Galaxy Posted March 28 Author Posted March 28 28 minutes ago, allforyou said: This was tough but Madonna wins, although I don't think it makes sense to compare christmas songs with regular ones I agree but I wanted both to have the same number of songs
Jay07 Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You But if we're being honest, it would be a wash for Like a Prayer, Frozen and Music alone.
helpthomas Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You 7 v 7... but it's unfair to include xmas songs imo
Miracle Whip Posted March 28 Posted March 28 20 minutes ago, Kimi said: emotions is lowkey better than any madonna single You're thinking of Honey. 1
Kimi Posted March 28 Posted March 28 39 minutes ago, Miracle Whip said: You're thinking of Honey. no im not
Wildcat Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You 11 - 4
Bacardo Royale Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You 5 - 10
Green Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You TIE Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You 8-8 It's a tie
superben Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You
eli's_rhythm Posted March 28 Posted March 28 (edited) Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You 10-6 Madge. Last 3 were rough! Edited March 28 by eli's_rhythm
HardBambi Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Like a virgin, Like a prayer, Vogue, Hung up, Mariah lost on those alone
Mocha Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You 1
Ashley Banks Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You Mariah: 9 Madonna: 6
stevyy Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You
stevyy Posted March 28 Posted March 28 1 hour ago, HardBambi said: Like a virgin, Like a prayer, Vogue, Hung up, Mariah lost on those alone Fantasy, AIWFCIY, Vision of Love, Emotions are literally staples and beyond legendary.
HardBambi Posted March 28 Posted March 28 1 minute ago, stevyy said: Fantasy, AIWFCIY, Vision of Love, Emotions are literally staples and beyond legendary. Let's dissect Fantasy - nyes AIWFCIS - yes Vision of love - no Emotions - absolutely not So not really
stevyy Posted March 28 Posted March 28 2 minutes ago, HardBambi said: Let's dissect Fantasy - nyes AIWFCIS - yes Vision of love - no Emotions - absolutely not So not really Emotions is the blueprint for whsitle notes. Fantasy is the blueprint for Hip Pop. Vision of Love is the blueprint for melismatic singing. AIWFCIY is the blueprint for modern xmas tunes. so yes.
nostalgic Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You
HardBambi Posted March 28 Posted March 28 3 minutes ago, stevyy said: Emotions is the blueprint for whsitle notes. Fantasy is the blueprint for Hip Pop. Vision of Love is the blueprint for melismatic singing. AIWFCIY is the blueprint for modern xmas tunes. so yes. In the lamble maybe but we don't know her stevvy, Just the Christmas song
Elvenpath Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You 1
sasashite Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You
HardBambi Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! (none) Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You I was honest for statsvvy
Loca Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love - EVERYBODY Like A Virgin vs. Emotions - LIKE A VIRGIN Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover - DREAMLOVER Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You - LIKE A PRAYER Vogue vs. Fantasy - VOGUE Erotica vs. Honey - EROTICA Secret vs. Heartbreaker - SECRET Frozen vs. Loverboy - FROZEN Music vs. Through the Rain - MUSIC American Life vs. It's Like That - AMERICAN LIFE Hung Up vs. Touch My Body - HUNG UP 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed - OBSESSED Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! - GMAYL Living for Love vs. #Beautiful - L4L Medellín vs. With You - MEDLLIN
Rogue_Redux Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Everybody vs. Vision of Love Like A Virgin vs. Emotions Live to Tell vs. Dreamlover Like a Prayer vs. All I Want For Christmas Is You Vogue vs. Fantasy Erotica vs. Honey Secret vs. Heartbreaker Frozen vs. Loverboy Music vs. Through the Rain American Life vs. It's Like That Hung Up vs. Touch My Body 4 Minutes vs. Obsessed Give Me All Your Luvin vs. Oh Santa! Living for Love vs. #Beautiful Medellín vs. With You Madonna: 9 Mariah: 6
stevyy Posted March 28 Posted March 28 Lead single comparison: 5,112,247 - Everybody ----------------- 68,158,566 - Vision of Love 375,184,682 - Like a Virgin ------------116,557,331 - Emotions 78,483,649 - Live to Tell ----------------70,250,250 - Dreamlover 604,349,596 - Like a Prayer --------- 2,171,469,624 - All I want for Christmas 305,161,843 - Vogue ------------------ 476,710,865 - Fantasy 19,380,417 - Erotica --------------------- 95,411,594 - Honey 34,434,710 - Secret --------------------138,413,950 - Heartbreaker 136,247,520 - Frozen -------------------- 3,556,197 - Loverboy 92,428,646 - Music ---------------------40,649,866 - Through The Rain 10,192,436 - American Life --------------98,602,699 - It's Like That 548,393,572 - Hung Up ----------------279,808,277 - Touch my Body 451,978,035 - 4 Minutes --------------- 534,764,434 - Obsessed 40,592,641 - Give me all your Luvin -----46,891,652 - Oh Santa! 37,635,982 - Living for Love ----------- 129,976,244 - #Beautiful 73,900,062 - Medellin ------------------- 20,994,101 - With You 6 versus 9 accordint to the GP.
Recommended Posts