chaeyonce Posted March 30 Posted March 30 I'm That Girl vs Ameriican Requiem Cozy vs Blackbiird Alien Superstar vs 16 Carriages Cuff It vs Protector Energy vs Texas Hold 'Em Break My Soul vs Bodyguard Church Girl vs Jolene Plastic Off The Sofa vs Daughter Virgo's Groove vs Spaghettii Move vs Alliigator Tears Heated vs Just For Fun Thique vs II Most Wanted All Up In Your Mind vs Levii's Jeans America Has A Problem vs Ya Ya Pure/Honey vs Riiverdance Summer Renaissance vs II Hand II Heaven Delresto (Echoes) vs Tyrant My House vs Sweet ★ Honey ★ Buckiin' Unsurprisingly the first half of Rennie clears the first half of Cowboy Carter but the Cowboy Carter second half clears Renny 9 vs 9 Neck and Neck
sillycilla Posted March 30 Posted March 30 7 minutes ago, Shelter said: Bey is normally a perfectionist so I'm surprised this whole vinyl thing. The Beyince and Cowboy Carter thing. So they are sending the Beyince version to stores, the one with less songs? No one can buy the CC version with the new cover? Seems like that version is the real limited one. Disaster The music is always phenomenal but the rollout is never up to par. 1 1
Pepo Posted March 30 Posted March 30 (edited) 1 hour ago, Burn said: I think it was probably recorded at least a year ago because we heard some of Spaghettii at RWT. She's never beating the troll allegations. Edited March 30 by Pepo
Devin Posted March 30 Posted March 30 25 minutes ago, Queenyoncee said: Texas Hold' Em is in my Top 5 jail. 2
Negiiiii Posted March 30 Posted March 30 Im not doing the Rennie VS CC ranking cuz I'm pressed. not but for real, one cannot compare these 2 projects. 1 was made to be a « banger on banger / no skip album ». The other one was made as a whole « trip / experience » to live through. i'm more of a banger person so obvs Rennie would win but the quality of CC as a project is everything to me. A CC VS Lemonade would make more sense to me, they are more comparable I'd say. 1
chaeyonce Posted March 30 Posted March 30 10 minutes ago, Shelter said: Bey is normally a perfectionist so I'm surprised this whole vinyl thing. The Beyince and Cowboy Carter thing. So they are sending the Beyince version to stores, the one with less songs? No one can buy the CC version with the new cover? Seems like that version is the real limited one. Disaster Her changing "creative direction" aesthetic and name wise last minute (which was the right thing to do) is probably the reason.
Devin Posted March 30 Posted March 30 I'm That Girl vs Ameriican Requiem Cozy vs Blackbiird Alien Superstar vs 16 Carriages Cuff It vs Protector Energy vs Texas Hold 'Em Break My Soul vs Bodyguard Church Girl vs Jolene Plastic Off The Sofa vs Daughter Virgo's Groove vs Spaghettii Move vs Alliigator Tears Heated vs Just For Fun Thique vs II Most Wanted All Up In Your Mind vs Levii's Jeans America Has A Problem vs Ya Ya Pure/Honey vs Riiverdance Summer Renaissance vs II Hand II Heaven Delresto (Echoes) vs Tyrant
Draper. Posted March 30 Posted March 30 It's lovely how she approaches album curation nowadays, but can we get that with a R&B/Soul record tho? If she did an 80 minute album with the influences behind 4 and B'Day and her current creative approach that would absolutely be her best album. Think Miseducation of Lauryn Hill, think Songs In the Key of Life. I hope she's already thinking about going in that direction for B10.
Pepo Posted March 30 Posted March 30 I wonder what happened behind the scenes, so what made her change her mind about the cover and the title of the album. There's no booklet available either, nor any hint of the credits in the physical format which IS very odd to say the least. Maybe the album was supposed to come out a few months later, but something happened and the drop had to be rushed.
Negiiiii Posted March 30 Posted March 30 1 minute ago, Devin said: Cozy vs Blackbiird My previous still stands but THE REACH !? Babe is you DEAF ? You must talk about another song because COZY is COZY !? C.O.Z.Y sis please I don't want to hear nothing today I will not TOLERATE that.
Negiiiii Posted March 30 Posted March 30 Maybe a booklet + credits will be for the « regular edition » so that we buy it as well ?
Pepo Posted March 30 Posted March 30 32 minutes ago, Queenyoncee said: Texas Hold' Em is in my Top 5 It's genuinely a great song. Don't let the contrarians convince you otherwise. OT: I can finally say that I like virtually every song minus Levi's Jeans. It's easily the worst song of the album, that guy makes me puke. Sorry not sorry. 1
Devin Posted March 30 Posted March 30 Just now, Negiiiii said: My previous still stands but THE REACH !? Babe is you DEAF ? You must talk about another song because COZY is COZY !? C.O.Z.Y sis please I don't want to hear nothing today I will not TOLERATE that. both are amazing i refuse to pick.
Pepo Posted March 30 Posted March 30 Just now, Negiiiii said: Maybe a booklet + credits will be for the « regular edition » so that we buy it as well ? Yes, hence it's getting released in two weeks. Hopefully the standard edition turns out to be complete 1
Mitsouko Posted March 30 Posted March 30 I'm That Girl vs Ameriican Requiem Cozy vs Blackbiird Alien Superstar vs 16 Carriages Cuff It vs Protector Energy vs Texas Hold 'Em Break My Soul vs Bodyguard (almost a tie) Church Girl vs Jolene Plastic Off The Sofa vs Daughter Virgo's Groove vs Spaghettii Move vs Alliigator Tears Heated vs Just For Fun Thique vs II Most Wanted All Up In Your Mind vs Levii's Jeans America Has A Problem vs Ya Ya Pure/Honey vs Riiverdance Summer Renaissance vs II Hand II Heaven Delresto (Echoes) vs Tyrant My House vs Sweet ★ Honey ★ Buckiin' what can I say 2
xrosup Posted March 30 Posted March 30 It's too early for me to compared both Acts. For now I can say that Cowboy Carter as an entire album is better but I like the Renassaince songs individually better 1
Negiiiii Posted March 30 Posted March 30 Just now, Mitsouko said: Energy vs Texas Hold 'Em Good because the death penalty is waitin for you in Texas babe 2
Lose My Breath Posted March 30 Posted March 30 Alligator Tears is criminally underrated my top 5 for right now Bodyguard Alligator Tears II Most Wanted Flamenco Riverdance 2 1
Negiiiii Posted March 30 Posted March 30 Just now, xrosup said: It's too early for me to compared both Acts. For now I can say that Cowboy Carter as an entire album is better but I like the Renassaince songs individually better EXACLTY what I meant with my post earlier
Negiiiii Posted March 30 Posted March 30 (edited) My Top 5 as of now would be (no order) : Spaghettii Daughter Bodyguard II Most Wanted Tyrant Edited March 30 by Negiiiii
Starshine Posted March 30 Posted March 30 We really need an umbrella for all of the acts, I still see it as one project.. but I'm That Girl vs Ameriican Requiem Cozy vs Blackbiird Alien Superstar vs 16 Carriages Cuff It vs Protector Energy vs Texas Hold 'Em Break My Soul vs Bodyguard Church Girl vs Jolene Plastic Off The Sofa vs Daughter Virgo's Groove vs Spaghettii Move vs Alliigator Tears Heated vs Just For Fun Thique vs II Most Wanted All Up In Your Mind vs Levii's Jeans America Has A Problem vs Ya Ya Pure/Honey vs Riiverdance Summer Renaissance vs II Hand II Heaven Delresto (Echoes) vs Tyrant 1
Pepo Posted March 30 Posted March 30 Both Alligator Tears and Just For Fun are exquisite. It needs time maybe, but when it hits it hits! Protector gives me I Miss You vibes. It's definitely one of the most touching songs in her discography.
chaeyonce Posted March 30 Posted March 30 2 minutes ago, Pepo said: Both Alligator Tears and Just For Fun are exquisite. It needs time maybe, but when it hits it hits! Protector gives me I Miss You vibes. It's definitely one of the most touching songs in her discography. I didn't get Alligator tears at fist but now I'm obsessed. Just for fun is one of her best ever duet. 2
xrosup Posted March 30 Posted March 30 Top 6 tracks, singles aside, as of now: Bodyguard Daughter Spaghettii Alliigator Tears Ya Ya Tyrant 1
Recommended Posts