #1  Fifty Fifty could have done it if that mess hadn’t happened 

 

New Generation is our only hope. @ador we need english versions yesterday

[Mitsuki]

1 minute ago, Century said:

I'VE was available at Target.

Then they added later, cause during their comeback someone here asked why they didn't chart on Billboard 200, I was curious and went to search their album on major stores on US. And I only found on B&N 

 

[Sheep]

1 minute ago, rzal said:

they definitely wouldn't 

no, aespa sold less tickets on their entire US tour than blackpink sold at 2 dates

Maybe in your dreams. Hopefully your favs can rebound from this embarrassment and don't disband.

[BlackAura]

2 minutes ago, rzal said:

 

no, aespa sold less tickets on their entire US tour than blackpink sold at 2 dates

[CandyCoatedClouds]

8 minutes ago, Mitsuki said:

Stray Kids is charting on Spotify US since the beginning of the year.... 

 

Their streams on US in 2023 through catalog only: 

 

 

This does not invalidate a single thing I said. We have established that SKZ are basically the second coming of bts with less good music. I would sure hope they were there since they released an ep late last year. 

[katyberry]

30 minutes ago, Born to Run said:

 

The wall of NO ENTRY is sending me  

 

aespa album was released internationally nearly 2 months late but idk about the others

[ItsJustMe.]

hihi this is so cute

 

 

i know it's probably the aussie accent but why is dani lowkey serving pick me  she's super cute tho!

minji is very naturally charismatic, it really showed on stage as well

maknae hyein is not afraid to talk, she even tries to get haerin to answer who just refuses lol (serving jisoo)

and hanni is just adorable

[lgaga1fan]

The continual mid off between the 4th gen bgs. Go worry about getting some songs to chart in the countries where theyre selling hundreds of thousands of records. 

 

[naomi24]

The endless disputes over the same topic for the last ten pages omg...

 

 

TGIF (Thank God I stan Flops)

[Mitsuki]

Just now, CandyCoatedClouds said:

This does not invalidate a single thing I said. We have established that SKZ are basically the second coming of bts with less good music. I would sure hope they were there since they released an ep late last year. 

Actually, It does. You were answering to Pluto's post mentioning Stray Kids outstreamed TXT on US this year and how they are still charting in Artists Category saying they only did due their full-length released. 

 

But It isn't true. They outstreamed TXT on US even prior their full-length release with data from January to late May. 

 

[lgaga1fan]

Bang PD put Twink x Twunk in the same room with the man who wrote Halo, Already Gone, Battlefield, Bleeding Love, Burn, Cry For Me, I Aint Worried, I Know Places, Maps, Rumour Has It, Welcome to New York, etc... and paired them up with one of the biggest radio payola acts of all time (Jonas Brothers) and the song is charting nowhere and will be lucky to be played in back to school ads for Kmart at this rate. TXT fighting!

 

the song isnt bad but y'all are literally grasping at straws to talk about relevancy in a market where neither group has cracked anything major. they have massive fanbases and are similar in stats just move on from the constant mid off. 

Edited August 5, 2023 by lgaga1fan

[Mitsuki]

5 minutes ago, lgaga1fan said:

The continual mid off between the 4th gen bgs. Go worry about getting some songs to chart in the countries where theyre selling hundreds of thousands of records. 

 

MYs are discussing aespa's success in a country they chart digitally worse than Stray Kids (Japan) and you don't see me saying a single bad thing about It. If anything, I even had positive remarks. 

 

So get off your high horse. 

 

[Sheep]

I hate it when the boy group stans fight because they're supposed to be the ones breaking up the feed of catfights between the same 10 of us girl group stans. 

Edited August 5, 2023 by Century

[illia]

This remix ended the original. Surprised?

 

 

[lgaga1fan]

1 minute ago, Mitsuki said:

MYs are discussing aespa's success in a country they chart digitally worse than Stray Kids (Japan) and you don't see me saying a single bad thing about It. If anything, I even had positive remarks. 

 

So get off your high horse. 

 

aespa and skz/txt aren't comparable acts and have massively different fanbases and discography lengths. I just think the infighting about these two bgs is getting a bit absurd. Both are headlining the same festival in different continents, both are doing stadium dates at the same venues in the US, both have similar album stats, both lack a single charting entry on the US Hot 100 despite selling hundreds of thousands of albums. Until one has a clear breakout ahead of the other that's significant enough to warrant the constant fighting its giving sones vs. blackjacks in the modern day. 

 

[lgaga1fan]

I will admit that TXT make some good songs here and there tho. We do love tracks like Blue Hour 

[LCTV]

2nd half of the Get Up EP coming

to send Cocke  Zero down to their least

played track on Spotify.

[Mitsuki]

Just now, Century said:

I hate it when the boy group stans fight because they're the ones breaking up the feed of catfights between the same 10 of us girl group stans. 

We need variety

I'm actually laughing at how there are two stan discussions in parallel

 

[LCTV]

1 minute ago, Flomik said:

This remix ended the original. Surprised?

 

 

I didn't know they could legally release a RaveDJ mashup of

Super Shy with the Do It Like That Acapella