MetropoliMusical Posted Thursday at 05:54 PM Posted Thursday at 05:54 PM (5) "1 Thing" Amerie vs. (2) "Toxic" Britney Spears (1) "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. (10) "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop (5) "SOS" Rihanna vs. (6) "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve (13) "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. (3) "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey
pride4jc1222 Posted Thursday at 06:25 PM Posted Thursday at 06:25 PM "1 Thing" Amarie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey Gosh, these servers are so bad, lol. 1
Quicksand Posted Thursday at 06:41 PM Posted Thursday at 06:41 PM (edited) double post Edited Thursday at 06:42 PM by Quicksand
naval23 Posted Thursday at 06:53 PM Posted Thursday at 06:53 PM (edited) VOTE "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey Edited Thursday at 06:55 PM by naval23
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted Thursday at 07:02 PM Author ATRL Moderator Posted Thursday at 07:02 PM 1 hour ago, makeawish said: hang on @supaspaz, is toxic playing hung up or 1 thing? Oh my, the dumbassery on my part… 1
Gwegend Posted Thursday at 07:03 PM Posted Thursday at 07:03 PM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears (subject to confirmation) "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey seriously, is this like the Mariah Carey fandom that is mostly voting in this tournament bc I'll have you know "The Roof" is an unknown Mariah song in the states. And it has no business beating songs like "212" and "Paper Planes". So it's either all the Mariah fans voting or everyone is European? (Since according to Google it was a single in UK/europe?) I will try to vote with zero whiney commentary from now on but the list of songs is dwindling to songs I don't even really like . It's like voting in a US presidential election of who sucks the least
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted Thursday at 07:07 PM Author ATRL Moderator Posted Thursday at 07:07 PM Okay, the post is fixed. Sorry about the confusion!
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted Thursday at 07:08 PM Author ATRL Moderator Posted Thursday at 07:08 PM 43 minutes ago, pride4jc1222 said: Gosh, these servers are so bad, lol. Just brutal the past few days! 1
CBC Posted Thursday at 07:09 PM Posted Thursday at 07:09 PM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted Thursday at 07:18 PM Author ATRL Moderator Posted Thursday at 07:18 PM 13 minutes ago, Gwegend said: seriously, is this like the Mariah Carey fandom that is mostly voting in this tournament bc I'll have you know "The Roof" is an unknown Mariah song in the states. And it has no business beating songs like "212" and "Paper Planes". So it's either all the Mariah fans voting or everyone is European? (Since according to Google it was a single in UK/europe?) I will try to vote with zero whiney commentary from now on but the list of songs is dwindling to songs I don't even really like . It's like voting in a US presidential election of who sucks the least In general, yes, it’s unknown. But this is a pop forum where people have an above-average knowledge of Mariah’s discography. “The Roof” is definitely beloved. Anyway, if you don’t like the songs left, vote based on what you think is a better sample. 1
McNulty Posted Thursday at 07:20 PM Posted Thursday at 07:20 PM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey
Luckitty Posted Thursday at 07:21 PM Posted Thursday at 07:21 PM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey
prézli Posted Thursday at 07:44 PM Posted Thursday at 07:44 PM 16 hours ago, supaspaz said: (6) "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve def. (2) "Crazy In Love" Beyoncé ft. Jay-Z [19-14] OMG
prézli Posted Thursday at 07:44 PM Posted Thursday at 07:44 PM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey
prézli Posted Thursday at 07:45 PM Posted Thursday at 07:45 PM 41 minutes ago, Gwegend said: seriously, is this like the Mariah Carey fandom that is mostly voting in this tournament sis, you voted Fantasy
Green Posted Thursday at 07:46 PM Posted Thursday at 07:46 PM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey
Suilen Posted Thursday at 07:49 PM Posted Thursday at 07:49 PM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey
Gwegend Posted Thursday at 08:45 PM Posted Thursday at 08:45 PM (edited) 1 hour ago, supaspaz said: In general, yes, it's unknown. But this is a pop forum where people have an above-average knowledge of Mariah's discography. "The Roof" is definitely beloved. Anyway, if you don't like the songs left, vote based on what you think is a better sample. Right…I'm trying to. I actually do like a few songs left. It's just sad to see such amazing songs get knocked out and then you're left with songs you aren't really "rooting for". Kinda like how you felt about "Steal My Sunshine" lol. And I personally think BSS and Fantasy are the 2 best samples and songs left. But we all know ATRL ain't letting a male vocalist win. Which is fine bc I kinda don't love male vocalists either lolz 1 hour ago, prézli said: sis, you voted Fantasy Well duh because that's an iconic sample and great song. But the roof is not for me. I'm not anti-Mariah, I'm anti-bias lol…but I guess The Roof is a fan fave amongst the people who are bigger Mariah fans than I am. at the end of the day, I'm just being an opinionated music snob which means I fit right in here at ATRL. @supaspaz- I just had a flashback memory of the show The List on VH1. Do you remember that show? Assuming you're a millennial or older… would you be willing to host a version of that on here? That could be fun. It would have to be a smaller group per category. I think it was like 5 guests compiling the list each episode… Edited Thursday at 08:49 PM by Gwegend
itshyolee Posted Thursday at 09:09 PM Posted Thursday at 09:09 PM "1 Thing" Amerie "Fantasy" Mariah Carey "SOS" Rihanna "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey
Ken Lee Posted Thursday at 09:31 PM Posted Thursday at 09:31 PM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back in Time)" Mariah Carey
confide in me Posted Thursday at 10:06 PM Posted Thursday at 10:06 PM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey
ATRL Moderator supaspaz Posted Thursday at 10:43 PM Author ATRL Moderator Posted Thursday at 10:43 PM 1 hour ago, Gwegend said: @supaspaz- I just had a flashback memory of the show The List on VH1. Do you remember that show? Assuming you're a millennial or older… would you be willing to host a version of that on here? That could be fun. It would have to be a smaller group per category. I think it was like 5 guests compiling the list each episode… I grew up on VH1! Raised by I Love… and their countdown shows. But I don’t remember that one. Can you refresh my memory?
Born to Run Posted Thursday at 11:16 PM Posted Thursday at 11:16 PM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey Too easy for a MCH
Reverie Posted Friday at 12:07 AM Posted Friday at 12:07 AM "1 Thing" Amerie vs. "Toxic" Britney Spears "Fantasy" Mariah Carey vs. "Lose Control" Missy Elliott ft. Ciara and Fatman Scoop "SOS" Rihanna vs. "Bitter Sweet Symphony" The Verve "Paper Planes" M.I.A. vs. "The Roof (Back In Time)" Mariah Carey
Gwegend Posted Friday at 12:14 AM Posted Friday at 12:14 AM 1 hour ago, supaspaz said: I grew up on VH1! Raised by I Love… and their countdown shows. But I don't remember that one. Can you refresh my memory? I believe it was a rotating celeb guest judge that hosted a few other celeb guests each episode. Around 4-5 people that each contribute their top 3(or 5) songs that fit the category for that episode (it was a new topic each episode: greatest rock bands, greatest one hit wonders, etc etc) and they go in a circle and get to take off a song from a list of their choice from another contestant. A couple rounds of that and then they narrow down to a final merged list. I might not have all the details right but that's what I remember. It lasted 1999-2000. I could have just found a YouTube video of it probably- instead of typing all this 1
Recommended Posts