Invisibility Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 1 minute ago, Overprotected said: Rihanna doesn't have any banned letter sweetie Thank you for the ratings tho that will go noticed!!! I was meaning that this is just a chopped and screwed version of a FlorenCe song aksjdkfjdj it was only a poorly executed joke
ughgabriel Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 troye sivan - could cry just thinking about you this is cute and sounds like a nice interlude, it’s way too short for me to have a solid opinion on it mahalia - what am i? i kinda liked it but then it got too monotonous, it’s short which is good but i still got bored towards the end kelela - bluff this is very nice and has the perfect length for what it has to offer liz phair - girls! girls! girls! i’m sorry i don’t have anything positive to say about this :( avril lavigne - contagious this is a very “quirky girl going to prom on a high school film” type of song. i dig the vibe and love avril so <3 magdalena bay - body i really like the production on this song c: kim petras - clarity I AINT WORRIED BOUT NADA LESS IT GUCCI LESS IT PRADA LESS IT DOLCE OR GABBANA sasha sloan - only child i really like slow songs but this just sent me to rem state mia gladstone - grow there was something unique about both the instrumental and her delivery, but i found it quite annoying :/ not the worst though! ariana grande - obvious(ly last place) megan thee stallion - rich this beat is so frisky i love it sm, i feel like sticking out my tongue vampire weekend - bambina this is probably the choice that surprised me the most but i really enjoyed it, it’s really fun! sza - anything hmm, this feels like she had a good idea for a song but the execution didn’t quite match the vision enon - salty i kinda like the messiness of this, there’s something about its chaotic nature that makes me want to dance halsey - walls could talk unfortunate
Auburn Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 GROUP A Spoiler Halsey - Killing Boys: this is very good yes Lorde - Million Dollar Bills: this is honestly quite annoying imo Tame Impala - Nangs: it’s not bad but it’s not giving much Miley Cyrus - Unholy: I love this song so much Neon Haze - Circus Minimus: this is quite a bop, not much else to say Bad Bhabie - Hi Bich: no ****ing ma’am Megan Thee Stallion - Work That: it’s pretty good Bruno Mars - Runaway Baby: it’s not the worst song here Rihanna - Goodnight Gotham: this is hardly a song I- Magdalena Bay - Nothing Baby: this is great I really enjoyed it Kero Kero Bonito - Flyway: this has a nice vibe Astrid S - Airpods: it’s very cute, unlike its namesake hihi Kehlani - F&MU: this is very good Kero Kero Bonito - Fish Bowl: it’s only okay for me tbh Shygirl - TASTY: big bop but there’s something I don’t like about it GROUP B Spoiler Troye Sivan - could cry just thinking about you: very very short but it does have more to it than some other songs submitted this round Mahalia - What Am I?: mmhmm I really enjoyed this Kelela - Bluff: queeeeeen, I wish she made this a bit longer Liz Phair - girls girls girls: queeeeeen [2] Avril Lavigne - Contagious: found my #1 whew I was PRAYING someone would send this Magdalena Bay - Body: this is v sexy, I like it Kim Petras - Clarity: this Charli XCX-lite garbage, it’s a no Sasha Sloan - Only Child: this is nice, although a bit underwhelming Mia Gladstone - Grow: I liked this actually, will probably be the middle Ariana Grande - obvious: **** song from a **** album, the way you can hear the phlegm in the back of her throat in the beginning I- Megan Thee Stallion - Rich: she went off Vampire Weekend - Bambina: it’s alright, not the worst by far SZA - Anything: nothing really special here, but it’s good Enon - Salty: noisy Halsey - Walls Could Talk: bop Spoiler @Anthem @Sanguine @K$Ellie @Noah @Not Like The Movies @Rotunda @Rence @Touch It @Psycho @bestfiction @Fruity @Alena @miguel @luckystrike @Future Lover @Staryu @Lucky#17 @MusicLoverDude @Tom Vercetti @PiecesOfYou @ughgabriel @Jay-Zicario @Mr. Duff @Pop culture @kipperskipper @Legend E @KevinDG@Born to Run @Queen Conchita @Invisibility @touya kinomoto
Mr. Duff Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 Troye Sivan - could cry just thinking about you - very pretty, but it's so short I wanted more. guess that's what interludes are for Mahalia - What Am I? - hmm, it did nothing for me Kelela - Bluff - terrible Liz Phair - girls girls girls - wtf is this Avril Lavigne - Contagious - it's okay, love Avril but not this song Magdalena Bay - Body - Ava Max/Lady Gaga-esque not in a good way Kim Petras - Clarity - hey I really like this, really nice song Sasha Sloan - Only Child - very slow but I thought this will be carried by the lyrics and it does, cute song Mia Gladstone - Grow - really bad Ariana Grande - obvious - really like it, but there's definitely something off in her voice here Megan Thee Stallion - Rich - pretty cool Vampire Weekend - Bambina - really good! might be my #1 SZA - Anything - it's nice Enon - Salty - it's pretty bad Halsey - Walls Could Talk - even though this is a good song, I will punish because rules are important
touya kinomoto Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 nnn not my original choice (killing boys) getting better reviews than my current entry. whoever got it, you're welcome.
KevinDG Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 (edited) Halsey - Killing Boys I love Halsey and like this, not my favorite on Manic though. Lorde - Million Dollar Bills Never really listened to Lorde's first album even though I loved Melodrama but this song definitely makes me want too! Tame Impala - Nangs This band seems popular in these kinds of games on ATRL. Would never listen to them if I don't have too and this song won't make me change my mind about that. Very boring. Miley Cyrus - Unholy Damn, I loooove this song but whoever chose this broke the rules so I'm gonna have to put this in last place. Neon Haze - Circus Minimus At first I really liked it but it got very irritating in the end. Don't know why though. Maybe because it sounds unfinished? Bad Bhabie - Hi Bich Uhm, not my thing AT ALL! And this was a single so Unholy is saved from last place! Megan Thee Stallion - Work That Very good for a hip hop song. Bruno Mars - Runaway Baby His first album remains his best one for me. Like this one but it wasn't the best on the album. But still good for this round. Rihanna - Goodnight Gotham This is not really an actual 'song', so not placing this very high. Magdalena Bay - Nothing Baby Never heard of her before but I like it and will check her other songs out. Kero Kero Bonito - Flyway No. No. No. Astrid S - Airpods This song is very catchy. She has way better songs but it does what it has to do in this round. Kehlani - F&MU These kind of slow r&b songs really aren't something I like but because some of these other songs this round are horrible it will have a decent place in my ranking. Kero Kero Bonito - Fish Bowl A bit better then the other KKB song but still nothing I like. It's also a single so along with the other songs who broke the rules this will be in the bottom. Shygirl - TASTY Wow, this really bangs. Save (one of the) best for last! Will check this artist out. Edited January 8, 2021 by KevinDG
Navyofbadgals Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 GROUP A Spoiler Halsey - Killing Boys - cute little moment actually okay miss frangipane Lorde - Million Dollar Bills - that awkward moment when the round before one of the best lorde songs was sent, and now one of the worst ones are sent Tame Impala - nangs - well i like it so i'll rank it nicely but it def isn't the smartest choice. It works extremely well in the context of the album, but on its own it's a bit of a weird choice. Miley Cyrus - Unholy - if you're gonna get penalized you might as well send a better song never cared for this or any other song from this EP besides MD. I'll pass Neon Haze - Circus Minimus - if you're gonna make me stop the spotify playlist to go to youtube.. make it worth it this is bad background music mama Bad Bhabie - Hi Bich - horrendous Megan Thee Stallion - Work That - not that great but it's fun ig not too mad at it tbh Bruno Mars - Runaway Baby - was.. this round really that rough? damn ma Rihanna - Goodnight Gotham - actually very good or maybe it's just me being biased anyways will get a cute lil rank Magdalena Bay - Nothing Baby - cute enough, not that big on em but this is fun enough and def good enough in this round Kero Kero Bonito - Flyway - this is lowkey incredibly oh MY!! i stan Astrid S - Airpods - basic, sushi was right there x Kehlani - F&MU - decent Kero Kero Bonito - Fish Bowl - cute, flyway is better Shygirl - TASTY - this bops x GROUP B Spoiler Troye Sivan - could cry just thinking about you - a snooze but not a bad one Mahalia - What Am I? - very cute bop Kelela - Bluff - incredible Liz Phair - girls girls girls - goes nowhere Avril Lavigne - Contagious - not that interesting but not that bad x Magdalena Bay - Body - cute enough Kim Petras - Clarity - terrible vocal performance, terrible lyrics, terrible production, no x Sasha Sloan - Only Child - boring Mia Gladstone - Grow - messy and unpleasant vocal tone Ariana Grande - obvious - very unremarkable Megan Thee Stallion - Rich - very fun x Vampire Weekend - Bambina - cute, they have better but i'll take it x SZA - Anything - nice x Enon - Salty - both hate it and love it Halsey - Walls Could Talk - actually like this halsshit song as well Spoiler @Anthem @Sanguine @K$Ellie @Noah @Not Like The Movies @Rotunda @Rence @Touch It @Psycho @bestfiction @Fruity @Alena @miguel @luckystrike @Future Lover @Staryu @Lucky#17 @MusicLoverDude @Tom Vercetti @PiecesOfYou @ughgabriel @Jay-Zicario @Mr. Duff @Pop culture @kipperskipper @Legend E @KevinDG@Born to Run @Invisibility @touya kinomoto
Anthem Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 Might actually be safe thanks to how poorly some other songs are performing.
KevinDG Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 9 minutes ago, Anthem said: Might actually be safe thanks to how poorly some other songs are performing. Exactly my thought
K$Ellie Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 Halsey - Killing Boys: a stunner, my second fave on the album Lorde - Million Dollar Bills: yeah this is pretty annoying but it's not the worst thing ever Tame Impala - nangs: deffo an interlude so it's hard to rank bc I don't think it's good for the round but it's nice as part of the album Miley Cyrus - Unholy: a bop but not good enough to send a banned letter I don't think I'll probs give it a decent rank Neon Haze - Circus Minimus: wasn't worth making everyone go out of their way x Bad Bhabie - Hi Bich: best rap song of the 10s Megan Thee Stallion - Work That: quite annoying but it's not even the worst on the album Bruno Mars - Runaway Baby: nice try x Rihanna - Goodnight Gotham: again, this is totally an interlude and doesn't work for the round, what a waste of a sample too lmaoooo Magdalena Bay - Nothing Baby: it's cute, guess it'll rank high cause this round is weak Kero Kero Bonito - Flyway: not my fave from them but it's v nice Astrid S - Airpods: this whole album was so lame Kehlani - F&MU: she dropped off HARD after SweetSexySavage Kero Kero Bonito - Fish Bowl: super cute Shygirl - TASTY: amazing EP, one of my faves from it too
Overprotected Posted January 8, 2021 Author Posted January 8, 2021 GROUP A Killing Boys - I’m an OHH but I gotta admit this was actually cute, I enjoyed it yes Million Dollar Bills - I don’t think this is something I would like to listen to again but it wasn’t bad bad in the context of this round Nangs - Well this passed me by, go on girl give us nothing! It’s listenable at least though Unholy - Um this was cute actually! Circus Minimus Hi Bich - Now this is something you only stan ironically otherwise I don’t know what to tell you, her voice is so annoying Work That - Well this was a bop Runaway Baby - Easily one of the best songs for me this round but is that really an accomplishment Goodnight Gotham - This was also just a cute interlude moment but not as nice sounding as Nangs I fear Nothing Baby - Yes this is giving me nothing baby Flyway - Very cute and fun and works great as a short song unlike some other entries Airpods - I enjoyed the chorus here! The bar is very low so this might rank high for me F&MU - It’s also just cute alright I really don’t know what else to say Fish Bowl - Um yes good too like their other song uh uh oh yeh TASTY - Kinda dated and that cover… GROUP B could cry just thinking about you - This was pleasant to listen to, his voice is nice and I didn’t mind the length x What Am I? - Um maybe you snapped with this choice Bluff - Cute? girls girls girls - Oop this is an interesting choice, I quite enjoyed it Contagious - Filler on her best album but I still love it https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wjk2TGjXjeM Body - Better than their other song this round, it’s true it’s true Clarity - I thought I was an OKPH but turns out it’s only her high belting voice I find unbearable so this is actually not bad... Only Child - Not very interesting to me Grow - This has a fun production but her voice is kind of irritating hmm... obvious - Bop x Rich - Banger I think Bambina - I usually skip this to get to This Life but it’s actually very nice here I like Anything - Talent Salty - Me thinks your first choice outsold but I still liked this a lot, we love a nice discovery Walls Could Talk - Welp Spoiler @Anthem @Sanguine @K$Ellie @Noah @Not Like The Movies @Rotunda @Rence @Touch It @Psycho @bestfiction @Fruity @Alena @miguel @luckystrike @Future Lover @Staryu @Lucky#17 @MusicLoverDude @Tom Vercetti @PiecesOfYou @ughgabriel @Jay-Zicario @Mr. Duff @Pop culture @kipperskipper @Legend E @KevinDG@Born to Run @Invisibility @touya kinomoto
Overprotected Posted January 8, 2021 Author Posted January 8, 2021 Circus minimus - It's a no from me
Alena Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 alena's thots ♥ round 2 /// (G)I-DLE new album I BURN out on January 11 x ♥ Troye Sivan - could cry just thinking about you: it was cute but too short sadly :c Mahalia - What Am I?: beautiful voice, it was pretty cute! :o Kelela - Bluff: was okay i guess. Liz Phair - girls girls girls: no ma'am... a short song and i couldn't wait for it to end. Avril Lavigne - Contagious: i mean it's better than the previous song but i wouldn't listen to this again. Magdalena Bay - Body: gorgeous voice and overall just a really cool song, loveee. ♥ Kim Petras - Clarity: a BOP! love it. ♥ Sasha Sloan - Only Child: very pretty! lovely. Mia Gladstone - Grow: what in the cheap sounding sh is this... Ariana Grande - obvious: garbage. Megan Thee Stallion - Rich: YASSSS ♥ a bopp, love her. Vampire Weekend - Bambina: not for me. SZA - Anything: ehh, it was okay i guess but im fine not hearing this again. Enon - Salty: kinda salty i had to hear this, sounds like a migraine. Halsey - Walls Could Talk: it's pretty good :3 ♥
ATRL Moderator Legend E Posted January 8, 2021 ATRL Moderator Posted January 8, 2021 Halsey - Killing Boys - cute bop actually Lorde - Million Dollar Bills - aged a bit ngl and was never my fave on the love club ep Tame Impala - nangs - in contradiction to the tame impala entry last round, i actually love this Miley Cyrus - Unholy - banned xoxo Neon Haze - Circus Minimus Youtube Link - also known as rihanna - cirque du soleil (jk it's okay actually) Bad Bhabie - Hi Bich - banned xoxo Megan Thee Stallion - Work That - a bit boriing Bruno Mars - Runaway Baby - this is a cute bop tbh Rihanna - Goodnight Gotham - florence's > Magdalena Bay - Nothing Baby - wottice henny Kero Kero Bonito - Flyway - i like this Astrid S - Airpods - bop tbh Kehlani - F&MU - also nice Kero Kero Bonito - Fish Bowl - banned xoxo Shygirl - TASTY - this actually sounds better than the first time i heard it
Anthem Posted January 8, 2021 Posted January 8, 2021 Troye Sivan - "could cry just thinking about you" You really said SHORT with that track length. Very beautiful and dreamy. This is one of those short, almost like an interlude tracks that you wish would have been full-length. (see: Rihanna's Birthday Cake) Which I know wasn't the theme, but evoking that feeling made me like the submission even more lol. Mahalia - "What Am I?" ouu, I really like this! Gorgeous vocals on a really mellow track - it's RnB gold. Kelela - "Bluff" I like the tone set by the track's production, but it sort of loses me with it's lyrical repetitiveness. This definitely feels like it was meant to lead into something much bigger, presumably the next track on the album. It's still okay though, I guess. Liz Phair - "girls girls girls" I love "Exile in Guyville" and know that this song plays an important turning point for the album. I think it stands on it's own pretty well, though! The production has a very specific tone, and you have to commend Liz for complementing it so well with her delivery. Extra points for provoking lyrics. Avril Lavigne - "Contagious" This sounded generic and dated back then, and sounds even worse now. Don't get me wrong, I love a fun generic pop song.. just not this one. Magdalena Bay - "Body" Really love how this song INSTANTLY captivates and pulls you in with it's production. Despite it's length, I feel like I've just experienced an entire 80s-inspired trip. I really enjoyed everything about this entry and had to go back to give it another listen. Kim Petras - "Clarity" I expected a lot worse after reading some earlier critiques. It's an okay song, but it doesn't feel special to me. Honestly, it feels like it would just be a filler track that was solely intended to help push a specific image/sound for Kim's album. Sasha Sloan - "Only Child" Albeit sad, this was a really cute and relatable song. Lyrics were so well-written, and it all flows wonderfully. This is also probably the first song in this group that really didn't feel like it needed to be any longer because we got the full story in the two~ minutes. I'm very glad you sent this! Mia Gladstone - "Grow" This song feels very airy and fun, which I loved! Lots of soul to be found here. It makes me want to listen to the parent album in hopes that this tone will follow throughout. Ariana Grande - "obvious" Had to listen to this twice, because I zoned out while listening and forgot what I was doing. Much like the rest of the album, this song is rather boring for me and quite forgettable. It really just sounds like any other Ariana filler track. Sorry! Megan Thee Stallion - "Rich" This is an absolute BOP! Very solid (and smart) choice. Vampire Weekend - "Bambina" This reminds me of when I use to stan Dylan Minnette's band back when it was called The Narhwhals. I've never listened to Vampire Weekend before, but I really REALLY enjoyed this song and will definitely be diving into more of their work later. Hope you'll get lots of high rankings with this entry. SZA - "Anything" I'm not sure what to make of this, honestly. It's not a bad song by any means, but it didn't really do anything for me. I even gave it a second listen and still nothing. It's just.. there. Good background noise, but not a great submission for this game. Enon - "Salty" This started fine, but after the first minute it just becomes noise. Chile, what happened? This isn't okay. And yet.. it's still not the worst of the group, since it at least some levels to it. Halsey - "Walls Could Talk" This is probably the best track in the group. Unfortunately, since it was a banned song I'll have to rank it accordingly.
Rence Posted January 9, 2021 Posted January 9, 2021 Troye Sivan - could cry just thinking about you this is nice for an interlude Mahalia - What Am I? okay this is really nice Kelela - Bluff oh wow, I wish this was longer though Liz Phair - girls girls girls it was fine but it kinda went nowhere tbh Avril Lavigne - Contagious cute sing Magdalena Bay - Body oh wow oh wow! Kim Petras - Clarity a bop me thinks Sasha Sloan - Only Child sorry no Mia Gladstone - Grow eh it’s alright Ariana Grande - obvious not a fan but it’s cute Megan Thee Stallion - Rich booooooooop Vampire Weekend - Bambina very interesting SZA - Anything really enjoyed this Enon - Salty interesting, I kinda dig it Halsey - Walls Could Talk sorry no [2]
Overprotected Posted January 9, 2021 Author Posted January 9, 2021 Spoiler @Anthem @Sanguine @K$Ellie @Noah @Not Like The Movies @Rotunda @Rence @Touch It @Psycho @bestfiction @Fruity @Alena @miguel @luckystrike @Future Lover @Lucky#17 @MusicLoverDude @Tom Vercetti @PiecesOfYou @ughgabriel @Jay-Zicario @Mr. Duff @Pop culture @kipperskipper @Legend E @KevinDG@Born to Run @Invisibility @touya kinomoto This is your 22 hours reminder to send your rankings and if you already did then be here for RESULTS TOMORROW at 6PM EST
Pop culture Posted January 9, 2021 Posted January 9, 2021 1 hour ago, Legend E said: Halsey - Killing Boys - cute bop actually Lorde - Million Dollar Bills - aged a bit ngl and was never my fave on the love club ep Tame Impala - nangs - in contradiction to the tame impala entry last round, i actually love this Miley Cyrus - Unholy - banned xoxo Neon Haze - Circus Minimus Youtube Link - also known as rihanna - cirque du soleil (jk it's okay actually) Bad Bhabie - Hi Bich - banned xoxo Megan Thee Stallion - Work That - a bit boriing Bruno Mars - Runaway Baby - this is a cute bop tbh Rihanna - Goodnight Gotham - florence's > Magdalena Bay - Nothing Baby - wottice henny Kero Kero Bonito - Flyway - i like this Astrid S - Airpods - bop tbh Kehlani - F&MU - also nice Kero Kero Bonito - Fish Bowl - banned xoxo Shygirl - TASTY - this actually sounds better than the first time i heard it F&MU is also ineligible x
Overprotected Posted January 9, 2021 Author Posted January 9, 2021 1 hour ago, Pop culture said: F&MU is also ineligible x Me and Clue will be the judges of that thank you
Recommended Posts