Fruity Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 should've banned M in the artist name to avoid some of these overly obvious artists (N too if u wanted to be nasty)
Navyofbadgals Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 4 minutes ago, Fruity said: should've banned M in the artist name to avoid some of these overly obvious artists (N too if u wanted to be nasty) Or y’all just needed to step it UP
Fruity Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 Just now, Navyofbadgals said: Or y’all just needed to step it UP and you need to SHUT it up
Navyofbadgals Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 5 minutes ago, Fruity said: and you need to SHUT it up Fine no critiques this round
Fruity Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 (edited) 12 minutes ago, Navyofbadgals said: Fine no critiques this round pls dont do this Edited January 19, 2021 by Fruity
bestfiction Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 Blondie - Heart of Glass: A stunning classic Still stomps on Miley's cover, it was too shouty No Doubt - Just a Girl: A bit annoying, idk. Don't really care for their music outside of Don't Speak The Pretty Reckless - Just Tonight: I recall trying to get into them to pass as cool to some rock kidz. Um, anyways... the song is meh, a bit corny HAIM - The Steps: legendary, iconic, absolutely breathtaking, a feminist anthem Phoebe Bridgers - Garden Song: a bit of a snooze, but pretty Garbage - Push It: the production ****ing knocks Beabadoobee - Together: pretty nice. can't say it's a standout or anything but it's solid. I liked her album overall The Veronicas - 4ever: very 2007 P!nk - U+Ur Hand: that's fine Avril Lavigne - Don’t Tell Me: a classique. I'd have ranked you instantaneously #1 had you sent in a The Best Damn Thing song though. Evanescence - Bring Me To Life: a meme straight classic Paramore - Grow Up: pretty fun, I liked it! St. Vincent - Los Ageless: SOTY of 2017 HAIM - 3 AM: this... isn't even a rock song... Beabadoobee - Worth It: cute! Fleetwood Mac - Rhiannon: I prefer their Rumors stuff but this isn't bad Sade - Love Is Found: the intro was amazing, very cinematic and intriguing. as for the rest of the song... well x Joan Jett - Bad Reputation: Godvril's cover is better
thecptz Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 49 minutes ago, Fruity said: and you need to SHUT it up so rude of you
Fruity Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 32 minutes ago, thecptz said: so rude of you i see bagels i flame bagels
thecptz Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 Blondie - Heart of Glass oh i havent listened to the original much.. i think i've listened to it once after i heard miley's cover this is so FUN even though it drags in some parts but its a cute one No Doubt - Just a Girl well i expected worse but like this is not really bad at all?? i found myself bopping to it as the song went on still, it's not that memorable for me so other songs might outshine it.. but i enjoyed this! The Pretty Reckless - Just Tonight serving avril lavigne a bit hmm idk i'm pretty mixed about this yea i def enjoyed it a bit but then i feel like its pretty forgettable? so prob not good for you in my rankings HAIM - The Steps its def a highlight from the album. i remembered not rlly liking it when it was first released but my feelings have changed! its a good song and whew vibing~ also, rlly love the bridge it brings the song up! Phoebe Bridgers - Garden Song god this is like my favorite phoebe bridgers song its so beautiful and so interesting like the lyrics are so confusing that you need to take a deep breath and just read them SFSDFDSF you touch my leg, and i insist but i wake up before we do it whew Garbage - Push It oh wow i went from hmm i dont rlly like this to yup this is so cool in the chorus it def takes time but when it hits, it hits! an enjoyable submission (it kinda drags towards the end tho giggles) Beabadoobee - Together beabadoobee's songs are very hit or miss for me cause like ive tried listening to this album but can't finish it SFSDF this is alright, i guess? not rlly impressed with it but its not that bad either.. hmm The Veronicas - 4ever yup YUP yup.. the veronicas, classic, absolutely. and this song is just chefs kiss AMAZING JOB! idk what else to say but this is SOOOO GOOOODDDD WOOOOO P!nk - U+Ur Hand this is not bad at all and i actually enjoyed it a lot more than some submissions this round i feel like pink has better choices than this though but whatever, i enjoyed it Avril Lavigne - Don’t Tell Me the verses are better than the chorus imo i really liked this one cause i thought this was gonna be bad but then it's not. so yeah quite impressed with this one, nice avril nice Evanescence - Bring Me To Life screams WHAT A CLASSIC. and the fact that its still so good now.. whew blows my mind evanescence.. a talented band great job, thank you. Paramore - Grow Up its not bad and yes i enjoyed it but it prob ranks somewhere in the middle for me hmm like yes its good but others are a bit better :| St. Vincent - Los Ageless its cool but i'm not kinda feeling st vincent much so i'm sorry for that giggles having said that, this prob won't get ranked high for me but its not gonna be low either cause its a cool song! HAIM - 3 AM wow i remembered this sounded better than now when it was first released :/ grr i don't think i care about this that much now? like its very very okay-ish Beabadoobee - Worth It remember when i said beabadoobee's songs are mostly a hit or miss for me? now this one... this one is def a hit i liked this and yes, its a great submission for this round Fleetwood Mac - Rhiannon ^^^ i was like that for the whole time so yea, i don't think this is bad at all. i just think its pretty forgettable compared to others but its not BAD and i won't rank it low so dw <3 Sade - Love Is Found the production is very cool and interesting but the song altogether is just.. ahem not for me so sorry </3 Joan Jett - Bad Reputation ooh this is a very nice ending to this round tbh i don't think i like her collab on mileys album much but this song is soooo good. i wish cherry bomb was eligible but i'll take this! thank you very much. Spoiler @Alena @bestfiction @Fruity @Rence @Sanguine @luckystrike @miguel @Noah @Lucky#17 @Tom Vercetti @MusicLoverDude @Jay-Zicario @Touch It @Psycho @Not Like The Movies @touya kinomoto @ughgabriel @Mr. Duff
touya kinomoto Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 (edited) the generally positive acclaim for my song serving high 70s on metacritic the way i went from a banned paramore song to sending liz phair - never said to another banned song (this time by yeah yeah yeahs) to asking if i can send a maggie rogers song to the song i ended up with was so worth it. again sorry to @Overprotected for the flip flopping Edited January 19, 2021 by touya kinomoto
Fruity Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 6 minutes ago, touya kinomoto said: the generally positive acclaim for my song serving high 70s on metacritic the way i went from a banned paramore song to sending liz phair - never said to another banned song (this time by yeah yeah yeahs) to asking if i can send a maggie rogers song to the song i ended up with was so worth it. again sorry to @Overprotected for the flip flopping PLS same and also last round I was the biggest nightmare he hates me and with good REASON!
Navyofbadgals Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 Spoiler Not a terrible round.. but def a bit underwhelming So many better options to pick Blondie - Heart of Glass ngl I'm kinda so used to mildred's version that I had to readjust for this one This is a great pick tho, and still feels very contemporary with how this is a rock song but has become more poppy due to the discogenre which was also popular at that time. Pretty nice song overall No Doubt - Just a Girl It's a nice song, I don't think it's as bad as the crits this is getting. Is it as interesting as some of the other songs this round? Not really no but it at least has some character and isn't a total failure. The instrumental is pretty cool here and there The Pretty Reckless - Just Tonight It's not a total disaster but this feels very much rock by the numbers, and if any genre doesn't benefit for being by the numbers it's rock truly forgettable HAIM - The Steps this grower I love the mix between the acoustic guitar and the electric here. Hope either this or Shameika pulls through at the scammys Phoebe Bridgers - Garden Song Well this being so slow, sure makes this a standout in this round. Not really in love with it, it's pretty but nothing here is really gripping or screaming for my attention. It's bordering a bit on soulless for me but it has its pretty moments so I'll take it Garbage - Push It Both the songs I've heard in this competition for them are surprisingly great The chorus on this is absolutely amazing and I love how the pre-chorus works with it. The verses are admittedly a lil weaker, but they in contrast also make the chorus even better so I'm really not mad at it. Great choice Beabadoobee - Together Cute! It has enough punch to it to be interesting but it doesn't overdo it which is nice. The Veronicas - 4ever yeah this is 00s pop punk/rock at its best idc idc this is a big bop P!nk - U+Ur Hand It kinda reminded me of 4ever at moments too and then I found out they pretty much have the same production team (of max martin and the dr. who shall not be named ). That said, 4ever is much, much better. This very much feels p!nk like i've seen a million times and it's not that interesting to me. The production here is okay and its saving grace, not really into the rest. Avril Lavigne - Don’t Tell Me this is so.. average It's at least cuter than the pretty reckless song which was also so.. average. Not that great tbh Evanescence - Bring Me To Life big (meme) classic yes although I don't really like it that much. The iconic parts of this song are cool, along with the mysterious intro in the song. But for a song that's less than 4 minutes.. it still overstays its welcome The man in here esp.. is a choice Paramore - Grow Up CPG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Anyways; It's okay. I love the way she sings in the chorus, and the rest here is fine. I'm sure they have better than this but this should at least get you through to the next round St. Vincent - Los Ageless what an incredible song whew. The production on this is amazing, and I love how hard this goes and ends in this feeling of despair. Great pick HAIM - 3 AM hmm yes this def stretches the limits of this round and isn't really rock.. but OP accepted it and besides it is also an amazing song. Such a standout for them and it's nice to see them constantly evolving Beabadoobee - Worth It Personally prefer the other song by her, this is a little bit faceless. That said it's still cute Fleetwood Mac - Rhiannon surprised we have only one song from them, esp after regained popularity through tiktok anyways this is a great song, can't really complain. Sade - Love Is Found I can tolerate a lot of lyrics and all, you really don't need to give me a taylor swift song to satisfy me, but this is begging for some more lyrics. The production on this is so interesting and progressive, the vocals are good too, but the lyrics hold this back so much because it still feels like the song ain't progressing Anyways at the very least it's interesting so points for that Joan Jett - Bad Reputation i get it, it's a classic, but this is very much is serving me annoying teen kid who starts to rebel and it's quite annoying honestly Spoiler @miguel / @MusicLoverDude @Alena / @Not Like The Movies @Fruity/ @Mr. Duff @Tom Vercetti / @Psycho @Jay-Zicario / @luckystrike @Touch It / @bestfiction @Rence / @ughgabriel / @Lucky#17 / @touya kinomoto @Noah / @Sanguine
touya kinomoto Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 5 minutes ago, Fruity said: PLS same and also last round I was the biggest nightmare he hates me and with good REASON! nnn i was similar last round too and in the 90s round too i can see OP just tanking our songs on one of these rounds to get us eliminated for this reason and i can't blame ha
touya kinomoto Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 ooh bagels giving my sing a positive critique we love ha again
Mr. Duff Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 Wow at the choices I've considered a lot of songs here This is gonna be tough for me. Blondie - Heart of Glass it's okay, classic but not my favorite No Doubt - Just a Girl classic and something I like! The Pretty Reckless - Just Tonight not bad but not strong enough HAIM - The Steps it's not for me Phoebe Bridgers - Garden Song very pretty Garbage - Push It it's like the band/artist name Beabadoobee - Together her voice is annoying The Veronicas - 4ever yes classic! P!nk - U+Ur Hand yes classic [2] Avril Lavigne - Don’t Tell Me yes classic [3] Evanescence - Bring Me To Life yes classic [4] the 1-2-3-4 punch!!! Paramore - Grow Up it's good, but lackluster after the four above St. Vincent - Los Ageless really cool! but I feel like this is less rock than others HAIM - 3 AM not my taste, I mean is this even rock? Beabadoobee - Worth It oh this girl again. not better than the one above I guess Fleetwood Mac - Rhiannon it's okay, classic but not my favorite [2] Sade - Love Is Found really interesting! i like it Joan Jett - Bad Reputation Avril's version >>>>>>
smholiv Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 HEART OF GLASS: I find that this aged kind of weirdly, if not badly. I find it really strangely annoying even though its definitely a light, upbeat song JUST A GIRL : not my favourite ND song but I suppose I don't dislike it. Gwen Stefani has a voice that can veer into unbearable territory - it sort of does that here a few times, and the chaos of the song as a whole is a bit much to take in. I have other faves from them I wish could've been sent. JUST TONIGHT : this was new to me, it doesn't really hold up as well as it should. incredibly repetitive in a grating manner - it very much feels like something from the mid 2000s, and that it should've probably stayed there. THE STEPS : YESSSS excellent choice. this album had to grow on me but i'm so glad it did. it's a really fun track and one of their best GARDEN SONG : !! so pretty. for a while this was my favourite off Punisher and its still very high up there. I love the lyricism and the vibe of the song (her vocals on the chorus!). there's a melancholy feel to this song that i really love and i mean she's generally great at setting up the mood and transporting you into the song PUSH IT : not bad, this isn't something I'd totally get into, i don't have much to say TOGETHER : VERY beautiful. I love the sentiment of this song. her whole thing is inspired by female 90s alt rockers, and i like the modernization of it 4EVER : yikes what a weird choice. try again U + UR HAND : something about this song always irked me. it's actually not the worst in the group though, but idk i just can't vibe DON'T TELL ME : a lot of people saying "you should've sent x" and ... that's kind of me too I don't dislike this song, its definitely good, but its not as strong as some of her other material that would've fit well and probably stood out even better. this kind of gets lost in the mix so i foresee a middle rank BRING ME TO LIFE : this is very meme'd at this point. it's also coming out of a weird place of nostalgia. and yet? i can't hate it, far from the worst this round GROW UP : yeah they're too good to deny, especially with THIS album. this is an excellent track LOS AGELESS : i'm an OSVH, and definitely a Masseduction hater, but this is one of the best. the synth-rock is really cool (and stands out for this round). It's repetitive at times but in a good way actually 3AM : nah this is really cool, the R&B tinge to it makes sense since rock and R&B kind of go hand in hand in a lot of ways. I like this track a lot, its an easy standout for HAIM. It's up against some competition this round but I still like it a lot! WORTH IT : YESSSS WINNER? SOOO good, very much feel this song oozing with the 90s influence but a current twist. THe chorus is soo fun RHIANNON : Very good, a classic i thoroughly enjoy LOVE IS FOUND : new to me, definitely enjoyable but its landing somewhere in the middle for me BAD REPUTATION : was this in shrek? this is awful i'm sorry Spoiler @miguel / @MusicLoverDude @Alena / @Not Like The Movies @Fruity/ @Mr. Duff @Tom Vercetti / @Psycho @Jay-Zicario / @luckystrike @Touch It / @bestfiction @Rence / @ughgabriel / @Lucky#17 / @touya kinomoto @Noah / @Sanguine
mokitsu Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 Heart of Glass - Yeah this ***** all over Mildred's version. I hated her screamo version since day one, it works so much better with Debbie's ethereal light vocals. Just a Girl - I don't like this at all... her voice is not built for rock. It sounds like Fergie singing the national anthem with all the acrobatics she's doing. No ma'am. Just Tonight - I don't hate this, don't love (or like it) either. It's just there. Very early 2000s. The Steps - I like this but I might have overplayed it, it doesn't hit as much after listening to the other strong entries in this round. Garden Song - Such a beautiful, dreamy track. Her lyrics and delivery are unmatched. Push It - Absolute masterpiece. Love this. Together - Refer to Worth It because they're basically the same song lmao. Her baby voice is much more annoying in this chorus, but it's a cute song overall. 4ever - I listened to U + Ur Hand before this and they lowkey sound exactly alike I don't like this as much though, sorry. U + Ur Hand - I kinda love how this suddenly goes into a chorus that has nothing to do with the verses in terms of production and then goes back again as if nothing happened It's an interesting song for sure. Don't Tell Me - Very early 2000s in the worst way. Very cheesy. She had better rock classics. Bring Me To Life - Cringe Grow Up - It's okay. The chorus is a bit annoying. I really love the second verse/bridge (?) section though. I just realized that this has a really weird structure Los Ageless - This surprisingly held up pretty well. Great fusion of her and Jack's styles. Kinda tired of it though. 3 AM - Somehow this reminds me of Britney???? I don't know. It has a nostalgic feel to it, while still verging on dream pop/alternative R&B? It's a mishmash of genres that works perfectly. Worth It - I looooooove the 90s rock feel to this. Very much Soccer Mommy reject. Her baby voice is kinda weak for this kind of production because it gets drowned out and it just doesn't match much, but I can't deny it slaps. Rhiannon - This song is really elevated in their live performances. It's eerie and beautiful. The album version lacks the epic climax Stevie does in their performances, but I'll judge this as if it was the 8 minute version Love is Found - I'm sad because this sounds really muddy and cheap. Like the mixing is just off...... there's a good song in this, but it's all over the place as it is. Bad Reputation - This is a slapper, iconic and timeless. A perfect representation of the badass women I wanted to see in this round. Spoiler @miguel / @MusicLoverDude @Alena / @Not Like The Movies @Fruity/ @Mr. Duff @Tom Vercetti / @Psycho @Jay-Zicario / @luckystrike @Touch It / @bestfiction @Rence / @ughgabriel / @Lucky#17 / @touya kinomoto @Noah / @Sanguine
touya kinomoto Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 i really can't gauge moki's critic but it isn't totally negative so i'll take that
ABYSIL Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 Blondie - Heart of Glass: Such a lovely and pleasing song to listen. Way better than that Miley Cover! No Doubt - Just a Girl: Just a Meh! The Pretty Reckless - Just Tonight: I don't dislike it...that's all I have to say HAIM - The Steps: Fine...I was expecting more... Phoebe Bridgers - Garden Song: Cute to listen it. Garbage - Push It: I love the instrumental. Beabadoobee - Together: OK. This just there for me. The Veronicas - 4ever: I am not much into this, sorry. P!nk - U+Ur Hand: I am not much into this, sorry. [2] Avril Lavigne - Don’t Tell Me: I am not much into this, sorry. [3] Evanescence - Bring Me To Life: Fantastic and Spectacular. A Big Classic. Paramore - Grow Up: Another that is just there for me. But still better than half of the entries. St. Vincent - Los Ageless: Interesting song to listen. It's really great. HAIM - 3 AM: Way better than the other entry that was sent from them, that's for sure. Beabadoobee - Worth It: Slightly better than the other entry that was sent from her, that's for sure. [2] Fleetwood Mac - Rhiannon: Iconic and very deserved of its Classic Status. Sade - Love Is Found: Another interesting choice. This is very good. Joan Jett - Bad Reputation: A Great Classic. Nothing else to say. I was Expecting more from this Round. Really disappointing. Underwhelming Overall. .
Alena Posted January 19, 2021 Posted January 19, 2021 alena's thoughts. HEART OF GLASS: not a fan. JUST A GIRL: dont' like this uwu. JUST TONIGHT: idk what some of you are smoking but i thought this was quite nice actually! she sounds nice and it's definitely enjoyable. nice! THE STEPS: i hate them. GARDEN SONG: it was decent. PUSH IT: some parts are alright but overall i rly don't like it. TOGETHER: i do not like this. 4EVER: ahh a classic! maybe u snapped sis... U + UR HAND: i mean it's kind of a guilty pleasure but it's by p!nk so... DON'T TELL ME: compared to alot of songs i've had to listen to so far this is really great. BRING ME TO LIFE: yasss!! i thought of sending them too actually, a great choice loves it. GROW UP: mehh. LOS AGELESS: pretty cute. 3AM: i really have to listen to 2 of their songs this round? disgusting. WORTH IT: definitely like this better than the previous song by her! it's okay. RHIANNON: not bad. LOVE IS FOUND: kindaboring but atleast it has some interesting elements going on for it. BAD REPUTATION: ma'am this is a wendy's. UwU
Recommended Posts